10 Wrestlers The Fans Did A Complete 180 On

A look at ten wrestlers who span fans' emotions right round baby right round.

Forbidden Door 2024 Britt Baker
AEW

In 2023, AEW's Wardlow gave an interview where he lamented his lack of appreciation for how over he was during his heyday. During his ascent, he had yet to realize one of the cruel realities of the wrestling business - there's a big difference between getting over and staying over. After all, us wrestling fans are - as Daniel Bryan used to remind us - a fickle bunch, quick to turn the flavour of the month into another passed over dish on the great smorgasbord of professional wrestling.

Sometimes, however, fan emotions go to further extremes. Once-loved WWE wrestlers can become figures of seething contempt, despised wherever they go. And on the flip side, talents that used to be booed out of arenas have gone on to be cheered as conquering heroes wherever they tread.

It's these contrasting figures who this list will focus on - wrestlers who, by virtue of their actions in and out of the ring, went from loved to loathed, or vice-versa. And who better to demonstrate an example of the former sentiment than our first entrant...

10. Hulk Hogan

WWE Raw Hulk Hogan Jimmy Hart
WWE

The scale of Hulk Hogan's fall from grace is staggering when you consider the career he had.

Here was a man who managed to become the most popular wrestler in the world across three separate decades (Hulkamania in the eighties; NWO leader in the nineties; and the immediate aftermath of his legendary WrestleMania encounter with The Rock in 2002). Now, he can't even show up in his home state without getting mercilessly booed out of the arena.

Really, you could almost feel sorry for him. But then you remember he:

 - Snitched on an attempt to form a wrestlers' union.

 - Deliberately screwed up the end of Starrcade '97, starting the "That doesn't work for me, brother" meme.

 - Stole Bret Hart's thunder at WrestleMania IX, then refused to drop the belt to him.

 - Tried to gaslight a rookie Undertaker

 - And, most importantly of all, his vitrolic, racist tirade - for which he has still shown no genuine remorse.

Given all that, it's no wonder fans have chosen to echo the sentiments of the late Iron Shiek and (metaphorically) declared, "F**K THE HULK HOGAN!"


9. Ronda Rousey

Ronda Rousey
WWE

The above quote may seem a little harsh, but given the circumstances you can understand Rousey's frustration with the WWE fanbase.

For context, the above photo is taken from Survivor Series 2018, shortly after Charlotte Flair unleashed a vicious post-match beatdown on Rousey. Inexplicably, the audience started cheering Flair during the attack, and heckled Ronda as the latter made her way to the back.

To this day, it's unclear why WWE fans suddenly decided to start hating Rousey, especially after widely supporting her since her goosebump-raising WrestleMania debut. As Michael Sidgwick alludes to in the linked article, the former UFC champion had made disparaging comments about "avocado-eating millennials" weeks prior to the match, but the fans' rancorous reaction to Rousey felt massively out of proportion to her remarks.

Unfortunately, Ronda never got over the fans turning their backs on her. Her subsequent WWE run lacked all the spark of her incredible debut year, giving the fans just cause to boo her as she put in one lacklustre performance after another.

Once again, avocado ruins everything (seriously, it's just slime with good PR).


8. Saraya

Saraya AEW Loser
AEW

As the previous entry showed, there's not always a clear-cut reason for fans deciding to turn their back on a former favourite. That certainly isn't the case here, as Saraya's AEW run is a textbook example of how to inadvertently turn cheers into boos.

Saraya's comeback into wrestling should have been one of the biggest feel-good moments in the history of AEW. Having been sidelined with a serious neck injury in the WWE and being told she'd likely never wrestle again, Saraya's return to the squared circle should have been a moment of pure, genuine triumph that left fans beaming with happiness for her.

And that's exactly what happened...until she opened her mouth. Inexplicably, Saraya decided to denounce AEW's locker room as a bunch of scrubs who'd been scraping by and just waiting for a big-time superstar like her to come along and show them how things are done. As introductions go, it was reminiscent of Leeds United manager Brian Clough walking into his team's locker room for the first time and telling his new players to throw away all their old medals because they'd won them by cheating.

Clough lasted 44 days as Leeds' manager. And while Saraya's AEW tenure has lasted a fair bit longer, she's never become the fan-favourite she could have been had she been a tad more gracious to her peers.


7. Lita

Lita Steve Austin Broken Skull Sessions
WWE

It's often said that great wrestling angles mix in real-life issues. And while that can be true (just check out Cody and Punk's latest promo masterclass for an example), sometimes the blending of fiction and reality becomes uncomfortable.

Case in point: The Matt Hardy/Edge/Lita debacle.

To be fair, once the aforementioned trio's dirty laundry became public (Lita cheated on Matt with Edge, and if you didn't know that - hi mum! Hope you're enjoying the article!), WWE were basically forced into making it a storyline. Where it became uncomfortable was in how the audience treated the cheating couple.

While Edge earned a good amount of heat for his actions, the abuse WWE fans directed at Lita felt wildly disproportionate. Even during her final match, fans were vitriolic in their abuse to the former golden girl of the women's division - an attitude WWE went out of their way to encourage, as seen by the vile send-off they gave the former champion.

Fortunately, time worked its magic and Lita now receives the respect her career earned her. Fans cheered her on during her subsequent comebacks, and she was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2014 and given her props by Stone Cold Steve Austin on the latter's official WWE podcast.


6. Cody Rhodes (AEW)

Cody Rhodes AEW Boo
AEW

Given Cody Rhodes' current status as the most beloved WWE champion since the early days of Kofimania, it's surreal how accurately the above picture summarizes his last days in AEW.

It certainly wasn't like that at the beginning. As one of AEW's founding members, Cody was lionized by wrestling fans for offering a genuine alternative to the then-abysmal WWE. Naturally, Cody's ability to deliver excellent promos and matches further stoked fan ardor for the bleached-blonde superstar.

Unfortunately, Cody's much-lauded promo ability deserted him during his feud with Anthony Ogogo. In Cody's own words:

"I thought the content was good. I thought the intentions were good. However, a white guy talking about race relations who has an American flag tattoo on his neck, I can see why people would use the term tone-deaf when it came to that.

Yeah, "tone-deaf" about sums it up. Fans began to turn on their former favourite, booing him relentlessly during his feud with the cartoonishly villainous Malakai Black. Most damingly, when he threw items of clothing into the audience, they began chucking them right back at him. Increasingly disillusioned with both the fans' perception of him and the direction AEW was going, Cody left the company in returned to the WWE in 2022, where he is now arguably the most popular wrestler on the planet.


5. Asuka

Asuka Return
WWE.com

Asuka's relationship with WWE fans has essentially been ten years of unbroken adoration. Even when booked horribly, WWE fans have always rallied around Asuka due to her selfless attitude, unbridled charisma and world-class wrestling ability.

Which makes it somewhat of a shock to discover that the wrestling community in her home country used to have a very dim view of her.

Asuka's problems in Japan started in 2010, when wrote an open letter to the joshi (female wrestler) community in Japan. In the letter, she essentially said the current crop of joshis were boring, fake and more interested in being idols than wrestlers. Unfortunately, despite the letter being blatantly written under the guise of her heel character, the wrestling community in Japan adopted the Michael Jordan approach in their reaction and took it personal. Very personal.

Asuka herself has since blasted the way she was treated by the media in her home country afterwards, saying that they did everything they could to distort fans' perception of her. As an example, Asuka pointed out that after she became a champion in WWE, said one prominent Japanese publication asked its readers if they really believed her to be a worthy of the honour.

Fortunately, the answer came back in WWE's latest tour of Japan. Discussing the event on her YouTube channel, Asuka said she was hugely moved by the overwhelmingly positive reaction she received from her fellow countrymen and women, as all the negative backlash provoked by the Japanese media was washed away in a tidal wave of support and positivity.

Like so many before them, the haters weren't ready for Asuka.


4. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin Sad Bum Ass
WWE

If you had to choose one word to define Baron Corbin's stay in WWE, "tumultuous" would be an appropriate choice.

Corbin travelled through a lot of peaks and valleys during his 12 year stay with the company. The 6'8'' wrestler soon found himself catapaulted into the upper-card, causing no small resentment from fans. At the time of his heyday, Corbin simply wasn't at the level needed to justify his position in the company - he certainly wasn't the right choice to retire a generational superstar like Kurt Angle, yet that's exactly what happened in their frankly awful match at WrestleMania 35.

WWE eventually picked up on the fans' backlash, leading to "Bum Ass Corbin" - a hapless, down on his luck sadsack who became the punchline for every joke. Such was Corbin's skill at playing the role, fans began cheering for the downbeat loser, leading to WWE abandoning the character for becoming too popular (a surprisingly common risk in wrestling).

Naturally, fans went back to hating Corbin again, resulting in his demotion to NXT. However, Corbin maximized his minutes in the lesser brand, forming a genuinely excellent tag team with Bron Breakker and getting himself over once again. Bafflingly, WWE chose to reward Corbin's exemplary efforts by taking him off air for a year, then letting him go once his contract ran out.

Like the intro said - "Tumultuous".


3. Britt Baker

AEW Collision Britt Baker
AEW

The above photo sees Britt helpfully illustrating her career trajectory since 2022.

There is a fascinating documentary to be made about the rise and fall of Britt Baker. In 2021, dentist-turned-wrestler Britt Baker was one of AEW's biggest success stories. After debuting as a bland babyface, Baker's transformation into the egomaniacal, ironically-named "Role Model" turned her into one of the most popular characters in all of wrestling, with audiences cheering wildly whenever the letters "D.M.D" appeared on-screen. After winning the AEW Women's Championship and entering a feud with the highly acclaimed Thunder Rosa, Britt Baker appeared set for a generational run.

Unfortunately, it was at this point the D.M.D. began leaving a sour taste in people's mouths (sorry, couldn't resist). News began to leak of Baker and Rosa's real-life animosity, leaving fans focusing more on what was going on behind the scenes than what was happening on-screen. Not only that, injuries - and the rising popularity of Baker's sidekick, Jamie Hayter - saw Baker falling down the card.

Since then, Baker has done little to quell fans' criticism of her. Her in-ring work, never her strongest point, has deteriorated notably, and her conduct on and off-screen has been questionable to say the least. From shrieking "Nobody cares!" at Serena Deeb, killing their feud before it started, to being removed from television over an altercation with MJF, the narrative currently surrounding Baker is one of a star who let the fame get to her head and became a monster as a result.

If Baker's time in AEW is at an end, it will be a sad conclusion for a wrestler who once looked to be the future of the company.


2. Randy Orton

Daniel Bryan Randy Orton WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

The above photo shows arguably the greatest wrestler of his generation - a technical virtuoso whose combination of easygoing charisma and once-a-generation grappling ability won him the love and respect of millions of fans over the world.

The other wrestler is Randy Orton.

Neatly, the photo also shows why Randy was despised by fans for years. He's the one punching Daniel Bryan - the aforementioned "greatest wrestler of his generation" - in a neat encapsulation of how fans viewed their relationship. Randy was the corporate golden boy, chosen to unceremoniously ruin Daniel Bryan's championship win at SummerSlam 2013 and send him packing to the midcard.

Fortunately, both stars got happy endings - Daniel Bryan became WWE Champion, and Randy Orton eventually found his way into the fans' hearts.

Years after stoking fan resentment, Randy began getting the crowd back onside with his odd-couple tandem with Matt Riddle. Watching the dour Orton interact with the goofy, bro-spouting Riddle endeared the former to WWE audiences, as Orton came across as a lovable grump who nevertheless found kinship with his excitable partner.

Unfortunately, injury struck and left Orton on the shelf for 18 months, with retirement even being hinted at for the veteran superstar. The upside was, absence made the heart grow fonder as Orton's return to the ring at Survivor Series 2023 caused the biggest pop of the year (well, until it was superseded by CM Punk's return later that night).

Having one of the biggest moments of his career stolen by another wrestler? Now Randy knows how Daniel Bryan felt at SummerSlam...


1. John Cena

lets go cena cena sucks
WWE.com

It feels appropriate to bookend this list with Hulk Hogan and the man who spent years being derided as his modern-day counterpart.

It's true that there are parallels to be made between the two. Both were undoubtedly the WWE's golden geese during their respective primes; both were all-American faces who pandered to the crowd; both came under fire for relying on the same template in all their big matches (get beaten up, stop selling, hit signature moves, win); and both caused huge fan backlash for using their political stroke to win matches they really shouldn't have (Hogan stealing Bret Hart's thunder at WrestleMania IX, Cena single-handedly derailing the once-promising Nexus at SummerSlam 2010).

Having said that, Cena's detractors were far more vocal than Hogan's during their respective peaks. For years, whichever arena Cena entered would erupt into duelling chants of "Let's go Cena!" and "Cena sucks!", to the point WWE even started selling shirts with the chant emblazoned on them.

Yet while Hogan's reputation has only worsened over time, Cena's has soared.

Unlike Hogan, Cena hasn't been afraid to give back to the industry that made him a household name. Since becoming a part-timer, Cena has used his appearances to put over the current crop of talent, rather than let his ego run wild over the roster. Fans have recognized his selflessness to the extent that, when he declared his intention to win the Royal Rumble, they cheered wildly - unthinkable scenes even a few years ago.

Combined with growing awareness of his astonishing charity work, it's never been easier to root for John Cena - a real American hero.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.