12 WWE PPVs With TWO Unsatisfactory World Title Matches
Del Rio vs. Swagger? Twice in a lifetime? It's the worst of both worlds!
In the wake of the article posted over a year ago looking at some of the Pay-per-views with two great WWE World Title matches, it's only natural we would turn the tables and look at the other side of the coin as a follow-up.
Since the day said piece was posted (4th September 2019), there have been fifteen more occasions in which two World Championships were defended on the same night, with the new Universal Championship joining the classic WWE Championship in all of those.
This is a "tradition" that started back during the Invasion angle, at SummerSlam 2001, where the WWE (Stone Cold vs. Kurt Angle) and the WCW (The Rock vs. Booker T) straps were both defended on the same show.
Ever since, the WWE Championship has been present in all the 141 pay-per-views that have featured two or more World Championship matches on the same night, with the old World Heavyweight Championship being its most common partner, on 105 occasions between 2002 and 2013.
As seen in the previous article, on some nights both title matches absolutely nailed it. Other times, one delivered and the other not so much. However, there have also been other shows where both bouts were either forgettable or just plain bad.
Today, we will be looking at some of those awful nights...
12. Armageddon 2002 (Shawn Michaels Vs. Triple H; The Big Show Vs. Kurt Angle)
First up on that night was SmackDown's WWE Championship match, which saw Kurt Angle challenge the then-champion, The Big Show. 'The Olympic Hero' would win that bout and his third WWE Championship with a huge assist from a p*ssed off Brock Lesnar, who came in and F5'd the giant after being robbed of the belt at the prior pay-per-view, Survivor Series.
The match itself wasn't necessarily bad, especially for The Big Show's standards, but it doesn't compare to most of the matches from the glorious days of the 'SmackDown Six' era.
Meanwhile, fighting over RAW's World Heavyweight Championship in a brutal(ly long) Three Stages of Hell Match were Shawn Michaels and Triple H. It was the third chapter of the former DX members' feud, whose ending never came, despite the pay-per-view's theme song! It was far from being as good as their confrontations at either SummerSlam or Survivor Series earlier that year.
Sure, the match had its moments and features some insane spots, but it didn't grab the fans' attention as much as their first encounter at SummerSlam, which featured stronger psychology and felt more like a "blood feud" instead of a glorified spot fest.
11. Royal Rumble 2006 (Edge Vs. John Cena; Kurt Angle Vs. Mark Henry)
Thanks to the introduction of brand-exclusive pay-per-views in 2003, here we are a little over three years after Armageddon 2002.
When people think of Edge and John Cena in January 2006, there's one moment that comes to everyone's mind first. And I can guarantee you: it's NOT this match!
After the huge success that was Edge's Money in the Bank cash-in at New Year's Revolution earlier that month, 'The Rated R Superstar's inaugural run with the gold immediately came to an end just three weeks after that unforgettable night. These two had many classic matches later that year and beyond, but this was easily the weakest pay-per-view bout from an otherwise epic rivalry.
What can't be described as epic in any way, shape, or form, though, is Kurt Angle's World Title defense against Mark Henry from that night's main event.
The two had a slow, boring, plodding match that ended abruptly with a 'sleep on a banana peel' finish, which saw Henry run into the turnbuckle right before getting rolled up.
Most people only remember the angle between Angle and The Undertaker that followed this match, which began the build to their awesome match at the following month's No Way Out, and rightfully so.
10. Unforgiven 2007 (John Cena Vs. Randy Orton; The Great Khali Vs. Batista Vs. Rey Mysterio)
After a two month run as SmackDown's World Heavyweight Champion that felt more like two decades, full of horrible matches with the likes of Batista (SummerSlam comes to mind immediately), Khali's reign FINALLY came to an end in a triple threat bout against 'The Animal' and Rey Mysterio.
Granted, this was actually by far the best match from The Great Khali's title run, but that's not saying much. At all! The finish saw Batista drop the future 'Punjabi Playboy' with a Spinebuster, finally ending the nightmare and capturing his third World Heavyweight Championship.
Meanwhile, fighting over RAW's spinner strap were John Cena and Randy Orton, fresh off a match at SummerSlam (actually one of the best encounters from their forced feud) that had already ended with Cena going over cleanly. Why the need for a rematch, then? Remember Orton kicking Mr. Cena's head off his shoulders!?
The in-ring action was subpar, to say the least, and ended after seven minutes via DQ when Cena refused to stop punching 'The Legend Killer' in the corner. Out of their 9836 matches, this was arguably the most forgettable.
Speaking of forgettable, the main event of this pay-per-view? The Undertaker vs. Mark Henry. Yeah...
9. No Way Out 2008 (Randy Orton Vs. John Cena; Edge Vs. Rey Mysterio)
Oh, look. Another match between Randy Orton and John Cena!
Unforgiven 2007 and No Way Out 2008 might have been just a handful of months apart from each other, but it felt like a completely different world. Between one and the other, Cena got injured, the title got vacated and we were now living in the 'Age of Orton' - now in high definition!
So how was this happening AGAIN already? When John Cena came back from injury at the Royal Rumble in 2008 and won the match, he chose to use his WrestleMania title shot against Orton... before WrestleMania.
This match was better than the one at Unforgiven, with Orton working over Cena's surgically repaired chest, but featured that dumb finish that saw Orton slap the referee to get DQ'd and retain the gold. This might sound cool and all, but not so much to the live pay-per-view audience who had to pay 40 dollars to get this.
The World Championship match saw Edge put the gold on the line against an injured Rey Mysterio in a rematch from the Royal Rumble.
They worked a safe five-minute match since Rey was in no condition to wrestle, and he was immediately attacked and eventually written off TV by the returning Big Show afterwards. Floyd Mayweather Jr. came out to confront the returning giant, knocking him out and starting the build to their meeting at WrestleMania XXIV.
8. Survivor Series 2008 (Triple H Vs. Vladimir Kozlov; Chris Jericho Vs. John Cena)
'Super Cena', back sooner than expected from yet another serious injury!
After hurting his shoulder at the hands of Batista during their big clash at SummerSlam, John Cena made his return (again) to challenge Chris Jericho for the World Heavyweight Championship at Survivor Series.
Jericho, who was coming off a terrific feud with Shawn Michaels over the belt, immediately dropped the belt to 'The Champ' in a one-sided match via submission. The two would have a better bout the following month at Armageddon.
And over on SmackDown, Vladimir Kozlov. That pretty much tells the whole story, doesn't it?
Kozlov made his debut in 2008, spending a couple of months destroying jobbers in two-minute squash matches on TV before suddenly being pushed into a WWE Championship program with Triple H. To say Kozlov wasn't ready would be putting it mildly, as he and Hunter had a really bad match at this event.
You remember Edge's run-in near the end and him stealing another WWE Championship, but if you ever consider watching the whole match that came previously... please think again!
7. Hell In A Cell 2009 (Randy Orton Vs. John Cena; CM Punk Vs. The Undertaker)
The inaugural Hell in a Cell pay-per-view came at a time when WWE was introducing gimmicked events left, right, and center.
Another thing that WWE kept throwing away left, right, and center was John Cena vs. Randy Orton, with this following their 'I Quit' encounter from September's Breaking Point event.
The match was sandwiched between their Breaking Point and Bragging Rights (60 minute Iron Man bout), with the two trading the belt back and forth in all three of those events. This, being no exception to the rule, was Orton's sixth World Championship victory after a Punt Kick.
SmackDown's World Heavyweight Championship scene also featured a rematch from Breaking Point, with The Undertaker challenging CM Punk inside the cell after the Teddy Long Screwjob(!) that took place.
Undertaker completely wiped the floor with the soon-to-be leader of the Straight Edge Society, beating him decisively and ending Punk's reign after a relatively poor match - especially when compared to their bout at WrestleMania 29 years later.
CM Punk wasn't the same after this one-sided feud, going from retiring the hottest babyface in WWE (Jeff Hardy) in the Summer to being one whole year without one single win on pay-per-view just like that.
6. Bragging Rights 2010 (Kane Vs. The Undertaker; Randy Orton Vs. Wade Barrett)
People say a picture is worth a thousand words, and it's quite the challenge to think about an angle in recent wrestling history that went as nowhere as the one pictured above did.
The Brothers of Destruction went to war over Kane's World Heavyweight Championship in quite the dull Buried Alive Match, in what was their third pay-per-view title match in a row already, with the other two being gimmicked matches as well.
This bout saw the 'brothers' exchange a really weak Attitude Era-like brawl all over ringside until they took the fight into the grave, eventually. Undertaker had the match won near the end but decided to turn his attention to Paul Bearer, falling victim to the mother of all random attacks, courtesy of The Nexus, and losing thanks to them.
Speaking of The Nexus, the leader Wade Barrett found himself challenging Randy Orton for RAW's WWE Championship in the main event of this very same event.
John Cena would be fired in case Barrett didn't win the match, so Cena came in at the end and AA'd Barrett himself, keeping the strap on 'The Viper' while giving Barrett the cheap win (but a win regardless) that allowed him to save his job.
Again, people used to pay 40 dollars to get these finishes...
5. Survivor Series 2010 (Randy Orton Vs. Wade Barrett; Kane Vs. Edge)
Believe it or not, Survivor Series was the pay-per-view that came immediately AFTER the aforementioned Bragging Rights!
Orton and Barrett went at it again over the WWE Championship, this time with Cena as the referee and the added stipulations that if Barrett didn't walk away with the gold, Cena would be fired. On the other hand, Cena would be free from The Nexus if Barrett won the title.
The match was better this time around (though that's not saying much at all), and ended with Cena shoving Barrett into the RKO to cost himself his own job. Well, for the couple of weeks it lasted!
Elsewhere, over on the blue brand, Kane moved on from the Undertaker feud to a strange rivalry with Edge. The Canadian, despite being the babyface, bullied Paul Bearer's father, who was in a wheelchair, during the build to this pay-per-view
To say it created a weird dynamic would be putting it mildly, with Kane somehow finding himself as the BAD GUY in this whole thing! At least they delivered once the bell rang, right? Well...
The match was mostly Kane "interrogating" Edge about his actions while in chinlocks, and ended with Edge pinning both Kane and himself after a Spear for the really f*cking lame double pinfall draw finish. Good lord.
4. WrestleMania 29 (The Rock Vs. John Cena; Alberto Del Rio Vs. Jack Swagger)
In life, knowing when to leave things well enough alone is a huge value.
One year after the legendary 'once in a lifetime' encounter between John Cena and The Rock at WrestleMania XXVIII, which did record-breaking business, the company decided to do the very same match, this time with the WWE Championship up for grabs.
It obviously wasn't even close to being as special as the original match, with the two wrestling a video game-like match (with multiple finishers activated) in front of a relatively quiet crowd until Cena got his win back in the end. To make matters worse, poor Rocky would get injured during this match.
The World Heavyweight Championship bout saw Alberto Del Rio defend against Jack Swagger. This will forever be one of the most 'eh' World Title matches in WrestleMania history, just having midcard written all over it.
Del Rio won the match via submission and held the strap for a one more day, losing to Dolph Ziggler on RAW in one of the most memorable Money in the Bank cash-ins ever. It comes as no surprise that everybody remembers that instead of WrestleMania when this was the title match they presented at 'The Grandest Stage Of Them All'.
3. Survivor Series 2013 (John Cena Vs. Alberto Del Rio; Randy Orton Vs. The Big Show)
Remember that time when Daniel Bryan was really over with the audience and WWE responded with their annual Big Show push that rarely goes anywhere?
In the final pay-per-view before the WWE retired the World Heavyweight Championship and unified it with the WWE Championship, they were clearly thinking ahead already and thus left Survivor Series with a pair of forgettable title matches.
Randy Orton was challenged by The Big Show in a plodding bout in front of an equally dead crowd, retaining the gold after taking Show's head off his shoulders with a rare Punt Kick.
Earlier that night, John Cena put the World Championship on the line against former champ Alberto Del Rio in a rematch from Hell in a Cell. The two kind of walked through the motions and worked a very similar match to Hell in a Cell, with Cena winning yet again and sending Del Rio all the way down to the undercard.
The most notable moment from this whole show was the challenge between both champions at the end of the event, setting the stage for the title unification match at December's Tables Ladders & Chairs event.
2. Greatest Royal Rumble 2018 (Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns; AJ Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura)
The Greatest Royal Rumble event in April 2018 was nothing more than a glorified house show in Saudi Arabia, and proof of that was the fact that both WWE and Universal Title matches were the same as WrestleMania 34.
Sure, WrestleMania 34 itself would be a worthy entry when it comes to pay-per-views with unsatisfactory World Championship matches, but there would be no point in adding two entries with the very same matches. The Greatest Royal Rumble was really f*cking pointless, so we went with it.
First on the card came the WrestleMania rematch (the first of three...) between AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura for the WWE Championship. The in-ring match itself was very good, but the finish was awful and only helped in delaying the payoff even further.
The main event between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns was equally pointless and worse in the ring, featuring a very strange finish. Reigns speared 'The Beast' through the cage and thought he'd won the strap, only for the referee to declare Lesnar won since his feet hit the floor first, delaying the payoff to SummerSlam. Notice a pattern here?
1. Super ShowDown 2020 (Brock Lesnar Vs. Ricochet; The Fiend Vs. Goldberg)
Ricochet punched his ticket to a rare WWE Championship match with Brock Lesnar on pay-per-view after the low-blow that allowed Drew McIntyre to eliminate 'The Beast' in that year's Royal Rumble Match. There's not much to say about the actual match itself, though, as Ricochet did a grand total of zero moves to the champion and got completely jobbed out to Lesnar, who was on his way to McIntyre at WrestleMania.
However, there is A LOT to say about the Universal Championship match from that show. The Fiend walked into the event as the reigning champion against Goldberg and dropped the belt after a two-minute match that ended with a very weak Jackhammer which looked more like a suplex.
Goldberg was supposed to wrestle Roman Reigns for the belt at WrestleMania 36, who eventually got replaced by Braun Strowman when COVID-19 ran roughshod over the world. Not only was this title reign beyond unnecessary, but it also hurt The Fiend and the character hasn't been as interesting ever since.