10 WWE Wishes (That Will Never Come True)

Puncturing your wildest wrestling dreams.

Undertaker Sting
WWE.com

Professional wrestling is a dream factory, where improbable things come true.

Men survive terrifying plunges from cages, women go from obscurity to world-beating popularity, and Undertakers, demons, and Fiends compete for title belts. In the WWE, anything can happen.

Only, a lot of the time, it doesn’t. Every wrestling fan has their own wish list, be that dream matches they’d kill to see or booking directions they crave for their favourite stars. Sometimes these come true - The Man, Kofimania, The Yes Movement - but often, they don’t, no matter how many fans online and beyond clamour.

Now, we’re not talking about your Owen Hart vs Kurt Angle dream matches here - this list comprises angles and matches that could, within the realms of reality, actually take place. But for whatever reason (practicality, timing, inflexibility on the part of Vince et al), we can say confidently they won’t.

WWE wishes can come true, and they’re not always great (we’re looking at you, Nakamura vs Styles). All the same, it’s nothing short of heartbreaking to think of the sheer possibility WWE has in its hands that will never bear fruit...

10. Tommaso Ciampa On The Main Roster

tommaso Ciampa
WWE.com

The road from NXT to the main roster is a rocky one, with many surefire prospects underutilised on Raw and Smackdown. With the upcoming NXT shakeup, many black and gold stalwarts must be thinking about their next move. One wrestler who’d surely have a place in the big leagues is Tommaso Ciampa.

That’s never going to happen, and for once, it’s due to the performer’s own principles rather than company mismanagement. Ciampa has a history of neck injuries, and while by no means in advanced years, has been around the block a few times. He has explicitly said that, due to the workload, he’d sooner retire than join the main roster.

That’s completely understandable - he’s a family man and sensibly health-conscious - but no less a shame. While he’s not the tallest of superstars, Ciampa is stacked, intense, feels like a proper character, and comes with a ready-made angle courtesy of his online beef with Randy Orton.

We’d never suggest that Ciampa should do anything other than what’s best for him and his, but of all the NXT veterans, few seem so well poised for a big push (which probably means Vince et al would ruin him all the sooner).


9. Edge and Christian Reunion

Edge Christian
WWE

For two Royal Rumbles in a row, WWE fans were overjoyed to see the returns of Canadian veterans whose in-ring days appeared to be long over. 2020 saw the improbably re-emergence of Edge; a year later the less flashy but equally heartwarming comeback of his best pal (and former brother) Christian.

The two embraced in the ring and did a little double team action - and then that was sort of it. Captain Charisma’s release was confirmed shortly after, and he’s now with AEW (and presumably transitioning to Impact, whose world belt he’s just won), doing very nicely indeed.

The sheer fact that these two are competing in 2021 is enough for most fans, but to reunite one of the all-time great tag teams, even just for a few matches, would have been a dream come true. Both men are pushing 50 and most likely want to explore new angles with their remaining years - besides, they hadn’t teamed for many years before their early retirements - but nobody knows the power of nostalgia better than WWE.

It’s hard to see Christian making yet another WWE return, so with a heavy heart, we’ve most likely seen our last five-second pose already.


8. Stone Cold Steve Austin: One More Match

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

Among his myriad achievements, Stone Cold Steve Austin can lay claim to being the only retired wrestler who has actually stayed retired. Recent years have seen the likes of Ric Flair and Shawn Michaels come off the bench, back into active competition, usually with disastrous consequences.

In all likelihood, were Stone Cold to lace up his boots and buckle that knee brace one more time, it would probably be a horror show. The man’s nearly 20 years out of the game, and while he keeps in good shape, he’s 56 years old.

All the same, the roar when that glass smashed and the Rattlesnake walked and talked his way to the ring would perhaps justify the inevitable shoddiness of the following match. Austin can pop a crowd with a promo and a Stunner like few on Earth, but there’s a difference between doing that on Raw Legends Night and in an actual match.

Austin’s opinion on the matter seems to be that he doesn’t want to come back for anything less than a great match, which he feels he isn’t capable of, and he knows better than anyone else what he’s able to achieve. He’s a bonafide wrestling titan who deserves his comfy retirement, even if we still can’t help wondering “what if?”


7. AJ Lee Getting Her Due

CM Punk AJ Lee
WWE.com

The women’s evolution was the best thing to come out of WWE’s 2010s, and while the revisionism was a tad distasteful (namely the amount of credit Stephanie McMahon lavished on herself), pay per views like Evolution and the 2018 Royal Rumble were a great opportunity to celebrate women who were never used to the fullest in the bad old days, like Lita, Trish Stratus, and Beth Phoenix.

One woman whose influence is rarely mentioned, however, is AJ Lee. Before the Four Horsewomen, female PPV headliners, and WrestleMania main events, AJ was one of the best female talents (we won’t say “divas”) the company had to offer, explosive on the mic and more than proficient in the ring, though seldom given much time to work.

She even called out Stephanie publicly after the CBO supported fair treatment in Hollywood, pointing out that McMahon’s own company failed to practise what she preached.

Shortly before things changed for the better, AJ retired, citing injury and burnout. We don’t expect her to get back in the ring, but her role in the company should be more frequently celebrated - and possibly would be, were it not for her marriage to one CM Punk.


6. Dolph Ziggler Utilised Properly

Dolph Ziggler
WWE

What does it take to get a push in WWE? A great physique, technical skills, the ability to make others look better, confidence, gift of the gab, crowd support. Some combination of these attributes should, in theory, set you up as a star in the company - unless, of course, you’re Dolph Ziggler.

The mismanagement of Ziggler in WWE beggars belief. The guy can have a good match with anyone, bumps like you wouldn’t believe, looks the part, and can talk. He’s a terrific heel and at times has excelled as a babyface. You only need to look at his Money In The Bank cash-in or his career vs title match with The Miz to see that, booked right, the universe absolutely adores him.

And yet, WWE has lost interest in the show off so many times. He’s reached the top of the mountain, only to be flicked off or fed to Goldberg (and even then, he made Goldberg look as good as he has in years).

If it hasn’t happened now, it never will - Ziggler’s 41, rarely makes it to PPV, and mostly occupies the tag division now. The guy is well paid, well respected, and has the freedom to go off and do other stuff (namely stand up comedy) that few others do - still, his career is a mystery.


5. The Undertaker Vs Sting

Undertaker Sting
twitter

To call this a wish in 2021 may be stretching things a little. The two spooky legends are deep into middle age, with Undertaker formally retired and Sting still working but booked very much around his limitations (which is no insult - the guy’s 62 and in phenomenal condition). The time for this match would surely have been WrestleMania 31, a card on which both men performed, and were essentially wasted.

All the same, this may be wrestling’s greatest ever What if? match, beyond even Hogan vs Austin. Two great company men, locker room leaders, masters of reinvention, quasi-supernatural figures who never felt daft or corny.

Sting has recently expressed interest in a cinematic match (Undertaker for his part has always seemed less enthused, stating that the fantasy match “looked better on paper”), but with his departure to AEW, the WWE Hall of Famer is unlikely to lace up boots for Vince McMahon ever again.

It’s probably for the best, and the last thing any wrestling fan wants is for either guy to tarnish their legacy chasing a dream. Won’t happen, probably shouldn’t, but you can’t help wishing it already did.


4. The Shield Triple Threat To Headline WrestleMania

The Shield WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

The Shield might be the last great WWE creation. The intention was to put together fresh young superstars in a group, get them over, and then split the team, resulting in three brand new main eventers. And, a few teething problems aside, it worked like a charm.

Seth Rollins was company MVP for much of the late 2010s, Dean Ambrose became hugely popular through force of charisma, and while the inorganic nature of Roman Reigns’ push soured some fans on him, there’s no denying the man’s star power.

The end result should have been a WrestleMania triple threat main event for a major title. Three proper WWE inventions (or reinventions, with Rollins and Ambrose heavily indie-seasoned) in the company’s biggest match of the year, without leaning on nostalgia - that would be something to be proud of.

Instead, The Shield’s sole triple threat was at Battleground 2016, a C show. The match was cool, but a waste of something that could have been truly major. Ambrose has left the building, become bigger than ever, and probably won’t be coming back. The Shield remains a genius creation, but they’ll never get that perfect payoff.


3. Kharma's Unfinished Business

Kharma On SmackDown Live
WWE.com

While WWE was doing little of note with its female roster in the late ‘00s-early ‘10s, over in TNA things were different. Its Knockout Division, headlined by Gail Kim (whose time WWE repeatedly wasted) and Awesome Kong, was putting on some of the best women’s wrestling in the US. As is their wont, WWE eventually nabbed Kong, who was renamed Kharma and teased in exciting fashion.

Kharma’s time with WWE can be put down to equal parts bad timing and mismanagement. She made a few appearances on TV and PPV in 2011, but soon had to step down due to pregnancy. Her reemergence at the Royal Rumble the following year was memorable (mostly for terrorising Michael Cole), but only six months hence, she was released.

It feels as though Kharma, an excellent worker and incredible presence, still has a ton to prove at WWE, and had she made the jump five or six years later, she’d have found a revamped division far more in line with her skills.

Having since worked for TNA and AEW, Kharma/Kong seems as though she’s more or less done with wrestling, on a full-time basis at least, finding plenty of work as an actor. Given the brevity of her WWE tenure, it’s hard to imagine she’d be worth much of a nostalgia pop, but she was certainly underutilised by the company.


2. Cesaro Getting A World Title

WWE WrestleMania Backlash 2021 Roman Reigns Cesaro
WWE.com

Sorry, but it’s true. It shouldn’t be true, but it is. Cesaro will be remembered among the likes of Owen Hart and Mr Perfect, exemplary wrestlers who were never trusted with WWE’s big belt, and while that’s an outrageous oversight on the part of the booking committee, at this point we might as well face facts.

Cesaro was thrust ever so briefly into the spotlight in 2021, and he seized the opportunity as anyone who’s seen him work knew he would. He excelled in Elimination Chamber and took Roman Reigns to the limit at Backlash, a match of the year contender.

No one was expecting WWE to pull the trigger there, given the long term project that is Reigns, but this should have been the jumping-off point for Cesaro to stake a claim as a true top guy. While we’re not too far removed from that rare headline spot, though, Cesaro has already tumbled back down the card after coming out the loser in his feud with Seth Rollins.

The guy looks like he could go forever, but he’s 40 years old. If it’s not going to happen for him right now, it’s probably never going to happen. All we can do is accept it, and continue to puzzle over how this guy isn’t the company’s top star.


1. Shawn Michaels vs AJ Styles

Shawn Michaels AJ Styles
WWE

While Shawn Michaels’ wrestling retirement wasn’t as permanent as Stone Cold’s, he learned his lesson from the Crown Jewel debacle and has retreated back into his prominent NXT trainer role. And in all likelihood, that’s where he should remain. Still, though, the idea of just one more match against AJ Styles can’t help but get the cogs whirring in any fan’s brain.

AJ’s jump to WWE in 2016 opened the door for all manner of dream matches, against the likes of Cena, Reigns, Orton et al. But it’s hard to imagine a more apropos and exciting opponent for the Phenomenal One than the Heartbreak Kid.

Two undersized wrestlers who nevertheless became true main eventers, won the trust of Vince, became the faces of their respective companies. Cocky southern high flyers who can throw down on the mat as well as leaping from the top rope.

You could extend this to other dream HBK matches - Bryan, Rollins, Cole - but AJ feels like the one we should by all rights have gotten to see. Michaels is a smart guy with a good job behind the scenes - he’ll surely never be back. If this was on the table, though? Surely he’d be tempted.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)