10 Wrestlers Who Would Have Made Better Managers

Whose talents might be better off employed in a slightly different capacity?

Enzo Amore Ringside
WWE

Making the switch from wrestler to manager is often seen as something of a negative. Many might see it as an admission of failure, or a relegation to a less prominent role. Many people would also be wrong, because often that kind of thinking is anything but true.

Managers aren’t just failed wrestlers; usually a manager is someone who possesses a unique charisma or eccentricity, or perhaps they just have that “it” factor that makes them stand out from the crowd. Considering their roles to be “less prominent” or somehow not important as that of a wrestler is seriously undermining a manager’s value and the great contributions they’ve made over the years.

Take Paul Heyman for example; would Brock Lesnar’s initial rise have worked out so well if he hadn’t had a mouthpiece to talk for him? And what about the work of the likes of Bobby “the Brain” Heenan, “Classy” Freddie Blassie, or Captain Lou Albano?

Obviously these guys are the cream of the crop, but the point remains that managers can be an awesome addition to proceedings if used in the right capacity.

So rather than see this as a list of stars whose in-ring work is being criticised, view it for what it really is; a list of wrestlers whose wider-ranging talents could be of benefit to the product elsewhere.

10. Damien Sandow

Damien Sandow promo
WWE.com

See; I told you this wasn’t going to simply be a list of wrestlers being bashed for their abilities. Because during his run as Mizdow, Damien Sandow was one of company’s most entertaining performers.

The only problem was; the writers didn’t seem to have a position for him once his alliance with the Miz had ended. So why not officially rebrand him as a manager and channel that brilliance from the Mizdow shtick in a pairing him with someone else? Or better yet, revisit the Intellectual Saviour of the Masses gimmick that he portrayed with such eloquence and excellence.

Plus, given his background as a wrestler, he could still have been the type of manager to have got involved in the thick of it as and when the situation demanded.

Point being, the guy’s a natural entertainer and capable of performing any number of roles. If the WWE didn’t have a slot for him as a wrestler, then there was nothing stopping them from making him a manager and he likely would’ve smashed it out of the park.

To me, that sounds like a far better alternative to terminating his contract and giving him a chance to shine with the competition.


9. Titus O’Neil

Titus O'Neil
WWE.com

Titus O’Neil may never have been the revelation that Damien Mizdow once was, but he still boasts his own array of talents that extend beyond the ring.

Recently he’s been heavily involved in all of this Father of the Year stuff, so clearly he knows how to handle himself in a more professional type of situation. Not that all WWE managers have necessarily been “professional” but you get what I mean; it certainly helps the image.

He also had a massively entertaining, and obviously unscripted, stint on commentary back in 2012 on Raw. Ripping into Jerry Lawler and Michael Cole, Titus really caught the eye—or ear—with Paul Heyman himself calling it a “rare breakthrough moment.” Then as recently as last year, it was JBL who felt Titus’ wrath as he was put in his place at the table.

That kind of confidence and those kind of witticisms would certainly serve him well in a managerial capacity—not to mention the glowing recommendation from one of the best in the business.

Regardless of the reasoning behind it, he’s hardly set the word alight in in-ring competition, and so a switch to the world of wrestling management could be just what the doctor ordered for Titus.

Just don’t let him manage Vince McMahon. On seconds thoughts, maybe he’s not quite as professional as I first thought…


8. Eva Marie

Eva Marie
WWE.com

Okay, so I know I said I wouldn’t be bashing any wrestlers for their in-ring contributions, but I think it’s fair to say that Eva Marie hasn’t necessarily had the best of times between the ropes.

Technical shortcomings aren’t even the basis for my argument though, as she clearly has talent in her own right beyond mere good looks and a modelling body.

As one of the stars of Total Divas, she’s confident in front of the camera. While she also has a bachelor of arts in business management and a minor in human resources, so she’s obviously no slouch upstairs. Or at least, that’s the line I have to tow because I too am a business management grad.

And if people still have reservations about her, she wouldn’t even need to be a mouthpiece necessarily, as she could easily slot into the kind of role that Sable or Debra played in the Attitude Era; female valet that the crowd adore, but whose client is jealous and overprotective, prompting an eventual face turn for the manager.

Sure, it’s not very progressive, but it was pretty much working with Lana last year because we got that weird, love-quadrangle story.

Plus, I have a feeling managers are exempt from the company’s Wellness policy. Too soon? It’s probably too soon.


7. Cameron

cameron wwe
WWE.com

Having been released earlier this year, Cameron’s of course no longer with the company, and I feel like that’s partly a result of her lack of experience and knowledge of the business.

Case in point; on season five of Tough Enough, she infamously claimed that Melina vs Alicia Fox was her favourite match of all time. While later on once she’d made in to the main roster, she tried to score a pinfall with her opponent laying on her front…

Again, though, this isn’t “Have A Dig At Cameron Day,” because during her brief stint as one of Brodus Clay’s backing dancers, she filled her role pretty perfectly. Playing to something that was clearly a strength, against all odds she managed to help get over the gimmick of a disco-dancing, 375lb monster.

So based on the fact that it worked first time out, there was nothing stopping the WWE from reverting Cameron to her former role instead of letting her go. There, she could have learned from some of the best, built up a decent understanding of the profession, and ultimately stepped out into her own spotlight to become a manager on her own.

That of course now looks rather unlikely, what with her no longer being a WWE employee and all.


6. Rosa Mendes

Primo Epico Rosa Mendes
WWE.com

Throughout her WWE career, Rosa Mendes has indeed fulfilled the role of manager on plenty of occasions. Some of her former clients include Zack Ryder, during an ECW run that saw him retire Tommy Dreamer, as well as Adam Rose and the teams of Primo & Epico and Tamina & Alicia Fox.

Rather than allowing her to hone her craft though, she was then pushed into in-ring competition, and flitted between the two roles for much of the rest of her career. That kind of double-duty and inconsistency didn’t really allow her to gain any momentum and get a good run in either of the two fields.

Now, you could argue that her lack of momentum was due to other ability-based factors. Or, you could suggest that they’d have been far better off focusing on one or the other—wrestling or managing—instead of bouncing between the two.

Currently, Rosa’s on maternity leave, but she was last seen working for the company as a backstage interviewer, a position from which a transition back to management would certainly be feasible.

Although, if her Twitter feed is anything to go by, it looks like she has her sights set on an in-ring return.


5. Bo Dallas

Bo Dallas Glasgow 2016
WWE.com

During his run in NXT, Bo Dallas was absolutely brilliant. His portrayal of the “delusional babyface” act was second-to-none, culminating in that great segment in which he was dragged kicking and screaming from the Full Sail campus.

We’ve also seen glimpses of that brilliance on the main roster, from some of his comments as “the Inspirational One” and of course his rap battle with Flo Rida in which he was clearly, genuinely the victor.

You’ll notice that most of these highlights don't relate to actual wrestling matches, per se. Which suggests that Bo’s true value lies in his entertainment factor as opposed to his technical wrestling prowess; an ingredient that makes for a vital element in being an effective manager.

Plus, they’re hardly doing anything with him anyway, especially after disbanding the Social Outcasts in light of the recent brand split. I bet a lot of people can’t even remember which roster he was drafted to.

Besides, if anything, his motivational speaker spiel is tailor-made to be applied to a managerial role. He may even be capable of giving Coach Backlund a run for his money…


4. Road Dogg

Road Dogg
WWE.com

Road Dogg may well have been one of the company’s more popular characters during the crazy days of the Attitude Era—which is no mean feat at all. That being said, though, how many excellent Road Dogg matches can you remember off the top of your head?

My guess is not very many, and that’s not necessarily because he wasn’t proficient in the ring; it’s just that he was downright excellent with the microphone in hand.

His pre-match tirades, spawning some awesome one-liners along the way, were basically laying the foundations for the likes of Enzo Amore in the modern era. Admit it, you’ve probably joined in with his “ladies and gentleman, boys and girls…” spiel even when watching at home. I know I’m fairly embarrassed to concede that I have.

Again, all of this points towards a more managerial role. In fact, I’m struggling to think of too many hype men that I’d rather have announcing me to the ring. Aside from Mr. Heyman, of course.

Obviously his career in D-Generation X reached some pretty lofty heights, but I think there’d have been plenty more longevity in the D-O-Double-G if he’d made a more permanent move to mic duties.


3. Santino Marella

Santino Marella splits
WWE.com

I may have been a little embarrassed to speak of my Road Dogg sing-alongs, but I’ve no shame in admitting this one; Santino Marella is my favourite comedy wrestler of all time.

Everything he did seemed to tickle me, from his powerwalking down the ramp, to the more nuanced details like his mispronunciations and comical faux-Italian grasp of the English language. Sometimes I still find myself going back and watching videos of his failed pronunciation of John Cena’s name.

Much like the case of Bo Dallas, though, these highlights tended to arrive in moments that didn’t necessarily take place in the ring. He was by no means a bad pro wrestler—not by any stretch of the imagination. It’s just that he was so great with the rest of his character traits, and for me, that kind of greatness should be taken advantage of wherever and whenever possible.

Plus, with neck troubles consigning him to an early retirement, using Santino as a manger would mean we’d still get to see and hear from him on a far more regular basis. Which, to me, is most definitely a good thing.


2. Enzo Amore

Enzo Amore Big Cass
WWE.com

Perhaps a controversial entry here, but again—not one that reflects poorly on the guy. Because I genuinely believe that Enzo Amore is one of the greatest talkers of all time, no matter which era you compare him against.

Back in the early 2000s, week-in and week-out we’d see the Rock come out and deliver some of the most entertaining trash talk we’d ever heard. And that’s exactly what Enzo’s doing every week on Raw, with the kind of originality, creativity, and most importantly confidence, that we haven’t in years or even decades.

Plus, he’s working within the confines of the PG era, which only makes it even more impressive.

Regarding his in-ring work, though, if I did have one complaint to make it would be that his matches are a little formulaic; start the match, take a beating, tag in Cass for the finish. Sure, it works, but it’s nowhere near as unique as the work he’s delivering when a microphone’s in hand.

For the sheer gulf in class between his perfectly passable wrestling ability and his truly awesome mic work, Enzo Amore may well have made a better manager than a wrestler.


1. Kurt Angle (in 2016)

Kurt Angle milk
WWE.com

If that last entry wasn’t dubious, then I’d imagine this one certainly is, because in Kurt Angle we have one of the absolute greatest performers in the history of professional wrestling.

I’d like to stress that I’m exclusively talking about Kurt Angle in 2016, though. As in, the Angle who the WWE won’t medically clear to compete, and therefore the Angle that we don’t get to see on our TV screens each week.

I’m by no means saying that Angle should have never been a wrestler. That would be an utterly ridiculous claim. But with the way things are in 2016, a switch to management is definitely something that’s worth considering, if only as it could yield a return to the WWE.

Also, it’s probably worth mentioning that he was arguably just as good on the mic and in various backstage skits as he was inside the squared circle. Part of his character’s charm, during his early days at least, was his blissful ignorance to some of the things that came out of his mouth. That in itself sounds like a perfect fit for today’s less-raunchy product.

Plus, it would open up the possibility of the dream alliance of Kurt Angle and American Alpha...

Inside the ring, he’s already achieved everything he could have possibly dreamed of. So now may be time to replicate that success in the world of wrestling management.


In this post: 
Enzo Amore
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Elliott Binks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.