10 Wrestlers Who Should Switch Companies
Wrestlers who really need a change of company to revitalise their careers
Sometimes in the grappling business it's quite possible to have wrestlers who possess the skills, the look and the promo ability but struggle in the company they're currently in.
Perhaps they don't fit into any current stories or the person pushing the pen simply doesn't like them anymore. Sometimes talent just don't get the TV time they perhaps deserve. Yet, wrestlers - and they suffer the consequences of this - are independent contractors, not employees. All of these things could be resolved by quitting their current place of employment and finding somewhere new, though turning down (theoretically) guaranteed money is easier said than done, and the path of least resistance is at least a simpler route in a notoriously complex industry.
They do however say that a change is a good as a holiday, and this is of particular importance in wrestling. For the first time in many years there's finally more than one viable mainstream company out there - the opportunities to have a change in scenery are far more prominent than they have been in years past.
Even this very list begins with a wrestler who would have a ready-made history to fall back on if they change company soon....
10. Bayley (WWE to AEW)
In a recent interview, Bayley spoke about how she has never been the type of person to barge down the office doors when they feel aggrieved about not being used on TV . Perhaps, she figured, this was the reason why she is sometimes overlooked. She then went on to allude to the biggest example of her being put to one side that was upcoming but didn't mention what it was. We later came to learn that this was the fact she was bumped off the card for WrestleMania 41 in favour of a returning Becky Lynch. It seems that nice girls do sometimes finish last.
The most frustrating thing about this from a fan point of view is that Bayley has been putting out some of her best work in the last five years. Her heel turn and subsequent pairing with real life friend Sasha Banks in the COVID years of WWE was brilliant. The storyline of losing her power over Damage CTRL in the run up to WrestleMania 40 was also wonderfully paced. Even after all of this there's a feeling that nobody in WWE sees her as a main event player anymore.
It would be best therefore if Tony Khan would have a word in her ear and bring her down to Jacksonville. Bayley still has plenty to offer in ring and reuniting with Mercedes Mone on an episode of Dynamite would truly get fans talking. Much like The Hurt Syndicate there would be plenty of distance left in AEW taking over an idea that WWE dropped the ball with.
9. Shinsuke Nakamura (WWE to AEW)
Has Shinsuke Nakamura's time in WWE been a success? If 'success' means being at the top of the card, main eventing WrestleMania for multiple years in a row and gaining a steady collection of belts in the process then probably not. If on the other hand you value a wrestler's happiness and consider their enjoyment of regular surfing sessions in the sea off the shore of Florida (judging by his Instagram account) then it's a certain yes. As is often the case, Nakamura treads a line between the two.
After a main event level career in New Japan the 'King of Strong Style' arrived in NXT in 2016 and tore the house down alongside Sami Zayn upon his debut. Hopes were indeed high that Nakamura could bring the hard hitting style alongside his natural charisma to the wider stage of WWE. The turning point came after Nakamura's win at the 2018 Royal Rumble. He went on to face a familiar foe in AJ Styles at WrestleMania. Fans were expecting something along the lines of their match at Wrestle Kingdom 10 inside the Tokyo Dome. Japanese Strong Style was surely about to hit the main event of WrestleMania. Sadly it ended up being just another match with the decision made at the end to turn Nakamura heel by having him low blow Styles in the post match sequence. It became something that would be repeated on numerous occasions in the weeks that followed, usually after Nakamura had been handed another defeat.
It appears that Nakamura will be letting his WWE contract expire soon and his next step in wrestling is is unclear. If he did want to make one last hurrah in the industry though then AEW might well be the place to reinvent himself. Alongside a lighter schedule matches against the likes of Will Ospreay, Konosuke Takeshita and Kenny Omega would await,
8. FTR (AEW to WWE)
The list of NXT talent who rocked it in developmental only for Vince to then lumber them with ridiculous storylines or gimmicks once they hit the main roster in long indeed. FTR, or The Revival as they were back then, are near the top of it. Known on the black and gold brand for their no nonsense, no flips just fists style they were a hark back to a king of wrestling that hadn't been seen in a while. They were also a fully fledged tag team rather than feeling like two random wrestlers stuck together. Quite why they were forced into a prank battle with The Usos upon arriving on the main roster is anybody's guess.
AEW seemed like a much more natural fit for them and they have indeed thrived in that company. They've won the AEW Tag Team Championships twice and have only recently turned heel on Adam Copeland.
There's still the feeling about what could have been back in WWE however as they never quite got that absolute barnstorming match on the main roster that they are so obviously capable of having. FTR left WWE alongside many other names who felt that the direction the company was going under Vince McMahon wasn't to their liking. Others such as Rusev and Alistair Black have since returned now that Triple H is in charge of creative. FTR would be a fantastic addition to the tag team division in WWE and there would be a chance to right so many wrongs from the first time around.
7. AJ Styles (WWE to AEW)
AJ Styles debut in WWE was one of the best Royal Rumble surprise entrants of recent years. The fact that the company managed to keep it a secret until the last possible second made the crowd reaction all the better. Not even the camera ingering on Roman Reigns squinting towards the aisle could ruin it. The man himself has done great things in WWE since then.
Despite the fact that people had doubts as to how far he would get in Stamford due to coming from 'elsewhere' he held the WWE Championship twice, the United State Championship three times and the Intercontinental Championship once. He also managed to get the phrase 'Beat up John Cena' over with the masses. These are additions to an already long list of accolades in the world of professional wrestling. He also had the honour of being the opponent for The Undertaker's last match at WrestleMania in 2020.
As he approaches what feels like the end of his career though there's a feeling that he's done everything there is to do in WWE as it stands and perhaps new surroundings could give him those last few challenges to round off an already glittering career. A match with Kenny Omega, referencing him replacing AJ as leader of The Bullet Club, surely writes itself? The sight of the two of them standing across the ring from each other at All Out next year would surely be something.
6. Wardlow (AEW to WWE)
Is there a bigger example of AEW's booking mishandling than Wardlow? There was a time in the early days of AEW that Wardlow could truly have been considered the first 'home grown' star of the company. After his run as MJF's bodyguard and subsequent face turn after handing the diamond ring to CM Punk it seemed like there was going to be a rocket strapped to him. What happened instead were three stuttering TNT Championship reigns followed by Wardlow being passed around factions.
He's currently with The Undisputed Kingdom and was introduced to the group by Adam Cole saying Wardlow would win the AEW Heavyweight Championship in the near future. It seems like an event very unlikely to happen now so distant is Wardlow's name from those conversations. Wardlow has spent years being the man who could have be AEW's break out star but never truly hitting his stride.
If Wardlow was given the time to develop as a singles wrestler and not be simply presented as somebody's sidekick then it's possible he could once again capture the magic of 'The Powerbomb Symphony' that captivated so many people in the early days of Dynamite. Perhaps a short stint in NXT would be the boost the man needs?
5. Andrade (WWE to AEW...again)
In the early days of the company AEW spent a lot of time and money signing wrestlers who were probably going to struggle for screen time under Vince McMahon's watch in WWE. The '...is All Elite' graphic was pushed on social media on a frequent basis. Andrade had a promising start to his career in WWE, the peak of which was being part of NXT's first five star match versus Johnny Gargano in 2018. After being sent to the main roster later that year he suffered the fate of many NXT wrestlers when the aura he had built in development didn't quite translate to Raw and Smackdown. He cut a frustrated figure when requesting his release in 2021.
Andrade El Idolo would appear in AEW later that year and would spend just under three years with Tony Khan with the highlights being a feud with Cody Rhodes and taking on The House of Black. Once again though it seemed that Andrade wanted to get back to WWE and did so when his contract expired in late 2023. He made his return to WWE as a surprise entrant in the 2024 Royal Rumble. Much was made amongst wrestling fans at the time that this would truly show how much AEW had wasted him. He would no longer be lost in the shuffle of Tony Khan's booking, Triple H would certainly have a clear vision for him.
Since then however he's been lost once more. Despite wrestling some solid matches against Carmelo Hayes over on Smackdown he's been wrapped up in the mix for WWE's Speed Championship. The much sought after rocket push has failed to present itself despite him being a steady hand to call upon when they need one.
AEW isn't as stacked in the midcard as it once was and a return back to Jacksonville would certainly allow Andrade to stretch his wings more second time around. Matches against the likes of Will Ospreay and Mike Bailey would certainly be well worth his time. and the fan's money also.
4. Hook (AEW to WWE)
Like so many others on AEW's books around 2021-22 Hook arrived with a certain aura. The son of ECW legend Taz didn't really have much to say in any early promos preferring instead to let his wrestling ability put his point across. The AEW fans still loved it though and Hook managed to get a pop for appearing on screen nonchalantly eating crisps so he must have been doing something right.
In between times he's fought over the FTW Title with the likes of Jack Perry (he was the recipient of the 'real glass' that caused Perry and CM Punk to have a slight disagreement), Christian and Chris Jericho. He's also avoided the pitfall of many a second generation wrestler by not leaning too heavily on his Father whilst on screen but still keep certain things in the family such as sharing a finisher all be it under a different name.
Since retiring the FTW Title however there really hasn't been much else for Hook to do. The current AEW tactic of putting young wrestlers in factions with those more experienced has been applied meaning that Hook is currently teaming with Samoa Joe and Katsuyori Shibata in 'The Opps'. It might be early days for the group but there's a concern that Hook will get lost in the shuffle.
Perhaps then a phone call to Hunter and a trip to NXT could well be something he'd want to try his hand at? Hook certainly has the talent to thrive in a company such as WWE and the bigger platform would mean his talents could reach more viewers than he does currently.
3. Tom Pestock (Free Agent to AEW or New Japan)
King Corbin, Happy Corbin, Unlucky Corbin, The Lone Wolf. It says something that, in his time in WWE that the wrestler formerly known as Baron Corbin has ran with all of these gimmicks and at least tried to make them memorable. Despite being in the WWE for a few short years it always seemed like he covered a lot of ground in that time. He also weathered the storm of fan criticism of being the opponent for Kurt Angle's last match at Wrestlemania 35 as if that was somehow his fault. There was always the impression that Baron Corbin was a WWE guy for life especially as he'd never wrestled anywhere else. It was therefore a huge surprise that he was informed that his contract wouldn't be renewed in 2024.
He seems to have jumped on the chances offered to him outside of the WWE system however as he's been free to appear in GCW and MLW. Now going under the name 'Bishop Dyer' he's obviously not allowed himself to become bitter at whoever it was in WWE that didn't see anything in him.
Yet a wrestler with the talent deserves to be in a company that can put him in front of a wider audience and televised shows. New Japan would always welcome a new gaijin into the mix and AEW would be an excellent home for him if he wanted to remain in America. Tom Pestock, under whatever pseudonym he wants, deserves another crack in a major company.
2. Jade Cargill (WWE to AEW)
It all seemed to make sense.
In September 2023 Jade Cargill had rejected a new contract with AEW and had left behind her beginnings in Jacksonville and gone to the WWE. The general consensus among wrestling fans was that this would be the ideal move as Jade would now be taught how to 'wrestle properly'. All those rough edges that were sometime apparent in her AEW days would be smoothed out once she landed in WWE's Performance Center.
Eighteen months in however and it really hasn't turned out like that. Jade does and always has looked every inch a professional wrestler but there are some moments that ability deserts her and things start to fall apart. Her recent tag team with Bianca Belair seemed designed to allow Jade to develop in a pairing rather than have the whole spotlight on her. More recently however she has taken time out in kayfabe due to being attacked backstage by Naomi. The resulted match at WrestleMania 41 was met with a tepid reception however. Wrestling fandom holds their collective breath with the prospect of Jade facing off with Tiffany Stratton in the very near future.
AEW might well be a smaller pool than WWE but this always worked to Jade's advantage. She always looked like a dominant force in Jacksonville and the rougher edges of her performances were always forgiven more easily due to not being part of the WWE machine and having that ever present glare upon her. A storm would surely be coming for AEW.
1. Chris Jericho (AEW to WWE)
Chris Jericho has always built a career on knowing when the time is right to switch things up and make a change. From his early beginnings in WCW around 1996 he's seemingly had a keen eye on when things are growing stale with his presentation or character. This is, after all, a man who managed to get a clipboard over with a crowd. At the current time though there's an idea that this ability is deserting Jericho rapidly. His recent 'Learning Tree' faction represented the third group he's been a leader of in AEW with mixed results for all those around him.
It's not like the current patch should sour his thirty years of effort though. Chris Jericho has certainly had a Hall Of Fame worthy career. He was the very first WWE Undisputed champion and has held the Intercontinental Championship a record nine times. He won't be making a speech in front of wrestling luminaries on the night before WrestleMania whilst he works for Tony Khan though.
A switch to WWE would mean Jericho could get the one last high profile run and WrestleMania match that he certainly deserves. Ideally it would be a match against a current up and comer in WWE such as Dominik Mysterio or Jey Uso before he could finally ride off into the sunset or to whichever city Fozzy are playing in that night.