10 Wrestlers WWE Failed In 2022

Those names done dirty by WWE when reflecting back on 2022.

Sasha Banks Failed
WWE

2022 has been one of the more crazy, newsworthy years in wrestling history.

Honing in on solely WWE, the market leader has seen Vince McMahon retire in disgrace, had Triple H take control of the company, had 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin wrestle his first match in 19 years, had the 76-year-old Vince work a WrestleMania match before his departure, had its first major UK pay-per-view in 30 years... and that's just the tip of the iceberg.

While various WWE names have shone across 2022, it's not been all sunshine and rainbows for other members of the promotion's Raw and SmackDown rosters. And it's on those such wrestlers that the attention is on here.

Following a similar thought process as our recent 10 Wrestlers AEW Failed in 2022 piece, it only seems fair to shine that same sort of spotlight on talents who've been let down by WWE across these past 12 months. For various reasons, certain WWE stars have been given the short end of the stick in 2022, with those grapplers deserving far better than what they were given by those steering the ship up in Stamford.

With that in mind, then, here are ten names done dirty by WWE when reflecting back on 2022.

10. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

With 2021 being full of the stench of the dreadful RETRIBUTION for Mustafa Ali, 2022 started by seeing the hugely talented star requesting his WWE release. Frustrated by how he was used by WWE - if he was even used at all, that is - the high-flyer was desperate to take his wares elsewhere.

After Vince McMahon refused this release request, Ali was eventually brought back to TV in April, immediately inserted into a rivalry with the Miz, and soon became embroiled in the United States Title picture; that belt having just been won by Austin Theory.

Hope was high that this would be a turning point for Mustafa, yet an initial fluke win over the Miz was followed by the Chicago native losing five of his next six TV matches before being demoted to working bouts on WWE Main Event. Since then, Ali has competed on Raw just seven times, and it's been frustrating in how WWE has used him during this time.

In terms of that 'used him during this time', several weeks of main roster absence has been followed by the former police officer turning up to get involved with a Bobby Lashley, a Seth Rollins, an Austin Theory... only to come up short once again before disappearing from TV for another spell.

WWE has teased big things for Mustafa Ali at several points in 2022, but it's ultimately all been for naught.


9. Ma.çé

Mace Mansoor Models
WWE.com

Whether the fella has the potential to truly succeed as a big-time player remains to be seen, but seriously, how could you expect anyone to succeed when they've been lumbered with not one, but two utterly dreadful gimmicks in such a short space of time.

For former NFL player Brennan Williams, he went from commentating on Raw as Dio Maddin, to being a part of the horrendous RETRIBUTION faction as Mace, to nowadays being ma.çé of the Maximum Male Models.

The MMM faction hasn't been seen on TV since October, where they were left in the dust of LA Knight and yet again lost to the New Day. Given how this stable was a Vince McMahon creation, one has to imagine that Triple H will be looking at how to handle ma.çé, mån.sôör and Maxine Dupri from here on out - particularly with how the Game was quick to have Knight drop the Max Durpi persona and revert to his old self.

To be handed the poisoned chalice of RETRIBUTION, only to have that followed up by a dire modelling gimmick, even the coldest of hearts has to feel some sympathy for how Brennan Williams has been used by WWE across these past couple of years. Likewise, mån.sôör was another who could've easily made this list for talents failed by WWE in 2022.


8. Baron Corbin

JBL Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Granted, there aren't all that many people clamouring for Baron Corbin to be positioned as a major player on either Raw or SmackDown, but WWE have yet again dropped the ball when it comes to making the most out of what Corbin brings to the table.

A reliable heel worker who can be a dominant bully to smaller talents, and who begs off at the right time for top babyfaces, the former NFL player was likely at his very best when he was under his Lone Wolf gimmick. That persona saw Corbin treated like a genuinely big deal in NXT before he likewise went on a tear upon graduating to the main roster.

Sure, the Happy Corbin schtick had its entertaining moments as Baron suffered a crisis of finances and confidence before regaining his mojo, but 2022 felt like Corbin was primed for a notable change in character. Once the split and rivalry with Madcap Moss was over with, Baron need something, anything, that wasn't just a rehash of what we'd seen in the past few years.

The game-changing answer to have Baron Corbin be taken seriously? Why, WWE opted to pair the one-time United States Champion with JBL.

While JBL is viewed by some WWE officials as being able to generate great heat, brother, the truth is that it's these days the wrong sort of heat for audiences to give a sh*t about. No, crowds aren't saying "booooo-urns". Instead, they're saying "boooooo, get the f**k out of my sight".

The way Corbin and JBL have been presented as a duo, it's now merely a case of two unbearable, channel-changing asshats rather than one.


7. Xia Li

Xia Li
WWE.com

It might be the case that your writer here is a rose-tinted Xia Li fan who thinks there's plenty to be tapped into with the real-life badass, but it's hard to argue that Li hasn't been totally shafted by WWE since moving to the main roster at the end of 2021.

While Xia's first main roster appearance came on a December '21 episode of SmackDown, it wasn't until the following February that the star made her in-ring bow on the blue brand. Introduced as the Protector, Li was a sh*t-kicking babyface who looked to thwart the nefarious rogues of the Smackers women's division. With a legitimate background in various martial arts, the one-time Tian Sha talent was - and is - as believable as it gets when it comes to slapping people around.

Surprisingly, that SmackDown in-ring debut - where Li defeated Natalya - was followed by a couple of months off TV, which in turn was followed by a heel turn when Xia did return to SmackDown in April.

As of this writing, Xia Li has only had nine televised matches since that February bout, and only one of those - a two-minute June loss to Lacey Evans - has been a singles contest. Throw in several prolonged absences from TV, and it's been a rough year for the Chinese battler.


6. Angel

Angel Garza
WWE

With the Garza now once again dropped from his name, Angel is a good looking third-generation talent who is a hugely exciting presence between the ropes and who oozes charisma. As a babyface or a heel, the 30-year-old can be massively effective, and his in-ring skillset means he can work a great match with almost any opponent.

So, here we are in 2022, with Angel being barely used on WWE programming.

Having previously feuded with his real-life cousin Humberto (don't call him Carrillo), the pair were teamed up as Los Lotharios towards the end of 2021. While Angel in particular had significant potential to be a prominent singles star, this pairing was at least one filled with promise. Humberto may not have the same charisma and personality as his cousin, but he's extremely capable in-ring, and this tandem could and should be a fun one brimming with energetic excitement once they step into the ring.

Unfortunately, 2022 has been a total bust for Los Lotharios.

As a unit, Angel and Humberto have only two TV wins in this past year; against the New Day back in February, then a victory over Jinder Mahal and Shanky in May. For the most part, WWE has only opted to bring out Los Lotharios when they need solid workers to put out over teams (such as Hit Row) or to pad out multi-team matches.

In the case of Angel, the one-time Cruiserweight Champion has likewise been utilised in this sort of role when a singles act needs to look good against a capable worker. Simply put, the former El Hijo del Ninja deserves better.


5. Doudrop

Doudrop wwe
WWE.com

2022 peaked for Doudrop on Saturday 29 January. There, the powerhouse unsuccessfully challenged for Becky Lynch's Raw Women's Championship at the Royal Rumble in the highest profile match of the Scot's life.

Since then, Doudrop has only picked up one win on main WWE TV across the rest of 2022, and that came all the way back in February when she bested Liv Morgan. While it's not exactly the most prestigious piece of gold, the former Piper Niven's first ever WWE title win - defeating Dana Brooke for the 24/7 Championship - was even relegated to Main Event.

Being paired up with fellow Scottish grappler Nikki Cross - well, Nikki A.S.H. - had promise for Doudrop, but that tandem ultimately came up short in any match of significance. Now, with Nikki once again embracing her crazy side, the one-time Viper has been left out in the cold - as reflected by the fact that she's not wrestled since a September appearance on NXT.

While there's been no reports of any injury issues for Doudrop across these past few months, one can only hope that her absence is part of WWE creative coming up with something fresh for the 31-year-old. And please, please, please, let that something fresh involve the dropping of that god-awful Doudrop moniker.


4. LA Knight

Adam Pearce Max Dupri LA Knight
WWE

Yes, LA Knight is currently, well, LA Knight, but a list such as this couldn't not address the elephant in the room that was Max Dupri.

Having arrived in NXT in early 2021, the former Eli Drake went about making himself one of the most engaging, entertaining parts of WWE's developmental brand. Even through the transition from NXT to NXT 2.0, Knight remained a huge part of NXT programming as it became clear he'd be main roster-bound sooner rather than later.

That move to the main roster came in April 2022, and frankly, it absolutely sucked.

Renamed Max Dupri, the one-time IMPACT World Champion went from barb-spewing loudmouth lone wolf, to a creepy manager of models who spent his time talking about titillating juices. This gimmick change stands as one of the worst in recent memory, and it's no surprise to learn that this was all a Vince McMahon idea.

With McMahon seeing nothing in the LA Knight character, Max was tasked with heading up the Maximum Male Models stable that seemed destined to lead to nothing but a "good luck with your future endeavours" notification for Dupri and his crew.

To take someone who is naturally such a phenomenal talker, and to land them with the utterly horrendous Max Dupri schtick... it was absolutely baffling to wrestling fans. For the treatment of the Namer of Dummies during this time, that's why La Knight lands on this list of WWE failings from 2022.

Thankfully, the forced retirement of Vince McMahon and the rise to power of Triple H has seen the Max Dupri character axed. Instead, as LA Knight, the real-life Shaun Ricker now finds himself in a prominent spot on SmackDown opposite Bray Wyatt.


3. Lacey Evans

Lacey Evans WWE 2022
WWE

Whether or not Lacey Evans can become a true top tier player in the WWE women's division is up for debate, but man, WWE did the Sassy Southern Belle no favours upon her return to action in April 2022.

Having been off WWE TV for over a year due to pregnancy and the subsequent birth of her second child, big things were expected of Lacey. One has to remember, prior to her time away from the company, there was talk that Evans was to dethrone Asuka at the 2021 Elimination Chamber pay-per-view to become the Raw Women's Champion and then feud with Charlotte Flair for that title.

As part of Lacey's return, WWE leaned into the star's very real, very emotional past, airing several vignettes where the former Marine openly discussed her troubled upbringing. That upbringing involved parental drug and alcohol addiction, homelessness, legal issues, and the death of Evans' father. To detail that, and to then detail the Georgia native's time serving in the Marines, was extremely heavy stuff for WWE - and it really gave fans a connection to Lacey Evans and what she'd been through.

So, after weeks of making Lacey the ultimate babyface who had overcome such staggering odds, WWE switched her from SmackDown to Raw and made her a villain. If that wasn't head-scratching enough, the talent was moved back to Smackers just a few weeks later, was quickly positioned as a babyface, then turned heel again and started to berate the fans.

For WWE to have the the 32-year-old show such strength and make herself so vulnerable by putting her real life front-and-centre for an international TV audience, it's disappointing and disrespectful to then use Lacey as the company did after her return to action.


2. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano
WWE.com

Many a wrestling fan was ecstatic to see Johnny Gargano return to WWE on the 22 August 2022 episode of Raw. With Triple H now leading the creative charge for the company, it was a no-brainer that Gargano would become a focal point of the red brand, would become embroiled in the same sort of emotional rivalries we'd seen from him in NXT, would be putting on banger after banger on a weekly basis, and would steal the show when Premium Live Events roll around.

Instead, Johnny Wrestling has only wrestled seven TV matches in the four months he's been back with WWE, and four of those outings ended in defeat for the former NXT Champion.

Of course, it's not just the lack of wrestling from Johnny that has felt off about his run on the WWE main roster, but it's the use of him as a character that's likewise been a disappointment. There was a smidge of something with one-time Way pal Austin Theory, there was a dollop of buddying up with Kevin Owens, there was the odd moment with Baron Corbin and JBL, and then there's been a lot of trash TV involving the Miz and Dexter Lumis.

The whole Miz/Lumis storyline has been naff from the get-go, and having Johnny Gargano tangled up in this web has done nothing but drag down the Cleveland native. Whether the latest unfortunate spell on the sidelines for Tommaso Ciampa hindered the original plans for Gargano is unknown, but one has to think WWE could have found something better for the 35-year-old to do since he returned to the market leader.


1. Sasha Banks

Sasha Banks
WWE

As the time of writing, Sasha Banks' WWE tenure is coming to an end, with the Boss currently set to appear at NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 17 in January ahead of re-starting her wrestling career away from the market leader.

Banks and tag partner Naomi walked out of a May 2022 episode of WWE Raw, placing their Women's Tag Team Titles on the desk of John Laurinaitis and exiting the building due to how unhappy they were for creative plans presented to them. Whether or not you deem this worthy of saying WWE failed Sasha Banks is up for debate, but either way, that's not the point being made here.

Instead, the way WWE has failed the seven-time Women's Champion and three-time Tag Champion is in how the promotion views Banks on the women's division's totem pole.

Recent reports note that one of the major reasons behind Sasha's WWE exit, is because the company didn't see her as being as valuable as Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch. These reports say that Banks was open to staying with WWE, but that she wanted financial parity with Flair and Lynch... which the market leader baulked at.

When looking at the stats, it does seems only fair for the Blueprint to want a contract more in line with those two particular members of the Four Horsewomen. After all, Banks has been involved in seven pay-per-view matches with Flair, has shared a pay-per-view ring with Lynch on eight occasions, all three of these women have competed against each other on the WrestleMania stage, Sasha has headlined a WrestleMania, and she was also a part of the first ever women's Hell in a Cell contest in history.

If Sasha Banks has been used in similar roles and positioned in similar spots on the card to Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch, surely that should be reflected in her contract.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.