3 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (17 July - Results & Review)
WWE's Saturday Night's Main Event stipulation, hot main event and tag division saves SmackDown.
The 2 biggest news items coming out of this week's SmackDown were: SummerSlam's scheduled WWE Title match between CM Punk and Cody Rhodes will become a Fatal-4-Way should Gunther and Sami Zayn emerge victorious at Saturday Night's Main Event. Also, WWE will crown an interim Women's Champion via a ladder match in early-August. Then, injured champ Rhea Ripley will meet the winner to determine who holds the belt going forwards.
That last one won't work for fans tired of the interim gimmick and all of the injuries that have blighted the division in 2026. In fairness, the fact that key figures keep having their momentum halted by injury isn't the company's fault, and they're trying to come up with a satisfactory workaround without stripping Rhea of her title. Fair enough.
A couple of qualifiers took place on Friday's show. Did they work? Read on to find out.
Gunther and Cody clashed yet again in the main event, Charlotte Flair looked like an absolute moron in the babyface role, there was a rare chance for the blue brand's tag-team division to shine, Finn Bálor continued his path towards upper card stardom as a face, and Blake Monroe was badly let down once more. How many times?!
SmackDown was a mere speed bump on the road to SNME and SummerSlam, but the rejigged 2-hour runtime does make the weekly flash past in the blink of an eye. Here's all the good and bad from Triple H's latest, including that welcome Saturday night stip.
Downs...
4. Not Exactly A Hot Start For Blake Monroe
At this rate, would it actually be that huge of a surprise if Blake Monroe went back to "Coming Soon" vignettes next week? WWE bosses bungled her arrival on the main roster by turning her into the next coming of Veer Mahaan. Endless hype vids looped, then Triple H put Blake in a nothing backstage segment with Chelsea Green before pressing the reset button.
More "Coming Soon" stuff followed, and now Monroe is attacking random wrestlers behind the scenes without adding much context as to why or what her ultimate plan is on SmackDown. It's all extremely messy, and it isn't doing much to make the ex-AEW standout look like someone worth caring about. Note to WWE: This is not how you get somebody new over in front of a casual audience.
Here, Blake ambushed Candice LeRae following LeRae's chat with Gunther. Without being cruel to Candice, going after her is 100% a step down for Monroe. Sure, she could be targeting the biggest stars in the division and trying to win titles. Or, y'know, she could do this. WWE's writing team are smoking something funny if they think that LeRae vs. Monroe is the kind of match everyone wants to see on SmackDown soon.
Candice also...isn't a sympathetic babyface, so this fell on deaf ears. There's nothing to be gained by booking Blake this way. Nothing. She might as well be on Main Event if this is all the company has in store for her. Actually, better not say that incase it comes true.
3. Glad Finn Won, But…That Was Boring!
Finn Bálor vs. Talla Tonga was a standard smaller guy swimming upstream against bigger guy match. There was nothing especially wrong with the way it was worked from a technical standpoint, but 90% of it was lifeless due to Talla’s sloooooooooow beatdown style. He's quickly turning into Shanky, and that isn't something anyone internally would like to admit. How long before this dude is working comedy spots? Answers on a postcard.
Listen, it’s good that Finn won to continue building some momentum for him on the blue side, but this just wasn’t close to Bálor vs. Tama last week. Creative should move Bálor on from this quickly now he’s beaten both guys. Also, where does this leave Tama and Talla? They left Solo Sikoa's side in The MFTs faction, and they don't appear to have anything worthwhile going on post-Finn.
WWE better not have Shinsuke Nakamura resurface as Finn's tag partner for a tag-team match or 2-3. There's no need to continue this mini-feud beyond Friday's episode. At best, Tama and Talla will get a move to Raw and go after tag gold there. They clearly need something other than what SmackDown's roster has to offer them. Opportunities will be seriously limited due to a lack of focus in the tag ranks, put it that way.
It doesn't sit right to call any Bálor match boring, but you've got to call what you see. This is just one fan's opinion anyway. Perhaps others out there feel differently and thought this made the Irishman look like a million bucks. One man's trash, and all that.
2. Jacy Jayne/Fatal Influence Need More
Things got off to a top start for Fatal Influence on WWE's main roster when they were called up in late-April. Initially, it seemed like Jacy Jayne, Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid would become real power players on SmackDown, but backstage interest in pushing them to the moon has lessened with each passing month. Now, unless they win the tag belts from Paige and Brie Bella at SNME, the faction is in trouble.
Reid and Henley will presumably come out on top of that match in MSG, which will go some way to easing concerns. However, Jacy losing to Tiffany Stratton in this SummerSlam ladder match qualifier is a real knock on the group's efforts. Jayne being beneath a pretty lifeless babyface version of Stratton isn’t a great sign for her, is it? Fatal Influence as a whole has cooled off just a little too much.
Yeah, it feels like Jayne should’ve won here to breathe some fresh life into the hunt for Rhea’s title. She represents something totally fresh compared to 'Tiffy Time' (which is creaking and playing before diminishing returns the longer Stratton remains baby), and that should've been taken into account.
Win here then seize the tag belts on Saturday and Jacy could've boasted about Influence's impact. As it stands, she'll be little more than a ringside pest for Henley and Reid against Paige and Bella. Lord only knows what happens to the trio if they don't come out on top in the Garden as predicted.
Fatal right enough.
1. Charlotte Flair Looks Idiotic
It always sucks when pro wrestling makes babyfaces look like absolute idiots.
WWE's announcers could go with the story that Charlotte Flair was blinded by rage and thus didn’t realise she’d actually helped Jade Cargill qualify for SummerSlam, but someone like Charlotte should be smarter than that. No, it’s no great loss that Jade vs. Nia Jax lasted less than a minute, but this booking really didn’t make Flair look smart at all. Even the live crowd seemed a bit confused by it all.
Flair rushed in to interrupt the match, take out Michin and B-FAB, then try to break Cargill's arm as revenge for Alexa Bliss last week; Bliss did her double jointed 'broken arm' sell there, so she'll probably be on the shelf for a little while whilst Charlotte battles for her honour. That's all cool, but effectively handing her main rival a spot at SummerSlam on a plate? Nah, that made Flair look like she just isn't paying attention to the way things work.
If anything, it would've made way more sense had she booted Jax in the chops to cost Jade. As it is, Adam Pearce (who's standing in for Nick Aldis following Gunther's attack) made Nia vs. Charlotte next week in another qualifier. That was an apology to Jax for the way things went down here.
Again, Flair could've avoided all of that by taking out Nia then flashing an evil grin at Jade. She helped her enemy advance, then didn't even get the revenge she was looking for. Oops. This was an off night for 'The Queen', at least in terms of logic.
Ups...
3. Solid Tag-Team Showcase
At first, War Raiders vs. Fraxiom looked like it might be Erik and Ivar eating Axiom and Nathan Frazer alive in 90 seconds (because the latter didn’t even get an entrance), but this turned out to be one of the better matches on the show. Sure, it remains to be seen if there’s anything to this Raiders reprieve on the main roster, but they looked decent here. As usual, the tag-teams deserve better on SmackDown. However, everyone worked hard and did well to make something of this by sucking the live crowd in come the end.
What a fab near fall on a Phoenix Splash from Frazer too. The crowd bought that one as the finish.
Wade Barrett and Joe Tessitore went above and beyond to present the Raiders as a simplified, no-frills version of themselves. Will it work and lead them to tag glory on SmackDown? Again, the jury is out on that. They'd need to oust Damian Priest and R-Truth as champs first, but that comedy double act has been sucking wind for a while now. Anything's achievable if WWE really knocks heads together creatively and sticks to a plan.
Triple H surely saw enough from Erik and Ivar here to suggest they'd be excellent heel linchpins for a revamped division. Axiom and Frazer likely deserve some proper storytelling to sink their teeth into as well - they consistently do their best no matter what's put in front of them, whether as a duo or individually.
This was better than it probably had any right to be, not least when WWE has deleted the third hour that'd normally make matches like this more commonplace.
2. Stip Added, Main Event Made!
That was a perfectly serviceable opening segment.
Gunther moaned about Nick Aldis, then Adam Pearce came out to say that a stipulation had already been added to the Saturday Night's Main Event tag-team match before that attack last week. In short, if Gunther and Sami Zayn win, then they’re added to the WWE Title match at SummerSlam. It becomes a Fatal-4-Way, which CM Punk later told Pearce doesn't suit him.
Cody Rhodes then attacked Gunther and the main event for SmackDown was made. Slick work from everyone here, because there was no time wasted and they managed to make a previously-throwaway situation (that SNME tag) seem like something worth checking out. Kudos to Trips and his army of writers for that, 'cause Gunther and Zayn teaming up vs. Cody and Punk seemed like a waste of everyone's time before Friday's episode.
Fired up Cody is the best kind of Cody too. He excels when he has a reason to be annoyed, and he definitely owed the 'Ring General' a receipt after Gunther's Raw attack took him out of the WWE Title clash with Sami. That paved the way for Punk to sneak in and win the gold, so Rhodes always had to come for his Austrian nemesis again at some stage.
In around 10 minutes or so, WWE lined up a headliner everyone in attendance wanted to see and put some importance on Saturday's show inside Madison Square Garden. Presumably, Cody and CM will win out there, but all 4 guys involved now have ample reason to work with their respective partners.
That wasn't the case before this quarter hour.
1. Leg Work Made That Main Event Worthwhile
Gunther went after Cody and hurt his leg early in the aforementioned headliner. That brought out a concerned CM Punk, who only really cares because of the stip for his tag match at SNME. Wade Barrett brought that up on commentary - basically, CM knows he and Rhodes must win or SummerSlam’s title bout becomes a Fatal-4-Way. It's a rock solid story, if nothing else.
All of the leg stuff gave Gunther and Cody a focal point for their TV headliner, which helped it stand out from their other recent showdowns as well. Also, it’d be a shock if Rhodes didn’t do some serious selling come MSG on Saturday. He's old school in that sense, so look out for some hobbling/limping and the heels going after his injured wheel throughout the match.
Here, the DQ finish made sense, and the brawl at the end put over how feisty the tag outing at SNME should be. There was a lot to like about all of the little character moments from Gunther, Punk and Zayn in particular. Gunther used his in-ring IQ to try and win Friday's bout whilst forcing Cody into Saturday ravaged with pain, Punk showed his selfish side by only trying to help Rhodes because it affects him, and Zayn is just a ball of rage generally after his 9-day WWE Title reign. That came to the fore when he attacked Punk then stared down Cody.
Great work from all 4 guys then, and the SNME tag outing should be a hoot in the main event slot at MSG.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: TNA (Part 3) and 101 Shocking Wrestling Plans You Won't Believe Almost Happened!