10 Worst Finishes To WWE WrestleMania Matches
Ending on a bum note
So you’ve got a match on WrestleMania.
This is it: the culmination of a dream. Years of hard work, heavy graft, all leading up to this point - your chance to strut your stuff on the biggest stage the industry has to offer. You work your match, all goes as planned, and now the final hurdle: the finish. Here’s where it can get tricky.
Despite the grandeur of WrestleMania and unimaginable man hours ploughed into staging the event, it’s not at all uncommon for Show Of Shows’ matches to end on a real bummer. We’ve seen great matches take a plunge in the final three seconds, fair fights turned foul by a scuffed ending, and shoddy fixtures made downright rotten by baffling conclusions.
There can be nothing more frustrating for a performer than a bad finish - more often than not it’s the enduring image viewers will go home with. Whether these are botches, stumbles, or just stupid pieces of booking, these endings left sour tastes. Think of these as cautionary tales: it’s only the most important part of the most important match of your career, lads. No big deal...
10. John Cena vs The Miz (WrestleMania XXVII)
This one was a bad idea from the off, and everyone knew it. In 2011, swathes of fans had never been more down on Cena, and for all he’s a commendable professional, a WrestleMania headliner The Miz ain’t.
WWE bolstered this with a decent build and an excellent pre-match package highlighting the competitors’ disparate paths to the top, and from there, the bout was perfectly fine, a distinctly WWE contest by two excellent workers.
This would have been a disappointing but unexceptional main event, up until the finish. The pair were counted out to a hail of boos. Enter The Rock, who took it upon himself to restart the match, then swiftly nailed Cena with the Rock Bottom, allowing Miz to retain the title.
What this amounted to was an advert for next year’s WrestleMania, the main event of which was sealed the following night on Raw. Rock vs Cena was a huge match, and the lengthy build paid off in the amazing business the show did, but it’s a bit of a slap in the face for the paying fans in 2011, who’ve been subjected to a duff match and a commercial for what they could be watching in a year’s time.
9. Hulk Hogan vs Andre The Giant (WrestleMania IV)
The year prior, Hogan and Andre did battle in the main event in a match that’s short on in-ring quality but nigh unbeatable in terms of iconic value, culminating with the slam heard around the world, one of the most legendary moments in wrestling history.
As such, a rematch between the two at 1988’s event was a big deal, or should have been, anyway. Andre and Hogan met early on in the card-long tournament to crown the new world champion. It was exciting stuff, not only because we were guaranteed the removal of a tournament favourite, but because the pair remained two of the biggest names in the business.
What we got was five minutes of choking and punching, building up to the pair walloping each other with chairs for the double disqualification finish. It feels like WWE trying to have their cake and eat it - they wanted the razzle dazzle of Hogan/Andre round two, but had no intention of handing either man a loss.
There’s plenty of rubbish on this WrestleMania but this is probably the most downright disappointing match on the card, a major step down after the previous year’s triumph.
8. The Undertaker vs King Kong Bundy (WrestleMania XI)
While the streak might just be the most impressive achievement in WWE history, it’s fair to say that, for a while, the matches were pretty lousy. Undertaker’s bout against King Kong Bundy doesn’t scrape the depths of the Giant Gonzalez fight, but there’s something so ridiculous about that chloroform-assisted finish as to be deeply funny.
The Bundy match, meanwhile, loses points for making Undertaker look so utterly mundane. Instead of a quasi-mystical giant, here he’s fighting an ageing, out of shape dude with whom he has no chance of working a decent bout.
The problem is that ‘Taker can’t really deliver any of his signature offence to Bundy, a man with too much heft and not enough athleticism to assist in any measurable way. This leads us to the finish. We’re used to seeing Undertaker dispatch enemies with the tombstone, the chokeslam, or the Hell’s Gate submission.
Here, it’s a clothesline from the top rope. Not a special clothesline of any kind, just a jump and a forearm and we’re outta there. Onwards and upwards to better things for Undertaker - in about six years when the streak actually got good.
7. Becky Lynch vs Ronda Rousey vs Charlotte Flair (WrestleMania 35)
The finish to the first ever women’s match to headline WrestleMania isn’t a bad one by any means - it’s just a little oddly underplayed given the sense of history behind the moment.
The culmination of a remarkable ascent saw Becky Lynch as the most over figure in the company, and taking on perennial rival Charlotte Flair and bonafide bigger-than-wrestling superstar Ronda Rousey in an eagerly anticipated main event with both brands’ belts on the line.
After a quality match, Becky scooped Ronda into a crucifix pin and… won the match. The fans were so desperate for Becky to triumph that they didn’t care too much how she did it; all the same, this wasn’t the decisive victory we might have hoped for, looking on the lucky side - and not unlike a botch.
It doesn’t do the match any harm - the important thing was to get the belts on Becky and send the fans home happy after an incredibly long show. Still, conventional wisdom would have suggested Becky went over more emphatically (and probably pinning Charlotte rather than the otherwise-unbeaten Rousey).
6. Mark Henry vs Ryback (WrestleMania 29)
About as pure filler as a WrestleMania match can get, Mark Henry vs Ryback wasn’t a pairing that anyone will have been particularly looking forward to, and by virtue of the goofy ending, it’s not a clash anyone will hold fond memories of.
The basis behind the encounter was that both men are big and strong, and they demonstrate this by bear hugging and clubbing one another for eight of the longest minutes you could ever hope (not) to endure.
Eventually Ryback - who once seemed tipped for the top, don’t forget - has had enough, and he lifts up Henry to dish out his Shellshock finisher. Unfortunately he failed to factor in the sheer weight of Mark, and is flattened under the strongman’s heft and pinned for the three.
After this, Ryback pops up and delivers the Shellshock anyway, having already lost the match. It’s hard to know whose stock suffered the most in this ill thought out snooze, but the fans certainly suffered alongside them.
5. Miss WrestleMania Battle Royale (WrestleMania XXV)
On the one hand, it seems churlish to complain about the conclusion of a match like the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royale. Before WWE made the overdue decision to actually care about its women’s roster, this was about all you could hope for as a Diva: a spot in a 25 woman, six minute match during which the crowd would, at best, not jeer at you.
But the ending to this one is so bad that it would be downright irresponsible not to mention it. After 24 women have been evicted (including talented performers like Beth Phoenix, Gail Kim, Natalya, and Mickie James), we’re presented with our winner - Santina Marella, sister to comedy Italian wrestler Santino.
Only, it’s not Santina Marella, is it. It’s actually Santino in a dress and a wig. The entrants were snuck into the ring as Kid Rock played (indignity upon indignity) so as not to spoil the surprise; the crowd picks up on it pretty quickly, and Jerry Lawler as usual does himself proud on commentary discussing at length the relative attractiveness of his colleagues.
It’s one thing to not bother booking your women’s division, but to treat the entire roster as a joke is contemptible stuff from WWE. Luckily they’d only have seven further years to wait before getting a truly great match at WrestleMania.
4. Bret Hart vs Yokozuna (WrestleMania IX)
Circa 1993, it felt as though the Hulk Hogan era had just about come to a close. The man who had headlined seven of eight WrestleManias had come off the back of two disastrous main events on the trot, and was showing his age.
In Bret Hart, they had the future, an understated but charismatic technician who could have a great match with anyone. At WrestleMania IX, he was ready to face his biggest challenge yet, the gigantic Yokozuna. Could Hart overcome the monster?
No. In a pointlessly limp finish, Yoko’s manager Mr Fuji threw salt in Hart’s eye, allowing the big man to assert his heelish dominance by grabbing a fluke win over the Canadian.
Obviously that’s not why we’re here, though. The real dreadful finish came moments later when Hogan strode to the ring to check on Bret. The clownish Fuji then challenged Hogan to take on Yokozuna himself. 22 seconds later, the Hulkster dropped the leg, pinned Yoko, made everyone else look dreadful, and left with the strap. Hulkamania lives! (For about four months)
3. The Undertaker vs Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XXX)
This isn’t a conversation about whether or not Brock Lesnar should have been the one to break the streak (or whether it should have been broken at all). That’s written into wrestling lore now, and whatever you make of the decision, the logic behind the choice - that Lesnar was one of the few who could convince in the position - is sound.
To have the streak end as such an anticlimax, though, is a disappointment that can never really be rectified. The Undertaker took a hefty blow to the head early on, and never quite shook it off for the rest of the match.
The result is a ponderous affair, all the way up to a clumsy ending that sees Brock counter a tombstone into an F5 for the shocking win. No one can believe it happened; it takes a long while for the truth of the matter to resonate around the arena.
Ultimately the end of the streak felt like an accident, not the momentous, baton-passing moment it could have been. This makes it more realistic than many wrestling matches, perhaps, but this was the streak. That’s not the time for realism.
2. Hulk Hogan vs Sid Justice (WrestleMania VIII)
Even without the terrible finish, this would be down there with the worst WrestleMania main events, but the idiotic ending pushes it over the edge. Here we had a stale Hulk Hogan up against a never particularly talented Sid Justice in a completely undeserved headline slot.
The two worked badly together for 12 minutes, with Hogan doing nothing to make Sid seem a real threat and the outcome never in doubt. As Hulk made his way towards his trademark ending sequence, Harvey Wippleman interfered for a disqualification. In the main event of WrestleMania, in front of over 60,000 paying guests.
To make matters worse, the ending was re-shaped on the fly due to Papa Shango missing his cue. The future Godfather was meant to break up the pinfall following Hogan’s leg drop; instead, Sid was forced to kick out of the unbeatable move, with a red faced (not literally) Shango jogging to the ring shortly after.
While the Ultimate Warrior save that follows is iconic, this is an insultingly weak finish to a card that Hogan had no business headlining.
1. Michael Cole vs Jerry Lawler (WrestleMania XXVII)
Imagine you’ve somehow given a WrestleMania slot to a match between two of your commentators. One’s never wrestled a minute in his life, the other is 60 years old and long retired. All the same, you’ve built a lengthy angle around the rank amateur being relentlessly antagonistic towards the ex-pro. The fans have rejected it en masse; indeed it’s stinking out your programming. But you’re in too deep at this point.
The sensible thing to do would be to make a swift dismount by having the baby face commentator, a respected former wrestler and the likeable figure in all this, go over quickly, and forget all about it. Even if the angle was dire and the match likely to be bad, there'd be some fun to be had in seeing the incredibly annoying Cole take a beating.
Instead, after Lawler tapping Cole out, the always-unwelcome Anonymous Raw General Manager got involved. He declared that guest ref Steve Austin had overstepped his authority, and awarded the DQ win to Cole.
This was a baffling choice, particularly after 13 minutes of dreadful action. Prolonging the angle was the last thing anyone wanted.