10 WWE Returns Nobody Saw Coming

SURPRISE!

Ric Flair Return 2001
WWE.com

There aren't too many wrestlers who don't make a WWE return at some point.

Vince McMahon's approach to things has always been very much 'business first, personal stuff second', which is why so many guys and gals he's fallen out with over the years have been welcomed back into the fold eventually. This is true even when it seems like the least likely thing ever amongst wrestling fans or industry critics.

That skepticism is something that suits the company; if fans don't expect someone to return, then their reaction will be priceless when they do. That's the thinking anyway, and it typically works. WWE's fondness for shocks and surprise comebacks has led to some truly beautiful moments over the years, and that's true even when success ended up being more short-lived than anyone would've liked.

The rise of the internet (and social media with it) has made it harder than ever for McMahon to keep things under wraps. Someone will probably talk, thus killing any sudden astonishment when that returnee strolls through the curtain.

What about the times they don't though? They're often the most special...


10. Heath Slater (6 July 2020 - Raw)

Heath Slater
WWE

Here's the most recent example.

Former Nexus, Social Outcasts, Slater Gator, 3MB and "I Got Kids" underdog Heath Slater was one of the many let go from WWE in April. Since then, he's been talking about his run in the media and teasing a gig with Impact Wrestling, so nobody expected him to launch a comeback on the 6 July Raw.

He did though - Slater wrestled old pal Drew McIntyre and then they threw up that old 3MB sign. There's no news yet on whether this is a one-off (probably) or the start of something more for Heath, but it's the actual comeback that was shocking. It's doubtful anyone could've predicted that one.

Some on Twitter are happy to see Slater back, whereas others pointed out that he wouldn't have much of a role now WWE has burned through his most natural story with McIntyre. Let's hope the guy at least got a nice pay day out of it.


9. Alberto Del Rio (Hell In A Cell 2015)

Alberto Del Rio Zeb Colter
WWE.com

Not even the truly woeful 'Mex-America' fallout involving former xenophobe Zeb Colter could kill the pop for Alberto Del Rio's unforeseen Hell In A Cell 2015 return. Fans in LA were hot for his comeback, and the goodwill continued for around eight more minutes until Del Rio beat John Cena for the US Title.

Then, it faded.

The crummy alliance with Colter must share part of the blame there, because nobody wanted it. Fans were stunned by the sight of a fired-up Alberto bounding out to take the belt from Cena, and they didn't need some old dude on a mobility scooter to help them react.

Del Rio had been fired amidst allegations of racism towards him from a WWE backstage employee in August 2014. When he reacted to that, Alberto was canned for "unprofessional conduct", and few expected to see him back so soon (if at all).


8. Tatanka (Royal Rumble 2006)

Royal Rumble 2006 Tatanka Triple H
WWE

'Who's that guy?'.

That was surely the sentiments of most youngsters attending the 2006 Royal Rumble when early-90s Native American sensation Tatanka rocked up as #15 in the titular match for a 15-minute cameo. The former 'New Generation' fave hadn't been seen since 1996. 10 years later, he was back, and it was... unexpected.

The fact that Tatanka then went on to trade a nostalgic Rumble bit part for a full time role on the WWE roster was even more stunning. He'd last until january 2007 before being released from his contract, but then showed up for yet another cameo at WrestleMania 32.

To put this one into perspective, consider an alternative. Imagine the company had brought back Henry O. Godwinn for one more run in 2006, and then hired him so he could work a tag feud against rising stars MNM on SmackDown. That's along the same lines.


7. D'Lo Brown (21 July 2008 - Raw)

D'Lo Brown 2008
WWE.com

After five years away in TNA and All Japan Pro Wrestling, ex-Nation Of Domination head bobber D'Lo Brown returned to WWE television with a win over Santino Marella. His return, on the 21 July 2008 episode of Raw, flew under the radar. Fans seemed genuinely happy to see him though.

WWE's interest didn't last - Brown was relegated to dark matches, house shows and (worse) ECW before being released once again the following January as a cost-cutting measure. All in all, his grand comeback extended to one win over Marella, a tag-match loss to Santino and Beth Phoenix with Kelly Kelly and another DQ loss to Santina's brother.

It'd be interesting to grill someone in the know about exactly what WWE had in mind for D'Lo before re-debuting him on TV. Keep in mind that Marella, comedy character or not, was a popular character in the mix for the Intercontinental Title at the time, so it had to be something.

Long live the head bob. You better recognise.


6. The Hardy Boyz (WrestleMania 33)

WrestleMania 33 Hardy Boyz
WWE.com

This one is personally meaningful to your writer.

He was there in the tarted-up Camping World Stadium for WrestleMania 33, and he leapt out of his seat (spilling a $15 Jack Daniels and Coke in the process) when guest hosts New Day proudly announced that The Hardy Boyz were in the house. As soon as that trademark music hit, the entire place lost it.

Approximately 24 hours before, Matt and Jeff had worked ROH's Supercard Of Honor XI pay-per-view. Some suspected something was afoot when they dropped their Tag-Team Titles to The Young Bucks, though nobody could've predicted the scenes in Orlando. That WWE return came much sooner than even the smartest fan would've imagined.

The reaction was almost indescribable. People on all levels of wrestling fandom hugged like all their dreams had come true, and the siblings were visibly over-the-moon to be back "home". This must rank as one of the best 'Mania comebacks of all time.


5. Shane McMahon (22 February 2016 - Raw)

Shane McMahon Vince McMahon Stephanie McMahon
WWE

Forget the ensuing "lock box" fiasco, because Shane McMahon's big comeback on the 22 February 2016 edition of Raw sent chills running up and down the spines of all who witnessed it live. To their credit, both Vince and Stephanie also produced excellent facial expressions to sell their own shock.

This was as organic a moment as WWE could produce on an otherwise-contrived Monday night flagship that year, and it did promise shake-ups on the road to WrestleMania 32. At that moment, when Shane flashed a smile at his baby sister and dad, he was the man around those there parts.

The 'Boy Wonder' done good was back.

The best thing about it was that WWE successfully kept everyone off the scent. Reports had been rife in the media for years that Shane was happy doing his own thing outside the company, and that meant his Raw return caught everyone off guard.


4. Edge (Royal Rumble 2020)

Edge Royal Rumble
WWE.com

Was Edge's Royal Rumble 2020 comeback the best ever?

There's an argument for it, certainly. When Alter Bridge's classic 'Metalingus' track blared out into the night air in Houston, the rush was immense. Sure, there had been conjecture about a possible return from retirement for the 'Rated-R Superstar' beforehand, but those reports were always met with doubts.

How could he? The man had retired in 2011 with a serious neck injury that doctors said was untreatable. The mere thought that Edge would launch back into fan consciousness as anything more than a WWE Network host-come-cameo attraction seemed impossible, but it happened. What a moment it was.

Edge was teary-eyed as he breathed heavy before even lifting a finger in-ring, and fans all over the world sat in stunned amazement as the Canadian prepared to wrestle his first match in nine years. Literally everyone watching felt that lump of emotion in their throats, and it was awesome.


3. Ric Flair (19 November 2001 - Raw)

Ric Flair Vince Mcmahon
WWE.com
"We're partners!".

With those two words, obviously accompanied by his trademark "Woo!" refrain, Ric Flair closed his first WWF appearance since the 25 January 1993 episode of Raw. Precisely 3,320 days following that 'Loser Leaves Town' loss to Mr. Perfect, 'Slick Ric' was back in the big time.

Obviously, the fact he'd been missing from the WCW invasion angle was regrettable; as the figurehead of some internal power struggle between his old stomping ground and a place he'd sought solace in the early-90s, Flair would've been brilliant. It wasn't to be, but his night-after-Survivor Series re-debut was arguably worth sacrificing that.

OK, so maybe some fans inside the Charlotte Coliseum might've known there was a good chance of some 'Nature Boy' action, but they were in the minority. People watching at home were pleasantly surprised by Ric's interruption just as it looked like Vince McMahon was going to gloat about killing WCW all over again.

Woo!


2. CM Punk (12 November 2019 - Backstage)

CM Punk, WWE Backstage
WWE.com

Had some eager soul from November 2019 shot back in time to claim that want-away rebel CM Punk would show up on a peripheral WWE talk show after leaving with a bad taste in his mouth in 2014, everybody (and their granny...and their granny's dog) would've chuckled.

Fat chance of that ever happening.

Sometimes, reality is stranger than any fantasy scenarios fans could come up with though. Seeing Punk, who had left WWE with a middle finger raised over five years earlier, walking out to play host on a show hardly anyone was interested in was damn weird. It'd be like if Bret Hart had strutted his stuff on Bottom Line back in the day.

News that Punk's contract was actually with FOX and not WWE didn't pick jaws up off the floor. Most had predicted he'd return someday, but those folks reasoned that it'd be for a massive WrestleMania pay off or something like that. Nobody had Punk pegged as a background analyst on a background show.


1. John Cena (Royal Rumble 2008)

John Cena Royal Rumble 2008
WWE

John Cena is superhuman.

That's the only explanation for his implausible return from injury at the 2008 Royal Rumble. Mere months earlier, on 1 October, Cena had torn his pectoral muscle during a hip toss spot with Mr. Kennedy. Worried doctors declared that WWE's poster boy would take six months to recover, and that meant he'd likely miss 'Mania.

'Screw that', said gym freak John. 118 days later (which was just shy of four full months on from his nasty muscle rip), Cena was back in the mix and winning the '08 Rumble match. What's more, he looked like he hadn't missed a step - no lost muscle mass, no ring rust and one beaming smile.

Madison Square Garden erupted like it was 1977 and Bruno Sammartino had just entered the building when Cena marched out as #30. It was ridiculous that he'd been able to rehab such a bad injury so quickly, and it caught everyone by surprise.

-

What other WWE returns did nobody see coming? For more like this, check out 10 Ridiculous Tag-Teams WWE Missed Out On and 10 Sneaky Tributes To WWE Greats!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.