13 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Feb 12)
Omega/Page vs. SCU, Rose vs. Riho, and a top-three episode of Dynamite.
Last night's AEW Dynamite was, at minimum, one of the three best weekly shows this young company has produced since its inception.
Almost everything got over on this episode. The Texan crowd were wired, engaged, and popping all night long, from the Kenny Omega and Hangman Page vs. SoCal Uncensored opener all the way through to the big debut at the end. Everything important connected - an objective measurement of success from a TV show that is firing on all cylinders at the moment.
Dynamite was largely built around its two title fights, with the aforementioned tag team tilt a repeat of the epic encounter those two teams forged on the Jericho Cruise. Later, Nyla Rose challenged for Riho's Women's World Championship, looking to overturn the loss she suffered to the Japanese star on the very first episode of Dynamite back in October 2019.
Elsewhere, we got MJF vs. Jungle Boy, Dustin Rhodes vs. Sammy Guevara, and more, including a host of new matches for upcoming Dynamites and the Revolution pay-per-view, which is filling up nicely ahead of 29 February.
This week's Downs are largely negligible. They were significant enough to be brought up but nowhere near disruptive enough to derail what was an excellent, excellent show. Let's run through them...
Downs…
2. What Happened Next?
The Dark Order briefly interrupted the show's opening stages to cut a promo as SoCal Uncensored and Hangman Page/Kenny Omega got ready to fight. Evil Uno wished the competitors luck, said they Order will be watching and when the time is right, they're going to strike.
Cue: Christopher Daniels decided he'd had enough and stomping to the back, presumably to find Uno and co. That's fine and makes perfect sense within their ongoing storyline, but there was no follow-up. AEW just forgot about it.
What happened to Daniels when he went backstage? Did he find The Dark Order? Did they evade him? Was he beaten up or even assimilated by the group? We don't know. Dynamite didn't tell us.
A strange move to focus on Daniels and leave the thread dangling, particularly as the Dark Order were in the ring 15 minutes later.
1. This Formulaic Angle
Again, these Downs are minor. Such a small angle finishing as the episode's biggest negative speaks volumes of its all-round quality.
The angle designed to build to next week's Tag Team Championship number one contender's battle royal was lazy and formulaic. It featured a bunch of AEW's biggest tandems hitting the ring to simulate the bout by lobbing each other out two-by-two until one was left standing. In this case, it was The Young Bucks, who dived on the mass of humanity on the outside to close the segment.
We've seen this kind of thing time and time again in mainstream American promotions, to the point that it's no longer effective. It wasn't bad; just boring. Perhaps a cluster of quick backstage promos from a handful of participating teams would've been a better shout, particularly for duos like The Butcher and The Blade, whose manager The Bunny rarely exercises her vocal cords.
Jim Ross calling the Jackson brothers "the Bucks of Youth" was a hoot, though. Guess we know where this 'Exalted One' storyline is going...
Ups…
13. Hit Him Up, Sammy
Following on from the previous week's flamethrowing session with another gritty vignette was Darby Allin, who aped Sammy Guevara's commercial break card presentations with one of his own.
This was good, effective stuff. In "smashing my throat with the skateboard," Allin said Sammy had made a mistake and that sooner or later, "I'll find ya." The conclusion was a challenge for Revolution. Via card, Darby asked if Guevara if he was busy at the pay-per-view and signed off with a little "hit me up" a la the Inner Circle man himself, setting up his next big programme.
Darby could be heard struggling to breathe throughout all of this, a consequence of his injuries, which the announcers explained were much worse than originally thought - hence his absence. Nobody knows what he's coming back, apparently, but stuff like this keeps him relevant.
12. Hometown Throwdown
Sammy Guevara vs. Dustin Rhodes was a hoot not only because of the work, which was excellent, but also Dustin's hometown crowd.
Texas loved him last night. The veteran hails from nearby Austin and was treated like a returning hero as he thought that dastardly little puke, ensuring big pops for everything he did and heat whenever he was worked over. It was fun stuff and Jake Hager's ringside presence was well-worked, with 'The Big Hurt' interjecting himself enough to be a pest, but not to the point that he got his stablemate disqualified.
Rhodes took the victory with his Final Reckoning finisher following a Canadian Destroyer. He was a perfect fiery foil for his sh*thead opponent in their rematch from 1 January, and the win was the right result given what went down immediately after. More on that in a bit.
11. Lucky Little Bastard
Another week, another glorious black-and-white PAC promo, this time featuring 'The Bastard' running, flexing, and gurning his way through the streets of his Newcastle-upon-Tyne, England hometown.
Watching PAC stand on street corners and use bridges your writer literally passes on his way to WhatCulture HQ every morning was a subjective treat. As far as the content itself goes, PAC was great. He claimed Kenny Omega hadn't been the same since he'd choked him out, understanding that 'The Best Bout Machine's' self-confidence was going - because he was the reason. PAC said Kenny was scared, "as you f*cking" should be, and soon, Omega was "30 minutes with the best in the world."
The beauty, as always, is in the delivery. PAC is such a gruff little grump that he could probably read your mother's shopping list and sound imposing. This format suits him extremely well and he's doing a sterling job of building the Omega bout while Kenny occupies himself with Tag Team Championship matches.
10. Bounty Set
Chris Jericho's preferred problem-solving method in AEW is throwing as many meat shields at them as possible before picking the bones. With Jon Moxley outfoxing and outdoing him and The Inner Circle last week, he decided a four-person advantage wasn't enough, dipping into the free agent's market to grab Jeff Cobb and throw him at his Revolution opponent.
This news was broken through a typically strong backstage promo in which Jericho called Moxley "the lowest-level scumbag" he'd ever seen. He said he'd scoured the globe to find a bounty hunter to tear Mox apart next week, saying that if Jon survived Santana last night, he'd get Cobb on the next show.
A big announcement in itself. The crowd popped for it and Jericho was his usual entertaining self, staying true to form as a chickensh*t World Champion content to hide behind his minion at every opportunity.
9. Dustin Says What Everyone Was Thinking
Dustin Rhodes was on tremendous form on the microphone last night, ethering Jake Hager to revive and reheat their feud in just a few short minutes.
"Turn around," he barked. Sammy Guevara obliged, but Dustin was looking for "Jericho's b*tch," not the up-and-comer, which got a huge pop. Dustin is so bloody over. "Are you ever gonna step in the ring or are you just gonna keep collecting a paycheck?" he asked, echoing many an AEW fan, adding that Hager was failing in MMA and failing here by not stepping between the ropes.
Dustin's demand was clear: he wants 'The Big Hurt' at Revolution. Jake almost got into it with him there and then, but turned back to head up the ramp instead of throwing down with Big Dust.
Great stuff from Rhodes here, but what's most important is that we're finally about to see Hager step into the ring. Fans have been waiting to see him wrestle since October. That's a long, long time, and while the Dustin feud has been put on the backburner several times over, that we're heading towards a resolution at Revolution is a big positive.
8. MJF Goes Prehistoric On Jungle Boy
A shook Brandi Rhodes joined the commentary booth as MJF battled Jungle Boy in a great midcard battle preceded by both men seemingly banishing their seconds to the back, content to wrestle the bout on their own terms.
MJF went back on this, because of course he did. The finish saw Wardlow come out, slip the Dynamite Diamond Ring to his boss, then watch on as MJF clocked Jungle Boy and hit the Double Cross for the win. An effective finish that poured further heat on the victor but kept the babyface protected.
The work preceding this was strong. It had a great dynamic with MJF in total prick mode and the fast, expressive Jungle Boy popping the crowd with his offense. His sympathy and athleticism makes him extremely easy to root for, particularly up against a guy like MJF - his polar opposite. The audience was fully into this as well, because that's what happens when you throw two performers of opposing alignments with well-defined in-ring characters against each other.
A supplemental Down for Arn Anderson watching the match at a stupid angle backstage (why would you ape one of WWE's sillier minor tropes here?), but the match ruled.
7. Britt Baker Just Kills It
Britt Baker is straight-up killing it as a heel every single week and last night may have been her finest effort yet, with the dentist drawing mad heat in Texas.
She chastised Tony Schiavone's "stupid question" about justifying what she did to Yuka Sakazaki by stating that as a dental surgeon, she has ethical and legal obligations, one of which is improving the health of the public. A bunch of impenetrable jargon followed as she patted herself on the back for removing Sakazaki's tooth for free before it fell out anyway, before turning her attention back to "Mr. Starbucks."
Ripping Tony is easy heat because he's such a beloved figure, and it worked again here. "I'm seeing a lot of confusion in these chubby Whataburger faces" is what really got under the Texas crowd's skin, though. They hated Britt for this, and that helped make another searing, effective promo from the evolving heat magnet. She's doing a tremendous job with this new character.
6. Everything Goes Dark
The list of active professional wrestlers who feel more believably gritty than Santana starts and ends with Eddie Kingston. That's high praise, and while the duo's similarities make this an easy comparison, the Proud and Powerful man stands on his own as an awesome, underrated talker dripping with real-world legitimacy, as he showed again in last night's pre-taped Jim Ross interview.
Getting his eye stabbed was enough justification for Santana to want to turn Jon Moxley's work dark, but he took it deeper, harking back to a time when he was broke, unemployed, directionless, and living in a hellhole Bronx apartment. The walls were closing in; he was buried alive. Santana called his dad at 3:30am, saying that his every waking day was dark. His dad's response? "That's my everyday."
Santana's father, we learned, was fully blind by 25. That's why this angle hit Santana so hard. That's why he claims Jon Moxley built his own coffin by p*ssing away his Inner Circle opportunity. That's why he promised that Mox was about to find out how it felt to live in the dark.
To hell with everything else. This guy is real. You feel what he says every single time, so here's hoping he gets more promo opportunities in the future.
5. A Restaurant-Quality Slobberknocker
Jim Ross couldn't have come up with a more perfect description than the above for Santana vs. Jon Moxley, which came exactly as advertised.
This was different to any other match on the brawl. It was, at times, a wild, unhinged brawl between two guys who work that style so well, particularly early on. Santana jumped Mox was he was entering through the crowd. They fought all over the arena floor before eventually making it to the ring, with the Inner Circle man trying to take Jon's good eye by jamming it into the ring step's corner. It was grimy as f*ck, even when they got between the ropes, and it was full of thrills.
With the rest of the IC watching on from a luxury suite, Ortiz got involved by spitting booze in Moxley's good eye. He was temporarily blinded. The 'Purveyor of Violence' was swinging blindly, flailing around the dark, but enacted revenge by jamming a thumb into Santana's peeker, seizing the advantage, and smashing him with the Death Rider for the W.
Thematically, this was a home run. It needed to be ugly and it needed to work the storyline. Both checkboxes were marked emphatically.
4. Big Boy Stuff
The Inner Circle destroyed Jon Moxley after he'd beaten Santana, but Jeff Cobb wasn't waiting until next week's match to make his presence felt.
Chris Jericho called the big Hawaiian out from the back and Cobb marched down, hit the ring, and hit Mox with his eye-catching, Tour of the Islands finisher. Moxley was put down ahead of their big match next week and immediately, Cobb was installed as a monster.
This was a great exclamation point to cap an awesome night of action and Cobb is an exciting pick-up, provided he's here for longer than the angle dictates. AEW needs a few more powerhouses. Yes, Hager and Wardlow are going to be wrestling soon, but Cobb has a different skillset to both and should be a better fit here than he is in NJPW, where he doesn't quite suit the environment. He can become a big AEW player by doing big boy stuff alone, so let's hope he decides to stick around.
3. Hangman & Omega Star In Another Tag Thriller
The great shame of this wonderful Kenny Omega/Hangman Page storyline is that it'll spell the end of the duo's awesome string of tag team matches. These guys are wonderful together, raising the standards for AEW tag bouts every time of asking, and the scene will be hurt when they eventually split and go into their singles feud.
That observation aside, their rematch was SoCal Uncensored was outstanding. On the Jericho Cruise, they worked a slower, more traditional style partly enforced by the lack of space around the ring. This left little scope for dives. This time, they found a happy medium. Athletic feats were back on the menu with Omega and Scorpio Sky setting that tone early on, but there was plenty of classic tag team wrestling as well, particularly when SCU were in control. Those guys are total pros.
Page's attempts at going it solo vs. SCU ended in both him and Omega being trapped in dual submissions. Earlier, Kenny had tried to force synergy with his disillusioned partner by wearing a similar black best to the ring, though there was a point where he was desperate for a tag with a knocked-down Hangman nowhere to be found. They pulled it together in the end, though, as a beautiful tandem flurry ended with their V-Trigger/Busckhot combo for the win.
If it wasn't already, AEW's tag team division is fast becoming the best in the wrestling. Bouts like this are the reason.
2. Riho & Rose Kill It… Again
Riho vs. Nyla Rose II went down halfway through Dynamite, and what an absolute triumph it was.
The first match slapped. The sequel slapped harder. They worked the best possible version of the fast, evasive babyface vs. imposing heel powerhouse format they could concoct at this stage in their careers. Riho was slippery, quick-witted, and never unrealistic, scoring her opportunities through intelligence, superior speed, and counters. Rose, meanwhile, went full 'Native Beast.' One particularly brutish moment saw her pluck Riho out of the sky, nail a rib breaker, then crush her spine against the apron. Later, she hit her awesome rope-draping knee drop before an arrogant hands-on-chest cover and a top rope Death Valley Driver that looked like it killed Riho. She is an evolving powerhouse and not yet the finished article, but performances like this suggest she'll be one of the best in the world in a few years' time.
"This is awesome" ringed out through the building as the match entered its fantastic, climactic final gear. Rose kicked out of the top-rope double stomp at one. Fuelled only by adrenaline, Riho took her broken body to the top turnbuckle, nailed two more, but still couldn't put Nyla away - Rose's foot on the rope saw to that. Seconds later, Riho's spine was split by a spear. The Beast Bomb ended her reign at four months.
Comfortably the best women's match in AEW history, this thing absolutely ruled. Let's hope this continues throughout Rose's reign.
1. The Right Decision
We have a new AEW World Women's Champion, and switching the belt was entirely the right move.
Riho wasn't around enough to get the strap over. Her busy Japanese schedule limited her appearances at a time when she really needed to be showing up every week. This is a young belt in a young company and it required visibility to really get over, which Riho couldn't provide. It's a shame, and your writer has been more complimentary to Riho's run than most, but it wasn't working. It had to change.
Brock Lesnar's part-time championship runs are justifiable because he's a massive star with a unique aura, presence, and mystique. Riho isn't that. She's a great wrestler, sure, but that isn't enough to pull the role off.
In Nyla Rose, AEW has installed a champion that will be around most weeks, will help raise the bar, and will engage in fresh matches with new opponents, some of which may have been set up in her backstage confrontation with The Bunny, Britt Baker, and others after the bout. She's an evolving wrestler but one AEW is wise to hitch their wagon to at the moment.