12 Exact Moments AEW Booking Stopped Making Sense

When the AEW “feeling” was pure, unadulterated confusion…

Hangman Page AEW Title
AEW

At time of writing, AEW has entered a period of resurgence.

After a few fraught years, defined by backstage turmoil and desperate publicity stunts designed to restore the infernal “feeling” - Tony Khan even took a bump to get people talking in 2024 - we might be…back?

You must be careful with this sort of thing, even after the seminal, triumphant All In: Texas PPV. That show, which was too good to consider too long, even though it very much was, underscored the great momentum shift of 2025. AEW built the event superbly, and paid off the sense of hope and enthusiasm equally well.

Revolution 2024 also felt like the start of something - and then CM Punk buried AEW (and members of its roster) on the Ariel Helwani Show, which prompted Adam Copeland to cut a promo in the style of a blue-tick AEW engagement account. This defensive streak, and AEW’s general desperation to tell people how good and back it was, was very off-putting. It was essentially incel-style marketing, how much they screamed “WE’RE THE GOOD BUYS! BUT WE’RE THE GOOD GUYS!” over and over again.

This wasn’t just annoying marketing rhetoric, either. This idea of AEW as some wonderful haven that must be defended replaced personal grudge rivalries as the primary narrative thrust. The Soul of AEW was considered of equal importance to the World title. Now, with the Death Riders in retreat, AEW is beginning to feel like a backdrop to the important stuff: championships, hatred, competition, the pay window.

Hopefully, the following convoluted gibberish is no more…


12. The Interim AEW World Title Picture (June 1, 2022)

Jon Moxley
AEW

On the June 1, 2022 Dynamite, new AEW World champion CM Punk was scheduled to wrestle Max Caster and the Gunns alongside FTR. He just about gutted it through what was meant to be a low-stakes, celebratory affair. It is infamous in retrospect; Punk shattered his foot and the complexion of the company by first jumping into the crowd.

He vacated the belt on the subsequent edition of Rampage. Because Tony Khan wanted to strap Punk back up as soon as was practicable, he created an interim World title. This idea was disastrous.

Firstly, it seemed to annoy the guy who got it, Jon Moxley, because it cast him as inferior to and a placeholder for CM Punk - resulting in an infamous programme teeming with political tension. This didn’t do much for Mox; even though he was one of the absolute best wrestlers in the world, it portrayed him as solid, reliable, dependable - words you don’t tend to associate with genuine superstars.

The process of arriving at Mox was also baffling. Ahead of Forbidden Door - at which Mox represented AEW against NJPW’s Hiroshi Tanahashi - Khan booked a Battle Royal to determine Mox’s opponent for the #1 contender spot. That man was Kyle O’Reilly, who outlasted top stars such as Bobby Fish and John Silver en route to victory.

Missing from that match was Hangman Page, who didn’t get the chance to win his belt back, and Wardlow, who was white-hot following his awesome rampage to avenge MJF between March and May. Wardlow was even scripted to bury the idea of the interim title to explain why he wasn’t in the match.

As great as Mox was throughout 2022, this business stigmatised him as a safe pair of hands; fuelled CM Punk’s top star entitlement; undermined Wardlow as a major prospect worth investing in; and diminished the value of the World title.


11. Bryan Danielson’s World Title Reign

All In Bryan Danielson
AEW

Something clearly happened during Bryan Danielson’s AEW World title reign that wasn’t communicated. The easy if perhaps unfair inference is that he was far more banged up than he and AEW anticipated when the decision was made to plot his World title run last stand.

Darby Allin had become #1 contender by winning a Royal Rampage battle royal, and was indeed meant to dethrone Bryan Danielson in a Seattle derby at WrestleDream. He was made to look like an idiot when the booking plans changed; it was thought a better idea for a heel Moxley to dethrone Bryan and later drop the belt to Darby. Darby put his shot on the line against Mox at Grand Slam and lost. This weird shift wasn’t helped by Mox’s experiments with cryptic Malakai Black-style promos.

In the meantime, Christian Cage won a Casino Gauntlet match at All In: London, securing, essentially, a Money In The Bank contract. Didn’t AEW think WWE was bad?

Surely, the idea wasn’t for him to cash in on fellow heel Jon Moxley. He was either going to ruin Darby’s big moment or fail in the pursuit when challenging Danielson, perhaps when Luchasaurus had finally tired of his bullying. Luchasaurus was suffering terribly unfortunate health issues at the time, so if that was the plan, clearly AEW could not proceed. In another odd development, Nigel McGuinness and his return from injury, a great story AEW didn’t even need to write, was complicated by Nigel’s insistence that Bryan was a coward who might not even make it to Grand Slam. That match was a worthy last chapter that needed no bogus episodic TV crap to build. It made narrative sense for Bryan to work Jack Perry, who'd been favoured in the booking, but who really asked for that?

Here and thereafter, AEW’s booking fell off a gorge, was airlifted back up, struck a tree, and went back down again.


10. The Early Days Of The Death Riders (October 30, 2024)

Death Riders Claudio Castagonli PAC Wheeler Yuta AEW Trios Titles
AEW

The Death Riders stable, ultimately, was a major success. In this era, the booking draws more heat than any fictional heel. The idea of Hangman Page finally putting a stop to hokey crime sprees and relentless heat angles drove the smash success of All In: Texas. (It helps and should not go unmentioned that Jon Moxley finally realised his potential as a top heel with a couple of months to spare). Bad and or repetitive booking with a great payoff is the new long-term storytelling.

Initially, the stable was abysmal and nonsensical. Here’s an example, one that thwarted the early promise of an overarching, interconnected plot designed to restore “the feeling”.

Jon Moxley broke Zay’s hand because he was disgusted that the Private Party member had stagnated in the same spot. Zay was everything wrong with AEW: a company that itself was languishing.

Zay together with Marq Quen very quickly - too quickly - dethroned World Tag Team champions the Young Bucks. Surely, Private Party should have cut a promo on the Death Riders, telling them they had not forgotten about Mox’s violent attack. They should have asked the Death Riders to call them stagnant now. Private Party should have then feuded with Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler YUTA over the belts. Nope: this thread was dropped. Instead, the two squads simply ignored one another.

Daniel Garcia, another early defender of AEW, won the TNT title, and didn’t do a great deal with it. Shouldn’t this have drawn the ire of PAC? Shouldn’t Garcia have asked PAC, who in his mind was superior to anybody else in AEW, where his singles title was?

It was as if Private Party and Daniel Garcia skulked away, defending their titles in random matches. Neither reign, unsurprisingly, was particularly good.

This was haphazard in the extreme. Nothing fit together.


9. CM Punk’s Collision (June 17, 2023)

Samoa Joe CM Punk Collision Aug 12
AEW

‘CM Punk’s Collision’ is a strange thing to hold nostalgia for. It only happened two years ago, for one, and was it that good?

It was refreshing, a welcome shift from the often frenzied, numbing pacing of Dynamite, on which too many angles aren’t registered for long enough. But how good was it, really?

Beyond the overlong main event matches, the storytelling was baffling - one long unkept promise. CM Punk unveiled an AEW World title with a spray-painted ‘X’ on it, proclaiming himself to be the Real World champion. Naturally, fans expected a unification match against recognised World champion MJF. This, astonishingly, was never formalised nor even planned - so why did Punk, who asserted a degree of creative control, do this?

It was difficult to interpret as anything other than a political power play. Which, factoring in the rumours of certain talents being banned from the building, might sum up CM Punk’s Collision generally.

Why did Tony Khan approve it? You don’t tease or hint at matches you have no intention of delivering. That’s the first rule of promotion. Did Khan just expect everybody to magically get along?

That might read as snarky, but honestly, it’s not untrue. Khan booked his show in the summer of 2023 with total naivety. It was almost cruel to his fanbase, but eventually, at least until 2025, scorned fans taught themselves not to get excited.

Cloaked by a darkened cloud the entire time - a happy ending to the unresolved CM Punk Vs. the Elite feud was never remotely likely - the early days of Collision were beyond untenable. A source of anxiety, not escapism.


8. The TNT Title Picture (April 27, 2022)

Scorpio Sky
AEW

Eddie Kingston should have dethroned TNT Champion Miro at All Out 2021.

Kingston was the rarest of wrestlers in the modern scene - all soul, a living folk hero - and his output that year was phenomenal.

Tony Khan instead gave the nod to Sammy Guevara, who defeated the Redeemer on the September 29 Dynamite. This was an understandable decision and noble failure. Guevara was a day-one project who for a time was very over as a charismatic, obnoxious heel; the TNT title was both his reward and an instruction to the fans that, if they connect with a wrestler, that wrestler’s career will progress. Your long-term investment matters.

If the Guevara push was a justified tactic, the Scorpio Sky push was irritating.

Guevara in his second reign dropped the belt to Sky on the March 9, 2022 Dynamite. Guevara won it for the third time proper at Battle of the Belts on April 15. The idea of one Scorpio Sky reign was inexplicable enough, since he was a mere solid hand in the midcard scene whose work never approached Best Match In AEW History-level. He embarked on his second after winning back the title on April 27 before dropping it to Wardlow on July 6.

This was all kinds of awful. Sky was a barely over heel whom Khan saw more in than most; Guevara an increasingly unlikeable babyface. Nobody wanted either man to reign with a belt that lost its prestige at an alarming rate. A blur of hot potato nothingness with minimal fan interest, the “What are we doing here?” of it all was compounded by the fact that AEW’s roster of 2022 was teeming with countless better options.

Tony Khan is a patient, loyal booker - but this was idiotically stubborn business.


7. The Full Gear 2023 Show-Long Angle (November 18, 2023)

MJF Jay White
AEW

There’s a lot to unpack here.

MJF and Adam Cole became friends in the late spring of 2023. They formed the skit-loving team Better Than You Bay-Bay, the most succinct way of describing which is “just about entertaining and charming enough to get away with itself”.

That was the peak. The decline was astonishingly bad.

Adam Cole shattered his ankle at Grand Slam in September ‘23, which somehow didn’t necessitate a TV write-off. This injury was so bad that Cole ended up missing over a year of action. The injury was so bad and complex that a dead man’s bone was inserted into his foot via experimental surgery.

AEW was and is meant to be the vaguely sports-oriented promotion in the U.S. mainstream. At a minimum, its “world” should make sense in the context of a sport. Typically, football players with destroyed legs are not allowed to enter the field.

On the Full Gear pre-show, MJF was attacked by the Gunns and, in a hook, was sent away in an ambulance. With his knee in agony, he couldn’t defend his title against Jay White! Who stepped up?

The even more injured Adam Cole. The even more injured Adam Cole who A) was even more injured than MJF, B) under no circumstances would ever get cleared to compete by a conscientious, fit-for-purpose medical team, and C) was plotting to betray MJF, and had no idea that MJF would make his heroic return just in time for the main event.

Illogical barely captures how overthought this whole thing was - and that wasn’t the worst of it…


6. The Devil Storyline (September 27, 2023)

The Devil AEW
AEW

Adding to the above entry on Full Gear, in September 2023, Jay White was attacked by several mysterious figures. One was wearing the Devil mask worn by MJF at All Out 2022. It was implied that this must have been MJF, but it was very obviously a red herring. Jay himself didn’t even seem that bothered. Few were, really.

A couple of characters accused MJF of being the Devil - Roderick Strong, most notably and most obnoxiously - but MJF was adamant that he wasn’t. This saga was horrendous: the hokiest tripe AEW ever served up at such a prominent level. It killed MJF as a babyface. People gravitated towards him because he was an entertaining d*ck. They didn’t care about those old evil deeds catching up to him. They would have preferred to see him do more of them than this.

At one point, this was a Vince Russo-sized disgrace to the idea of a sports-oriented, high-quality wrestling league.

The storyline was all over the place narratively, since the only person to care about it for a month of inactivity was Roddy, and the logic was equally dismal. The Devil was able to hack into the mainframe, to deliver his glitchy messages, and even put on a dazzling lights display when his masked men made their entrance for matches in which their opponent never immediately removed their disguise.

This was dumb and goofy at the time, and was somehow worse when the perp was revealed to be Adam Cole at Worlds End.

Cole - the Devil - plotted to betray MJF and distracted him from the masterplan when at Roddy Strong’s place, pulling slow-motion happy faces while making sandwiches and riding around on mobility scooters.

Positively satanic stuff here.


5. The Codyverse (November 13, 2021)

Cody Rhodes Malakai Black
AEW

Cody Rhodes was savvy and bold enough to realise that, by late 2021, he had effectively been sidelined to accommodate CM Punk and Bryan Danielson. Mired in the upper midcard and through his own decision-making unable to vie for the World title, there was nowhere to go but out. The widely derided ‘Codyverse’ booking was the first sign that there was nothing of purpose for him to really do.

He traded wins with Malakai Black over the summer as Tony Khan bottled jobbing out his rapidly expanding roster. The exact same thing happened with Andrade el Idolo. This is less “stopped making sense” and more “political booking with zero drama” - until the bizarre events of November 2021.

At Full Gear, a perma-bleeding Cody teamed with PAC to defeat Malakai and Andrade in a weird, tweener-tinged match. PAC teaming with Cody made sense. They were locked in singles feuds with their opponents on the night. But what drew Malakai and Andrade together? Well, as alluded to onscreen, Malakai was married in real life to Andrade’s fictional valet in WWE. That was cute insider knowledge masquerading as a story.

At some point, after inexplicably waiting well over a year, FTR decided they wanted to attack Cody for saying “F*ck the Revival” on Being The Elite several years prior. This led to an eight-man tag on the November 24 Dynamite. FTR, Andrade and Malakai defeated Cody Rhodes and his loyal, trusted friends Death Triangle. MJF “loaned” his Pinnacle stablemates to make this deal happen, just in case this storyline was missing yet more extraneous detail.

Convoluted and very wasteful, WWE’s far simpler approach won out with Cody Rhodes.


4. Don Callis Tries To Recruit Chris Jericho (August 16, 2023)

Chris Jericho Don Callis
AEW

Chris Jericho - sorry, AEW - had an idea for the inaugural All In: London in 2023. It just so happened that Jericho got a match, bound for a cauldron atmosphere and critical acclaim, against the best in-ring wrestler in the world: Will Ospreay.

The process of getting there, and slowly turning Jericho babyface, was so convoluted that he instead turned even more heel (!). Moreover, the very idea was dumb before the botched execution. Most fans would rather Jericho have gone away for a while than received him as a hero.

Don Callis, Ospreay’s manager, tried to persuade Jericho not to retire (itself an unconvincing storyline tease). They held secret meetings in a bid to hash out an alliance. Eventually, Jericho, spurning his Jericho Appreciation Society stablemates, made the decision to align with the heel Don Callis. Callis, expecting a rejection, had actually intended to betray Jericho, as an oil painting uncovered by Jericho revealed.

Why, then, did Callis make such an effort in the first place?

To recap: Jericho teased turning babyface by appealing to the crowd, asking them to believe that he was still good enough. The Callis betrayal was meant to pile the sympathy on Jericho, turning him face, but Jericho had seconds earlier made the decision to continue his cheating ways with Don’s help.

All of this happened ahead of a match against the Essex, England-born Ospreay, who was going to draw the majority of cheers at Wembley regardless. In AEW’s defence, they had existing continuity to worry about. Ospreay and Callis were presented as heels in Canada at Forbidden Door in June; booking him in London two months later was always going to require some careful thought.

This was overthought to a stupid extent - but Jericho got his ****¾ from the Observer, so…


3. The Blackpool Combat Club, General (August 23, 2023)

Blackpool Combat Club William Regal Jon Moxley Claudio Castagnoli Bryan Danielson Wheeler YUTA
AEW

The Blackpool Combat Club seemed like a winning idea.

Bryan Danielson and Jon Moxley drafting in Wheeler YUTA (and perhaps others) to reshape AEW in their own violent image? While continuing to escalate their now very bloody, stiff matches? Before inevitably feuding with and elevating their proteges? Sounds great!

No, not great.

It was more an identity, a “lifestyle”, than a faction - or, less generously, an excuse for Mox and Danielson to indulge their tough guy leanings. When they actually did engage in stable warfare, the results were underwhelming. They feuded over concepts in emotionless sagas. They defended the art of wrestling against the evils of sports entertainment versus the Jericho Appreciation Society in 2022, which, without any believable hatred, dragged on and on. Against the Elite a year later, there was lots of vague, unengaging chat about “professionalism” amid the usual Anarchy In The Arena and Blood & Guts faction feud template.

Mox barely cut promos throughout this run, preferring instead to mow down midcard opposition in increasingly random and pointless matches. This moody tweener role made for such bland television.

This was a foolish use of the man, and things got plain dumb narratively the longer it went.

By August 2023, with CM Punk’s exit causing several migraines, the BCC played heels against career rivals Best Friends and the Lucha Bros. (!) as Danielson played face against Ricky Starks.

At the exact same time.

The matches were outstanding, the booking made zero sense. Everything the grifters spout about AEW was sadly true during that dumbass summer.


2. The Babyface Super-Team Device (June 28, 2023)

AEW Dynasty 2024 Adam Copeland Eddie Kingston Mark Briscoe House Of Black
AEW

It used to be that AEW’s hold on alliances was very tight and logical.

If you had a loyal friend, they’d back you up in a fight. If that friendship was strained, they might be reluctant to help. This was so well observed in the early days of Dynamite that the decision whether or not to back up a fellow babyface was a key phase in a wrestler’s character development. Hangman Page specialised in making these decisions. AEW installed a much-needed rule, exercising a promotional advantage over Vince McMahon’s WWE: babyfaces should have friends.

Eventually, this frittered away.

The Conglomeration (which for a time was very charming, granted) accelerated a certain booking crutch: the babyface super-team, a good, early example of which unfolded on the June 28, 2023 Dynamite. Orange Cassidy, El Hijo del Vikingo and Keith Lee defeated Daniel Garcia, Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ang. As many of these matches are, it was loads of fun in and of itself. Tony Khan subsequently became fixated on this type of match: wholesome strange bedfellows babyfaces defeating a team of heels.

This quirk is a cool novelty for live crowds, and a neat way of adding levity to the TV show in the midcard, but what does it truly achieve?

Very little - and, what’s more, when the time comes for a babyface to get saved, their new pals desert them. Orange Cassidy made dozens of friends in these sorts of matches throughout 2023, but they were nowhere to be found when he needed them the most. This vacuum business adds up to a whole load of nothing. AEW never feels quite as empty and trivial when Khan books this stuff for no real purpose.

How many of these matches do you actually remember?


1 - The Death Of The Rankings System (April 2024)

AEW Rankings
AEW

It used to work, and it used to be great.

Remember when Darby Allin was on the rise in the early days? Simply seeing his face near the top of the rankings graphic was a visual hint as to how close he was to making it. Hangman Page hovering near the top, only to get displaced, was a clever device. The fans were told to worry about but never give up on him.

Now, with no fixed narrative structure in place, the idea and value of contendership is under constant (deserved) scrutiny. Broadly, AEW gets it right more often than not. Consider the Hangman Page comeback of 2025; he won the Owen Hart Cup, was protected in the booking elsewhere, and won a major match against MJF at Revolution. He was built brilliantly, and with conviction, as the World Champion-elect.

There is no flawless, wholly logical method to booking pro wrestling and determining who is positioned where - indeed, the rankings wasn’t that, either - but the dismantling of the system has spawned far too many bad and nonsensical habits.

Hologram embarked on a double-figures winning streak without even challenging for the lowly TNT championship. Challengers pin champions in a direct, potentially damaging, WWE-style way far more than they did in 2019 and 2020. Toni Storm has taken pins from Megan Bayne and Athena this year, in two examples of an accelerated development. It’s just as well that Toni is too big a star for this to matter.

Because Tony Khan has recruited too many star acts, wins and losses don’t matter as much as they once did. FTR, who win a great deal on their beloved Collision, should have received infinitely more tag title shots than they have over the years. FTR even made a mockery of this quirk on TV in 2022.

The Eliminator match has replaced the intricate map to the top, and it lacks any real heft. Who hasn’t “earned” the chance to defeat a champion at this point?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!