10 WWE Matches That Didn't Know When To End

Because sometimes less is more.

Edge Randy Orton sleeper
WWE.com

One key component of making a wrestling match hit home in the right way, is knowing when to call time and bring it to a close.

So many times over the years, we've seen great matches brought down by going on for too long, and likewise some bad matches have been turned into absolute stinkers due to an inability to go home in a reasonable time. Telling the story of a match is one thing, but there's also got to be an acknowledgement of maintaining your audience's attention and also of upholding a sense of believability to what is being seen in the ring.

In particular, when it comes to big matches at major events, there's a habit of wanting to do too much for the audience - hence why we've all had to sit through some utter snoozefests at several WrestleManias over the decades.

At times in wrestling, less is more. Unfortunately, that's something that the performers featured in this article have occasionally lost sight of. Here are ten prime examples of WWE matches that simply didn't know when to ring the damn bell.

10. Triple H Vs. Scott Steiner - Royal Rumble 2003

Royal Rumble 2003 Scott Steiner Triple H
WWE

God love Scott Steiner.

From tag team icon to Big Poppa Pump, the legit tough younger of the Steiners was so entertaining for so long. Heck, even in his recent appearances for the NWA, this multiple-time WCW World Heavyweight Champion has still shown that he has value in the 2020 landscape of professional wrestling.

Despite his standout tag team career and his several runs as WCW's top dog, it quickly became clear that the Scott Steiner who returned to WWE in late-2002 wasn't the Scott Steiner seen throughout the '80s and '90s. In fact, this wasn't even the same Scott Steiner seen during WCW's dying days.

Instead, Freakzilla was a shell of his former self when it came to his in-ring work, with that largely down to getting one of his ankles fused in place.

Still, Steiner ended up facing World Heavyweight Champion Triple H at the 2003 edition of the Royal Rumble PPV. The build to that match was fun, as the two rivals used smoke and mirrors to get around Steiner's mobility issues. But by the time their Rumble match came along, for some reason the call was made to go nearly 20 minutes.

The end result was a match that stunk out Boston's Fleet Center venue, a match that won numerous awards for being the worst of 2003, and a match that sadly highlighted just how restricted Scott Steiner now was.

Thankfully, their No Way Out rematch was trimmed down to 13 minutes - although, even then, that still felt like a contest that should have ended far sooner than it eventually did.


9. Edge Vs. Randy Orton - WrestleMania 36

Edge Randy Orton WrestleMania 36
WWE.com

Man alive, wasn't it all kinds of great to see Edge return to a WWE ring at this year's Royal Rumble PPV? Yes, yes it was.

The *begins Tony Chimel voice* Rated R Superstar *ends Tony Chimel voice* had the sort of return that many can only dream of. Nine years after his passion and childhood dream had been ripped out from under him, Adam Copeland had gotten to a place in life where he was finally able to step between the ropes once more.

Of course, the buzz around this return was only amplified further after Edge was left laying by Randy Orton on the night after the Rumble, and it's fair to say that Edge vs. Orton was the match that the majority of us were most looking forward to at WrestleMania 36.

While the current global chaos and lockdown measures meant that this match had to take place at the empty WWE Performance Center, the contest did itself no favours by going nearly 40 minutes.

It's always going to be hard to maintain an audience's attention for any significant amount of time in such an empty setting, and that indeed proved to be the case for the clashing of these two multiple-time World Champions.

Edge and Randy both put it a great effort, the build to the match was truly must-see TV, and the proposition of a Last Man Standing Match only added further fuel to the fire. Unfortunately, clocking in at 37 minutes meant that this much-hyped match just fell disappointingly flat.

Given the empty arena, capping the match at 20 minutes would've likely resulted in a vastly improved final product for one of 'Mania 36's biggest attractions.


8. D-Generation X Vs. The Brothers Of Destruction - Crown Jewel 2018

Shawn Michaels Undertaker Crown Jewel
WWE.com

Three part-time wrestlers and a retired former wrestler walk into a wrestling ring...

While the D-Generation X vs. Brothers of Destruction match at the 2018 edition of Crown Jewel was viewed as a joke by many wrestling fans as soon as it was announced, that contest went on to bore the pants off each and every person who opted to watch the match.

After seeming to be one of the extremely rare wrestlers who were going to stay retired, Shawn Michaels was lured back into action by the Scrooge McDuck levels of money offered up to him for this one-and-done bout. By this point, Michaels was alongside The Undertaker and Kane in being in his 50s. Throw in Triple H and his notorious penchant for having matches that go painfully long, and the ingredients suggested that this wasn't going to go well.

Four veterans battling each other in tag action is something that can be successful if done well, yet this Crown Jewel clash played out to be a truly painful 28 minutes.

An injury to Triple H obviously didn't help the match, but there's an argument to be made that that derailment should've been the cue to go home earlier than originally intended. Instead, we got an overly-long, plodding tag team encounter that not even the undeniable brilliance of the hadn't-missed-a-step Heartbreak Kid could salvage.


7. Bret Hart Vs. Bob Backlund - Survivor Series 1994

Bret Hart Bob Backlund Survivor Series 1994
WWE

In Bret Hart and Bob Backlund, you have two multiple-time World Champions, two Hall of Famers, two top level in-ring technicians, and two of the most respected grapplers of their respective generations.

Despite all of this, the pair's match at Survivor Series 1994 dragged on for far longer than was necessary - to the point it became a chore to sit through.

Sure, the story of the match meant that Bob had to lock Hart into his patented Chicken Wing in order to have Owen Hart convince mother Helen to throw in the towel for Bret. But still, this could have all been executed just as well without having to drag the audience through a match that landed at just over the 35-minute mark.

Bret himself has gone on record himself to say how his clash with Backlund at WrestleMania XI is his least favourite PPV match, yet that match was at least done and dusted after nine minutes.

The story of that Survivor Series match was actually rather good, it's just that it took far, far too long to get to the twist of Owen and his crocodile tears costing the Hitman his WWF Championship. Backlund having Bret locked in that Chicken Wing for ten minutes is questionable in itself, yet alone to have a further 25 minutes of the match take place before that spot came to fruition.


6. Michael Cole Vs. Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania XXVII

Michael Cole Jerry Lawler
WWE.com

14 minutes is how long was decided to give Michael Cole and Jerry Lawler in their god-awful WrestleMania XXVII match. And that's not counting the post-match BS that followed this horrendous contest.

Decked out in amateur wrestling headgear and with his prison tattoos on display, Cole actually went down as the winner in this content thanks to a cheap DQ victory after the anonymous Raw GM declared him the winner. Forget Jerry Lawler though, for the real loser of this match was the watching audience.

If WWE wanted the cheap win for Cole, fine, but that is something that could've been done in half the time it took for this match to play out to its close.

Just when you thought the King was close to wrapping up a victory and bringing this match to an end, Cole would fudge his way out of that particular predicament. Then, even when Cole tapped out and the match concluded, we were "treated" to all of the post-match controversy.

To give some context on the time afforded to Michael Cole vs. Jerry Lawler at WrestleMania XXVII, the match was longer than that PPV's bouts of World Heavyweight Champion Edge vs. Alberto Del Rio, US Champion Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan, Rey Mysterio vs. Cody Rhodes, and was only a matter of seconds shorter than Randy Orton vs. CM Punk.

Basically, the only matches given significantly more time than Cole vs. Lawler were Triple H vs. The Undertaker, and The Miz defending the WWE Championship against John Cena.


5. Macho Man Vs. Ultimate Warrior - SummerSlam 1992

Ultimate Warrior Randy Savage SummerSlam 1992.jpg
WWE.com

'Macho King' Randy Savage vs. Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VII is one of the very best matches in the history of WWE's annual Showcase of the Immortals. For sheer emotional storytelling, very few professional wrestling contests can get anywhere even close to matching that retirement match.

Skipping ahead to SummerSlam '92, and these two icons would again be doing battle - this time with Savage's WWF Championship on the line.

Anticipation was high, the Wembley Stadium location offered something utterly unique, and the looming presence of the nefarious duo of Ric Flair and Mr Perfect added a sense of intrigue to this match-up. Unfortunately, the bout would go far, far too long - especially for a Warrior match - and would go to the well one too many times on the mystery over which of Savage and Warrior had the secret backing of Flair and Perfect.

Of course, Flair and Perfect would be out for themselves and would leave both competitors lying. That in itself was fine, but it took 28 long minutes to get to the anticlimactic finish of the Warrior picking up a countout win.

A long Ultimate Warrior match was a rarity, and with good reason. The fact that Savage got a stunning match out of the Parts Unknown native at WrestleMania VII was the stuff of legend. To expect the Macho Man to be able to repeat that trick once again was simply asking too much of even somebody as great as Randy Savage.


4. Adam Cole Vs. Johnny Gargano - NXT TakeOver: New York

Adam Cole Johnny Gargano NXT TakeOver New York
WWE

Hear me out here...

It's hard to say that the NXT TakeOver: New York battle between Adam Cole and Johnny Gargano wasn't a fantastic example of just why professional wrestling is so special to so many people. The thing is, even with the two-out-of-three falls stipulation, there were just so many moments where it felt as if this match should have ended before it did.

Adam Cole is great. Johnny Gargano is great. This match, for the most part, was great. Without trying to go too 'old man shouts at cloud' about it, there were just too many false finishes on display in the closing moments of this battle.

With the contest tied at one fall apiece, Gargano was hit with several of Cole's trademark Last Shot manoeuvres, only to kick out time and time again - and then there was the Panama Sunrise kicked out of by Johnny, too! Even after Undisputed Era interfered in a way that allowed Cole to hit yet another Last Shot, Johnny Wrestling again kicked out.

False finishes can add so much to a match, and Gargano showing the fighting spirit of a champion by surviving some of Cole's best shots is great... to an extent. Despite being so brilliant in so many ways, even the most avid of NXT fans will struggle to deny that Cole vs. Gargano at TakeOver: New York could have ended a little earlier than it ultimately did, and the closing moments of the match rode a dangerous line between tense drama and diluting the impact of these supposed big-time moves.

Anyway, it's back to shouting at that cloud for me.


3. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton - Super ShowDown 2019

WWE Super Showdown 2019 Triple H Randy Orton
WWE.com

It really is hard not to litter all ten entries in this piece with Triple H matches, but three seems like a realistic limit for The Game's outings that went far longer than they ever needed to.

Make no mistake about it, Triple H was a truly elite level worker for years. Even then, mind, he had a habit of his matches often going on for far longer than was realistically necessary. Case in point, his Super ShowDown match against Randy Orton just last year.

In amongst their multitude of matches against each other over the years, it's often pointed out how the pair's WrestleMania XXV match just didn't know when to call it a day. That match would clock in at 25 plodding minutes, although there's the argument that this contest was the main event of that 2009 edition of the Showcase of the Immortals, that the match was for the WWE Championship, and that both Hunter and Randy were both premium workers still in their prime.

Skip ahead ten years to Super ShowDown, and there really is no excuse whatsoever for allocating another 25 minutes to an ice cold meeting between Randy Orton and a largely-retired Triple H.

Seth Rollins was given only 11 minutes as he defended the Universal Championship against Baron Corbin at that Saudi Arabia special, while Intercontinental Champion Finn Bálor was allotted the same time in his match against Andrade. For Orton and Triple H though, they were given over twice as long as any other singles match on the show - all for a match that should have ended with a solitary RKO.

In the end, we got to see a couple or RKOs and a Pedigree before all was said and done in a match that was at least 10 minutes too long.


2. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon - WrestleMania XXVI

bret hart vince mcmahon
WWE.com

As somebody whose absolute favourite wrestler of all-time is Bret Hart, it goes against every fibre of my being to have to include the Hitman in this article - let alone include him twice! - but let's be honest, that WrestleMania XXVI match against Vince McMahon was agonisingly too long.

What audiences needed to see in that match, was McMahon taking the sort of unrelenting beating that many thought he deserved for how he handled things in Montreal back at Survivor Series 1997. And while Vince was largely dominated by Bret throughout their match, this was a contest that could and should have gone no longer than five minutes at the absolute most.

It's actually a little surprising to look back and realise that Hart vs. McMahon only barely scraped 11 minutes in length, for the slow, repetitive beatdown of Vinny Mac honestly felt like it lasted at least 20 minutes in real-time back in 2010 and in any subsequent repeat viewings.

For fans, it would have been enough to see the Excellence of Execution land a few good, stiff shots on Vince, before then tapping him out with his iconic Sharpshooter. And while those said shots and Sharpshooter were indeed accounted for in the match, there was so much needless other shenanigans incorporated into what should have been a brief, laser-focused display of revenge and comeuppance.


1. Shane McMahon Vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania 32

WrestleMania 32 Undertaker Table
WWE.com

A Shane McMahon match should never, ever receive anywhere even close to half an hour.

While WrestleMania 32's main event of Roman Reigns vs. Triple H was the typical overindulgent Triple H match we've come to expect at such big shows, so too did Shane McMahon vs. The Undertaker deliver the usual guff that we see whenever Shane O'Mac steps into the ring.

The Undertaker is one of the all-time greatest to ever lace up a pair of boots. WrestleMania is where the Phenom's star shines brightest. The Hell in a Cell structure is his playground. Yet still, Shane was made to look like The Undertaker's equal for so much of this 'Mania 32 contest.

Realistically, an early Last Ride should have been more than enough to put McMahon away. Then came the Deadman's Hell's Gate submission move, which Shane and his MMA expertise countered into a Sharpshooter. After that, going through a table still wasn't enough to keep Shane O' down. In fact, in a narrative sense, it was really only Shane McMahon who beat Shane McMahon on that 2016 night.

Deciding to take the high-risk road and dive off the top of the cell, only to crash and burn, that was what led to Shane's downfall in this match.

Remember, Undertaker has won championship gold with both the Last Ride and the Hell's Gate. But Shane McMahon is a McMahon, dammit, and thus this WrestleMania match was given a ludicrous 30 minutes - which was likely 20 minutes more than this contest should ever have been allocated.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.