10 Wrestlers WWE Gave Up On In 2021

These wrestlers went from hero to zero in next to no time in 2021.

John Morrison
WWE

Your writer will admit that, with WWE seemingly stripping away shocking amounts of its roster by the month over the course of the last 12-months, it would've been very easy to just overload this list with talented performers let go before their time in 2021.

And though this list will come equipped with a number of the stars at the centre of some of the company's most jaw-dropping departures in recent memory, stars still signed to Vinnie Mac's empire have also found themselves in the undesirable position of eventually unappreciated as the year has rolled by, despite even appearing in top matches at 'Mania 37.

If this article proves anything, it's that unless you're a former UFC Champion or sit at the very Head of the Table, you're in no way safe from the wrath or ever-changing mind of the Chairman of the Board.

And even the strongest of starts to a calendar year can lead to the limpest of conclusions when all is said and done.

From Monsters Among Men being thrown to the wolves, to Role Models being taught head-scratching lessons on The Grandest Stage, these WWE stars all undoubtedly fell out of favour as the months rolled by...

10. Bayley

Bayley WrestleMania
WWE

Putting together the strongest run of her nine-year stint in WWE as the company endured its most difficult period in recent memory, Bayley would become arguably the most eye-catching part of Friday Night SmackDown throughout the ThunderDome era.

Frequently stellar displays on the mic were matched only by her deliciously sadistic work in the ring. Yet, her undoubted highlight in this period came in the form of a career-best feud with old sparring partner Sasha Banks which eventually resulted in a spectacular Hell in a Cell showdown over the SmackDown Women's Championship.

Now sure, Bayley may have been left title-less coming into 2021, but the longest (and most entertaining) reign in the blue brand's history pretty much ensured that she would have something compelling to do coming into the biggest show of the year, right?

But alas, instead of gifting us a Role Model taking on The Man, Bayley was fed to The Bellas at 'Mania 37, only to lose back-to-back PPV contests against new blue champ Bianca Belair before being struck down by injury. Here's hoping this ThunderDome MVP proves just how idiotic the company were to bench her on The Grandest Stage when she does eventually return.


9. Kyle O'Reilly

Kyle O'Reilly
WWE

For a time, it seemed as though Kool Kyle O'Reilly was destined to become NXT's latest golden boy in 2021. But as a ton of once-black and gold fans have come to terms with over the last 12-months, a great many plans were torn up when Vinnie Mac decided to go 2.0 with the developmental show.

O'Reilly likely sits as the most notable casualty of NXT being pumped full of multi-coloured freshness, with his drawn-out blood war with former UE pal Adam Cole eventually resulting in him becoming anything but the next face of the brand. Instead, stellar showings against former NXT Champion Finn Balor and a win in that programme against Cole paved the way for a disappointing follow-up.

Lumped together with Von Wagner on this paint-splattered revamp of a show, O'Reilly has gone from intriguing potential new NXT champ to painfully bland side-character in another performer's story. With the one-time NXT Tag Champion's contract reportedly coming up in December, don't be too surprised if O'Reilly follows in the Undisputed footsteps of his former pals and seeks pastures new in 2022, bay bay.


8. Bray Wyatt

The Fiend Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

For an example of just how quickly a seemingly untouchable superstar can fall out of favour with the man up top, look no further than the curious case of Bray Wyatt in 2021.

After being one of the company's biggest merch shifters from the moment he unveiled his Fiend-ish alter ego in 2019, Wyatt had rarely found himself out of the spotlight/main event on WWE programming. Divisive clashes with Seth Rollins, Goldberg, and Braun Strowman all suggested that Vince was still willing to force this creature down his fans' throats, regardless of whether they wanted to embrace the sometimes non-sensical booking that accompanied the creation or not.

Then, a black-goo and fire infested feud with Randy Orton dominated much of the conversation coming into 'Mania 37, only for Wyatt to shockingly fall to The Viper in yet another high-profile failure on The Grandest Stage. Yet, even with that loss, few could've imagined WWE parting ways with such a sure-fire moneymaker. But part ways they did, with Andrew Zarian of The Mat Men podcast stating that Wyatt was "being difficult" in the lead-up to his sudden departure in July.


7. Eva Marie

Eva Marie
WWE

Perhaps one of the strangest acquisitions in recent WWE history came to pass in May 2021, with one-time Total Diva, NXT, and SmackDown troll Eva Marie being brought back into the fold for... reasons?

Aside from being a natural heel, capable of eliciting a whole host of boos through simply taking the credit for unearned victories, Marie didn't offer anywhere near as much as the rest of her contemporaries both on the mic or in the ring. Hell, it even appeared as though the star herself wasn't entirely interested in being a part of the WWE circus, recently taking a break from the company to shoot a film.

Just a few months on from being heavily promoted through a series of vignettes and battling Alexa Bliss in front of a packed-out Allegiant Stadium at SummerSlam, though, Marie ultimately found herself on the outside looking in, with WWE's clear lack of a plan for the character becoming even more evident post-release in November.

Judging from her response, or lack of, on the back of her exit from WWE, it hardly seems as though this development will affect a star who is clearly relishing embracing other facets of the entertainment industry.


6. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Shane McMahon WrestleMania 37
WWE.com

Falling into a similar category to that of fellow former Wyatt Family member Bray Wyatt, Braun Strowman was another star who seemed pretty much set for life in terms of having a role to play in Vinnie Mac's empire.

Built like a literal monster, with all the roaring intensity the boss usually has personal wet dreams about, a world where The Monster Among Men wasn't bellowing out that his enemies were set to "GET THESE HANDS!" in WWE seemed unimaginable. Reinforced by the fact that Strowman had literally just battled against Shane-O-Mac at 'Mania 37 and fought over the WWE Championship at WrestleMania Backlash.

But, clearly sensing the character had run its course and simply wasn't worth the large expense, Strowman was unleashed onto the free agency market in June. You could argue that the character had been treading water for a significant amount of time on the main roster, but is there ever such a thing as having too many terrifying forces of nature on your show?

With the mighty Omos taking his place as Raw's resident Goliath, it appears Vince McMahon just didn't see the value in keeping this expensive titan around any longer.


5. John Morrison

Karrion Kross John Morrison
WWE.com

To say it's been a rough ol' time since John Morrison decided to embark on another adventure in the land of Sports Entertainment in late 2019 would be putting it mildly.

A stale-on-arrival teaming with The Miz was a safe if unspectacular piece of business from the get-go, but Morrison still found a way to stand out from the crowd when given the time or space to show off his next-level parkour-infused stylings in-between the ropes.

With The Shaman of Sexy and The Awesome One being given a decent bit of attention coming into this year's Show of Shows, battling against Bad Bunny and Damian Priest in an unexpectedly riveting showcase, fans were forgiven for thinking there may actually be life in a Morrison solo run yet in 2021. And a long-awaited split from Miz a few months later seemed to finally set that wheel in motion.

However, what should have been the catalyst for a compelling singles climb back into relevancy soon devolved into an afterthought when Miz waltzed off to Dancing With the Stars, leaving Morrison being choked out by Karrion Kross and setting up shop on Main Event for the foreseeable.


4. Karrion Kross

Karrion Kross
WWE.com

The fact that a star responsible for choking the life out of another given-up-on performer's push has still somehow found a way onto this list tells you all you need to know about WWE's booking strategy in modern times. To summarise: They don't have one.

If they did, then the absolute can't-miss, bombastic powerhouse that was Karrion Kross wouldn't have wound up being met by indifferent jeers or being stripped of everything that once made him a considerable asset down in NXT.

After going on an absolute tear through developmental, picking up two NXT Championship reigns in the process, Kross arrived on the main roster sans Scarlett and the heavily theatrical entrance that had once set the stage for his often dominant in-ring displays. A shock defeat at the hands of Jeff Hardy did little to endear him to fans on his Raw debut, and set the tone for an ill-thought-out push going forward.

Surprisingly, after already shifting his character twice in his short time among the red brand, reports state that WWE were preparing yet another character change for Kross. But said plans were ultimately never to be as they cut their losses due to "budget cuts" in November.


3. Keith Lee

Keith Lee Cedric Alexander
WWE.com

Another former NXT Championship-winning hero to zero story here, and this one centres around a star who once had the world at his feet, only to realise that said world was hellbent on bending him to its will.

On NXT, Keith Lee quickly forged his own unique path, flipping and flying around the ring like a man a third his size and exuding bucketloads of charisma all the while. A life-changing 2019/2020 then saw the Limitless performer bump heads with Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar at Survivor Series and the Royal Rumble, respectively, setting the stage for one of the most euphoric moments in a once-adored show's history.

However, just a few months on from becoming both NXT and North American Champion at The Great American Bash, Lee was quickly shuffled into the main roster pack, disappearing entirely after pulling out of a triple threat over the US title at Elimination Chamber. A scary COVID-19-induced spell on the sidelines followed before a Bearcat emerged from the other side, stripped of the out-of-this-world move-set that once made Vince himself gush over the one-of-a-kind sensation backstage.

Likely sensing Lee would never be content with being Limited, WWE parted ways with him in November.


2. Kevin Owens

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Ending on two stars now who both started 2021 with an almighty spring in their step. First up is the performer who took the self-professed Head of the Table to his limit at the Royal Rumble in January.

A few months removed from a rejuvenating Roman Reigns series, Kevin Owens may have been able to boast a WrestleMania victory over old pal Sami Zayn, but who was the real winner here? In the months that followed, KO was thrust into a rudderless IC title scene, failing to win that title on a number of attempts.

A body-breaking showing at Money in the Bank was fun, sure. But the likelihood of WWE doubling down on another KO run at the very top seems less likely by the week as he routinely finds himself being fed to the names Vince really wants to get behind.

In all honesty, it's impossible to escape the feeling that the Kevin Owens Show may be enjoying its last hurrah as we speak. With his contract coming to an end in early 2022, don't be too surprised to see this star Steen-roll his way out the door soon enough.


1. Apollo

Apollo Crews King Nakamura
WWE.com

And now for the star the aforementioned KO was served up to during what initially seemed to be a career-making run with SmackDown's mid-card title. Oh, what a difference a few months make.

Coming into 2021, Apollo was enjoying his finest period since signing with the biggest wrestling promotion in the world. Fresh off of turning heel and embracing his Nigerian roots, a meaty feud with Big E culminated in the hyper athletic performer being strapped with the IC title at 'Mania 37.

But if you thought this coronation, with a little help from Commander Azeez, would catapult the often under-utilised superstar to the next level, you've sadly not been paying attention, have you? Instead of building the former NXT man into an unstoppable monster or calculating menace, a brief KO detour was soon followed by a lazy, never-ending series with King Nakamura.

Eventually dropping his title to Nak, Apollo has since been thrust into the abyss with his partner in crime, pretty much going missing since being drafted over to Raw. Will Apollo ever be given another chance to prove he's worthy of more than Main Event obscurity? Here's to a hopeful 2022, eh...


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!