10 Wrestlers Who Could Debut (Or Return) On AEW Collision
CM Punk isn't coming to AEW Collision alone - so who will be joining him?
Dave Meltzer, writing in the 28th April Wrestling Observer Newsletter, left an important assertion that may have sweeping ramifications for All Elite Wrestling's impending future:-
“The show, believed to be called AEW Collision, as noted last week, is expected to debut on 6/17 with a show from 8-10 pm. Eastern, from the United Center in Chicago, which would also be the return of CM Punk along with what is expected to be either another major name debut or return.”
AEW has seldom failed as it pertains to their bombshell debuts and comebacks. The most recent Dynamite proved as such when Roderick Strong, universally believed to be controlled under the limitations imposed by an NXT contract, orchestrated a genuinely and authentically surprising arrival in AEW. His exodus from WWE went unmentioned, as is WWE's disregard for acknowledging NXT talents' departures.
For this rumoured debut/return, a talent of a higher calibre is required. That's not a dig on Strong - your writer raved over his ROH and PWG work - but given the nature of who they'd be resurfacing alongside, and where and when they'd be doing so, any random WWE castoff won't suffice. CM Punk's resurgence will be the dominant talking point, so Tony Khan would receive astronomical humiliation for sending out a Bodhi Hayward or a Flash Morgan Webster.
He needs to be finicky and precise in his choice because with the right meeting, maybe, just maybe, he can coax another wrestler out of retirement...
10. AJ Mendez
AJ Mendez is a generational professional wrestler.
Before her unforeseen April 2015 retirement, the once longest-reigning Divas Champion was a needle-mover in the viewpoint of women's wrestling, competing as the archetypical anti-Diva by lambasting the so-called 'cast' of Total Divas, and putting weight and meaning back into the very title she famously held. The influence put on her career by similar empowering female figures - Lita, Trish Stratus, Molly Holly, et al - was palpable; AJ wrestled an antithetical style that didn't push itself through until after she'd retired, calling it a day at a period where she'd cultivated an imposing body of work without anything left to achieve. The Women's Tag Team titles weren't in existence yet. Neither were women's Royal Rumble, Money in the Bank, or Elimination Chamber matches, but AJ's crusade for greater treatment and opportunity led to such achievements being inaugurated.
Unfortunately, the nature of her retirement wasn't as straightforward as it may read - cervical spine damage unequivocally forced her to hang up her Converse.
An executive producer and colour commentary role in Women of Wrestling scans as a small-scale resurgence for AJ ahead of a major landing point; ruling out an in-ring comeback, this is a role she could slot into in AEW to strengthen a usually-fledging women's division.
9. Kyle O'Reilly
As has become something of a running joke within AEW, its index of hurt talent maintains a high figure, but arguably no current injury is of more concern than Kyle O'Reilly's.
Last wrestling a thrilling encounter vs. Jon Moxley on the 8 June Dynamite, itself the penultimate act to crown an interim AEW World Champion in the wake of CM Punk's wounds, KOR has been kept out of action by a series of nagging neck and shoulder injures accumulated from an eighteen-year career. He is expected to make a full rehabilitation, but when and where his comeback is declared is currently anyone's guess.
Given Adam Cole recently being given the all-clear after his own battle with injury and Roderick Strong's very recent arrival in the Tony Khan-fronted organisation, a Kyle O'Reilly return would be best placed within the next month or so, particularly as it pertains to Cole and Britt Baker's ongoing saga with both The Jericho Appreciation Society and The Outcasts, if he's good to go mind. Pushing Kyle too hard too quickly runs the risk of his remedies becoming undone, and so, like Adam Cole, perhaps a non-active comeback may suit him better before his first match a few weeks thereafter.
8. Andrade El Idolo
AEW's reputed brand split is said to be coming into effect when Collision launches and if bridges are being built to get CM Punk back on board, it may be prudent to do the same with Andrade El Idolo.
Publicly airing his own resentment of Sammy Guevara, the ex-NXT Champion was swiftly sent home and suspended, where he's remained since. That was in October, almost one month to the day of the infamous events that led to Punk's apparent second exit from professional wrestling, though Andrade hadn't actually wrestled since the day of Punk's actions, 4 September's All Out; in this instance, it's been a torn pectoral surgery that's kept El Idolo out, not merely a suspension.
Andrade would be better suited on AEW's Saturday show. Reports from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter indicate that Wednesday's Dynamite crew will be headed up by The Elite and Blackpool Combat Club, whereas Saturday's Collision will have CM Punk and FTR at its forefront. It provides AEW's best opportunity yet to restore buzz in some of its otherwise secondary, Andrade being a key example. He's not been a top draw since his June 2021 arrival. Admittedly, he may never fulfil AEW's vision of such a role, but he absolutely should, and Collision will be the best place to test the waters for his ascendancy.
7. The Garcia Twins
You may not want it to happen, depending on if you have taste or not, but The Garcia Twins will be All Elite eventually.
If they weren't, why would they have left WWE? They're no longer full-time pro wrestlers seeking a new opportunity elsewhere, so predicting Nikki and Brie Bella to remain WWE ambassador lifers would have at one time been considered an educated prognosis.
News of the twins' free agency and brand identity switch came days after they were seen backstage at AEW's Revolution, prompting vigorous conjecture that they were in the process of signing with the other major wrestling group in North America. Nikki, specifically, was quick to cut this guesswork down during an Instagram livestream, stating her and Brie's visit as being exactly that - a visit:-
"We are not going to AEW. I know, I've seen a lot of that because, I think, we were just there visiting Renee and Paige...I was like, I haven't had the opportunity to take Matteo backstage to a wrestling event and when he knew uncle Bryan was going to be there, Matteo loves his uncle Bryan, Brie and I were like, we have to go see Bryan. The kids had so much fun."
Believe her if you want, but it reads as her failed attempts at throwing fans off the scent. Like AJ Mendez, the twins may never be full-time pro wrestlers again, but bringing them out for a nostalgia run now and again would be wholly acceptable, if they're not strictly in ambassadorial roles.
6. Miro
Miro, in 2021, legitimately could have carved out a path toward the AEW World title.
As TNT Champion, he played the stereotypical foreign heel champion role as inversed as he could. Rather than playing heavily into the WWE-like mannerisms of literally any foreign champion ever, Miro instead bulldozed challengers. He was authentic in doing so; at a compact six foot and 304-pounds, you honestly believed that 'The Redeemer' could have suitably crushed Dante Martin with his bare hands or snapped Lance Archer in half with the Game Over. It was arguably his career-best work - and then it suffered an abhorrent climax.
Dropping the title to Sammy Guevara was, at the time, a compelling moment for the AEW original. Miro's successor wasn't the issue. His booking post-TNT title was.
He dropped the title on the 30 September 2021 Dynamite and has wrestled a combined seven matches in the twenty months that have followed. Admittedly, chunks of this time have seen Miro both injured and absent while filming CBS' East New York, however, Fightful stated that he'd been fit for a while. If he is indeed ready to return, why hasn't he?
Like Andrade El Idolo, Miro could ostensibly become a top star to propel AEW's impending new show. If Tony Khan wants a new monster heel to domineer the opposition, he's got it sitting in front of him.
5. Thunder Rosa
Thunder Rosa is not liked.
It's an understatement to say as much, but it rings true, given that in the hopes of revitalising a relationship between the former Women's World Champion and her peers, an AEW management-led meeting was held prior to the 8 February Dynamite. Whether the meeting was successful or not remains a mystery.
News of relationships having frayed between Rosa and numerous AEW talent won't be new information to many. Brought into AEW in late 2020, the ex-NWA star has been accused of sandbagging opponents, working stiffly, and conducting herself in such a manner that her colleagues came across as bullies. Britt Baker, specifically, isn't keen on Rosa as a person, doubling down on such claims more often than not in interviews. "I stand by everything I said", Britt uttered to SLAM Wrestling in March, questioning why Thunder Rosa was traveling for other work-related commitments when she wasn't doing so regularly for AEW tapings.
In short - keep Britt Baker on Dynamite and have Thunder Rosa on Collision, or vice versa. The former is adamant she'll continue working with Rosa as she's aware of what draws money; drama. If that's what Tony Khan wants, go ahead. To maintain a positive backstage environment for the women's roster though, keep the pair separated for a while.
4. Mandy Rose
Mandy Rose doesn't need to actively pursue a return to professional wrestling.
Refusing to rule out a WWE comeback has been a rigid statement reassured by Rose in the wake of her 14 December release, telling AEW's Renee Paquette via her Sessions podcast that it wasn't her "main focus". Why should it be? The former WWE star made $1 million in December via FanTime alone! She needn't ever make a return to the squared circle, but it's evident she wants to. Mandy refused to divulge any disgruntlement aimed at WWE to Tamron Hall. Instead, she expressed gratitude and thankfulness to the sports entertainment brand.
A WWE comeback indeed may be in Rose's mind moving forward, although she'd be foolish not to envisage what her future would look like elsewhere. She's the sort of WWE release who'd work deftly in IMPACT Wrestling, as Trinity Fatu seemingly already has, but AEW would benefit most from her.
AEW's women's division, in essence, is entirely contradictory to what Mandy Rose's aura is based on. She's a modernised take on the Diva adage unwillingly forced upon any female WWE talent pre-2015 - which is precisely why she'd thrive in AEW. A solid hand between the ropes and on the microphone, a two-for-one concept scarce to AEW-contracted talent, Rose is the missing piece of the puzzle for a complete AEW women's roster.
3. Kota Ibushi
Kota Ibushi is a foundational pillar of modern Japanese wrestling. Masterfully combining the quintessentially potent puroresu art-form with sleek springboards, 'The Golden Star' hadn't proven himself as a golden star since October 2021, a serious injury and subsequent issues with NJPW management keeping him in the dark until he reached free agent status as of 1 February.
Ibushi has since wowed audiences in North America. Two matches over WrestleMania 39 weekend - vs. Joey Janela and vs. Mike Bailey - received rave reviews, though noticeably contrasting to what a conventional Kota Ibushi match looks like. There was a distinct lack of Neck Stuff, the foolhardy, almost negligent style in which Kota is typically known for; turning 41 on 21 May, Ibushi is wise to tone this style down, at most using it strictly in marquee matches.
Such as his AEW debut.
With each passing week, a new hypothesis emerges on how, exactly, the inaugural IWGP World Heavyweight Champion will arrive in All Elite Wrestling, the most popular being his joining The Elite in their saga vs. Blackpool Combat Club. It makes the most sense, given Kota's esteemed history with Kenny Omega, and it'd certainly allow for some glossy contests, given the antagonists involved.
A one-night-only venture to Collision for The Elite and BCC, coinciding with his expected debut, would certainly make the launch of Collision on par with Dynamite's audacious beginning.
2. Mercedes Moné
A favoured guess for the AEWxNJPW Forbidden Door 2 match card is that of an AEW Women's World title bout pitting Jamie Hayter, the champion as of press time, against Mercedes Moné.
But Moné must appear beforehand.
Last year, the build to the inaugural Forbidden Door was critically hampered by a lack of NJPW talent on AEW programming in the build to the auspicious pay-per-view. Kazuchika Okada, for instance, only rocked up on the last Dynamite before Forbidden Door; promoting an Okada bout on this Dynamite following his debut the week before would've proven more opportune.
Such is the case with Mercedes Moné. A recent Fightful Select report indicated that Mercedes isn't expected back in Japan "for a while" following her aforementioned loss of NJPW's Women's title on 23 April to Mayu Iwatani. She will, however, be competing in North America imminently, competing in a four-woman tournament for the newly-introduced STRONG Women's title on 21 May. This only adds further substance to the fire that is her sanguine AEW debut, and thus having the former IWGP Women's Champion arrive on the 17 June Collision, ideally by Hayter, before wrestling on the 24 June Collision ahead of Moné vs. Hayter the day after is a succinct piece of booking that Tony Khan is routinely known for.
1. Goldberg
When AEW launched, were they expected to land Sting?
When AEW launched, were they expected to land Christian Cage?
When AEW launched, were they expected to land...Bill Goldberg?!
Indeed, 'Da Man' is a free agent following the expiration of his latest WWE contract, bringing to an end his inexplicable comeback tour that began in 2016 and bafflingly brought with it TWO runs as Universal Champion. Goldie won't become AEW World Champion any time soon because unlike both of his former employers, All Elite Wrestling values its World title - but he could debut on Collision.
Tony Khan has openly discussed the possibility of Goldberg, one of the Ted Turner-helmed organisation's prominent in-house talents, signing for AEW. Speaking to The Bet Las Vegas' Adrian Hernandez, TK affirmed that Goldberg was one of the biggest active names in pro wrestling, noting that it'd be one for AEW to keep an eye on:-
"Bill is an exceptionally exciting name and one of the biggest names in the sport. It's certainly a big thing for us to pay attention to. I would take notice of that. It's interesting."
News of AEW's United Kingdom debut on 27 August has brought forth speculation that there, Goldberg may wrestle his final match alongside Darby Allin and ex-WCW rival Sting, which coincidentally may also be 'The Icon's farewell, too.
Would Tony Khan do it?
You tell us.