10 Wrestling Stables That Never Fulfilled Their Potential
For every Shield and Evolution, there are the stables that could never hit the big time...
With the right storylines, promos, and people (sorry Mark Jindrak), the creation of a stable can do wonders for those that test their trade within the squared circle.
Evolution refreshed interest in Triple H amid his reign of terror, as well as giving Ric Flair chances to engross fans with his impeccable mic skills, and helped make stars out of fresh faced rookies Randy Orton and Batista (you may have heard of them?). Meanwhile, The Shield launched WWE's most marketable star in Roman Reigns and made names out of AEW World Champion John Moxley and the Monday Night Messiah. Even the long-running comedic trio The New Day created infectious chants, showcased underrated talent Xavier Woods as one of the company's best talkers and transformed Kofi from mid-card filler to underdog champion.
Yet not every stable can enjoy success. For everygroup that builds a new star or launches a new storyline, there are plenty of others that fall flat on their faces, making everyone associated with them worse off. These are the worst offenders, that excited and intrigued the fans with their arrival, only to leave less impact than a mouse's fart. These are 10 wrestling stables who never fulfilled their potential...
10. Immortal
When Abyss first announced that "they" were coming, turning heel in an attack on top babyfaces Jeff Hardy and Mr Anderson, wrestling fans were immediately pointing the fingers at the debuting wrestling legends Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff. This was the predictable part of the faction that came to be known as Immortal.
What fans didn't expect is that the faction's prized asset was none other than Hardy himself. The Charismatic Enigma, for the first time in his TNA career, turned his back on the fans and captured the company's World Championship in the same night.
Unfortunately, the initial swerve was really the height of the stable. Whilst Hardy made a compelling and rather underrated heel, fans felt uncomfortable booing him and cheering self-confessed prick Mr Anderson. When Hardy dropped the strap to a beaten and outnumbered Anderson only three months after the shocking heel turn, the writing was already on the wall. Coupled with far too many parallels to the nWo, which didn't help when Bischoff and Hogan led the group, questionable recruitment such as a dreadlocked Matt Hardy in the worst shape of his career both physically and mentally, and the confusing alliance with fellow stable Fortune, the remaining members of Immortal fizzled out of the main event scene within two years.
9. The New Brood
Another failed faction featuring the Hardy Boyz. This time, it's the opening years of their careers with the short-lived New Brood. Initially, the Brood was the trio of the vampiric Gangrel and his fraternal minions Edge and Christian, before they went on to define Attitude era tag team wrestling and become individual main eventers in the Ruthless Aggression and PG eras respectively.
The Brood's popularity essentially sums up the Attitude era, with the group's signature "blood baths", New Romantic attires and cheesy fangs earning the love of the fans and a notable main event feud and alliance with Undertaker's Ministry of Darkness.
Meanwhile, when E&C turned face, the original Brood was disbanded. Enter the New Brood... Only spanning just over two months, the then-WWF saw the success of the original Brood and thought by replacing one young, athletic tag team with another, they could replicate their success. They couldn't. Whether it was the fans who simply refused to boo the now-emo Matt and Jeff Hardy, whether it was that they weren't Edge and Christian and were in fact very different personalities, or whether it was simply that the gimmick had run its course, the WWF quickly had cold feet, turning both teams face, pushing Gangrel away from the main event and leaving fans wondering what a fully heel Hardy Boyz would look like for years.
8. The Corre
For the creation of the Corre, WWE's creative team likely took the best elements of the Nexus - Wade Barrett's leadership, Justin Gabriel's agility and Heath Slater's... and Heath Slater, paired them with the first big man they could find and called it a day. Even though the Corre were essentially just a smaller Nexus with the rather bland Ezekiel Jackson tagged on, fans were still cautiously optimistic. Barrett had proved that, despite WWE hamstringing him with terrible booking every step of the way, he was a superb villain, with his booming British baritone, and an even better leader, through his sheer size and presence.
So the creative decision to declare the Corre a leaderless group perplexed and even turned sections of the fans off. Whilst the group all had what it took to make it, capturing midcard gold along the way, terrible shirts, entrance music and eventually booking just told the fans that these four lads weren't worth anyone's time and effort. This was summed up best by their WrestleMania XXVII burial, with the group soundly squashed by a rag-tag quartet that included Santino bloody Marella.
But the most unforgivable? WWE asked themselves "which of these could make a main event heel?" and decided that Jackson, the group's least popular member, was their man. Shame.
7. League Of Nations
Oh Wade Barrett. This isn't his first entry and unfortunately it won't be his last either.
The four superstars that made up the League were exactly that: superstars. Three out of four were incredibly over, with fans adoring Barrett's Bad News gimmick and Bullhammer elbow, popping huge for Alberto Del Rio's return following a successful run on the indies and clamouring for a Rusev push after an impressive maiden year on the main roster. Unfortunately, only Sheamus was struggling with the fans, so WWE naturally had him win the WWE championship and had the other three be his minions.
However, fans and critics alike soon grew aware of creative's real reason for the group: make Roman look strong. Arriving between 'Manias 31 and 32, the height of Roman rejection, within only their SECOND match, the entire group were defeated on RAW in a 4-on-1 handicap match. Whilst the defeat was merely a countout, to the fans it portrayed the League as idiots and Reigns as an unstoppable bore. Had WWE used the group properly and truly shown Reigns' struggle, all five superstars could have been solidified in the fans' eyes. Instead, fans internally weeped for their fallen favourites and continued to boo Roman. Still, at least we got to see Stone Cold, HBK and Mick Foley... burying these four at Mania.
6. Latino World Order
Another one of wrestling's biggest 'what ifs?', the LWO, or Latino World Order, came after Eddie Guerrero became unsettled with his position within WCW. Eric Bischoff was convinced to turn Guerrero's displeasure into an angle and, thus the LWO were born.
The biggest drawback to the group was their association with the nWo. Whilst at their peak, they were the '90s' hottest stable and, in many fans' eyes, rival the likes of the Horseman, the Von Erichs and The Shield in wrestling's greatest, the nWo had slowly wilted due to divide, overpopulation and overexposure.
Thus, despite the inclusion of highly regarded Latino talents like La Parka, Juventud Guerrera and Psychosis, the stable stood little chance in WCW. A recruitment-based rivalry with a pre-WWE Rey Mysterio Jr got fans intrigued, but oversaturation of the nWo gimmick, combined with a lack of interest from Bischoff himself soon led to the ball being dropped. The group was soon fed to their namesake, beaten down and publicly humiliated by being forced to bend the knee before Jon Snow made it cool. Perhaps if Eddie Guerrero hadn't been out of commission with a real-life car crash, the group may have lived longer. Either way, the LWO were a missed opportunity for a company that, within two years, would be humbly defeated.
5. Legacy
Legacy had all the makings to match and even surpass their predecessors Evolution. Whilst Rhodes and DiBiase might have tried to distance themselves from the Evolution tag, it wasn't difficult to see why fans felt that same energy and were hooked to the stable's... well, evolution! With Randy Orton having become a main event star as the cold, calculated Viper that stalked and systematically picked apart his rivals, he became the perfect candidate to engage in the circle of life and become Legacy's leader.
Meanwhile, the group's selective nature of only second-generation and beyond wrestlers MOSTLY worked to its advantage. Whilst Ted DiBiase Jr was still green and was a shadow of his father on the mic, even back then Cody Rhodes was a solid performer with a sharp tongue, just like Dusty. It comes as no surprise to see Rhodes as a main event star in AEW, whilst DiBiase has stepped away from the sport. Yet whilst Rhodes and DiBiase were excellent protégés, Manu and Sim Snuka simply were not. The duo, sons of Hall of Famers Afa and Jimmy Snuka respectively, were green in the ring and anonymous on the mic.
Whilst they were quickly dispatched, the damage had been done. But the final nail in the coffin came when Orton defeated his remaining protégés at WrestleMania 25. Whilst Evolution allowed Orton to capture the big gold belt and launched Batista as a SmackDown's top babyface, Rhodes and DiBiase were left looking like heelish chumps, to the fans' chagrin.
4. Aces And Eights
Whilst overall Aces and Eights was a messy main event stable/storyline, it was also one of TNA's biggest long-term bookings in its history. Whilst unfortunately they failed to stick the landing, hence the stable's place on this list, TNA should be commended for being patient and slowly revealing members, whilst keeping their attacks and dominance rather fresh. With WWE currently trying the RETRIBUTION angle, they should take some notes on avoiding repetition and keeping fans invested.
Aces and Eights ended up being two things: an attempt to cash in harder than Edge at the booming success of biker-gang TV hit Sons of Anarchy, and unfortunately another string in the bonkers bow that was the Hogan family within TNA. The group started strong, attacking a well-known, beloved face in the Icon Sting, whilst sending a message to Hogan. Dressed as masked bikers, armed with chains, and attacking wrestlers indiscriminate of heel or face status, the gang genuinely felt a dangerous group within their first few months.
Eventually, members such as Devon of Team 3D and DOC "Luke" Gallows were revealed, with fans rather indifferent about the lack of starpower. Whilst Mr Anderson would join, the biggest reveal was the leader: Bully Ray. Whilst this made for a shock, since Ray was marrying target Hogan's daughter, it made no sense, as Ray himself had feuded with them earlier in the year. Whilst TNA tried to explain, fans balked at the logic. Things were only made worse with the kayfabe firing and hiring of new gang members, leaving the Eights to dissolve quietly.
3. The Alliance
Seeing Mr ECW Paul Heyman, who at the time represented everything anti-McMahon, side by side in cahoots with Shane and Stephanie McMahon was a sight to behold indeed. However, despite the shocking swerve that both ECW and WCW were together all along, which thinking about it shouldn't have shocked anyone, The Alliance struggled under the weight of the invasion angle.
As with most everything during this time, the stable was simply an illogical mess. Led by Stone Cold Steve Austin, who had been chewed up and spat out by WCW and had left ECW for bigger and better things (AKA the WWF), the stable only furthered Vince's guys, creating high profile positions for the likes of the McMahons, Triple H, Kurt Angle and of course Stone Cold himself.
Meanwhile, WCW and ECW talent was simply shunted into the background. Stars such as one of the '90s' most over wrestlers in DDP, ECW legends the Dudley Boyz, and other vastly underrated workers like RVD, Lance Storm, and Test were all merely cogs in the machine that was Vince's ego. It wasn't enough to kill the competition; he had to dance on their graves. The group were humbly and soundly beaten after Kurt Angle defected AGAIN and most of The Alliance quietly went their separate ways, worsened by the experience.
2. The Union
In 1999, four of the Corporation's finest talents splintered off into a vigilante quartet. The group contained a young and fresh Big Show capable of moonsaults, a real life badass like Ken Shamrock, one of wrestling's most entertaining stuntmen in Mankind-era Mick Foley, and as stated in the previous entry, the grossly overrated Test. That statement alone is enough for The Union to make it onto a list of wrestling's most unfulfilled stables.
A group of immense talents who had come away from the megaheels that were The Corporation, The Union strolled in with 2x4s in hand, led by the boss himself Vince McMahon and spearheaded by Mankind. Alongside temporary alliances with the likes of The Rock, Shawn Michaels and Stone Cold, everything in the group screamed "babyface faction to remember".
Unfortunately, as with many of Vince's pet projects, The Union were soon locked away and faded unceremoniously from the wrestling scene. After a big win over the Corporation at Over the Edge that year, Foley took time off for surgery. Within a week, yes just ONE WEEK later, McMahon once again turned heel, revealing himself as the now Corporate Ministry's Higher Power in one of wrestling's most sigh-inducing moments. The group, having briefly touched the taste of glory upon their tongues, was axed without a word.
1. The Nexus
Perhaps the greatest tragedy in wrestling over the last decade or so. Despite Cena since seemingly winning back the love of the IWC with his charity work, willingness to put over young talent and edgier stories with the likes of Reigns and Bray Wyatt, his burial of WWE's hottest group still springs harsh whispers of bitterness and disdain.
When the Nexus debuted in the PG era's greatest debut, they put the entire WWE universe on notice. In June 2010, the octet, who had been practically humiliated on the gameshow that NXT was back then, rushed the main event of Cena vs. Punk, savagely attacking them, Punk's manager Luke Gallows, the commentary team, the timekeeper and ring announcer, and even the set, tearing the ring asunder.
Whilst Daniel Bryan's firing for choking Justin Roberts with his tie set the group back, the group still combined brutes like Skip 'Ryback' Sheffield and Michael Tarver, and highflyers such as Justin Gabriel and Heath Slater, all spearheaded by the dastardly British leader Wade Barrett. Yet, when their chance came at Summerslam, backstage shenanigans saw super Cena prevail practically single-handed. Despite intriguing storylines revolving around the recruitment of Cena and the expulsion of Barrett by CM Punk of all people, the Nexus quietly died during the Summer of Punk, with all bar the Voice of the Voiceless fading into midcard obscurity at best.