10 Worst AEW Matches Ever (According To The Internet)
AEW is the best promotion ever when it peaks. These matches are...not that.
The star rating system - and indeed the Cagematch user rating system, from which this list is drawn - is flawed.
Even those who recognise it as a fun method of cataloguing matches in shorthand - as a recommendation or to simply place it on "record" somewhere - agree. The highest scores are awarded to lengthy and important main events, when there should be such a thing as a perfect 12-minute television match. Perhaps a better solution is rating matches by genre. There should also be such a thing as a high-rated comedy match, if that comedy match is significantly better than the rest, but that genre is rarely awarded for its craft and enthused crowd reaction.
Adam Cole Vs. Chris Jericho from this year's Double Or Nothing doesn't appear on this list - but should it?
It was a monumental disappointment and a waste of resources. It's just as well the MJF feud happened, because AEW - by presenting Cole as a vengeful badass in a role nobody took seriously - nearly scuppered his feel-good face turn. Isn't that worthy of more ire than a bad showing from an enhancement talent?
Writing subjectively, more than one of the following list entries borders on the cruel.
This however is as objective as it gets: according to the internet, i.e. you, these matches are the worst of the worst.
10. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Taya Valkyrie - Dynamite, July 26 2023 (2.42)
The first of...more than one Britt Baker match on this list, it is nice and accurate to point out that Baker is a star, is really, really funny, and, when paired against a very good talent is capable of brilliance. Her work with Thunder Rosa is iconic, and her match with Kris Statlander at All Out 2021 was one of the better efforts on what many people rate as the single greatest wrestling pay-per-view of all-time.
She is great at her best, but it would be naive to say that she is Bret Hart. Not particularly adept at carrying opponents, her opponent Taya Valkyrie is more star than craftswoman, and so, when they met in the ring, disaster ensued.
Very early, Taya hoisted Baker up for Road to Valhalla. What happened next is a mystery, albeit one that isn't anywhere near interesting enough to solve, like "Who was behind GTV?" or "What are the House of Black banging on about?"
Was this meant to be countered into a victory roll? It wasn't: Baker just landed awkwardly on her face without Taya knowing.
So technically, the move was struck. Awkwardly, yes, but it was struck. It couldn’t be the finish, since they had around seven excruciating minutes to go, so Taya instead just looked pissed beyond belief and did some form of ground and pound.
9. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Madi Wrenkowski - Women's Championship Tournament, February 22, 2021 (2.38)
If you go back and watch the first minute or so of this match, you'd struggle to think why it is rated so poorly.
It's almost good: Baker simply destroyed her far lesser opponent with a snug, cruel streak before Rebel got in on the fun. This is where the match fell apart. In retaliation, Wrenkowski aimed some forearms at Rebel, but the issue is that she put nothing behind them and made Jenna Morasca look like Katsuyori Shibata. A subsequent dropkick attempt might have compelled a flying insect to alter its trajectory, but that is about it.
The match was at this point atrocious, and understandably so. Wrenkowski has barely worked. But it was coherently bad; you could see a basic structure.
And then Baker tried to suplex Wrenkowski. Wrenkowski took two, then attempted to block the third attempt, but Baker threw her over anyway. Then, in what scanned as a bizarre technological glitch, the match sort of buffered as Baker did it again and again. And again. They were lost completely. That, or Baker sent her for a tin of tartan paint.
It all eventually ended up with a facebuster reversal, but Baker leapt so early that Wrenkowski just seemed like she was extremely proficient at musical chairs.
It would be far preferable to endure, with no anaesthetic, Baker's other profession.
8. Madison Rayne Vs. Tay Melo - October 28, 2022 (2.31)
ThIs wasn't a calamity, but it was rubbish.
The rating is strange, and probably harsh. It was a supbar wrestling match riddled with clichés, but nobody got lost and nobody's nose was broken. The fans couldn't care less, but that's par for the course, sadly, in AEW's women's division, which is apparently booked with a roll of the eyes and "Can't bloody not in 2023, it's political correctness gone mad".
It was bobbins, to be clear. A tepid and overlong match, in which nothing looked even remotely painful, worked at a glacial pace. Several moves missed by miles. That's an exaggeration - you couldn't quite use Lanny Poffo's appendage to measure the distance between the move and the intended target - but the selling was unconvincing as it gets.
What's worse were the constant, constant NXT Faces. It's bad enough when a wrestler with an established signature does it, but after the most gentle neckbreaker you've ever seen in your life?
Even Shawn Michaels would have told them it was a bit much.
Actually, that's too hyperbolic, sorry.
7. Jeff Jarrett Vs. Jeff Hardy - Dynamite, August 16 2023 (2.26)
Look, the money went to charity, so one good thing came from this video game tie-in, but the Texas Chainsaw Massacre Death Match wasn't even a good version of so-bad-it's-good schlock. And, while it wasn't so bad or egregious that it represented the beginning of the end of AEW's uncompromising artistic integrity or anything so daft - this is a company that promotes Battle of the Belts, after all - it was horrible.
Jeff Hardy entered the ring and immediately left it to wander through a backstage area bathed in red with an assortment of deadly weapons hanging on a wall. He was then attacked by Jeff Jarrett, who must have presumed Hardy would just wander off.
In a mess so dimly lit you could barely ascertain what was happening - probably by design, because AEW knew full well how bad it was - the various members of Hardy Party or the HFO or whatever that awful stable is now called clashed with Jarrett's gang. A bucket of blood was poured over Jarrett's head.
As Hardy advanced towards Karen Jarrett, she did her best final girl scream. She curdled blood with that thing, but come on: Hardy's output in 2023 isn't that horrifying, it's just really slow.
The brawl made its way back to the ring, and then Leatherface, who they hired from the same lookalike agency that WWE used to get a Doink for Money In The Bank 2020, scared away Karen Jarrett.
Jeff won.
6. Allie Vs. Brandi Rhodes - Fight For The Fallen 2020 (2.22)
Brandi Rhodes did a lot for AEW offscreen, for which she doesn't receive enough credit. She played a key role in making the shows more inclusive and while people mocked the subscription Heels club, try telling that to the members. They love it.
Onscreen, it is reasonable to state that she got in her own way, which was a shame: when she was laser-focused on one role, she was very good at it. She was exceptional in the build to the Cody Vs. Shawn Spears, which was a tremendous, enterprising bit of business.
The issue is that she was a very good vengeful babyface fascinated with the idea of playing a manipulative heel, and in the build to her match with Allie at Fight For The Fallen, she disclosed the severe (and real) mental health issues that affected her figure skating career.
And then she inexplicably played heel in an overlong and piss-weak match. A botched superkick was noticeably bad, but the whole thing was a slog, like they were wading through treacle.
In a post-match promo, burying the ref in character, Brandi said "The entire match, he kept counting to two and stopping because literally that match should have been over within two minutes".
She was correct, but not for that reason.
5. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Big Swole - All Out 2020 (2.03)
The cinematic match never stood a chance after the first Stadium Stampede because AEW perfected a one-off at the first time of asking. Stadium Stampede was a violent, irreverent and cathartic masterpiece, perfect levity for imperfect times, but the reality from which it acted as a distraction wasn't going away.
AEW did it again at the omni-cursed All Out 2020 in what could charitably be deemed as noble failure. Dr. Britt Baker was on fire throughout the closed-set Daily's Place era as an overbearing but very funny high-and-mighty heel who was impeccable at sending herself up. The eye-roll she pulled in the stands was the most funny was possible of registering boredom and disgust:
Fans petitioned for Baker to get a match on the main card, and they got it. They got the Tooth & Nail match, and it was rubbish. It was a hokey glorified walk-and-brawl necessitated because Baker wasn't fully cleared from injury, not that the match would've been particularly great if both were 100% fit and had trained at Olympic level in preparation.
A bizarre and unfunny horror comedy in which Rebel, ordinarily very funny, was just excruciating with her slapstick, the action, the jokes: none of it worked.
4. Allie & Brandi Rhodes Vs. Mel & Penelope Ford - The Deadly Draw, August 3 2020 (1.68)
Another entry in the "People are complaining about the women's division again, we should probably do some short-lived PR exercise" series, AEW promoted the 'Deadly Draw' tag team tournament deep into 2020.
It was not good, but it was delightfully strange: former Funkadactyl Cameron was in it!
This match wasn’t delightfully strange, nor was it good. Brandi wasn't on the same form with which she delivered a miraculously great match against Anna Jay on Saturday Night Dynamite. After a half-decent explosive salvo, she attempted to kick Mel in the head, but this missed just as dismally as the Nightmare Collective stable they were once part of. Mel sold it as some concussive blow, crumpling to the mat as the lights had gone out.
In general, everything took absolutely forever to happen. It felt like a rehearsal of a match that never stood a chance of being any good; at one point, and bear in mind this was the best combination of the four, Penelope Ford held Allie across her shoulders for what felt like the length of an ROH taping before hitting a lungblower.
It just went on and on and on, nothing looked good, and even the unintentional comedy - Mel dropping directly on the mat with an arse-first flying nothing like she was the Machine in that match against DDP - was too painful for schadenfreude.
3. Cezar Bononi Vs. Luchasaurus - Dark, March 11 2021 (1.59)
Tony Khan took a punt on Cezar Bononi for two reasons.
Firstly, Khan was quite nice in giving a lot of released WWE acts and indie names some work during the worst of the pandemic. Moreover, Bononi is an exceptionally tall bloke, and you know what Bill Watts always said (because Jim Ross says it whenever someone in excess of six foot appears in AEW):
You can make a lot of money with an athletic big man.
Now, writing this comes with a feeling of intense guilt, because Bononi is by all accounts is a really nice guy and has endured a terrible time n recent years, but an athletic big man he is not.
His match with Luchasaurus was such a disaster that it went viral.
In one infamous sequence, both men got so lost that it's a wonder they weren’t the subject of a worldwide manhunt. They did not have a clue what to do next as each came off the ropes. Bononi sort of hopped; Luchasaurus motioned to execute the chokeslam before realising that Bononi was so out of position he might as well have been one of the planted fans in the crowd.
2. Dr. Britt Baker & Rebel Vs. Nyla Rose & Vickie Guerrero - Dynamite, June 30 2021 (1.38)
Certain matches are doomed to fail. It is impossible for these matches to be either good, because the talent isn't good, or satisfactory, because the promoter doesn't want either character to lose.
The latter match happened about 90% of the time on Vince McMahon's watch in the 2010s, and the former took place on AEW Dynamite in June 2021. This was the preeminent "no good can come from this match" match in AEW history because it had Vickie Guerrero in it. 2018 Kenny Omega couldn't do anything with her, so what was Rebel going to do?
The answer: get injured from a save attempt.
The match wasn't terrible before that, at least when Baker and Nyla were in there, which is just as well: they were building to a singles match. Because Vickie Guerrero was in it, though, it sucked harder than an aeroplane toilet and you'd sooner have your guts forcibly sucked out of your ar*ehole than sit through it again.
At one point, in an attempt to get into position for the Lockjaw, she just flopped awkwardly to the mat in a way that was somehow comical but not slapstick, all at the same time.
1. Matt Hardy Vs. Sammy Guevara - All Out 2020 (0.55)
What was meant to be a Last Man Standing match booked to make All Out 2020 more interesting, via crazed backstage brawl away from the ringside plants suffering from sunstroke, went horrifically wrong.
Early in the match, the two men scaled a cherry picker in order to fall in tandem through a table placed conveniently below it.
This is where things went awry. Immediately, referee Aubrey Edwards sensed that something had happened. For a brief, terrifying moment, when he turned purple, it was thought that Matt Hardy had died. That is no exaggeration. Somehow, when something kicked in - instinct, muscle memory, whatever - Hardy continued and was allowed to continue. Inexplicably. AEW recognised their mistake and, in the aftermath, implemented an improved communication system between the medical team and referee corp.
This is such a strange match for the Cagematch users to have even rated. It hardly counts, does it?
Hopefully, the rating is a reflection of the disastrous handling of the match, and not a sociopathic meditation on its irrelevant quality.
"Hardy doesn't know to work and Guevara couldn't carry him. Minus five stars!"