10 Wrestlers Who Got TERRIBLE Advice From WWE
Goldberg, Randy Orton, D-Generation X and others who got awful WWE advice.
Everyone has received some bad advice before.
It could be something as simple as an errant financial decision that ends up costing you money, or maybe you're the sort who'd follow 'Stone Cold's' lead by hitting your boss with a Stunner when they ask you to work weekends. Usually, such things (maybe not the Stunner) are easily fixed, but what do you do when you're a pro wrestler and the company you work for doles out that obviously-dreadful guidance?
Sadly, workers in that position don't have many choices. They could yell, "I'm not f*cking doing that" before ringing up another promotion looking for work. Or, and this is more likely, they'll grit their teeth, get on with it and try to make the best of a bad situation whilst praying that the powerbroker sees sense eventually.
WWE are no strangers to dishing out terrible advice. Vince McMahon and pals have told some of the best wrestlers on the planet to do things their way or else, and that has led to some truly awful content that helped nobody.
Here's the worst of it, and the impact their dodgy input had...
10. Big Show Must Cut The Same Promo
Behold Paul Wight's concerned features.
The big man was surely bracing himself for another round of, "I'm 7ft tall and weigh 500lbs" chatter in the pic above. After all, WWE asked Big Show to do that constantly - it was like they'd written "must reference size" into the giant's company contract.
This was troublesome for Show. Via 'Talk Is Jericho', he recently moaned about having to repeat the same things over and over any time he had a mic in his hands. Did The Undertaker have to remind everyone that he was an undead supernatural zombie force in his prime? No, so why did Wight have to self-reference the obvious?
Regurgitating the same lines proved to be a colossal pain in the t*ts for Show, but Vince McMahon wouldn't have it any other way. He even told his writing staff to get even more banter about the man's physical stature in there whenever Paul was scripted to talk.
That left Show feeling like a robot, and made it harder for him to cut natural promos.
9. Rusev Should Ignore The Writers
Here's another McMahon pearler.
It's also another story from Chris Jericho's pod. On it, AEW's Miro recalled giving Angel Garza a pasting because the handsome devil had gone against a script the then-Rusev had been told. Garza wasn't wrong though; nobody had told Ru that Angel would stay in-ring after winning with a quick roll-up rather than scampering to safety.
That incensed Miro, so he gave Garza a kicking and tossed him out of the ring. Backstage, Vince told Rusev that the writers were "trying to bury [him] out there". The ticked-off Bulgarian, realising that nothing happened without McMahon's say-so, looked quizzically at his boss.
His puzzled looked worsened when Vince then told him to continue being aggressive no matter what the script called for. Why would Rusev do that when McMahon had clearly helped write the thing in the first place? It was all so counter-productive, and it hinted at some schism between boss and creative that he knew didn't exist.
8. Vader’s Insecurities Should Be On TV
"I ain't nothing but a big piece of sh*t. A big fat piece of sh*t!".
Those were Vader's words at the Over The Edge 1998 pay-per-view after losing to Kane. The behemoth then went on to wonder, "Maybe Vader Time is over?" before skulking away solemnly. This, dear reader, was a clear attempt to boot the powerhouse's arse into gear and embarrass him into shedding the pounds.
It wasn't fun to watch.
Jim Ross has spoken on his podcast before about how Vader and Yokozuna were sent to a weight loss camp for conditioning in the late-90s. Both struggled with the concept, but it certainly cannot have helped Vader's psyche to be told that he had to publicly humiliate himself on live television beforehand.
Turning the man's very-real issues into a self-loathing storyline achieved nothing. It shattered his once-proud monster aura with fans, and it exposed the WWF's inherent need to use someone's real-life fragility as a plot point on camera.
7. Chavo Guerrero Must Denounce His Heritage
Man, this was awful.
In 2005, Vinnie Mac approached Chavo Guerrero and told him that he'd be rebranded as "Kerwin White" - an emphasis was placed on the surname, because the hispanic wrestler would become "a white guy" (Chavo told Chris Van Vliet's show that those were the boss man's very words).
Basically, Guerrero was going to ditch his famous family name and turn into a soft version of Donald Trump years before he was the US President. This was clearly going to be sh*t, and Chavo probably knew it. Still, he wanted to do his best and agreed to the switch.
Months later, following the death of his uncle Eddie, Chavo scrapped the unsavoury gimmick.
Asking Guerrero to denounce his heritage and play what was effectively a white supremacist was in severely bad taste. People can hide behind any 'oh, the world was different back then' claims they like, but this still felt wrong in '05.
6. Dr. Death Needs To Win Shoot Fights
Steve Williams was hired for one reason and one reason only: 'Dr. Death' would be a fine (and realistically threatening) foe for Steve Austin somewhere down the line. The promotion's big challenge was prepping Williams for that run. Did they feed him babyfaces and put him on a winning streak before gunning for 'Stone Cold'?
Nah, they put the grizzled veteran with knackered knees in a series of shoot fights and just expected him to win. That'll work, lads! The whole 'Brawl For All' idea centred around Death's push, but it went belly up when Bart Gunn zoomed in out of nowhere to literally blast his way through the competition and win it all.
Meanwhile, Williams got knocked out in the second round and tore his hamstring in the process. His main event dreams went up in smoke, and the WWF were left with a legit hard nut (Gunn) that they didn't want. Someone really should've told Williams that this shoot tourney probably wasn't in his best interests.
Testosterone and macho pride got the best of everyone there.
5. Randy Orton Needs To Smile More
Randy Orton's appearance on the Steve Austin-led 'Broken Skull Sessions' show was a treasure trove of insightful stories and revelations from the man himself. At one point, Randy told a baffled Austin that WWE asked him to "smile more" during his first World Heavyweight Title run in 2004.
That advice collided with some other requests.
The company also wanted Orton to be menacing and present himself as a worthy World Champ when he was in front of crowds. Which one was it? Was he to grin from ear-to-ear in front of the people, or hold his head up high and do his best Derek Zoolander impression by busting out some 'Blue Steel'?
Smiling loads didn't come easy to Orton, mainly because he'd been playing a cocky young brat heel in Evolution for years before winning the belt. The smiley babyface gig didn't suit him at all, and it came across as totally put on or insincere to fans.
4. Brock Lesnar Should Never Sell
Brock Lesnar's matches with The Rock, Kurt Angle, John Cena, Goldberg, The Undertaker and countless others all had one thing in common: Brock sold for his opponents. He's deceptively good at that, and doesn't mind selling his ass off for smaller workers like AJ Styles or Daniel Bryan when the time is right either.
WWE producers originally told him never to do that.
It's criminal to think that one of wrestling's best sellers could've been lost here, but it's true. Paul Heyman once revealed during a live Q&A session that Tazz overhead company agents warning Lesnar that he better no-sell everything like some invincible brick wall "Russian character" back in 2002.
Tazz was appalled by that idea, and asked Heyman to intervene. The ex-ECW chief did, and he ended up becoming good friends with Brock. Imagine how different Lesnar's career could've been had he been cast as Kurrgan II? It doesn't bear thinking about.
Paul E's nous helped shine Brock's skills up instead of restricting them.
3. Goldberg Needs “More Personality”
Goldberg was a huge get for WWE when they finally signed him in 2003. Suddenly, fans who had enjoyed his wrecking ball antics in WCW would get to see him clash with fresh opponents like The Rock, 'Taker, Triple H and others in money-spinning pay-per-view battles, and it'd kick ass.
Then they put a wig on him.
Bruce Prichard has defenced such lunacy on his 'Something To Wrestle With' pod before. The WWE higher-up said that Goldberg needed some "more personality", and argued that fans wouldn't accept his squash-match style in '03. That sounds like someone clutching at straws, and it's likely untrue.
Goldberg knew starring in wacky skits (like the wig one with Goldust) was a mistake too. He later admitted in interviews that he should've turned such nonsense down and pushed for the formula that had rocketed him to super-stardom in the first place six years prior - he didn't though, and WWE believed hamming it up would endear Bill to a new generation of wrestling fans.
2. DX Must Be More Wholesome
The WWF was changing in late-1997.
Vince McMahon's family-friendly sheen of before gave way to a much more seductive style that'd appeal to an anti-authority generation. Sex, cursing and general sophomoric antics became the rule of thumb, and D-Generation X were the clown princes of McMahon's bold new direction.
Not everyone liked it. The USA Network, for example, warned Vince to tone things down. Specifically, they wanted DX to cease their juvenile behaviour, quit yelling things like "Suck It" and stop shoving socks down their shorts to make it look like they had massive penises.
Under pressure from the network, Vince pleaded with Shawn Michaels and Triple H to tone it down, but they wouldn't listen. Amazingly enough, USA stopped being so worried about the suggestive content when ratings started going through the roof. Imagine that.
DX proceeded to push the envelope even further. They had to, 'cause a PG-style faction that promised rebellion wasn't going to cut it.
1. Steve Austin Shouldn’t Talk (At All)
Steve Austin is one of the best talkers in wrestling history.
That's obvious to anybody who has ever watched his work as 'Stone Cold', and it should've even been clear to those who checked him out in WCW or ECW. Apparently, nobody in the WWF gave a hoot about what was happening in Atlanta or Philadelphia, which is why Austin was told not to talk when he signed for the fed in 1995.
Instead, Vince McMahon handed Austin a manager. Ted DiBiase, himself a tremendous promo man, would do all the talking for Steve, and that was that. Austin knew this was crap, and he must've been horrified when he was constantly reminded never to interrupt Ted or even open his mouth at all.
The guy had just found his mojo as a talker in ECW (thanks to Paul Heyman's prodding), and here was acting mute. The WWF's opinion on that would change following Austin's King Of The Ring '96 win. It was about time too.
Which other WWE stars got dreadful advice? For more wrestling, check out 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (March 29) and 10 Wrestlers Whose Stock Has Risen The Most Since WWE WrestleMania 36!