10 WWE Faces Who Were Actually Total Heels

Whatever happened to the heroes?

hulk hogan wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

What is it with WWE and babyfaces?

It seems that no matter how hard they try, the company just can't build likeable, engrossing protagonists anymore. Heels have never been an issue, but something has gone awry in WWE's babyface star-making machine, and there appears to be no fixing it.

Long gone are wrestlers like Dusty Rhodes, whose everyman charm superseded his physical limitations, or even Daniel Bryan, who will forever remain one of the most likeable men in wrestling. Wrestling faces just aren't sympathetic anymore, but the trend is far from new.

Babyfaces are supposed to be defined by their honour, spirit, and integrity, but that hasn't stopped some of the sport's biggest fan favourites from behaving like textbook villains. Regardless of their popularity, it'd be a stretch to call these competitors "good guys" by any stretch of the imagination, and while each of them were cheered, none were what you'd call a positive role model.

Here are 10 WWE faces who were actually total heels.

10. Sheamus

Sheamus Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

WWE have never quite found the perfect role for Sheamus. He’s always been far better as a villain than a hero, but aside from a few spells here and there, Sheamus has rarely connected with the crowd in the way WWE have wanted. His heel runs almost ran him into the ground, particularly during the League of Nations debacle, and Sheamus was even subjected to the dreaded “X-Pac heat” for a while.

Somehow, Sheamus’ big babyface run was even worse. From 2011 to 2014, Sheamus was the absolute worst kind of WWE face: an obnoxious, smug schoolyard bully who pushed heels around and attacked without provocation. His character was completely devoid of redeeming features, and his cheesy insults and corny jokes made it incredibly tough to get behind him.

Furthermore, Sheamus was far too dominant in the ring, and steamrolled through almost everyone he faced (see: Bryan, Daniel). His world title runs were unmemorable, his feuds incredibly one-sided, and WWE never gave fans a reason to build the all-important babyface sympathy.

Sheamus has fortunately found a nice niche as Cesaro’s tag team partner on Raw these days, but he’s still very much a heel despite his allegiance with the crowd-pleasing Swiss Superman. This is probably for the best, as the last thing Raw needs is another unsympathetic babyface with Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns going around.


9. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero WWE Title No Way Out 2004
WWE.com

It’s impossible not to love Eddie Guerrero. His story is one of the most compelling in wrestling history, and his real-life battles with his own personal demons made it incredibly tough to root against him. His WWE Championship win at No Way Out 2004 wasn’t just a victory over Brock Lesnar, but a victory over himself, and it is rightly remembered as one of the most heroic title wins that the business has ever seen.

With that being said, Eddie was never the most altruistic man in the world, even when he was playing face. He had the heart of a lion and an immeasurable skill level, but Eddie still lied, cheated, and stole at every opportunity. Eddie was easy to get behind, but he was never able to let go of his old ways, and he was still faking chairshots and blasting people with title belts all the way through his babyface run.

That was the genius of Eddie Guerrero, however. He was one of the most popular guys in the company, yet some of the things he did in the ring were almost inexcusable. He still made millions of fans love him in spite of this, however, and his natural everyman charm transcended everything else. There’ll never be another wrestler quite like Eddie, whose immense relatability compelled you to forgive him whenever he dipped back into his old heelish ways.


8. Batista

batista royal rumble
WWE.com

Batista actually called himself “the worst babyface in the history of wrestling” during a 2014 radio interview. There’s a degree of hyperbole in his statement, but if he’s talking strictly about his comeback a few years ago, Big Dave isn’t far off.

The Animal’s last WWE run was a complete disaster, and bringing him back as a face was the root cause. Batista got a solid pop when he came back on the January 20th, 2014 episode of Raw, but the goodwill didn’t last. One week later, Batista was one of the most despised men in the company.

It didn’t help that many fans had taken on the idea that Batista had only returned to take advantage of his Guardians of the Galaxy hype, but Batista’s return coincided with the height of Daniel Bryan’s popularity. Bryan’s omission from the 2014 Royal Rumble combined with Batista’s victory to create a cacophony of jeers, and babyface Batista was done for.

The former Evolution member entered a program with Alberto Del Rio, but he just couldn’t turn the crowd reactions around. Fans had had enough of him, and his Hollywood flexing wasn’t doing anything to win them over either. WWE fortunately saw the light and turned him heel ahead of WrestleMania a few weeks later, but there was absolutely nothing likeable about Dave’s final run in the first place.


7. Lex Luger

Lex Luger SummerSlam
WWE.com

It’s almost impossible to summarise Lex Luger’s career objectively. Some will tell you he was one of the worst wrestlers to ever be pushed as a main eventer, but while Luger definitely had his bad days, he was usually acceptable between the ropes. He was, of course, pushed for his muscles and stature over everyone else, and failed as WWE’s hand-picked Hulk Hogan replacement. This doesn’t help his case, but he has been called “overrated” insofar that he’s become underrated, and he definitely made a huge mark on the business.

That being said, there were times when Luger was an absolutely horrendous babyface. He used the surgically-implanted metal plate in his arm to knock opponents out when he was the heelish Narcissist, but Luger kept the tactic going long after he’d turned as face The All-American. Luger would often use the plate to crack opponents in the face and steal victory without showing a shred of remorse, with the most notable example coming during his SummerSlam 1993 match with Yokozuna.

Luger’s heelish ways extended behind the scenes, too. He was one of the first wrestlers to jump ship from WWE to WCW, and his unannounced appearance on the first episode of Nitro helped kick the Monday Night Wars off.

Lex’s Nitro appearance came just one day after wrestling at a WWE house show, and nobody had a clue that he was jumping ship. WWE were under the assumption that Luger was on the verge of inking a new contract, but while it can be argued that Vince McMahon and co. dropped the ball by not locking him down, it’s still a terrible way to leave your employer.


6. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Stephanie McMahon
WWE Network

When Chris Jericho eventually calls time on his wrestling career, he deserves to be remembered as one of the greatest of all-time. In his prime, he was one of the best wrestlers on the planet, and his combination of sublime technique and flashier moves made every match unmissable.

Additionally, Jericho is one of the best talkers that the sport has ever seen, and a guy who has kept himself relevant through constant reinvention over the past 27 years. Even today, at the age of 46, Jericho is one of Raw’s most consistently enjoyable performers, proving that his charisma is evergreen.

Y2J is probably better off as a heel, but he was always immensely popular as a babyface, particularly when he was feuding with Triple H at the turn of the century. Fans loved Jericho and clung to his every sharp-witted insult, but his persona was far from heroic, and for all his positive qualities, babyface Chris Jericho was a pretty terrible person.

He insulted and ran people down on the microphone whether they deserved it or not, with some of the insults he threw at Stephanie McMahon proving particularly heinous. Jericho was still battling the company’s apparent villains, but morals were a foreign concept to him, and he was routinely one of the most puerile wrestlers on a roster that also included The Rock. That’s some achievement, and babyface Jericho was still bullying heels in early 2016, specifically while confronting The New Day.


5. Triple H

Triple H CM Punk Night of Champion 2011
WWE.com

Triple H has worn the babyface hat a number of times throughout his career, and it has almost always been a mistake. The Game probably attracts more criticism than he should, but he was always an excellent heel, particularly while feuding with Mick Foley in 2000. His greatest babyface moment came after returning from a torn quad in 2002, but he has always been more believable as the bad guy, regardless of the circumstances.

Simply put, The Game just isn’t all that likeable. He’s a physically gifted rich guy who married into wrestling’s most powerful family, and has committed a number of on-air crimes against some of the sport’s biggest faces in Steve Austin, The Rock, and co. Triple H is a born villain, and as tiresome as his “evil boss” character type has become, it’s infinitely preferable to the occasions when he has tried to be the “good guy.”

As a face, Triple H’s worst run came in 2011. It was the tail end of the Summer of Punk, and Hunter was set to feud with the man himself. All logic pointed towards Triple H turning heel to feud with CM Punk, whose buzz was at an all-time high, but The Game remained the apparent “face” throughout. He was completely detestable in the role, and his ensuing victory completely derailed Punk’s momentum and set the events that would eventually lead to his WWE departure into motion.

Even today, Triple H still tries to curry favour by painting himself as NXT’s benevolent “creator” and taking Instagram snaps with the brand’s biggest stars. It’s a role he obviously does a lot of good in, but who does Triple H think he’s fooling at this point?


4. Edge

Edge Lita
WWE

It’s easy to feel sympathetic towards Edge in 2017. His career ended in horrendously depressing fashion, and his “farewell” segment remains one of the modern era’s most emotional moments. In addition, Edge was a tremendous “total package” athlete who combined great in-ring ability with bags of charisma, and his sublime championship record and Hall of Fame status are more than justified.

That being said, Edge was always more convincing as a heel than a face. He was at his absolute best when running as WWE’s Ultimate Opportunist, and his Rated R Superstar gimmick sent him through the roof. There were times when Edge was incredibly popular as a face, but he was still very much a heel in disguise.

Edge was particularly nasty during his post-King of the Ring run from 2001-03, when he’d act dismissive and abusive to almost everyone who crossed his path, particularly Kurt Angle. His absolute worst babyface run came in 2010, however, when he was feuding with Kane.

Over the space of several weeks, “babyface” Edge kidnapped Paul Bearer, tortured him, then used him as bait to lure Kane into a series backstage assault. Kane demanded Edge let go of his Dad, but no - the “good guy” kept him in custody, and WWE even produced an angle where he ran over a Paul Bearer dummy to rile Kane up.

The worst part? It ended with Edge tricking Kane into pushing the real Paul Bearer from a 15ft scaffold onto the exposed concrete below.

What a great guy.


3. John Cena

John Cena
WWE.com

John Cena has been fantastic in his current WWE role, and there’s not much reason to gripe about his presence anymore. Roman Reigns has overtaken him as the company’s most divisive wrestler, and Cena looks set to gracefully wind his career down with the bulk of the crowd finally behind him.

You can’t, however, make a list pointing out WWE’s flawed babyfaces without mentioning his name. WWE’s franchise player has, at times, been the most obnoxious guy in the company, and one of the most unlikable faces that the company has seen. It’s not fault of his own, but Cena’s Superman character was the opposite of sympathetic, and his backlash was entirely justified.

Cena, like everyone else on this list, was a bully and at his worst, Cena was the most obnoxious, self-centered, and egotistical man in the company. From stealing Zack Ryder’s girlfriend, Eve Torres, then publicly shaming her as a “hoeski” to single-handedly destroying the Nexus, Cena’s rap sheet is almost endless, and while history will likely be kind to him, there’s no escaping the fact that he has been a terrible babyface for much of his run.

Things like the “five moves ‘o doom” argument and his stale, child-friendly character add further fuel to the argument, making Cena one of the nastiest “top faces” that WWE have ever produced.


2. The Rock

Lana The Rock
WWE

The Rock is probably the most popular figure in professional wrestling history. He is without question the biggest mainstream crossover star that the sport has ever produced, and he still draws the loudest pop of the night whenever he appears today. In his heyday, Rocky was an incredibly sharp, witty entertainer whose heel act made him so popular that WWE were forced to turn him face, and he drew the kind of crowd reactions that today’s stars can only dream of.

He was also a complete and utter douchebag.

There’s nothing wrong with cheering for The Rock, but there’s no denying that while he might have been The People’s Champion, he was far from the nicest guy in the world. Rocky would regularly belittle staff members like Michael Cole, Jonathan Coachman, and particularly Kevin Kelly, and shamed countless WWE women over the years, including Stephanie McMahon herself.

The Rock was the most arrogant guy in the building, and never thought twice about savagely insulting anyone who crossed his path. As entertaining as his Rock Contests were, they were never much more than juvenile insult-fests, particularly the most recent examples. Even today Rock only ever seems to come back to shame Lana or bury Erick Rowan in less than ten seconds, and as much as he has entertained us over the year’s, The Rock’s wrestling character isn't exactly a positive role model.


1. Hulk Hogan

hulk hogan wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

Who other than Hulk Hogan could possibly sit at the top of this particular pile? Hogan has been the biggest babyface on the planet at various times in his career, and one of the absolute worst at others.

In his heyday, Hogan was the bold, brash, larger than life superhero that Vince McMahon needed to take wrestling to the next level. Without him, WWE wouldn’t be half as successful as it is today, and he was a massive crowd-pleaser in his prime. For all his modern day transgressions, wrestling owes a huge debt of gratitude to Hulk Hogan, whose impact on the sport was immeasurable.

Hogan’s behaviour wasn’t always in-line with his popularity, however. He spat on the Russian flag while wrestling Nikolai Volkoff in 1985, and cheated Ted DiBiase out of the title by attacking him with a chair at WrestleMania 4. The 1989 saw him thrown out by the Twin Towers then assault them like a sore loser, and at the same event in 1992, Hogan distracted babyface Sid Justice to effectively help heel Ric Flair win the match.

That’s just the tip of the iceberg, and doesn’t even consider his reputation as a backstage politician or things like the Yokozuna debacle at WrestleMania IX. He finally turned heel in WCW in 1996, and eventually became a poster boy for why that company went out of business, then returned to WWE for a nostalgia run in 2002. Hulk Hogan is a trendsetter, and the most important professional wrestler of all-time, but he was often the biggest villain in the business, and that shouldn’t be forgotten.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.