10 WrestleMania Matches That Shouldn't Have Sucked (But Did)

Great match on paper doesn't always mean great contest in the ring.

Performing at WrestleMania is the dream of pretty much anybody who has entered the wrestling industry over the past 30 years or so - since creating the event in 1985, Vince McMahon has made 'Mania the place to be. So big is the show, that several wrestling companies elect to routinely invade the area WWE call home for a week, putting on their own events and capitalising from the buzz around wrestling when WrestleMania is in town. Casual and lapsed fans are brought back out of hiding, simply unable to resist the charms of what is assuredly the biggest event on the pro wrestling calendar. 'Mania 31 also promises to be grand, even if there are gripes about how WWE have failed to produce sufficient numbers of genuine top stars over the past few years. Incredibly, there have been hundreds of matches at WrestleMania, and thankfully, many of them have featured amazing performances. On the other side of the coin, there have been battles that aren't so fondly remembered, but that's simply the law of averages, and such thinking is really down to personal preferences of individual fans. Then, there are those bouts that unite the watching audience, as everyone collectively wonders why these matches failed to be great. This list focuses on 10 such examples where magic was waiting to be made, but things just fell a little short of spectacular.

10. Roddy Piper vs. Bad News Brown (WrestleMania VI)

In the Spring of 1990, 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper wasn't really looked upon the same way he had been right before he elected to step away from the ring several years earlier, mainly to pursue a career in other forms of entertainment such as movies and music. Returning in 1989, the Canadian was now a fully-fledged babyface, having endeared himself to audiences with his performances over the years. Programmed opposite the heel, Bad News Brown, Piper decided to do something a little different to help make their WrestleMania VI match stand out, and it's not something any performer would get away with nowadays! Bizarrely wearing what can only be described as a Michael Jackson glove, Piper was also painted half-black - maybe this was foreshadowing the Jackson track, 'Black Or White', which would be released the next year. Designed to up the ante for their bout, the match itself was nothing special, and ended in a disappointing double countout. Generally, that's not the kind of outcome fans respond well to at WrestleMania, where people expect firm conclusions. A brawl between the men should have been memorable, but it's only notable for Piper's choice of body paint.

9. Bob Backlund vs. Razor Ramon (WrestleMania IX)

Has there ever been a wrestler that looks more out of place than Bob Backlund did in the garish, colourful world of the WWF in 1993? The promotion was starting to go through a noticeable shift in direction, one which would shortly kick fully into gear once Hulk Hogan departed the promotion in June. At WrestleMania IX, Hulk would leave with the belt, but another former champion would suck the life out of the live crowd. Backlund's pasty white skin and goody-two-shoes mentality clearly alienated a lot of people at 'Mania IX, who didn't seem too interested in his match with Razor Ramon. For his part, Razor was starting to hear some cheers from fans, who had been enthused by his work opposite the likes of Bret Hart since his debut the previous year. Due to time constraints, Razor vs. Backlund was cut short, only lasting around 4 minutes. Worse yet, fans seems bored throughout the match, and obviously didn't take Bob very seriously at all. It's unbelievable that Backlund would be able to repackage himself going forward, apparently losing his mind, because he looked dead in the water as a character here.

8. Vince McMahon vs. Bret Hart (WrestleMania XXVI)

Over a decade in the making, ever since the infamous events of the 'Montreal Screwjob' at the 1997 Survivor Series Pay-Per-View, wrestling enthusiasts wondered what might happen should Bret Hart get his hands on Vince McMahon. Had this bout taken place years before, it's possible it would have worked, but by 2010, Bret wasn't the most steady on his feet, following an unfortunate stroke in 2002. Imagine the heat for McMahon vs. Hart around the turn of the millennium? It would never have happened, sure, but it would have been mind-blowing. Sadly, things were a lot more tepid at WrestleMania XXVI. It's difficult to see things playing out any other way, simply due to the frosty relationship between both men, and the aforementioned health problems for Hart. That said, surely they could have come up with something better than the 'Hitman' borderline acting like a heel, thumping McMahon relentlessly with chair shots. The live crowd didn't really know how to take it all, because there didn't appear to be any chance the supposed bad guy, Vince, could win. Not only was he offered little-to-no offence, but practically the entire Hart clan surrounded the ring, and Bret's brother Bruce was the referee. Wasted opportunity.

7. The Miz vs. John Cena (WrestleMania XXVII)

It's not exactly a bold prediction to guess that The Miz will never headline WrestleMania again. There was a period, from around 2010 onwards, where the guy was rightly acclaimed for stepping up his game and being one of the most improved wrestlers in WWE. Credit where credit is due, Miz pulled himself up by the proverbial boot straps and became a valuable addition to the roster. Simply put, The Miz was a deserved choice to win one of the 'Money In The Bank' Ladder Matches at the initial PPV of the same name, but fans were still pretty surprised when he cashed in his opportunity in November, 2010 on Randy Orton, winning the WWE Title. It felt genuinely fresh, but sadly the man's WrestleMania XXVII main event against John Cena fell largely flat, even with interference from The Rock. It's admirable that WWE management believed in The Miz enough to headline 'Mania, but fans didn't quite buy him at that level yet. It'd take a lot more than a few months at the top of the card to convince people that he was ready for the top line slot of such a prestigious event, and thus the match didn't really end the show with a bang. It should have been much better, admittedly, because The Miz had improved, and Cena himself had pieced together great matches with others.

6. Rick Rude vs. Jake Roberts (WrestleMania IV)

It seems pretty cliched to rag on WrestleMania IV, an event which has been dragged through the mud repeatedly. The main crux of the argument against the show revolves around the painstakingly dull 14-man tournament to crown a new WWF Champion. It's fitting then that in the first round, Jake Roberts and Rick Rude would send everyone to sleep! In fairness to both men, they were saddled with the 'time limit draw' scenario, whereby they had to effectively kill time for close to 15 minutes, before attempting to piece together an end stretch which would keep fans guessing. The way WWE approach these tournaments needs to be addressed, people can spot these time constraints a mile away, and they're rarely satisfying. Jake Roberts vs. Rick Rude should have been gold, especially because there was a personal grudge thrown in there - Rude had been claiming a relationship with Jake's lover, which only added fuel to the fire. Unfortunately, that wouldn't be enough to overcome the cards the duo were handed for 'Mania.

5. Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan (WrestleMania XXVIII)

Any fans of the past few years have heard all about this one. Daniel Bryan and Sheamus had been bumped off the main card of WrestleMania the previous year, but their scrap for the World Heavyweight Championship was all set to kick start 'Mania XXVIII with a bang, surely lighting up the audience and setting the tone for the show. Who knows what the WWE creative team were thinking, starting out WrestleMania in this way, but Sheamus would defeat Bryan in around 18 seconds, making him look like a complete jobber in the process. This is a rare entry on this list, because much like the Roberts vs. Rude match previously, these guys weren't really given a chance by the writing staff. Daniel Bryan would eventually get his big moment at 'Mania 2 years later, winning the WWE Title in the main event, but this wasn't a very memorable first WrestleMania for the man. What an easy night for both guys, but when it comes to the biggest show of the year, hard workers such as Bryan and Sheamus want to tear the house down.

4. Triple H vs. Booker T (WrestleMania XIX)

It's been said that using racism in wrestling doesn't work. That point is arguable, because it likely could work in front of smaller, more focused audiences, but WWE is a global product, one which is supposed to appeal to everyone regardless of their beliefs, colour or background. It was therefore stunning that the promotion chose to have lead heel Triple H effectively tell Booker T that he wasn't a worthy World Champion because of the colour of his skin. Using the phrase, "people like you" to describe the challenger, HHH did get some heat for the comments, but it wasn't the right kind of heat. Fans felt pretty uncomfortable with it all, basically acknowledging that the hero was being held down due to race reasons if they fully got behind Booker. The match itself was fun, but the ending left a lot to be desired. Hitting Booker with a Pedigree, it took 'The Game' around 20 seconds to cover the man, and the challenger didn't kick out. What an unsatisfying end to a pretty unsavoury feud. There's absolutely no way that Booker T should have lost here, the rivalry demanded that the heel get his comeuppance.

3. Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XX)

One of the strangest set of circumstances surrounding a WrestleMania match ever, Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg played before one of the most unique crowd reactions of all time. The Special Guest Referee, Steve Austin, found it hard to hide his smile as fans hit both men with booing, and chants about selling out resonated through Madison Square Garden. Needless to say, everyone in attendance was aware that both men were imminently leaving the company. Goldberg's run hadn't been what he had hoped for, whereas Lesnar fancied a crack at playing American Football for a living. In turn, the fans almost treated both men like they had disgraced the name of pro wrestling. This one should have been titanic - WCW's home grown monster, Goldberg against WWE's own pet beast, Lesnar. The match should have been nothing but a smash-mouth affair, with raw power winning the day, but instead turned into a farce, one permeated with stalling as neither man could seemingly wrap their head around the red hot atmosphere.

2. The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XXX)

Surprise! This entry will do bout shock a lot of fans, and might even anger others, but there will be a lot of readers who agree somewhat with what is being proposed here. The Undertaker's vaunted winning streak at WrestleMania was priceless to WWE, perhaps even more valuable than a World Title match on the show each year. Nobody can deny the fact that it would have been The Undertaker who made the decision to lose at 'Mania XXX - Vince McMahon likely trusted the man's judgement enough to make the call for himself, and choose who he was going to stare at the lights for. Nonetheless, it came completely out of the blue, nobody expected it, despite what many have claimed. The match was fine, a truly exciting example of how powerful the streak was, but the ending completely deflated absolutely everyone. Paul Heyman has described in interviews since how the air was sucked out of the building when the referee made the count, and whilst it's up for debate whether or not it was the right call, it did suck to watch such a record come to an end.

1. Randy Orton vs. Triple H (WrestleMania XXV)

Given the build to Randy Orton vs. Triple H at 'Mania XXV, this should have been a genuine classic. Orton had been tremendous in his role as unhinged psychopath, playing mind games with the entire McMahon family, whilst Triple H filled the role of hero out to avenge evil perfectly. Add the WWE Title into the mix and it should have been a recipe for success. Tragically, it wasn't. There's an argument to be made that the incredible match between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels should have went on last, because the war between Triple H and Orton couldn't have possibly hoped to better it. Maybe it would have if the stipulation tacked on shortly before the match didn't completely ruin the purpose! This should have been a night when 'The Game' was able to truly let loose, raining hell down on Orton and righting all the wrongs his opponent had inflicted on he and his family in the months prior. Instead, the stipulation was that if HHH was counted out or disqualified, he'd lose the WWE Title, which didn't really do much for the bout. It was a slow, plodding affair, when it should have been frantic and stunt-filled. What other WrestleMania matches should have been better than they were? Do you agree with the choices on this list? Let us know down in the comments section below!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.