10 Wrestlers Who Are Wasted In WWE

Stockpiling talent isn't the same as using talent.

WWE.com

Vince McMahon is keen to regain his formerly-firm stranglehold on the pro wrestling biz, and part of his re-monopolisation strategy includes stockpiling talent so others can't have it. This isn't a new phenomenon for WWE; back in the 1980s, the company ruthlessly pursued wrestlers from other organisations (like the NWA and other territorial groups, for example) and hoarded as many talented workers as possible.

They're doing the exact same thing today in 2020.

The problem is that there's just not enough space for everybody, not even when WWE has three hours of Raw, two of SmackDown, two of NXT, one of NXT UK and other peripheral programming like Main Event every single week. The writing team can't sustain the sheer weights of numbers on company books, and that's partly why some are struggling.

In fact, going a step further, they're totally wasted on WWE and might be better off elsewhere. Of course, that's easy to say when people have families to feed and are still making good money, but it must be creatively exhausting for these workers to see their efforts go unappreciated...


10. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy
WWE.com

Even at 45, Matt Hardy has so much more to give.

The guy whipped himself into incredible physical shape a few years ago and looked set to ride the part-time veteran train alongside his brother Jeff. Then, Jeff got injured and smeared WWE PR by getting arrested for driving whilst impaired last October. Today, Matt is in limbo, and it sucks to see.

Hardy appeared to wave goodbye to WWE fans after his angle with Randy Orton on Raw, and his future is very much up in the air. If the company aren't going to use him as an in-ring attraction going forwards, then they should (at the very least) sign him up for some seminars at the Performance Center. This is a pro with some serious knowledge.

Failing that, Matt might be better off trying his chances outside the WWE sphere. Somewhere like AEW would be perfect, and there's already been a precedent set by other ageing warriors like Dustin Rhodes who took a chance on fleeing the coop.


9. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

Apollo Crews' last two singles matches on WWE television lasted a combined 4:29, and his latest (a 29-second loss to Sheamus on the 7 February SmackDown) was a real jobber's gig. This is a total waste of someone who can really go inside the ring and once seemed to have so much potential in NXT.

Right now, Apollo would be better off booking his own bus back to Full Sail.

It's tedious to hear Michael Cole remind viewers that Crews has "a bright future" and "could become a champion someday" whenever he gets meagre minutes on camera. It's even worse that Apollo hasn't moved on one bit since debuting on the the main roster in April 2016.

Think of the matches this man could have if he wasn't booked to be a nondescript loser. It's true that Crews doesn't have much personality, but then WWE has never really explored that side of things and has only allowed him to cut boring backstage promos that always get interrupted.


8. Cedric Alexander

WWE Clash of Champions 2019 AJ Styles Cedric Alexander
WWE.com

Cedric is in an almost identical position to Apollo Crews.

Things looked so positive just last summer. In 2019, Alexander received some vignettes hyping his place on the Raw roster and then worked seriously fun matches against everyone from Drew McIntyre to AJ Styles. It was a hot start, and Cedric also got to team up with poster boy Roman Reigns a time or two as well.

All that seems like a distant memory in February 2020. These days, instead of watching him fly around the ring or sell his ass off for his peers, fans are more likely to read about Alexander's frustrations on Twitter or learn that Vince McMahon ain't too high on the thought of pushing him. This has to be torturous for the former Cruiserweight Champion.

He's another who could easily slot in elsewhere. A return to the independents would let him enjoy wrestling again, and then Cedric could maybe seek a spot in AEW, the NWA, ROH or take his skills to Japan. At 30 years old, he's in his prime, and he has to do something before his dream job turns into a nightmare.


7. Lucha House Party

lucha house party
WWE.com

Lucha! Lucha! Luch-awww, what the hell is up with these dudes?

Kalisto, Gran Metalik and Lince Dorado are all fine workers, but they're handled with about as much care by creative as three job guys getting $150 a night. Compare how Lucha Bros are presented in AEW by comparison, and things become even more alarming. House Party should be having matches like Fénix and Pentagón Jr do.

It's not that the Lucha Bros get hot storylines, killer promos or top billing on Dynamite or AEW pay-per-views, it's that the bookers there know their strengths. WWE's writers don't seem to know how to use Kalisto and pals, so they just stick them out there as house show filler or to make up the numbers in multi-man tags.

If there's one obvious flaw in WWE's plan (if they even have one) for Lucha House Party, it's that they're rarely allowed to look like a threat. This makes it super-difficult for the trio to get fans into their matches, and it usually results in mass toilet breaks when they come out.


6. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali Samoa Joe
WWE.com

A mass toilet break could sum up Mustafa Ali's recent fortunes too, because WWE's handling of his progressive, inspirational character has been sh*t.

Ali's last televised match on SmackDown was a tag-team loss alongside Shorty G to The Revival on the 13 December 2019 episode. Since then, he's barely been seen outside of house shows, but one thing's for certain: Mustafa will show back up in those street-walking promos sometime soon.

They're part of the problem. Ali has been cutting the same speech for almost a year now, and he's been promising change without delivering once. That's on WWE. They're the ones who should've moved onto something more by now, and they're the ones who should realise that inserting random gaps between these vignettes doesn't trick people into thinking they're seeing something new.

It's unclear what Vince McMahon wants from Ali. He can fly, he can act as nice babyface foil for physically larger heels and he's shown he has more charisma than WWE probably thought going in. Despite all that, he's wasted.


5. EC3

EC3 WWE
WWE.com

Fans who watched him in TNA years ago must be sitting around scratching their heads and wondering when the real EC3 is going to show up again. Back when he was playing the role of Dixie Carter's privileged nephew and cutting intense, believable sit-down promos, EC3 looked like someone WWE would love a second chance with.

So much for that.

Since returning to WWE, Carter has done little besides become one of the never-ending NXT call-ups who has failed on Raw or SmackDown. His last memorable moments came against Dean Ambrose before he left and revived his own career as Jon Moxley in New Japan and AEW. That pretty much says everything right there.

EC3 has been starved of TV minutes to get himself over, and there's no sign that things will change once he returns from a recent concussion. A place like Impact or the NWA could do wonders with Carter if they were able to sign him again. Maybe, following recent reports, they'll get that opportunity soon.


4. Shinsuke Nakamura

Shinsuke Nakamura WWE
WWE

This writer has never really viewed Shinsuke Nakamura as a good fit for WWE. When others were fawning over the 'King Of Strong Style' and his work in NXT, yours truly cast a worried glance towards the future. Shin was doomed as soon as he arrived on SmackDown in 2018.

He couldn't rely solely on in-ring skills there.

Ever since then, Nakamura has turned heel (a role he's visibly more comfortable in) and enlisted Sami Zayn as a manager who cuts promos for him. That was a shrewd decision, but it can't alter the fact that Shinsuke has never really related to WWE's casual audience. To them, he's an overhyped workhorse who flopped in the main event scene.

In his native Japan, things would be very different. The 39 year old former New Japan great would tear the house down if he returned home and managed to motivate himself. That's proving a challenge in WWE's system; here, Naka looks like he's going through the motions constantly.


3. Cesaro

Cesaro WWE
WWE

So does his on/off tag partner Cesaro.

The Swiss strongman has been fighting a losing battle ever since Vince McMahon made those cursed "brass ring" comments on Steve Austin's podcast years ago. Things were briefly remedied by putting him in an excellent tag-team with Sheamus, and yet here he is – Cesaro is right back where he started.

Though he's not the greatest talker out there, Cesaro's in-ring skills should offset that. When he's left to his own devices between the ropes, he's a quite remarkable worker (watch his matches with Aleister Black at Extreme Rules 2019, or the cracker he had with Ilja Dragunov at NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff) who can adapt well to anyone's style.

WWE don't appreciate what Cesaro brings to the table, and that's sad. At 39, his best years are behind him now, so it'd be nice to see the he who's doomed never to get that top singles run under Vinnie Mac break out and get one somewhere else.


2. Shorty G

Shorty G entrance
WWE

When Sheamus returned and started a feud with Shorty G, it was hoped that the pair would have some ridiculously good matches and maybe, just maybe, show WWE what Chad Gable can do. The thing is, they know what he can do already. That hasn't stopped them from dressing him up like a dork from Saved By The Bell.

Who picked that outfit and thought, 'Yeah, that'll get him over'?

Gable is a former Olympian who can wrestle rings around most on the roster. Somehow, when they should be focusing on his athleticism, WWE are preoccupied with the fact that 'Shorty' isn't the same height as Big Show. His preposterous claims to have dealt with his lack of size (like it's a handicap in life) are worsened upon realising he's roughly the same height as some taking the p*ss out of him.

Shorty G should be having mouth-watering, chain-wrestling-infused clashes with guys like Dolph Ziggler, Cesaro and Daniel Bryan. He isn't. Nah, apparently looking like a Space Jam cosplayer is preferable booking for WWE.


1. The Revival

The Revival
WWE.com

Nobody deserves to be in the top slot here more than The Revival.

Dash and Dawson exhibit classic tag-team traits. They're watertight in the ring, use teamwork to overcome opponents and manage to take losses in stride without looking too foolish. On the mic, they're solid if hardly flashy, and they're respected by fans who like the duo's nods towards old-school tag wrestling favourites like The Brain Busters or Hart Foundation.

If this was 1989, The Revival might be handed Bobby Heenan as manager and secure their place as one of the top heel teams in the company for good. In 2020, they're persistently linked with a move away from WWE and look like they'll be plying their trade elsewhere by the end of the year. It seems unfair.

WWE doesn't deserve to have a tag-team like The Revival working for them. Sooner or later, Dash and Dawson will get to enjoy the money they've earned over the past few years and creatively relish working tags in the revived NWA or AEW. That, when it happens, will give them purpose again.

Who else do you think is wasted on WWE right now? For more, check out 10 Potential WWE WrestleMania 36 Opponents For John Cena and WWE 2K21: 10 Most Wanted New Features!


In this post: 
Matt Hardy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.