10 Worst Booking Decisions In SummerSlam History
Dodgy finishes, unwelcome interference, and a lot of drama for The Undertaker...
Over the course of its near three-decade history, SummerSlam
has provided us with some pretty awesome moments.
Way back in 1992, we saw the British Bulldog win the Intercontinental title in front of a packed out Wembley Stadium. Then in 2002, Brock Lesnar shocked the world by defeating the Rock to become the youngest WWE Champion in company history. And you’d struggle to forget the borderline ridiculous—albeit entertaining—once in a lifetime clash between Shawn Michaels and Hulk Hogan from 2005.
But for each of those highlights, and considering all the notches on the SummerSlam belt, there have naturally also been a number of duds served up to us over the years—specifically in terms of the booking decisions.
Now, I’m not necessarily an expert in how to book a global pay-per-view wrestling event, but sometimes it doesn’t take a professional to identify certain decisions as poor ones.
From questionable match-making to dubious outcomes, as well as a few logistical issues, brace yourself as this article recounts some of the worst SummerSlam booking choices in WWE history.
10. Jon Stewart’s Interference
As far as celebrity appearances go, Jon Stewart’s wasn’t
necessarily a terrible one.
Initially, he’d been brought in as the guest host for SummerSlam 2015, which in itself wasn’t a bad decision. He actually did a pretty great job of ushering in the show and hyping up the Brooklyn crowd.
However, later in the evening, someone made the call to afford Stewart rather more responsibility, when he was inserted into the WWE and United States Championship unification bout between Seth Rollins and John Cena. From there, he struck Cena with a chair to gift the victory to Rollins, which was certainly a surprising development, but not a particularly welcome one.
Don’t get me wrong: there’s a time and a place for celebrity appearances. But a title unification match isn’t one of them. To get the fans invested in such a high-stakes contest, only to have the conclusion marred by such shenanigans is a bit of a slap in the face to everyone who paid to see the show.
Again, Stewart’s personal performance may not have been all that bad, but the decision to cast him in such a prominent role is what consigns him to a spot on this list.
9. Re-Booking Undertaker Vs. Giant González
The Undertaker’s list of WrestleMania opponents is easily
the most formidable in history. But one entry that’s often cited as a major blemish on that list is his WrestleMania IX meeting with Giant
González—and for good reason, too.
A slow and clunky affair concluded with González getting disqualified for dousing the Deadman with chloroform.
Okay, so where did González get the chloroform from? And wouldn’t a “dead” man be immune to this? Why did I go back and watch this whole match whilst preparing to write this article?
All of these questions pale in comparison to the one surrounding SummerSlam 1993: why did we get a rematch of Undertaker vs. González just a few months down the line?
I suppose the nefarious means by which González won would usually necessitate some sort of retribution, but I’m not sure anyone was desperate to see it dished out after the glimpse that WrestleMania provided.
Either way, the decision to push ahead with Undertaker vs. González, round two, was not a particularly inspired one. Luckily, ‘Taker’s victory came clean this time, sparing us a third and final rubber match.
8. Luger’s Post-Match Celebration
As well as an Undertaker/González rematch, the WWE spent
much of the summer of 1993 building up Lex Luger as their next All-American
hero.
After his elaborate Lex Express tour, Luger was eventually granted a title match, but he had to agree to lose; he wouldn’t be afforded a rematch. Plus, he’d have to wear a protective pad to cover the steel plate in his forearm.
So it was somewhat ironic, then, when in the finish to the match he removed that pad and clattered Yokozuna, sending him tumbling to the outside where he remained for the referee’s ten-count.
The match was over, and so was Luger’s chance to win the title.
But what followed was a post-match celebration that simply wasn’t in line with what had just happened. Sure, Luger had won, but Yokozuna had kept the belt and Luger wouldn’t be getting another chance at the strap. Instead of ruing the error of his ways, Luger celebrated like an American hero: confetti, balloons, flag-waving, and all.
Basically, it was exactly the opposite of how you would really react to seeing your one title shot slip through your fingers… not the most logical post-match booking, but at least the crowd seemed to head home happy.
7. Edge Wins… By Knockout
In 2005, the WWE had one of the hottest angles of the summer on its hands. It wasn’t really a storyline,
per sé, as it was very much rooted in real life.
Having initially been released by the company, Matt Hardy was brought back into the fold when Vince McMahon had the genius idea to turn Edge’s real-world affair with Matt’s girlfriend, Lita, into a very public, on-screen angle.
And as difficult as that must have been for all parties involved, Edge and Hardy were nonetheless successful in building one of the most hotly-anticipated matches of an absolutely star-studded SummerSlam card.
However, that hotly-anticipated match would ultimately last less than five minutes. And not only that, but Edge emerged the victor after the referee deemed that Hardy had been knocked out and was therefore unable to continue.
Admittedly there were future matches, so the angle at least got some kind of pay-off down the line. But with the fans so firmly behind Hardy—and baying for Edge’s blood—this was not the way anyone wanted to see this clash booked in the slightest.
6. Team WWF Gets (Nearly) All The Gold
One of the biggest criticisms levelled at the WCW Invasion
angle was that it wasn’t anything close to an even contest. With the likes of
Goldberg, Sting, and the nWo absent, the WCW/ECW Alliance was represented by a
band of predominantly mid-card talent, and they were up against the Rocks,
Undertakers, and Stone Colds of this world. Long story short, it wasn’t a fair
fight at all.
The disparity between the Alliance and the WWE was never more apparent than at SummerSlam 2001.
That night, Vince McMahon’s boys left with the WCW world title, both companies' tag team titles, as well as Intercontinental, Cruiserweight, and Light-Heavyweight titles in their ranks, as Lance Storm, DDP, Kanyon and Booker T each lost their belts throughout the course of the night. Meanwhile, all the Alliance had to their name was Rob Van Dam’s Hardcore title win and Stone Cold Steve Austin's WWE Championship retention.
And besides, Austin wasn't even a true WCW guy anyway, so while his win may have benefited the Alliance as a whole, it didn't do much for the standing of the WCW newcomers.
This was a storyline that
desperately required the incoming WCW and ECW talent to be presented as a threat, given that
it would continue for another three months.
Unfortunately, though, the way SummerSlam 2001 was booked, they didn't get anywhere near to achieving this.
5. Kevin Nash Returns
Over the years, you could argue that there were many times
at which Kevin Nash would have been a welcome addition to the WWE title
picture. The summer of 2011 was not one of those times.
But that didn’t stop him from making his return to WWE programming at the end of that year’s SummerSlam show, where he hit CM Punk with the Jackknife Powerbomb, allowing Alberto Del Rio to slither in and successfully cash-in his Money in the Bank briefcase.
Now, admittedly Nash didn't actually compete in the title picture as a result of his imposition, but then again why did they even run with this angle in the first place if that was going to be the case? The lack of retribution for Punk made the booking of this all the more questionable. The only match we did get was Triple H vs. Nash at TLC in December—but even that was still too little too late.
The whole storyline just felt very unnecessary, and contributed to the derailing of Punk’s momentum. And the texting debacle that would soon follow was simply the icing on a badly baked cake.
4. Undertaker Taps (But Not Really)
After Brock Lesnar ended the Undertaker’s WrestleMania
Streak in 2014, it wasn’t until SummerSlam of the following year that we’d
finally see ‘Taker search for revenge. And while the rematch itself was pretty
great, there was one very noticeable booking touch that wasn’t quite as
impressive.
While Undertaker officially won the match by forcing Lesnar to pass out, a thoroughly confusing non-finish had preceded the final decision.
With ‘Taker in the Kimura Lock, Charles Robinson had begun to count a pinfall as Lesnar’s shoulders had both touched the mat. But in doing so, his view was obstructed and so he didn’t see Undertaker’s right hand tapping. The timekeeper called for the bell, prompting disarray as Robinson tried to explain the match would continue, allowing ‘Taker to capitalise and lock in Hell’s Gate, forcing Lesnar to eventually pass out.
Whether this was an error on the timekeeper’s part, or perhaps the cameraman’s fault for missing ‘Taker tapping—either way it came across as a massive shambles. When even the commentary team are muddling their way through an explanation, you know something's not quite right.
Perhaps it was just a case of poorly executing
a good idea, but for me it’s deserving of a spot on this list.
3. Team WWE Beats Nexus
In the summer of 2010, Nexus were wreaking absolute havoc
across the WWE. After one of the most impactful debuts in WWE history, this
rogue group of upstarts looked destined for big things.
Or at least until SummerSlam 2010 came along.
In a 14-man extravaganza, they were placed in 7-on-7 tag team action against John Cena’s Team WWE. Cena had recruited world-champion pedigree in the likes of Edge and Chris Jericho, meaning that all the company had to do was allow the Nexus to go over and they’d be well on their way to superstardom. Plus, the elimination stipulation meant it would be easy to ensure certain members of Team WWE looked respectable in defeat.
Instead, though, they bottled it. With Cena the final man on Team WWE, he eliminated Justin Gabriel and Wade Barrett in quick succession to overcome the odds and doom the Nexus to defeat.
Unfortunately, the faction never really recovered, and were unable to regain their previous momentum. Worse still, the group would disband and now Darren Young and Heath Slater are the only two that remain with the company, in what has to go down as a wasted opportunity.
2. Headlined By A Wedding
Our earliest entry on the list comes from 1991, when
SummerSlam returned to its spiritual home of Madison Square Garden.
The show hosted a number of major match-ups, including one of the greatest Intercontinental Championship bouts of all time between Bret Hart and Mr. Perfect, as well as a star-studded main event handicap match, as Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior teamed to face the Iraqi sympathisers, Sgt. Slaughter, General Adnan, and Colonel Mustafa.
And yet, despite all that, the main event of the show was the kayfabe wedding of Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth—who were of course already married in real life.
The wedding itself was as ridiculous as you’d expect from the WWE, with Jake Roberts and The Undertaker running the obligatory interferences—although at least they waited until after the vows. Still, it’s the sheer concept of having a wedding closing out such a huge event that sees this one feature on the list.
An episode of Raw I could understand, but even a B-level PPV would be a stretch—so for the second biggest show on the WWE's calendar to close with a segment other than a match isn’t a great piece of booking in my eyes.
1. Undertaker Vs Undertaker
Poor Undertaker; he’s featured an awful lot today. Still,
that’s not necessarily a reflection on him—he’s just been booked into some
rather odd scenarios. And perhaps the oddest of the lot was the SummerSlam 1994
main event, which pitted the Undertaker against...himself.
Of course, the doppelgänger was an imposter, portrayed by Brian Lee—a mystery that even Leslie Nielsen had trouble solving.
But other than the wackiness of having two Undertakers face off against each other, this was a strange booking choice for the sheer fact that it involved the Phenom in the first place. During his early days, Undertaker's style was very slow, methodical, and a lot of it based on no-selling. And while that worked against many opponents, it wasn’t necessarily the kind of moveset you’d want to see mirrored move-for-move by his opponent.
On top of that, the entire angle started after ‘Taker was buried in a casket and bizarrely “ascended to the heavens” during the 1994 Royal Rumble.
Still, watching it all back, between Leslie Nielsen’s cameo and all the supernatural nonsense, I’m wondering if it’s all so bad that it’s actually pretty good.
I’ll let you guys be the judge of that—comment below with your thoughts on this one, and let me know what you personally deem to be the worst booking decisions in SummerSlam history.