12 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2016

A 'Phenomenal' Rumble, with surprises and a new world champ!

Well, that was something. Don€™t get it wrong, the 2016 edition of the Royal Rumble broke the streak of bad Rumbles at three and delivered a solid show up and down the card, with an opening match that rocked the house and three other title matches that held their own. And of course, we got a Royal Rumble match that had just enough twists and turns throughout to keep fans involved and invested. A good Rumble includes surprise appearances, either in the form of a legend returning or a new superstar debuting. In this case, we got to see AJ Styles make his much-anticipated WWE debut, as well as Sami Zayn coming up from NXT to electrify the crowd. A good Rumble also includes several mini-angles that can develop into new feuds after the PPV, possibly setting up other WrestleMania matches or just new rivalries that can simmer during the next several weeks. Either way, a well-done Rumble does way more than just crown a winner. But it€™s the winner that really is the main story here, with Roman Reigns being eliminated before the match ended, leaving him yet again on the outside looking in. And we crowned a new world champion, as Triple H earned his first WWE World Heavyweight Championship (and 14th overall) in nearly seven years. And with that, our main event for WrestleMania XXXII appears to be set, as Reigns will attempt to once again overcome the odds and regain his world title. So, with that said, what ran roughshod and tossed foes, and what got clotheslined out unceremoniously? Let€™s get to it€


DOWNS€

8. Two Wasted Spots

The Royal Rumble kickoff show featured a fatal fourway tag match between the Dudley Boyz, the Ascension, Jack Swagger and Mark Henry, and Damien Sandow and Darren Young, with the winning team earning spots in the Rumble match. Henry and Swagger would win the match, and then would go on to draw prime spots in the Rumble, #22 and #24 respectively. However, both men lasted less than a minute combined, with Henry being quickly dumped by the Wyatt Family and Swagger getting pulverized by Brock Lesnar. It was embarrassing on some levels, with two former world champions being treated like low-level jobbers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoqND7UhdYQ It also rendered the entire pre-show match to qualify for the Rumble a joke. The €œwinners€ were simply cannon fodder. Lame.

7. Subtraction By Substitution

It€™s safe to say that many fans have been saying for some time now that Jerry Lawler is well past his prime as an announcer and probably should hang it up. Several months ago, he was moved from Raw to Smackdown, obviously a move to downgrade him to a lesser-watched program. But Lawler stayed as the color analyst for PPVs. That changed Sunday, when the King relegated to the Royal Rumble kickoff panel, and Byron Saxton (who also ultimately took Lawler€™s spot on Raw) landed in the third chair for the Rumble PPV. As much as King needed to move on, Saxton is not good. Sorry if you€™re a fan of his, but he needs some serious polish. And even then, there€™s just not a credibility in what he says. You don€™t feel like you believe what he€™s talking about. At least with Lawler, he has the €œbeen there, done that€ credibility you can€™t fake. That makes this a downgrade.

6. An Uninspired #2

Seriously, Rusev? Rusev was the #2 entrant into the Rumble, making him the first line of defense against Roman Reigns. Sure, we can say that the Bulgarian Brute is a tough man and can hold his own in the ring, but it€™s not like Reigns hasn€™t manhandled Rusev on multiple occasions in the past two months. And true to form, Roman eliminated Rusev before the #3 entrant came out. At worst, it was a callback to last year, when Reigns and Rusev were the last two in the 2015 Rumble. But still, this was an opportunity for the Authority to stack the deck even further and get Reigns out early, and they went with Rusev. Bravo.

5. League Of Idiots

If it wasn€™t official before, it should be now: The League of Nations is the dumbest heel faction in WWE in some time. Assembled to help protect Sheamus€™ WWE World Heavyweight Championship (and later Alberto Del Rio€™s United States title), the group has failed miserably at both tasks, with Sheamus and Del Rio both without titles. The group grabbed Roman Reigns during the Rumble and pulled him out under the bottom rope and assaulted him, beating him to a pulp before Rusev ran across two announce tables and splashed Reigns through a third table. The trio and Mr. McMahon celebrated their thrashing of the champion€ and then left ringside. What the hell?!? So the goal is to eliminate Roman from the Rumble match, and they don€™t even do the one thing that they€™re supposed to do €“ eliminate Reigns from the Rumble €“ by tossing him over the top rope. That obviously would backfire later. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zctkqazu3X8 The worst part is that the Wyatt Family would show everyone how that€™s supposed to work later in the match.

4. Roman Reigns, Selfish Jerk

This isn€™t on the level of Hulk Hogan whining and helping to eliminate Sid Justice after Sid tossed him from the 1992 Royal Rumble, but it€™s still a glaring example of selfishness. Throughout the summer and fall, Roman Reigns has faced challenge after challenge, whether it€™s from the Wyatt Family, the Authority or the League of Nations. Through it all, his €œbrother€ Dean Ambrose has been at his side, fighting all comers and watching his back. Ambrose has been the one true friend Roman can count on. So why, when Triple H tossed Reigns, did Roman not re-enter the match to help Dean Ambrose defeat the Game and win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship? Reigns wasn€™t battered into oblivion €“ he had just tossed Sheamus before Hunter eliminated him. Instead of climbing back into the ring and exacting revenge €“ and helping his buddy become champ €“ Roman pouted on the outside while Ambrose squared off against Triple H€ and lost. Sure, from a storyline perspective, Triple H needed his 14th world title so he and Roman have something to fight over at WrestleMania XXXII (/sarcasm/), but come on. We€™re supposed to believe that Reigns is suddenly all about fair play and sportsmanship? (For the record, Authority members Kane and Big Show attacked Reigns after being eliminated last year, so he could have gotten even this year.)

3. Roman Takes A Powder

When it was announced that Roman Reigns would be entering the Royal Rumble at #1, a very big question was left facing WWE: How do you get him to the end of the match without creating problems along the way? The Rumble is full of mini-storylines and angles, and having Roman in there the whole time could mess them up, unless he literally spends half the match lying in a corner recovering. Instead, WWE went the route of having the League of Nations take him out of the match €“ but not eliminate him €“ requiring that medics help him to the back. Thus, Reigns left the match at #14 and wouldn€™t return until Sheamus was entering at #29. That means that the world champion spent approximately 24 minutes not participating in the actual Rumble. Fifteen people entered the match in the time he was out of the match, and 15 were eliminated in that time, including Brock Lesnar and most of the Wyatt Family. Reigns basically bypassed half the match and half the field, including some of the biggest threats. It€™s no wonder that fans booed like crazy when he returned.

2. The Beast Neutered

If you wanted to see Brock Lesnar run roughshod over the Wyatt Family and anything else that moved in the Royal Rumble, then you got your money€™s worth Sunday night. Entering at #23, Lesnar tangled with the three members of the Wyatt Family in the match, eventually eliminating all of them single-handedly. He also tossed Jack Swagger in that span. However, Bray Wyatt brought the family back in later to decimate and then toss Lesnar, removing him from contention before Roman Reigns could return to the match. Just like that, Brock was gone from the Rumble, spending about seven minutes in the match. Worse, instead of charging back into the ring and destroying Bray and sending him packing, Lesnar simply walked to the back, accepting his fate. Giving up like that was completely out of character and just lame. It didn€™t make fans want to see Bray and Brock at WrestleMania, but that€™s what we€™re probably getting. This would have been so much better had Lesnar re-entered the ring and tossed Wyatt, at least then making the feud personal. When in the blue hell has Brock Lesnar ever just accepted his fate? This is the same guy who rushed the 2004 Rumble when he wasn€™t in the match to eliminate Goldberg because of a backstage run-in. Apparently costing Brock a title shot doesn€™t reach that level of rage.

1. Anyone But You, Roman

If the Orlando crowd wasn€™t clear Sunday night, Roman Reigns as WWE World Heavyweight Champion was not a popular option, even less so would have been back-to-back Royal Rumble winner. Fans were on Reigns€™ case from the get-go, and having AJ Styles debut at #3 didn€™t help. Then having Roman miss half the match by way of League of Nations beatdown made the crowd resent him even more when he returned €œtriumphantly€ at #29 to run wild on the field. Fans clearly didn€™t want to see Reigns go coast-to-coast Sunday night, especially after he avoided facing the Wyatt Family, Brock Lesnar, Kevin Owens and a host of others during his absence. The audience cheered like mad when Triple H eliminated Roman, which is not the reaction you want when you€™re trying to build to a WrestleMania main event pitting evil corporate champion the Game versus underdog Reigns. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFSi1Pv998E Despite their best efforts, WWE might need to wake up to reality €“ that fans simply aren€™t buying Roman as world champ. Period. Sure, Reigns got some good pops from crowds for a few weeks, and he certainly has his fans. But this is now two Rumbles in a row where Roman was largely booed, and it could easily be a second straight Mania where fans turn on him. If that happens, and Triple H is cheered by 100,000, then can we finally pull the plug on this experiment?

UPS€

12. One Last Time?

OK, admit it, the R-Truth gimmick of confusing events and messing up had long run its course, but Sunday night€™s mishap was actually pretty funny. Truth entered the Rumble at #12 and immediately retrieved a ladder from under the ring, set it up in the center of the ring and climbed. When he got to the top, he looked up at asked, €œWhere€™s the briefcase?€ clearly confusing the Rumble with the Money In The Bank ladder match. He was tossed seconds later for his troubles. The funniest part about it wasn€™t Truth; it was everyone else stopping and watching him set the ladder up and climb. The other wrestlers looked incredulous, but they let him continue. But now, a request: Can the joke be over? It€™s played out, and WWE lucked out that this one was funny. Unfortunately, you just know it€™s going to get beaten to death in the weeks and months to come.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.