10 WWE Wrestlers Who Could Thrive In AEW

Alternative Elite Wrestling.

AEW Logo
All Elite Wrestling

These are some damn exciting times for indy wrestling fans.

The announcement that Cody and The Young Bucks would take up roles as wrestlers and executives in All Elite Wrestling (founded by Jacksonville Jaguars and Fulham FC co-owner Shahid Khan) has people buzzing. Could this be a genuine alternative to WWE in 2019? Perhaps, though only time will tell how competitive it is.

If nothing else, AEW will provide the kind of in-ring centric product fans have come to expect from companies like ROH or New Japan. Should the promotion prove successful beyond this year, then it could also become a viable substitute for wrestlers disillusioned by WWE life or hesitant about letting the McMahon family control their entire careers.

Names that have already been signed include veterans like Christopher Daniels and Frankie Kazarian, as well as Scorpio Sky, Hangman Page and Britt Baker, and more are expected. What if some in WWE are amongst them?

Allow yourself to fantasise for a while, sit down with the WWE roster and join in the fun as we analyse just who might thrive in AEW...


10. Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder
WWE.com

Woo, woo, woo!

In another era, one free of WWE gobbling up talent to fill Raw, SmackDown, 205 Live, NXT and a UK division, there's a chance Zack Ryder may have been released. It's not like the dude does much on WWE television these days (Ryder appeared on Raw exactly once throughout 2018), and he must be feeling a tad melancholic about his prospects in 2019.

At 33, Ryder may also be wondering to himself what life would be like outside the WWE bubble. Would he be taken more seriously? Without doubt. Likeable veterans who have been with the biggest company in the land for 14 years don't pop up on the indy scene every day, and so Zack would have some buzz heading into AEW.

Biting the bullet and joining Cody and The Bucks in All Elite would give Ryder the chance to show a side of his work WWE fans rarely see. He's a walking cartoon character there, not a serious pro wrestler, and he might just fancy changing that perception before it's too late.


9. Tye Dillinger

Tye Dillinger
WWE.com

Fellow WWE enhancement talent Tye Dillinger would probably enjoy doing something other than holding 10 fingers aloft as well.

Dillinger has suffered from a common problem in the WWE sphere; a big cheese on NXT who had some hype, he ultimately failed to capture fan attention on the main roster and has thus rolled out of view. In 2019, the 'Perfect 10' may as well already be out of the company as far as some casual fans are concerned.

Time is running out for Tye too. He's 37, and it's hardly like he has some epic run ahead of him on SmackDown this year. His chances of doing anything other than jobbing or appearing in throwaway comedy skits are severely limited, and so he may well be better off building his own brand elsewhere rather than spinning his wheels in WWE.

Giving up the safety net of a WWE pay check wouldn't be easy, but it must be creatively disheartening for Tye that he's used so sparingly by his current employer. In AEW, he could ditch the 10 gimmick and get back to basics.


8. The Revival

The Revival
WWE.com

The Revival, bless 'em, have been trying to get back to basics all along and show their stock as the traditional tag-team WWE needs. They're akin to a second coming of Arn Anderson and Tully Blanchard, which is bizarrely something that seems to work against them in the character-obsessed promotion.

Apparently, it's a better idea to lump Bobby Roode and Chad Gable together, or to push The B-Team briefly instead.

That must be super-frustrating to Dash and Dawson. They're a technically-sound, well-matched unit who can't buy progress in a company that blatantly views them as small, bland and better served making others look good. If they jumped to AEW, their workhorse tendencies and similarities to teams of NWA yesteryear would surely help them.

The insider joke Dawson wore on his trunks for this past Monday's Raw shows their renegade spirit too. Maybe, just maybe, The Revival would indeed be "Top Guys" if they traded WWE mediocrity for All Elite's bold new vision.


7. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews
WWE.com

Whether he's been part of Titus Worldwide or teaming with Ember Moon in inconsequential mixed tag matches on Raw, Apollo Crews hasn't been able to show the same fire he did as Uhaa Nation on the independent circuit. There's a malaise afflicting every single one of his WWE performances.

Anyone who watched him in Dragon Gate pre-WWE (or even in NXT when he did sign) will know his current role is a complete waste of talent.

Crews can fly, and he has more personality than he's allowed to show on Monday nights. Something has been lost in translation since joining WWE, and it's confusing to his biggest fans. Again, much like Tye Dillinger, leaving guaranteed money behind to venture back onto the indys would be tough, but it could be for the best.

By returning to his Uhaa Nation roots in AEW, Apollo would be reinvigorated quickly. His combination of flying and power moves wouldn't be held against him there, and neither would the fact he's struggled to get to grips with WWE's heavily-scripted, unnatural promo style.


6. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

This one is simply delicious from a fantasy perspective.

It'd be weird to discuss the thought of Dolph Ziggler departing WWE without noting how much money he makes there. WWE life has made Dolph a multi-millionaire, and he's still someone the writers turn to when they need to elevate somebody else. His recent efforts cementing Drew McIntyre are proof of that.

In that respect then, Ziggler will always have a gig in WWE. He's too good a performer not to, and he's one who can flip between heel and baby depending on what creative needs. That makes him invaluable, but there must be a part of him that's sick of watching others get a leg up the ladder whilst he holds the bloody thing steady.

Unleashing Dolph on AEW sounds fun. The matches he could have with Cody (for a start) would be creatively exciting for the man, and he'd be a nice addition to six-man tags with The Young Bucks at some point too. Then, there's a tasty bout with Hangman Page that'd have indy fanatics licking their chops.


5. Cesaro

Cesaro WWE
WWE.com

No, Sheamus isn't coming as part of this package; he's a WWE lifer in this writer's mind. Meanwhile, Cesaro was an independent darling before making his way to McMahon-ville, and he's often woefully under-utilised by an employer who has long-held the opinion he needs to grab mystical brass rings.

There'd be none of that hogwash in AEW.

Cody and The Bucks will surely push the best pure wrestlers at their disposal, and that'd be enticing for Cesaro. As solid as The Bar have been over the past few years (when they're allowed to shine by WWE creative anyway), the threat of a main event run in the promotion is slipping further and further away for the 'Swiss Superman'.

At 38, he's in his prime. Cesaro is a much, much better worker now than he was as Claudio Castagnoli before, and the competitive fires burning inside him have never been doused by WWE's decision to overlook him. In a perfect world, he'd be a marquee signing for All Elite.


4. The Good Brothers

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE.com

So would The Bucks' old pals.

Since leaving the lucrative bosom of Bullet Club brilliance in favour of inking WWE contracts in 2017, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have dodged a few shells. They've gone from legit menacing tag-team to mid-card veteran duo who occasionally work so-so feuds or peddle WWE's crap attempts at comedy.

The Good Brothers are crying out for some direction in 2019, but they're unlikely to find any in their current guise on SmackDown. The Bullet Club ship has sailed, but they'd still have friends in high places if they scarpered for AEW. At least there the team would be guaranteed some solid matches that kept them busy.

A natural rivalry against The Young Bucks writes itself (imagine Gallows and Anderson as bloated heels dropping hints they're still on WWE's pay roll), and so does an all-vet showdown with SoCal Uncensored over some AEW Tag-Team Titles.


3. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano Venom
WWE.com

It might be unfair to judge before it actually happens, but this fan doesn't really trust WWE's writers on Raw or SmackDown to do anything of note with Johnny Gargano once he moves on from NXT. At the moment, Gargano is a big fish in a small-ish, contained pond. On the main roster, he'd be in shark-infested waters.

We worry, folks. We worry.

AEW would seem to suit Gargano's style more than the bright lights of Monday or Tuesday nights. He's not physically big, even by the modest standards set by top names like Daniel Bryan or AJ Styles these days, and that could work against him with casual viewers who don't care a jot for NXT's in-ring excellence over the soap opera approach.

Cody and The Bucks would see past that. To them, Johnny Gargano must surely be considered everything that is right with pro wrestling in 2019. He's a scrappy underdog who can implement genius into his matches, and he's a better talker than some will give him credit for.


2. Shinsuke Nakamura

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Nak-America's independence has been revoked and the country's leader has been exiled from WWE credibility yet again.

If that sounds rather dramatic, then contemplate how Shinsuke Nakamura must be feeling at the moment. His stock as one of the best wrestlers in the world has continually plummeted since joining WWE; Royal Rumble win and heel turn or not, Naka isn't quite the performer he was when tangling with the likes of Okada, Tanahashi or even Styles pre-WWE.

Shinsuke was a New Japan all-star before trying his luck in the US, but things haven't worked out well for him there. Frankly, WWE don't seem to have a clue how to book him effectively, and the language barrier is an obvious problem on their side. To the promotion's less-hardcore fans, the guy must be an overhyped snore.

AEW would solve one major problem with Nakamura's WWE run: it'd cut the forced character development bullsh*t and let him wrestle freely. He'd be back on top of his game within the span of one or two major matches, which is something he's failed to be in two years of WWE main roster work.


1. Finn Bálor

Finn Balor
WWE.com

We'd pop if AEW promoted a show called 'No More Smiles' and poked fun at WWE's incessant need to have Finn Bálor act like a cheeky Irish chappy for the cameras. Alternatively, his first All Elite show could be named, 'A Princely Sum', because that's what it'd cost Finn to ditch the E and revert to his Prince Devitt days.

Sacrificing some cash might be worth it.

Bálor cannot be thrilled with his role in WWE these days. He's gone from first ever Universal Champion to a bit-part player, and some of the feuds booked for him have been flat out horrendous. Remember the comical guff of Bray Wyatt? How about the stinker that was Finn's never-ending rivalry with Baron Corbin?

There was a time when Devitt wrestling conjured up butterflies in one's stomach. His matches came with an excitable rumble of anticipation, but those days have been rubbished by seemingly-endless dirge on Raw. Even aged 37 and after a serious shoulder injury set him back, Bálor would instantly become one of AEW's leading lights.

-

Which other WWE stars do you think would thrive in AEW? Let us know down in the comments section below!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.