10 Wrestlers Who Should Never Have Made WWE Royal Rumble's 'Final 4'

To think, Crush almost headlined WrestleMania.

crush shawn michaels royal rumble
WWE.com

The Royal Rumble is often jam-packed to the gills with top level talent. Sure, every year may have only one or two possible winners, but that doesn't mean the bout is two main event guys and 28 losers. The 30-man field is almost always made up of multi-time world champions, young stars, and top tier performers.

As such, we've seen some incredible groups make it to the final four of the match. In 2007, The Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, Randy Orton, and Edge battled it out at the death. Three years before, Edge, John Cena, Batista, and Michaels did the same. In 1992 the final four came down to Ric Flair, Sid Justice, Hulk Hogan, and Randy Savage, one year on from Hogan, Earthquake, Brian Knobbs, and Davey Boy Smith making it to the end.

Wait... Brian Knobbs?

Every now and then someone unexpected slips through the net and manages to find themselves in the mix at the end, outlasting genuine superstars to come within a whisker of earning a title shot at WrestleMania.

The glory never came, but the memories remain for these 10 (well, 11) superstars.


10. Fake Diesel

Fake Diesel
www.mtv.co.uk

After a few rough years, the 1997 Royal Rumble kicked off one of the most important calendar years in WWE history. As a result, the '97 Rumble was a much stronger field than years prior, with no less than 20 championship winners making up the 30 man field. Stone Cold Steve Austin was the controversial winner of the whole thing, running back in after elimination to outlast Bret Hart, Diesel, The Undertaker, and Vader.

That sounds incredibly strong on paper, but don't be fooled by the word 'Diesel' in there. This wasn't prime Big Sexy Kevin Nash, oh no. The Diesel who made it to the final four of the 1997 Royal Rumble (and was actually the final legal elimination, all things considered) was none other than Glenn Jacobs, better known as Kane, but also known as Fake Diesel and Isaac Yankem.

Fake Diesel didn't just luck out with a draw either. Jacobs entered the match at number 23, and lasted over 17 minutes before being thrown out by Bret Hart at the end, outlasting The Undertaker, Rocky Maivia, Mankind, and Vader, all of whom entered the match after him. Fake Diesel would continue to work live events, but this proved to be his final televised WWF appearance.


9. Bob Backlund And Rick Martel (1993)

Rick Martel Wwe
WWE

The WWE (then the WWF) was in a rough state at the beginning of the 1990s, as steroid scandals led to a number of major stars moving out of the spotlight, with some jumping ship to WCW. This meant that just one year after the most stacked Rumble in history of 1992, the Rumbles between 1993 and 1997 left a lot to be desired.

Yokozuna prevailed in the 1993 Royal Rumble, eliminating a clearly confused 'Macho Man' Randy Savage, who was attempting to pin the giant Samo-sorry, 'Japanese' wrestler. In pressing Savage over the top rope, Yokozuna became the first man to guarantee himself a WrestleMania main event by winning the Rumble. This was as close as Savage would ever come.

The other two men in the final four in 1993 would make an excellent trivia question. Joining Yoko and Savage were a 43-year-old Bob Backlund, and a past-his-prime Rick 'The Model' Martel. Martel was actually something of a legendary Royal Rumble competitor, but his best days were well behind him at this point.

For further proof of how thin the roster was at the time, the two other men who made up the final six were a High Energy-era Owen Hart and Repo Man of all people.


8. X-Pac (2000)

X Pac Kane Royal Rumble 2000
WWE.com

Every single year, the advantages of drawing number 30 in the Royal Rumble are thrown forward by the announcers. The last man to enter has a clear advantage over the other 29 competitors, the luckiest of lucky draws in a match that needs a whole lot of luck. Of course, the fact that The Warlord, Adam Bomb, Duke Droese, and Tugboat drew that number and did a whole lot of nothing is rarely brought up.

In 2000, the luckiest draw on offer almost came through X-Pac. Sean Waltman gets a whole heap of criticism, but the guy was a fairly valuable member of the WWF midcard back in the Attitude Era. Was he one of the four top contenders for a WrestleMania main event though? The WrestleMania 2000 closer had four men in it, an none of those men were X-Pac.

Pac even had the rub of a missed elimination, before vanquishing Kane with a spinning heel kick. He wouldn't last much longer however, getting press-slammed out by eventual runner-up, Big Show. That means that X-Pac managed to get eliminated twice in just three and a half minutes.


7. Billy Gunn (2001)

billy gunn mr ass
WWE.com

The 2001 Royal Rumble was another stacked contest. The Monday Night Wars were as good as over, and as a result a number of quality performers from WCW and ECW had defected to the WWF, wrestlers like Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, and more. The 2001 Rumble had a predictably stacked final four, with winner Stone Cold Steve Austin and runner-up Kane being joined by The Rock and Billy Gunn.

Yeah, Billy Gunn. WWE tried immensely hard to make Gunn a thing in the early 2000s, but they were simply pushing a lame duck. Gunn was a valuable hand on the card, but had spent far too much time languishing in the midcard and tag division for anyone to buy him as a potential main event performer come 2001.

To give a clearer image of how hard Gunn was being pushed, the man outlasted The Undertaker and a heavily pushed Rikishi to make it to the final four. Then packaged as 'The One', Gunn didn't even have his trademark bleached blonde hair at this point, a state of affairs that leads this writer to make an all-too-acceptable link between Gunn and Dolph Ziggler.


6. Fatu (1994)

Headshrinkers Samu Fatu
wwe.com

In truth, there is nothing wrong with a surprise making it into the final four, and the early '90s were a chance for such experimentation. The 1994 Royal Rumble ended with Lex Luger and Bret Hart co-winning the match, and the other men in the final four both went on to have long careers in the company. Shawn Michaels was one, and Rikishi was the other. Now, that doesn't sound so bad, does it?

Well, keep in mind that Rikishi wasn't Rikishi at the time, he was still Fatu. The Headshrinkers were a credible tag team but little else, solid hands but by no means a top team. As such, it must be considered strange for the Headshrinker to make it so far in the 1994 Royal Rumble.

There were other options. One year later Bam Bam Bigelow headlined WrestleMania, but here he managed to eliminate himself. Tatanka was over at the time, but Bigelow easily tossed him before the last. Heck, even Genichiro Tenryu was involved; surely he was a better option than one half of a middling tag team?

For perspective (and a familial link), this would be like Jey Uso making it to the final four in 2017. If that happens, I will eat my words.


5. Crush (1995)

Evil Crush
WWE

One year later and things weren't looking too great for the then-WWF roster. The 1995 Royal Rumble was one of the weakest in history, with Shawn Michaels entering at number one and in truth being the only option to win the entire thing. The roster was so weak that Henry O. Godwinn made the final five, and that seemed entirely reasonable.

Slightly less reasonable was the fact that post-Hawaii and pre-convict Crush made the final three. Crush had just returned to the company, and as a result was receiving his annual push in an attempt to make him a threat, which yet again ended in failure.

Such a failure in fact, that a few months later Crush was arrested for purchasing steroids and possessing an illegal gun. He would return to the company in 1996, for another failed run as a monster heel.


4. Kama (1996)

Kama WWE
WWE.com

Speaking of big men consistently being given pushes despite never really connecting with the crowd, WWE Hall of Famer Charles Wright is one of the biggest recipients of such a thing over WWE's history. Wright failed to get over as Papa Shango, 'The Supreme Fighting Machine' Kama, and good old Kama Mustafa, before finally finding success as a wrestling pimp, The Godfather. The man had an interesting career.

Whilst performing as TSFM, Kama somehow made it to the final four of the 1996 Royal Rumble. In fairness, Kama had feuded with The Undertaker throughout 1995, but after losing to the Deadman at SummerSlam he pretty much disappeared from TV. He returned for the Rumble, and promptly left again immediately after.

The '96 Rumble was the last truly weak Rumble, and a final four of Kama, Michaels, Diesel, and Bulldog was followed one year later by Bret Hart, Steve Austin, The Undertaker, and 'Diesel'. Well, fake Diesel, but that has already been discussed.


3. Hercules (1990)

Hercules Wwf
WWE.com

If X-Pac was the lucky recipient of the number 30 draw in 2000, a decade earlier the mighty Hercules (Jesse Ventura's words, not mine) was the lucky recipient of the number 29. By the time Herc' made it to the ring the match was all but over, as Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior had blown away the competition before their iconic stand-off. When Hercules got to the ring, there were three men plus number 30 left.

All of which meant that the final four was going to be Hogan, Mr. Perfect, 'Ravishing' Rick Rude, and one more, with the perennial WWF journeyman getting the nod for that fourth spot. The Barbarian made way, with his standing as a tag wrestler (at the time) possibly working against him back in 1990. Hercules was pretty much in the final four by default.

For modern context, think of this year's Rumble. Brock Lesnar and Goldberg have eliminated everyone, and then beaten the holy hell out of each other. Only four men are left to enter, and these four men are Konnor, R-Truth, The Miz, and Rusev. By the time Truth enters, Lesnar has been eliminated. Welcome to the final four, R-Truth!


2. Brian Knobbs (1991)

Brian Knobbs Earthquake Hulk Hogan Royal Rumble 1991
WWE.com

If Fatu was a strange choice for a final four spot in 1994, Brian Knobbs was a frankly mind-boggling one in 1991. The Nasty Boys weren't long in the WWF by January 1991, not long enough for the crowd to give two hoots about them in truth, and the only reason one can come up with for Knobbs lasting so long in this Rumble was to stack the odds against eventual winner, Hulk Hogan.

The final three of the '91 Rumble were Hogan, Knobbs, and Earthquake, with The British Bulldog the first of the final four to be eliminated. It wasn't as if the final stages of the Rumble were short on top heels either, as among the final eliminations were Mr. Perfect, Haku, and the then-record setting Rick Martel. Knobbs garnered no reaction upon entering, and nobody cared when he was eliminated.

In fact, Knobbs was so out of place that both Gorilla Monsoon and 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper on commentary only referred to him as 'one of The Nasty Boys'. The blonde Nasty Boy was pretty much anonymous in the match, and will almost certainly be the name most people miss when attempting such a quiz on Sporcle.


1. Kane & Big Show (2015)

Big Show Kane Dolph Ziggler Royal Rumble 2015
WWE.com

2014 and 2015 were grim years for the Royal Rumble, as the crowd's desperate love for Daniel Bryan overshadowed both matches. Bryan didn't even appear in 2014, but in 2015 WWE made the suicidal move of having Bryan enter and get eliminated early. This took the crowd out of the match, although the appearance of favourites like Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler gave the crowd something approaching hope.

It still baffles then that WWE thought it would be a good idea to have Big Show and Kane run through the field with ease, only to be thrown over the top by Roman Reigns at the last. In fact, the only thing that got bigger boos than Show and Kane's rampage was Reigns' attempts to eliminate them. Things were so bad that the crowd were chanting 'We Want Rusev', and no WWE crowd should be chanting in unison for a top heel.

Big Show knocked out Dolph Ziggler, and then Show and Kane dumped his lifeless body over the top rope. They did the same to Bray Wyatt, who had lasted over 45 minutes to that point. Ambrose got a chokeslam for his troubles, before being dumped over the top. With each elimination the apathy of the crowd increased, to the point where not even The Rock could bring things back onside.

Kane and Big Show had absolutely no place in the final four of the 2015 Royal Rumble, and that decision did harm not only to the match, but the future hopes of Roman Reigns. It will go down in history as one of the most misguided Rumbles in history, with a final four that must not be repeated.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.