10 WWE & AEW Wrestlers Who DESPERATELY Need A New Direction
Which wrestlers need to chart a new course in 2023?
Well, 2022 was quite the year wasn't it? (Walkouts, brawls and regime changes, oh my!) However, stepping away from the chaos that engulfed most of wrestling the last calendar year, there were plenty of success stories to celebrate.
Bianca Belair solidified her status as one of the pre-eminent figures in women's wrestling, and Rhea Ripley looks set to equal - and possibly surpass - her; AEW's flailing woman's division finally found solid footing with Jamie Hayter as its champion; and, of course, Sami Zayn and the Bloodline is the best storyline WWE has produced since Becky Lynch became The Man.
Unfortunately, not every wrestler enjoyed as productive a year.
Almost all the entrants on this list endured a disappointing 2022, and enter the new year in need of course correction. None of the wrestlers on this list are beyond saving - indeed, some are doing relatively well - but each of them could be doing so much more than their current position allows.
With a little TLC (the non-furniture-based kind) from WWE & AEW, these wrestlers have the potential to erase the disappointments of last year and turn 2023 into a banner year for themselves and their respective companies.
10. Asuka
The above picture - showing Rhea Ripley using the back of Asuka's head as a stress reliever - is an unfortunately accurate representation of how the Empress of Tomorrow closed out 2022.
Don't get us wrong: Ripley is undoubtedly the future of women's wrestling, and she needs to look strong for her inevitable title match at WrestleMania (he says, hoping WWE don't miss the open goal they've spent months setting up). But Asuka herself deserves a lot better than being used as glorified enhancement talent.
Asuka's WWE career is a strange one, in that it's been undoubtedly successful - she's a bonafide grand slam champion, after all - but there's always been the lingering sense that WWE could do so much more with her. She's essentially a modern-day Bret Hart, in that she gets pushed only until the office finds someone more to their liking to replace her with (usually Charlotte).
Asuka is still a dynamo in the ring - not for nothing did she main event half-a-dozen RAWs last year - and she herself has been complaining (in kayfabe, we think) at her current status on social media. Here's hoping this means WWE have something suitable in store for the Empress in 2023!
9. The Hurt Business
Watching MVP interact with Cedric Alexander and Shelton Benjamin backstage on a recent RAW episode elicited mixed feelings from this writer. On the one hand, it was great seeing The Hurt Business on-screen together. On the other, it was a reminder of how frustrating their break-up was in the first place.
Absolutely no-one wanted to see the The Hurt Business go their separate ways, and its safe to say their separation benefited no one whose name didn't rhyme with Gobby Rashly. Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander were particularly hard-done-by, going from Tag Team Champions to Missing In Action.
Which is ridiculous, as Shelton and Cedric would be a shot in the arm for any tag division on the planet. Both are fantastic in-ring workers (we can't be the only ones who remember Cedric's incredible run as Cruiserweight Champion, right?), and given adequate build-up The Hurt Business would be credible contenders to knock the Usos off their perch at this year's WrestleMania. Particularly with MVP as their cornerman, who could feasibly cut off any of the Bloodline's trademark shenanigans.
Reforming The Hurt Business would right one of WWE Creative's most egregious wrongs, give two excellent workers the chance to shine in the spotlight, and put the always-entertaining MVP back on television.
And while we're on the subject of rebuilding factions...
8. Damage CTRL
Don't let the above picture fool you - 2022 was not a good year for Damage CTRL.
When Bayley returned alongside NXT stalwarts Dakota Kai and I̶o̶ S̶h̶i̶r̶a̶i̶ IYO SKY, the excitement was palpable. A locked-in Hall of Famer teaming up with two of WWE's best workhorses? (Hell, IYO can make a legitimate claim to being one of the best workers on the planet). What could possibly go wrong?
Cue Bianca Belair's music.
Ah, right.
Like Asuka, Damage CTRL found themselves in the unenviable position of propping up one of the company's chosen ones. Unlike Asuka, Damage CTRL doesn't have years of fan support and a laundry list of accomplishments to fall back on.
Five months on from their inception, Damage CTRL have already been rendered toothless through Belair's domination of the nascent faction. Yes, Kai and SKY are two-time tag team champions but Bayley's continual failure to best Bianca hugely diminished the group's credibility. Would Toxic Attraction have worked if the recently-released Mandy Rose routinely failed to capture the NXT Championship?
Damage CTRL needs to either win something of importance or break up. They may be less than half a year old, but they already feel more filler than a threat.
7. Wardlow
The above photo depicts Wardlow trying to work out the logic in being on the losing end of his feud with Samoa Joe, only for the latter to be humbled by Darby Allin less than a week later.
Don't get us wrong - Darby Allin absolutely deserves his day in the sun. He's a genuinely unique talent, and the only one of AEW's original four pillars whose veneer hasn't been tarnished by backstage bullsh*t/poor booking. But having Darby vanquish Samoa Joe just one week after the latter cut Wardlow's hair - a deadly insult in the wrestling world - did Wardlow absolutely no favours.
Baffling as this decision was, it is unfortunately emblematic of the downward spiral Wardlow has been on since besting MJF in the first half of 2022. That feud turned Wardlow into the hottest act in AEW, but the past six months have seen his fire doused on by a slurry of poor booking, spotlight-sharing and a complete absence of the attitude that made him a star against MJF.
There's still time for Wardlow to recover from this latest setback, but for now he's another victim of the "two steps forward, three steps back" booking that has dogged so many of AEW's talent (See: Kingston, Eddie and Black, House of for other example).
6. Johnny Gargano
"You're bringing me back to do ?????", is what we imagine Johnny Gargano thinking in the above photo.
WhatCulture's distaste for how WWE have handled Gargano's return is well-documented, but to summarise: If you are going to bring back someone whose nickname is Johnny Wrestling, it may be a good idea to just let the poor sod go out and wrestle. Gargano's return has been blighted by the sub-Brookside level storyline he's been embroiled in, tarnishing a return that promised so much.
And that's what's so frustrating about all this - WWE gave themselves the perfect storyline for Gargano's return, then inexplicably changed direction. Johnny's initial promo on his return to WWE was pitch-perfect, as the fan-favourite wrestler outlined his desire to be a role model to his son and take care of unfinished business in the company. Heart-felt, relatable and easy to root for, this was the Gargano we wanted to see upon his return - not the SNL reject he has since become.
Johnny Gargano would and should be a valuable addition to the midcard title scene, as Johnny Wrestling isn't an ironic nickname - he can go in the ring like few others, and watching him battle the likes of GUNTHER and Theory as a lovable underdog is a program that practically books itself.
5. Bron Breakker
It might seem odd to suggest that a wrestler losing their championship would benefit them, but the time has come to call it a day on Bronn Breakker's NXT title reign.
Bron's time as NXT champion has been an unqualified success, transforming him from Rick Steiner's son into a worthy talent in his own right, but it's time for him to step aside. Bron moving on from the show that made his name would be the best decision for him and NXT as a whole, as NXT has the perfect replacement lined up in Carmelo Hayes.
Hayes has the charisma and ring skills to be a worthy champion (check out his recent belter against Apollo Crews if you haven't already), and having Breakker decisively lose to Carmelo would be the making of the latter. Bron, meanwhile, would be free to move up to the main roster, his reputation already secured by his own lengthy title run.
Bron helped NXT stay afloat during the tumultuous 2.0 rebrand, and the program actually saw its viewership increase while he held the belt. He deserves a fitting send-off, and the chance to spread his wings on the main roster.
4. Charlotte Flair
WWE's latest attempt to make Charlotte babyface seems to be working on the surface, but you'll forgive us if we remain unconvinced.
Yes, the crowds roared their approval for her triumph over Ronda Rousey, and continued to cheer her the week after. However, a notable number of those cheers were piped in, and Ronda Rousey is so universally despised that the crowd would have popped if she'd been dethroned by Santina Marella. (If you don't know who that is - consider yourself lucky).
Appropriately, Charlotte is the polar opposite of her father's perennial nemesis, Ricky Steamboat. Just as The Dragon was the consummate babyface, Charlotte is the quintessential heel. Hell, just look at her actions one week into her latest babyface run - she faced the champion immediately after the latter had gone through a gruelling match, and told the crowd a week later she didn't need their approval. Even when she's on the side of angels, she's still following the devil on her shoulder.
Charlotte is one of the few people working today who can still draw genuine, vicious heat from a crowd, and WWE need to tap into that aspect of her personality. Charlotte works best as the arrogant alpha Queen, and feuding her with one of WWE's top babyface (*coughBiancaBelaircough*) would be instant money.
3. Shayna Baszler
Staying with Smackdown's women's division, Shayna Baszler is a sad representation of its current woes.
Baszler's current role as Ronda Rousey's sidekick is symbolic of the struggles that assailed Smackdown's female superstars in 2022 - chiefly, good ideas marred by terrible execution.
Just as WWE shot itself in the foot over Liv Morgan's horrendously-booked run with the belt, Shayna's potentially constructive stint playing Krypto to Rousey's Supergirl has instead seen the former NXT champion neutered at every turn. Only a few weeks in, Shayna has managed to not only lose every fight she's been in, but also fail to help her boss hold onto the title. Like a kryptonite-poisoned Superdog, this sidekick already needs putting down.
The sad truth is, Shayna has been so badly utilized since her career-derailing loss to Becky Lynch at WrestleMania 36 that her Queen of Spades nickname now seems cruelly ironic, as no one has been buried more than her. The current Shayna Baszler is far, far removed from the badass that dominated the NXT women's roster for two years, and it's looking less and less likely we'll ever see her return to her former glory.
2. Bryan Danielson
Seeing Bryan Danielson toiling away in AEW's midcard just feels wrong.
We know Danielson is on the back-end of his career, and that the man himself has said he is happy working down the mines with the less-luminous members of AEW's talent roster. But seeing Bryan return to him hometown to wrestle Tony Nese - a fine wrestler, but not exactly a household name - makes us feel like AEW are missing the boat with the former American Dragon.
Danielson may be enjoying his less-stressful run in the midcard, but Tony Kahn needs to take a page out of JFK's book and tell Bryan to ask not what AEW can do for him, but what he can do for AEW. Any wrestling promotion on the planet would be better off with Bryan at the top of the card, and Kahn's company is no exception.
Expectation is the price paid for greatness, and Kahn needs to give Bryan Danielson the platform to deliver on wrestling fans' expectations before the clock runs out on the latter's career.
And while we're talking about elevating wrestlers...
1. Kenny Omega
When is Kenny Omega going to wrestle for the AEW World Championship again?
Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks have long since passed the point of needing each other in their respective careers, and each would be best served to go their separate ways for the time being. Don't get us wrong, their trios matches against Death Triangle have been fun to watch, but AEW needs Kenny to step away from the tag division and back into the singles.
Kenny earned his Best Bout Machine moniker through a host of dizzyingly great one-on-one matches and, as his show-stealing bout against Will Ospreay proved, he hasn't lost a step since returning from injury last year. Putting top-tier talent in top-tier positions is wrestling 101, and AEW is no exception to that rule.
AEW have managed to avoid putting Omega and current champion MJF in each other's crosshairs thus far, but now is the time to pull the trigger on the feud. The best performer in the company against the best promo? Hopefully, 2023 is the year we get to see it happen!