10 Wrestlers Whose Careers TANKED After Winning Big
WWE giveth, then WWE taketh away! Big moments followed by big disappointment.
Fickle.
That's what the wrestling biz is by default. Something that's immensely popular at Halloween can be the dirt worst by Christmas, and that'll never change. Take WWE as a prime example - the company produces so much content every single week that even the freshest ideas look stale to some people less than a full month into their run.
That can make it difficult to avoid following up on big moments with big disappointments. Everyone here experienced some sort of massive success (a title win, major show of faith behind the scenes, a jump from one top promotion to another etc), but those were quickly tailed by crashing lows that had to be seen to be believed.
Not every story is the same. A lot of tut-tutting could be aimed at WWE itself, sure, but they're not 100% responsible for antics outside the ring and away from arenas. Wrestlers have to take ownership of their behaviour and actions when the cameras are dark and they're going about their day-to-day lives off TV.
There would've been some confused looks in the locker room though. Seeing your peers go from the highest of highs to the lowest of lows must make everyone mimic Goldberg and wonder, "Who's next?!".
10. Bart Gunn
Take it away, Bart!
Or, perhaps more accurately, get taken away...Bart. He was never meant to win the WWF's atrocious 'Brawl For All' shoot fighting tournament in 1998, but Gunn proved to be the hardest on the roster and had his hand raised in the end. Reportedly, Vince McMahon had hoped that gig would go to spent force 'Dr. Death' Steve Williams instead.
Rather than accepting the random lottery of their own ridiculous concept, the company punished Bart by feeding him to walking boxing glove Butterbean at WrestleMania XV. Bart was tough for sure, but that was a fight he was never winning; the promotion walked him into that brick wall themselves.
Post-knockout loss, Gunn was yesterday's news in a hurry. His career faded fast, and any hopes the guy might've had about parlaying 'Brawl For All' into a serious run at top stars like Steve Austin vanished overnight. McMahon ditched Bart as soon as humanly possible, and never looked back.
9. Vader
Fans, staff and the man himself had every reason to be excited when WCW's Big Van Vader chopped off most of that name to become Vader in the WWF. His 1996 jump was huge news at the time, and rightly so. Leon White was roundly considered one of the best big men in the industry, and he'd surely thrive in the fed.
Or not.
Some histrionics from an under pressure Shawn Michaels curtailed Vader's early promise, but there were also issues behind the curtain. According to Vader, Vince McMahon pushed him into debuting at the '96 Royal Rumble despite the fact he was injured, and he felt the heat to heal up ASAP and get in the game.
As a result, Vader never actually really got going in the WWF. By 1998, he was a shadow of his former self and struggled to even put together a basic five-minute match. Being thrust onto a much bigger platform than early-to-mid-90s WCW didn't pay dividends the way everyone thought it would.
8. Otis
Admittedly, there's still time for Otis to pull the nose up on this one, but there's no denying his stock plummeted after being flavour of the month in 2020. The guy's work in Alpha Academy alongside Chad Gable has been good, but it thus far hasn't matched winning Money In The Bank, bagging Mandy Rose as his girl and being on everyone's lips.
WWE either got bored or just didn't know what to do with his push.
Winning MITB was a false dawn for Otis. Even at his peak, he never came across as the kind of worker WWE would put a World Title on, so everyone just sorta waited around twiddling their thumbs and knowing failure was around the next corner. Creative went ice cold on the super-endearing (and super-unlikely) love story with Mandy too.
Otis seemed to have won the creative jackpot by carrying about the briefcase and sharing sweet segments with Rose, but everything went to sh*t when tag-team partner Tucker betrayed him and The Miz took his Money In The Bank prize. He's been a lower midcarder ever since.
7. The Great Khali
Good lord, The Great Khali was limited. Actually, no, that's underselling it. Omos is limited; Khali's knees made it challenging for him to even walk around the ring freely. Recognising his extreme limitations but seduced by size, Vince McMahon put the old World Heavyweight Title on his new monster in 2007 and prayed for the best.
It was never going to be a long term solution for the big gold belt.
Khali worked some of the worst World Title bouts in living memory, then quickly dropped the strap to Batista. He was occasionally thrust into featured spots after that (against Triple H, for example), but Khali would never reach those heights again. Later, he'd go on to become a "Punjabi Playboy" and appear exclusively in comedy skits.
McMahon was always fascinated with physical marvels like Great Khali, but no amount of impressive stature could change the fact he sucked in-ring, or that a language barrier made his promos a chore. He went from World Champ to smooching a farting Natalya.
What a trip.
6. ‘Queen’ Zelina
Nia Jax is currently Queen Of The Ring, and WWE will be happy to pretend that she blazed the trail for women by winning the first female tourney. Truthfully, Zelina Vega is that trailblazer, but her stint as 'Queen' didn't really work out. Oh, also, Zelina's tournament was called the "Queen's Crown" instead.
She beat Doudrop (Piper Niven) at Crown Jewel 2021 to seize the cape, crown and sceptre for herself. There's a chance this success was part of an apology from Vince McMahon due to deleting Vega's emotional tribute to her father during a 9/11 episode of SmackDown, but that's just a theory.
It'd add up though, because WWE didn't appear to have any plans for Zelina after she won the crown. If anything, her career went further into the mire due to an unentertaining stint alongside Carmella in one of those thrown-together female tags. Vega did bounce back for one night only vs. Rhea Ripley at Backlash 2023, but memorable moments like that have been fleeting.
The "Queen's Crown" was her banner moment.
5. Rob Van Dam
You might be shocked to see 'Mr. Monday Night' here, but he belongs.
Most would agree that RVD was ready to ascend the throne as World Champion in 2001 or 2002. He was one of wrestling's hottest tickets back then, but ended up playing victim to Triple H's interminable World Heavyweight Title run. Things had changed by 2006 - WWE were ready to put their full might behind the Van Terminator.
At ECW One Night Stand '06, Van Dam beat John Cena in front of one of the rowdiest crowds ever to become WWE Champ. He'd hold that and the ECW World Title at the same time, but things fell apart just one month into his dual reign. Rob was busted on drug possession charges, and WWE promptly suspended him.
Yes, RVD has remained a popular star due to his work in TNA and cameo appearances for both WWE and AEW, but his career was never the same after that drugs bust. It stopped going higher (ahem), and he'd never really come close to WWE's top prizes again.
4. Rikishi/Too Cool
Too Cool were never meant to catch fire the way they did. If anything, Vince Russo's original vision for the team called for them to be an uncool version of Matt and Jeff Hardy. Fans found their retro flavour and dancing charming though, and the group had some serious steam once Rikishi joined the party.
Everything cooled significantly in late-2000. Rikishi turned heel (he "did it for The Rock", don't you know?) by getting involved in the ongoing whodunit surrounding Steve Austin, and an injury to Scotty Too Hotty left Grandmaster Sexay rudderless on his own. The fact he went on to team with Steve Blackman says everything.
Then, Sexay was released after a drug possession bust in May 2001, and the WWF didn't really know where to go with Hotty or floundering heel Rikishi. What should've been the apex (Kish moving up the card and Too Cool still getting huge pops from fans) turned out to be a nightmare for the trio.
We'll always have their first and second entrance themes, at least.
3. Mr. Kennedy
Oh, what might've been.
Mr. Kennedy had a rocket strapped to him when he won Money In The Bank at WrestleMania 23 and almost immediately announced his intentions to cash in 12 months later on the biggest show of the year. An injury forced WWE to alter plans, so Edge took the briefcase from Kennedy.
That's when everyone realised that Ken's injury wasn't as serious as feared and he could return in a matter of weeks. Eek. It was too late, and probably for the best anyway. Kennedy was named in a steroid scandal later that year, and was suspended anyway. In other words, his mega-push towards 'Mania XXIV was never happening.
Winning MITB was Kennedy's biggest moment, but it was followed by some of his most miserable. More injuries stalled attempts to rebuild, then a run-in with Randy Orton in May 2009 shattered his WWE career completely. Ken was scrapped and ended up moving to TNA.
His wrestling career never recovered from the initial spiral of injuries and poor PR.
2. ‘King’ Mabel
In fairness, following up on pay-per-view King Of The Ring winners Bret and Owen Hart with Mabel from Men On A Mission was one of Vince McMahon's boldest plots. It was also one of his worst, because the wrecking ball big man injured more wrestlers than doctors could keep up with in 1995. 'King' or not, Mabel was dangerous.
Red flags were popping up all over the place during his run to SummerSlam for a WWF Title showdown vs. Diesel, but that's when things properly tanked. Mabel slammed his full weight down on Kevin Nash's back, almost got fired immediately backstage, then failed to learn his lesson by smashing The Undertaker's orbital bone with a leg drop mere months later.
That's when Vince realised it was time to cut his losses.
The WWF did bring Mabel back for another run as Viscera between 1999-2000, and again as Big Daddy V between 2004-2008, but he was always a bit part player following the 'King' debacle. There was no getting around it - Mabel was and is the worst King Of The Ring ever.
1. Damien Sandow
Oh, what might've been x2.
'Intellectual Saviour Of The Unwashed Masses' Damien Sandow was tremendous fun as a snooty heel who dressed like he'd just finished smoking cigars whilst discussing the merits of the gold standard with his upper-class mates. WWE agreed that things were going well, and they decided to have Sandow win Money In The Bank by 2013.
People figured it was only a matter of time before Damien won a World Title, but he was booked to fail at the final hurdle by jobbing to John Cena approx three months later. There was no shame in losing to JC, but the circumstances and build made Sandow look like a total washout. He'd been losing matches aplenty before cashing in, basically.
Damien's career was in tatters, but he admirably made something of a stint impersonating The Miz before WWE released him in 2016. Dude went from being a can't miss hit heel in 2013 to out of the promotion within three years. Ouch!
What other wrestlers won big then quickly saw their careers roll downhill? For more WWE, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After King And Queen Of The Ring 2024 and 10 Exact Moments WWE Stars BURIED Their Own Careers!