10 Wrestlers Who NEED A Huge 2024
It's crunch time for these WWE, AEW and NJPW stars.
The dawning of a new year - no point on the calendar bristles with more possibility. From resolutions and personal improvement to career goals, the cracking open of a fresh calendar is usually a cause for unbridled optimism.
When it comes to these ten wrestlers, though, it’s less blue sky thinking and more last chance saloon. For reasons in and, more often, out of their control, they’re not where they’d like to be in the business right now. Whether it’s down to bad booking, a lack of TV time, or the cruel but reliable ticking of the clock, these superstars simply need 2024 to go their way.
For some wrestlers, this is a note of caution rather than a dire prognosis. For others, things don’t look so rosy, with momentum and the finite nature of wrestling careers very much against them.
There are so many things that can reshape and redefine a career in the squared circle, from fan interest to injury to sheer self promotion. Whatever it takes, though, these performers had better grab the bull by the horns, before it’s too late.
10. Ruby Soho
It’s been a funny run in AEW for Ruby Soho, who seems to have floated on the periphery of major success since she landed on these shores. Introduced as the Joker of a battle royale and given star treatment by the way of licensed music, WWE’s loss seemed set to be Tony Khan’s gain.
While she has enjoyed the spotlight from time to time, in two Owen Hart Foundation Tournaments most notably, Ruby Soho’s star has been consistently outshone. Most recently Toni Storm demonstrated that the best thing you can do if you’re a member of The Outcasts is to leave The Outcasts, becoming as over as she’s ever been by ditching the spraypaint and weird, adolescent behaviour.
The soapy stuff with Angelo Parker feels a step in the right direction, but not a particularly large one.
Soho has the attitude and the mic skills and has had a few decent matches, but if her time in AEW is going to be worth more than it was in WWE, she needs far more substantive booking as soon as possible. It doesn’t help that screen time for the women is in short supply to start with, mind.
9. Shingo Takagi
There’s an element of grading on a curve here, of course, as by any reasonable metric, Shingo Takagi isn’t exactly in a bad place. His 2023 saw exceptional matches against Aaron Henare and Will Ospreay, as well as another run with the NEVER Openweight Championship.
Not exactly thin gruel, then - but compared to where it looked like Takagi was headed three years ago, it’d be fair to say he’s off the pace. In March 2021, he became the IWGP World Heavyweight Champion for the first time, beating company ace Kazuchika Okada for the vacant belt. A lengthy reign of over 200 days was eventually ended by… Kazuchika Okada.
NJPW’s main event scene has felt a little stale for a while now, but Takagi hasn’t been utilised back in that top slot in the years hence. He has lost repeatedly to Okada since and had poor showings in the New Japan Cup and G1 Climax. Bafflingly he was restricted to Forbidden Door’s pre-show this time around.
Takagi’s highlights reel can’t be denied, to say less of his talent, but it’s hard not to feel he should be doing more than he has been since that run on top.
8. Britt Baker
While self promotion is of course a major part of professional wrestling, it’s never a good sign when a superstar has to take to X to air their grievances about their employer, and worse still when they do so in a manner that’s completely devoid of kayfabe and, indeed, fun.
One can hardly blame Britt Baker for being disgruntled at a lack of TV time, and she’s well within her rights to draw fans’ attention to the fact she’s had zero minutes of on-air promo this year. For one of AEW’s finest homegrown success stories, she certainly seems to be taken for granted at present. For every highlight - Wembley Stadium, a fantastic TBS title match with Kris Statlander - there have been weeks and months of inactivity.
Baker has said on AEW All Access that she’s none too interested in being champion again, but to write her off altogether seems crazy, even ungrateful treatment of a woman who’s shed a lot of blood for the company. Depending on how Jade Cargill gets on in WWE, Baker will surely be weighing up her options.
7. Bobby Lashley
If the best has been and gone for Bobby, he certainly exceeded expectations in his second WWE spell. The formerly bland powerhouse finally tapped into the perfect character, mean, edgy, and cool, and thoroughly deserved his championship runs and WrestleMania barnburner against Drew McIntyre.
If the 47 year old Lashley were to be phased out, it would be understandable, but he occupies a weird hinterland at present. When he pops up, the fans are thrilled to see him, and the nu-Hurt Business he’s been brewing with the Street Profits feels a no-brainer, a win-win-win for all involved.
There’s a reticence about the whole thing, though. The trio’s first match was a baffling loss to the LWO, and from there, forward motion has been hard to find.
It feels like the easiest booking in the world, especially in a WWE replete with groups and factions, but all we’ve got is shots of Lashley looking cross or pleased with his new mentees depending on how violent they’ve been. If this is the last chapter in Bobby’s WWE career, he deserves a good one.
6. Jay White
A near-faultless AEW rookie year for Jay White was brought to a crashing end in All Out’s main event. White losing to MJF felt a fait accompli going in, with a build that had its moments but trod a lot of water. The match itself, though, was genuinely damaging. White threw everything he had at a one-legged, match worn Max and still failed to get the win.
The overbooked mess of a blow off was particularly annoying because the two surely would have had a fantastic bout under normal circumstances, but for White, the plummet down the card feels worrying. He’s picking up wins in the Continental Classic, but no longer feels the arch heel capable of pushing the company’s top babyface to his limits.
This is Jay White we’re talking about, mind you. He’s as good a guarantee for a great match as the company has (bar Danielson), and still boasts a hugely impressive win-loss ratio for whatever that’s worth.
That he does need a rebuild so early in his tenure with the company, though, is worrying stuff.
5. Drew McIntyre
Is Drew McIntyre the unluckiest man in wrestling? 2020 was a stinker for us all, but McIntyre’s career-crowning moment occurring in an empty performance centre still feels cruel. Since then, there have been nearly-man vibes around the Scottish warrior, with ‘Mania 37, Clash At The Castle, and Crown Jewel all feeling like matches he could and even should have won, but didn’t.
With contract extension talk rumbling away, the situation seems obvious for McIntyre: WWE need to make it worth his while to stick around. There’s no doubt the company want him, but he has utility player vibes at present, someone who can slot into a main event at will but isn’t anywhere close to being The Guy.
The power would seem to be in Drew’s hands - but is it really? For all that he’s a terrific wrestler and a more than solid promo (and in spite of his extensive indie background), he feels distinctly WWE. Placing him on an AEW show would take some significant reshaping.
If WWE has its business in order, they’ll do the necessary to keep Drew around and give him what he wants. With a healthy contingent of top guys above him in the pecking order, though, it’s not impossible to see it going the other way.
4. Wardlow
It’s a fact well known amongst AEW sceptics that Tony Khan has far too many toys to play with, so it’s no surprise that some workers will struggle for TV amidst such a stacked roster. But how do you drop the ball so many times with a guy like Wardlow?
On paper he’s not far off being ur-wrestler. He looks great, he can talk well enough, with the right opponent he’s really fun in the ring. Most importantly, he has an aura, and as Big Bill will tell you, you can’t teach that. Throughout all his stop-start booking, the fans are always happy to see him back.
The blessing and curse is his tie to MJF. In recent memory he destroyed AEW’s world champion and, as he’s intermittently telling us, he has every intention of finishing the job, winning the belt. That’s built-in story. But what happens when MJF drops the belt (assuming - and one can assume this - it’s not to Wardlow)? Does Wardlow still feel like a guy who’d be pushing for the championship? Not in this state.
He’s a young man and so a year of bad booking wouldn’t spell the end of his wrestling career. What he also is, though, is a guy who’d fit in well up Connecticut way, and the way the winds are blowing, perhaps that’s what Tony should worry about.
3. Shayna Baszler
Without wanting to get off on an unduly negative foot: if you can be booked to beat Ronda Rousey, and subsequently still can’t get a push, it might be time to accept your company’s just never going to back you.
The strangest thing about Shayna Baszler is that WWE clearly knows exactly what to do with her; indeed someone who’s seen twenty minutes of wrestling would probably know what to do with her. Baszler has a legitimate fighting background, a scary aura, and a cocky, unkillable demeanour. So, like: let her do that.
When WWE has booked her thusly, in NXT and for the first three or so months of her main roster run, she was great. She had great title fights in her black and gold days, dominated a whole Elimination Chamber in hilarious fashion, and even bit a pregnant woman on TV. Ever since that ‘Mania loss, though, she’s stagnated.
It’s too late, bafflingly, to capitalise on the Rousey win, but Baszler so clearly offers something totally different on the roster that her lack of utilisation will always seem odd, no matter how many times they fumble.
2. Damian Priest
Of all the wrestlers on this list, Priest comes with the most glaring caveat: it can be assumed there are big plans in store for Senor Money In The Bank. Ever since Backlash and his masterpiece of mayhem with Bad Bunny, the company is clearly hot on the Bloodline leader, who carries TV storylines and the MITB briefcase alike.
That guaranteed contract, though, can be a poisoned chalice. Sometimes seen as a security blanket, its holder is often booked to lose a lot in the knowledge they’ve a world title redemption story lurking. As we’ve seen, though, it’s no guarantee that the briefcase winner will grab the brass ring - just look at Austin Theory.
Theory, at least, has time on his side. A clearer cautionary tale would be Baron Corbin, once a chosen man, now a wrestler whose inability to buy a win is fodder for NXT angles. Priest has been handled far more carefully than Corbin, but he’s been around the block, so if the trigger isn’t pulled now, it may never be.
Odds are, though, that the Bloodline leader gets his hands on gold in the coming months. How long for is another question (using him to transition between Rollins and Knight seems to make a lot of sense).
1. Andrade El Idolo
The curious case of Andrade El Idolo will mystify historians for years to come. There doesn’t seem to be any reason as to why he’s not a top guy, and yet with the brief exception of his NXT run, that potential never seems to be met.
On landing in AEW, it felt that the world would finally be his oyster, but this has never come to fruition. Few wrestlers of his talent have been so prone to disappearing off TV altogether, and his PPV bouts can be counted on one hand.
The dawn of Collision seemed like a clean slate for Andrade, who felt like one of the faces of the show. This lasted for a couple of weeks, in which he scrapped with House Of Black about a mask, but that seems to have fallen by the wayside too. The client-manager relationship with CJ Perry is thin gruel, especially as it’s pretty likely that angle ends with Miro battering him.
While Andrade can still be called upon for a scorching TV match, a man of his talents needs far more of a spotlight than he’s had for the past five years plus. 2024 needs to be his year.