10 Wrestlers Who Turned Heel On AEW

All Elite Wrestling isn't necessary the promotion for ALL wrestlers. Not anymore, anyway...

Bret Hart
AEW/WE

In his last big angle before setting his sights on the AEW World Heavyweight Championship in September 2022, MJF called Tony Khan a "f*cking mark" as he closed out an epic rant at the company and boss' expense, begging to be fired for not being given the respect he felt he was due.

It all followed an equally controversial Double Or Nothing weekend in which rumours swirled that the 'Salt Of The Earth' wouldn't even be appearing on the show for his planned match against former charge Wardlow. A flight home had allegedly been booked, Friedman missed a fan meet-and-greet

The persona turned heel on the company, but dating all the way back to his introduction to this world via Being The Elite in 2018, he never cared about anybody beyond what they could do for him. That very trait flew in the face of how many performers have viewed All Elite Wrestling and its (largely) well-liked president. WWE spent so long being a heel promotion within the walls of its own fiction that it's still strange to some to imagine that the organisation should fundamentally support its talent rather than bury them underneath bureaucracy and bad administration.

Characters aren't supposed to swing for the initials. In real life though...

10. Bret Hart

Bret Hart AEW Title
AEW

It was both a short and long-term endorsement of All Elite Wrestling by Bret Hart when when 'The Excellence Of Execution' appeared at the organisation's inaugural Double Or Nothing pay-per-view to unveil the design of the World Heavyweight Championship.

A sentimental favourite of many that fit the profile of AEW's largest demographic, Hart was also never shy of sharing exactly how he felt about things in the industry. A stamp of approval from him meant more than praise or criticism from some of the charlatans out there.

To that end, his shift in opinion over the last year or so won't make good reading for AEW diehards. Speaking to HNLive, he said;

"I really question the direction that the people that are in charge are taking wrestling. AEW has gone in a bad direction with all the violence and gore. I watched an episode, Dr. Martha Hart doing her big press conference, I’m watching AEW and [Jon Moxley] is sticking a fork in somebody’s head for five minutes with a close-up. This isn’t wrestling. I would recommend turning all that off and not watching because it’s not very good. Wrestling is going in bad directions because people don’t know what wrestling is or was."

Of course, the take might just be for now rather than forever, but 'The Hitman' knows what he likes, and right now, that's not everything he's seeing on Dynamite.


9. Miro

Miro AEW
AEW

Miro's unannounced return to All Elite Wrestling on the May 11th 2023 Dynamite marked the first time he'd appeared on the show in months, with his last match taking place at All Out 2022 in September.

It's been a long break - longer or as long as those involved in the infamous "Brawl Out" debacle - but a compromise had supposedly been needed for some time after news broke that Miro was none too keen on what he was being offered.

The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer reported that;

"In September, they came to him, Tony Khan came to Miro and he had this idea which would build to a match on the November 19 pay-per-view and [Miro] didn't want to do it... It's weird, a lot of people who come from WWE are very leery, obviously, Bryan Danielson being the exception, about doing jobs. Then it becomes very difficult to book when you don't really want to do programs where you are going to lose."

What specifically he baulked at wasn't clear, but various flashes of his teeth on Twitter and a continued absence from television all but confirmed that not all was rosy on either side. The prospect of mending fences is a hot one - Miro's 'Redeemer' character was the most awesome use of the 'Bulgarian Brute' since Rusev Day's WWE peak in 2018.


8. Eric Bischoff

Tony Khan Eric Bischoff
AEW

Eric Bischoff was a pleasant surprise when he returned to TNT and made his All Elite Wrestling debut on the August 5th 2020 edition of Dynamite.

Brought in to chair a debate between Orange Cassidy and Chris Jericho during the pair's uneven feud, he was perfect in the role as a warm nostalgic figure as well as somebody with enough gumption to stand down Jericho's nonsense. He worked three more times for the company in Jericho-adjacent bits between then and May 2021, and it appeared as though the two sides could enjoy a cordial relationship going forward as a result.

As well you'll know - whether you want to or not - that wasn't to be. Spotting a gap not entirely filled by all the other names you're tired of seeing, Bischoff decided to become an anti-AEW voice-for-hire via his podcast.

There were murmurs that Bischoff soured on AEW when Tony Khan (correctly) pointed out that his company stood more of a chance than WCW over the long haul, but 'Easy E' has been relentlessly hard on the promotion ever since. Or has, at least, said things destined to be shared even if he posits the polar opposite take the following week.


7. Dax Harwood

Dax Harwood
AEW

Dax Harwood spent a lot of time attempting to work a lot of people online that FTR could be returning to WWE in April 2023, using a combination of comments on his short-lived podcast and not-that-cryptic remarks about their unhappiness with various aspects of life in AEW at the start of the year.

Between defending his friend and company pariah CM Punk at every opportunity and carefully phrasing his tweets after significant in-ring defeats following the duo's iconic 2022, Harwood seemed to be trying to paint the picture of a man on the fringes of all he'd once loved.

Of course, with the benefit of hindsight, it appears very much as though the promotion was as in on it as the performer himself. When the group toasted wrestlers winning multiple Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards in early-2023 and conveniently left FTR out of their celebrations, it was Harwood that called out the error rather than an eagle-eyed fan. It was at this point it looked more like a Him problem than an AEW one, and a worked one at that.

They were back doing Top Guy stuff in April.


6. Jim Ross

Jim Ross
AEW

Jim Ross caused a stir amongst certain wrestlers on the AEW roster when he took a verbal swipe at the contrived nature of dive spots in late-2020.

Speaking on his podcast, the iconic commentator opined;

“All you guys go outside, you cluster up like quail, you stand there in a huddle, friends and foes together, side-by-side, so you can catch some leaping idiot going over the top who never wins with this move. They are looking for the ‘holy s**t’ chant. They love to hear, ‘this is awesome’. It’s a spot, folks. It’s a trapeze act. I don’t buy into that.”

It was his well-articulated and reasoned opinion, but it wasn't the only time he'd been hyper-critical of things in AEW, including during spells at the announce desk. At various points, he's dampened Tony Schiavone's enthusiasm for all in front of them, referred to something as "not good booking" and seemed intentionally keen to dismiss a backstory for a Kenny Omega halloween bit.

Whether you agree is subjective, but a man tasked with putting over the show shouldn't really be doing the opposite. Especially when he spent the most defining period of his career defending things just as preposterous.


5. Jonathan Gresham

Jonathan Gresham tony Khan
AEW/IMPACT

Jonathan Gresham's AEW/ROH run felt like it was over before it really began.

The ROH World Champion coming out of Tony Khan's first Ring Of Honor show, Gresham evidently wasn't in Khan's plans for long. He lost the title to new AEW regular Claudio Castagnoli three months later, entered without his signature mask, and didn't work for either Khan-helmed organisation in the aftermath.

It was rooted in miscommunication

"When I finally get a chance to have a face-to-face with him, he introduces me to someone he is close with and as I go to shake her hand, I turn around and TK, from the way it looked to me, was walking away from me. So, at this point, I am thinking to myself, ‘This guy must not respect me at all.’ I just started having things roll around in my mind and I think, at the time, I was my own worst enemy with this...A lot of this was just me under a lot of stress, I believe. But, I really felt I was disrespected.”

There were whispers of acrimony as Gresham distanced himself further from the brands ahead of signing with Impact. Several months later and more has at least emerged about the time. Gresham clarified his stance going as far as to bury any hatchets (if there were any) saying;

"But, before I did get out of there completely, my wife had my bags and stuff, and TK, he didn’t have to, but he came over to me and said some really nice things. He told me that no bridges were burned, he shook my hand and he said he knows that I am not a bad person. I can only imagine him dealing with athletes for so long. He kinda understands how things are, how people are. He deals with people from all different backgrounds. I’m pretty sure he probably saw where I was coming from and he just granted me my release. That was it.”

After seeming as though a door had been slammed shut, this might suggest it's not necessarily as forbidden as it first appeared.


4. Bobby Fish

Bobby Fish
TNA

Less of a heel towards AEW specifically - Fish was eventually more diplomatic in his assessment of the company and the mutual decision for them to part ways - the former Undisputed Era man was particularly critical of one of his former colleagues.

On working with CM Punk in All Elite Wrestling, Fish said;

“I’m working for AEW, they’re paying my check, you ask me to put my shoulders down for Phil Brooks, I go out and do it. Interestingly enough, there was a little whatever in the match we had, and Phil was…after the match, Phil was a c*nt. Frankly, as a martial artist, I went out and laid my shoulders down for you, you should be grateful that I did because on national TV, if I decided that I wanted to f*cking Haku your ass, I could have because you’re that little of a threat in my world. I’m not Jon Jones or Anderson Silva, but I’ve been doing martial arts long enough to where I can hold you like a wet nap Phil Brooks. For you to be c*nty after, for a mistake you made, it doesn’t wear well."

Fish's tenure with the organisation ultimately fizzled alongside the group's inability to get an Undisputed Era reboot over due to bad timing and injuries, and Punk didn't ever respond publicly to the comments.

Unlike when...


3. CM Punk

AEW All Out 2022 CM Punk
AEW

As you read this, CM Punk may well have returned or be as good as back in the fold in All Elite Wrestling, and how. But he very nearly wasn't after only a year with the group, and made no secret of his gripes with those at AEW's top table during his infamous post-All Out 2022 press conference rant.

You've seen it all before, but like every epic CM Punk promo, it bears repeating. On Hangman Page, Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks, he said;

“What did I ever do in this world to get to deserve an empty-headed, f*cking dumb f*ck like ‘Hangman’ Adam Page to go out on national television and f*cking go into business for himself...What did I ever do? I didn’t do a goddamn thing!...There’s people who call themselves EVPs that should have f*cking known better...It’s a disgrace to this company. When somebody [Page] who hasn’t done a damn thing in this business jeopardises the first million-dollar house that this company has ever drawn off of my back and goes on national television and does that, it’s a disgrace to this industry...Now, we’re far beyond apologies. I gave him a f*cking chance. It did not get handled and you saw what I had to do, which is very regrettable, lowering myself to his f*cking level, but that’s where we’re at right now.”

Cooler heads might prevail eventually, but they'll need to be ice cold to truly douse the heat created in this legendary (and/or legendarily horrendous) industry flashpoint.


2. Eddie Kingston

Eddie Kingston AEW
AEW

In a less-than-ideal worked shoot development, Eddie Kingston became increasingly frustrated with All Elite Wrestling in late-2022 and early-2023.

Taking to Twitter to blitz the company for featuring MJF heavily on the February 8th Dynamite, he said;

"Side note since we need to see his world champ 3 times within a hour and a half when it is a two hour show. f**k ortiz f**k house of black and f**k the roster. Born aline die alone I tried. I don't need anyone including mox and penta. f**k everyone. Especially the "pillars "

He followed that up with an interview for Sactown Sports 1140, ahead of the March 1st edition of the flagship where he was slated to compete in a "Face Of The Revolution Ladder Match", where he said;

“I may not be in Sacramento. It all depends how certain things in the locker room, and the office. Especially with this match that’s coming up Wednesday. I’m not real happy about it. So we have to have a talk. I’m not gonna say who’s the office. Everyone knows about Tony, but there’s others. We all gotta get together and talk. I wanna go everywhere, but I also gotta be a businessman and put my foot down at some point in a calm manner. That’s what I’m still trying to learn. In a calm, professional manner."

All of this resulted in 'The Mad King' "walking out" of the company...straight into the main event of Ring Of Honor's Supercard Of Honor. He lost that and has since had to take a break through injury, but turning on the company before he left felt as counter-productive as it was smalltime for a persona with such a high ceiling.


1. Tony Khan

Tony Khan
AEW

...but only because he earnestly knew there were better days ahead than some of the company's earliest ones.

Tony Khan never out-and-out heeled on his passion project, but he's since spoken honestly about a late-2019 judgment call to take a firmer hand in the creative process.

As he put it when speaking frankly to Marc Marton for his WTF Podcast;

"I was already kind of overseeing the creative process but I really became a lot more hands on with it going into 2020. So it was Christmas 2019, I was kicking myself because I really didn't like the way the show went the week before, and I really didn't like the rating, and I felt like we could do better, and I just wanted to hold myself and everyone to account...there needed to be consistency to it, that there was continuity problems and there was a sense of things that it just needed to flow through one person and then that one person was gonna be you because that's where the buck stops."

For somebody who's known mostly for the word "great" when talking anything AEW and occasionally overplaying his hand promoting big events, this sobering reflection gave the world a glimpse at the realist behind the unique idealist.


In this post: 
Bret Hart AEW
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.