10 WWE Matches John Cena Should Have Lost
There are myriad more times where Super-Cena should've met his kryptonite.
CENA WINS. LOL.
That's the sarcastic outcry of WWE fans distraught by the constant, never ending push of Vince McMahon’s favourite rainbow-coloured t-shirt vendor, John Cena. Partially, this is because of his extremely stale character, but mainly because he always wins, whether it makes sense or not.
Now, that’s not to say that Big Match John hasn’t done the favours and sometimes laid down when the time was right. Since the turn of the decade alone he’s put over CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, Brock Lesnar, Kevin Owens, AJ Styles, and Dean Ambrose, to name a few. But even so, there are plenty of times, whether to put someone over, to move a storyline foreword, or to prevent something stupid from happening, that Super-Cena should have met his kryptonite.
Here's just 10.
10. Vs. Brock Lesnar (Extreme Rules 2012)
Imagine, you have just returned to the WWE after an extended absence as the most legitimate fighter the company’s had since Kurt Angle, who left in 2006. You’ve become a big name draw in the UFC, and held titles in Japan. You are a true once in a generation attraction, this decade’s equivalent of Andre the Giant. Then, in your first match back, you get to lose to a man in a green T-shirt and jorts who just lost to a movie star that hasn’t wrestled in eight years.
Something’s wrong there.
That’s not to say that Brock didn’t look like a monster during his clash with the Cenation leader at Extreme Rules 2012, but the fact that he lost really took the wind out of his sails. Even though it took a chain shot to the head and an AA on steel stairs to fell the Beast Incarnate, his defeat made him seem less legitimate, as if he couldn’t take what he could dish out. This effect was so much so that he wasn’t truly seen as the Conqueror again, until the events of WrestleMania XXX.
9. Vs Edge And Big Show (WrestleMania XXV)
For the record, I’m not saying Big Show should have won this match. God no.
That being said, this match certainly felt like the lesser of the three big matches going into WrestleMania XXV, the others being Michaels-Undertaker, and Orton-Triple H. And it did feel quite predictable that Cena was going to win. Had this match closed out the show, I would’ve agreed with the face going over and the kids going home happy. This wasn’t the case, however, as the Triple Threat was sandwiched in between one of the greatest WrestleMania matches of all time, and a retribution storyline victory for Triple H. So there was room to shake things up a bit.
What the WWE should’ve done instead was have Cena lift both men, but only hit the AA on Big Show. Afterwords, Edge could spear Cena out of the ring, and steal the victory by pinning Show after Cena did all the work.
This could’ve set up their last man standing match at Backlash just as easily as a rematch clause. As an added bonus, the World Heavyweight Championship wouldn’t be a hot potato, Edge could’ve had a lengthier five month title reign before losing to Jeff Hardy, and he wouldn’t have had to wait two more years to get his first world title victory at WrestleMania. All Cena had to do was lose.
8. Vs. Chris Jericho (Survivor Series 2008)
First off, what did Cena do to earn this title match? He was out for three months with an injury, and certainly didn’t wrestle his way into the title picture. Was it just because Survivor Series was in Boston that year? Was it because Cena was debuting a new t-shirt? Whatever the reason, it still didn’t feel justified that Cena should’ve been Chris Jericho’s challenger for the World Heavyweight Championship
Further still, it didn’t make sense that the top heel on the card should lose the title so easily to a man with three months of ring rust. Jericho was fresh off his stellar feud with Shawn Michaels, and had just beaten Batista to regain his World Title. He was the best on the mic, putting on fantastic matches, and had a reputation for being devious. Surely, the Best in the World at What He Does could’ve found some way to weasel his way out of the match with title intact, and keep Cena chasing the gold for another month so he could really earn it at Armageddon?
Alas, this was not the case. Cena won clean with a surgically repaired neck in his first match back. Jericho looked out of his league and was sent back down the card to wrestle with a bunch of old-timers and get knocked out by Mickey Rourke, and the WWE went back to business as usual.
7. Vs. Alberto Del Rio (Night Of Champions 2011)
Alberto Del Rio’s first run in the company started well enough. He feuded with the likes of Rey Mysterio and Christian, won the Royal Rumble, and was a major player in the World Heavyweight Championship scene on SmackDown, before being drafted to Raw, winning Money In The Bank, and cashing in at SummerSlam 2011 on a beaten down CM Punk to win the WWE Championship almost a year after his debut. He did manage a successful title defence against Mysterio on the following Raw, but he never passed the one month mark with his first reign. Enter Mr. Cena at Night of Champions.
Cena picked up the win clean over Mexico’s Greatest Export, making Del Rio look like something of a transitional champion. This belief was reinforced when Alberto won the title back in a triple threat at Hell In A Cell, only to lose it again one month and two PPVs later to CM Punk. Perhaps if Del Rio had kept hold of the title from SummerSlam through to Survivor Series, he might not have such a reputation of being a weak champion.
The only reason why this wasn’t so was because WWE wanted to make Cena the first ever 10-time WWE Champion. But really, he would’ve gotten there eventually. Did it really have to come at the cost of an international star’s reputation?
6. Vs. Randy Orton (Bragging Rights 2009)
The long, monotonous feud between perennial dance partners John Cena and Randy Orton had neared its “peak” in 2009. After playing hot potato with the WWE Championship in an assortment of gimmick matches, the feud was set to conclude at the inaugural Bragging Rights PPV in a No Disqualification, No Countout, 60-Minute Iron Man Match. The stipulations were added that if the Champion Orton lost, he would relinquish his rematch clause, whilst a loss for Cena meant a departure from Raw, likely to join SmackDown.
After a long and admittedly decent clash between the prominent faces of the franchise, Cena emerged victorious by a score of 6-5. In hindsight, however, it would’ve made more sense for Orton to retain and for Cena to go to the blue brand. Orton could’ve taken the title into his feud with Kofi Kingston, and then into a feud with Legacy stablemates Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase Jr, elevating the importance of each feud and giving these young stars a rich taste of the Raw main event scene. All three are wrestlers that are either off our screens today, or stuck in the midcard, and could’ve been more prominent if they had that sort of exposure.
Cena, on the other hand, was heading for a WrestleMania feud with Batista, who had to transfer from SmackDown to Raw for the angle to work. Instead, have Cena go to Batista, and have the feud be over the World Heavyweight Championship instead.
As it happened, the result was short sighted, and could’ve worked a lot better had Cena been on the losing end.
5. Vs. Chris Benoit (SmackDown, April 17, 2003)
Yes, even back in his humble origins as The Doctor of Thuganomics, the Chain Gang Commander was still picking up victories where he shouldn’t have.
After Brock Lesnar won the WWE Championship at WrestleMania XIX, a No. 1 Contender’s tournament was held on SmackDown to determine his challenger for Backlash. The finals came down to Chris Benoit and a young John Cena, not even 12 months into his WWE career.
The match itself was nothing to scoff at, and Cena picking up the upset victory over the veteran Benoit was a great way to put the fresh star over. What was a problem, however, was Cena’s performance against Lesnar at the PPV. It was quite clear that the young lion didn’t belong in the main event scene just yet. If Cena had taken the fall on April 17, 2003, there would be little doubt that a Backlash main event between Lesnar and Benoit would’ve been an absolute classic.
4. Vs. Zack Ryder (Raw, December 5, 2011)
Now, I’m not saying that the Long Island Iced Z should’ve beat Cena clean (although could you imagine the pop!), but given the stakes and circumstances of the match itself, perhaps Ryder beating Big Match John could’ve been a welcome notion.
The stipulation was that if Cena won, he would’ve been added to a TLC match for the WWE Championship with CM Punk, Alberto Del Rio, and The Miz. A Ryder victory would’ve given him a one-on-one US Title match against Dolph Ziggler at the TLC PPV. Cena pinned Ryder clean after an AA, but seeing Ryder lose his long awaited opportunity to conclude the Ryder Revolution of 2011, Cena gave up his title shot to give the Internet Champion a shot at an actual WWE Championship. Cena then helped his ally beat Mark Henry in a No-DQ match. Cena wound up with all the glory, and Ryder looked more like a passenger than someone who earned his way to a title match.
It didn’t have to be that way, however. Instead, WWE should’ve had Miz and Del Rio interfere in the match to try and eliminate Cena from their match, and have Ryder, unknowingly, take advantage of the situation with a fluke roll up. While it does make Ryder look a bit of a heel, a simple handshake from Cena could’ve remedied that, and Ryder could’ve felt like he earned his place fighting for a championship. And if Cena wasn’t going to fight for the WWE title in the end anyway, he didn’t need the momentum of a victory.
Just one of many ways the Cenation leader hampered the Ryder Revolution.
3. Vs. CM Punk (Raw, February 25, 2013)
Sometimes, a bad booking decision isn’t about putting someone over, but about the path the combatants will go down after the match is done. Such is the case here.
Cena has put over CM Punk many times, and it wasn’t like Punk was in dire need of a victory here. He was only a month removed from his 434-day WWE title reign, and was on course to take on The Undertaker at WrestleMania 29. This, however, was a match the fans needed The Straight-Edge Saviour to win. Desperately.
The stipulation was that whomever won the encounter would face The Rock for his WWE Championship at ‘Mania 29. Cena staked his claim as that year’s Royal Rumble winner, while Punk wanted another rematch for his title after being unsuccessful in regaining it at Elimination Chamber. After another match-of-the-year candidate from the two rivals, Cena emerged victorious after a standing hurricanrana and an AA. Which meant we had to deal with…
…TWICE IN A LIFETIME. ROCK/CENA 2!
WWE could’ve prevented the integrity of one of their biggest encounters (and marketing ploys) from being annihilated by having CM Punk win one way or the other. A clean win would’ve meant a one-on-one match, while a dirty win could’ve been spun into one of the most appetising triple threats in ‘Mania history. Either possibility would’ve been miles better than the gutting realization that we, as fans, had been lied to for an entire year about Rock/Cena being “Once in a Lifetime”.
2. Vs. Bray Wyatt (WrestleMania XXX)
Here’s the part of the list where Cena gets the shovels out.
Bray Wyatt was on his way to becoming one of WWE’s major players in the future, seemingly destined to be the next Undertaker. His promos, although at times a little too much of a riddle to understand, were genuinely haunting and captivating. In the ring, he worked stiff, physical matches, that made him seem even more dangerous than his mannerisms showed, and when paired with the right guy, he could put on classics, like his match against Daniel Bryan at the 2014 Royal Rumble. The sky seemed the limit for The Eater of Worlds.
Unfortunately, his limit was Hustle, Loyalty, and Respect.
The story of their WrestleMania XXX encounter was that John Cena could only beat Bray and the rest of the Wyatt Family by unleashing his “inner monster”. What that entailed was hopefully a darker side of Mr. Fluorescent T-Shirts. For much of the match, Wyatt taunted Cena, at one point handing him a chair, and asking it to use it on him to force a DQ. Cena, however, overcame the odds, and won with the AA.
Imagine how different it could’ve turned out if Cena had started to fall into Bray’s darkness only to stop himself, and have Bray take advantage. It would’ve given Wyatt’s words so much meaning, and would’ve made him look unstoppable. Unfortunately, his speech seemed hollow by the fact that he couldn’t realize his own prophesies. In other words, his loss to Cena has sent him down a path he’s been walking ever since.
1. Team WWE Vs The Nexus (SummerSlam 2010)
Here it is. The big one.
This has been talked about so much on this site that it doesn’t need that much more explanation. Cena, using his own creative control, halted the white-hot careers of seven up and coming stars from the first season of NXT. Even taking a DDT on exposed concrete wouldn’t keep The Face That Runs The Place down. He fought back and made Nexus leader Wade Barrett tap to the STF in the middle of the ring. Suddenly, this imposing threat seemed castrated.
It’s a telling sign that the likes of Edge and Chris Jericho told Cena that it was a bad idea to humiliate the rookies in this way. It’s a telling sign that Cena later admitted regret for his decision. It’s a telling sign that for all the potential the likes of Barrett, Justin Gabriel, and Skip Sheffield (Ryback) had, the group of 7 from SummerSlam 2010 produced no World Champions in WWE. It’s a telling fact that the only former members wrestling full time for WWE today are Heath Slater and Darren Young, both relegated to comedy acts.
All and all, we can only dream of what could’ve been, had Big Match John refrained from saying:
CENA WINS.
LOL