14 Ups & 2 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Mar 19)

Indianapolis becomes Screwjob City as Vince crushes Kofi's WrestleMania dreams.

The New Day
WWE.com

SmackDown is rolling towards WrestleMania 35 with a freight train's momentum.

As illustrated by the lopsided Ups-to-Downs ratio, this was the blue brand's fourth great show in a row. Such scores are nothing new for Tuesday nights, of course, but it's refreshing to see SD's writers holding things together ahead of the year's biggest wrestling event, particularly with Raw grabbing most of Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair's best material in recent weeks.

Lynch and Flair were in the house for the returning Kevin Owens Show last night, but SmackDown wasn't built around them. This episode was all about Kofi Kingston's insurmountable gauntlet. He'd face The Bar, Rowan, Samoa Joe, and Randy Orton for the right to challenge WWE Champion Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania 35, and yes, shenanigans were afoot. The New Day man was soundly screwed.

Elsewhere, there were developments in the Women's Tag Team Title division as the boastful IIconics took on Bayley and Sasha Banks. Vince McMahon was in the house again, Rey Mysterio brought back a face from the past, and AJ Styles had pointed words for a certain 'Viper.'

Let's hope SmackDown's post-WrestleMania 35 standards are as high as this, because the past few weeks have ruled.


Downs...

2. Do Something Interesting Or Go Away: Redux

Lacey Evans
WWE.com

Lacey Evans is the worst.


1. Booked To Hell

Peyton Royce Sasha Banks
WWE.com

The way WWE have booked their Women's Tag Team Championships since Elimination Chamber has left much to be desired, and it continued as champs Bayley and Sasha Banks strolled into SmackDown last night.

They were defeated by The IIconics. This might not be a huge deal in itself, but it is when the context is applied. Bayley and Banks were originally booked like passengers in a Divas Of Doom vs. Nia Jax/Tamina feud on Raw. Now, those two teams have both joined the title hunt, and they're taking losses on SmackDown to boot, with the endgame being a bland, uninspiring four-way 'Mania match.

WWE aren't doing Bayley and Banks justice here. They look like dorks, they aren't going to be featured prominently at WrestleMania, and as things stand, it looks like they're going to be locked in the p*ss break spot. Shame on WWE for letting their longstanding issues with booking men's tag wrestling creep into the women's division so quickly.


Ups...

14. Chopping Down The Champs

The IIConics
WWE.com

Booking issues aside, the content put forth by SmackDown's women's division was solid last night, and between Peyton Royce, Billie Kay, Bayley, and Sasha Banks, it's hard to fault a single performance. It'd be wrong to hold the unimaginative path they're taking to WrestleMania 35 against them.

The IIconics kicked us off with a short, snappy promo after the Women's Tag Team Champions had made their entrance. Having called Bayley and Banks out the previous week, the Aussies claimed they looked "scared, strange, and small," as if their parents "bought their way into an Ivy League school they couldn't get into," then mocked them for going back to NXT for self-gratification, only to get "chased off their own turf" on Raw. The IIconics then claimed they'd no choice but to face "the best team in WWE," and the bout was on.

Such heat-building segments are necessary with acts like Kay and Royce, who are regularly booked to lose. Here, they stoked the crowd up ahead of an otherwise cold bout, coming off well in the process.


13. A Fine Women's Tag

IIConics Bayley
WWE.com

Again, the result wasn't ideal, but Bayley and Sasha Banks vs. The IIconics was a solid, functional TV bout that won't live long in the memory, but accomplished exactly what whoever laid it out wanted to with minimal fuss and no obvious flaws (other than Lacey Evans' pointless interruption).

The IIconics are basic, but fine. They're improving. Though Royce is perhaps the more advanced of the two between the ropes, Kay is starting to put it together as well, and while she may never be as fluid as her opponents, she doesn't look out of place sharing a ring with them.

Here, the Australians kept things simple. They spent time on the backfoot as Banks mocked their signature pose, but triumphed through solid heel work, with Billie damn near kicking Bayley's head off with a big boot on the outside, then holding Banks' leg down as Peyton made the cover, scoring their biggest victory since Super Show-Down.

Weekly TV was made for bouts this like this. It was alright.


12. The Prodigal Son Returns

Oh, Dominick: how you've grown.


11. Keep It Simple, Styles

The AJ Styles vs. Randy Orton feud continues to yield microphone magic.

Last week saw the former World Champions go bar for bar with a heated back-and-forth based on their divergent paths to the top, as AJ took on the role of hard-grafting ex-indie warrior versus Orton's entitled company man shtick. Yesterday's offering wasn't as pointed, but it still worked, as 'The Phenomenal One' joined Kayla Braxton to shoot more barbs at his apparent WrestleMania opponent.

Styles put Orton over with his opening salvo, calling him a great competitor with the kind of agility that'd usually belong to a man half his size, before diving into last week's material. He called Randy "a first-round draft pick" and himself "a walk-on," then said that at 'Mania, 'The Viper' will be stood across from a man who'd never been handed a thing, promised to tear the house down in New York, before signing off by wishing good old Kofi Kingston luck in the main event.

AJ typically benefits from keeping things simple in his promo work. That was the case here, with the former WWE Champion coming off as he should ahead of his next clash with Randy.


10. Cesaro Softens Kofi Up

Cesaro Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Last night's gauntlet match was good. It wasn't quite on the same level as the Elimination Chamber prelude or last year's Raw bout, but Kofi Kingston's performance was superhuman and each part of it hit the required notes, though only one was truly excellent.

It's perhaps surprising that Cesaro's part was the least effective, given 'The Swiss Superman's' talent. This was primarily a runtime issue. His and Kofi's scrap was the second shortest at just over seven minutes. They didn't quite have enough time to work to the level one might normally expect from them, and that Kingston had already fought Sheamus forced them into a one-sided layout the likes of which Cesaro isn't best suited too, but they worked a fun little fight regardless, culminating in Kingston's victory.

It came when the European was on the verge of crushing his opponent with the Neutralizer. Kofi countered out, hit the S.O.S., and that was that. The Bar had been felled, and Kingston moved on...


9. Classic Vince

VINCE MCMAHON
WWE

Vince McMahon is heeling it up something fierce these days, and it continued again last night, as the WWE Chairman appeared after the apparent conclusion of Kofi Kingston's gauntlet match to screw the victorious New Day man out of his WrestleMania 35 opportunity.

It was textbook Vince. He stood on the stage as Kingston and his boys celebrated, congratulating the former Intercontinental Champion on his victory. Then came the bomb: "Kofi, you are going to WrestleMania... if you can beat one last opponent," and out came Daniel Bryan, whose victory was all but assured.

McMahon family fatigue is a real problem, but what's the issue if Vince is using his considerable performance skills to put heat on an engaging storyline between two full-time performers? This is exactly how he should be used. He isn't hogging the spotlight, but enhancing Kingston's sympathy and Bryan's villainy at the same time, all for the betterment of a major WrestleMania programme. It's classic, classic stuff.


8. Sheamus Shines Vs. Kofi

sheamus Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Sheamus is one of the most underrated wrestlers in WWE by default. The Irishman has been criticised so vociferously throughout his WWE run that he can't not be.

Though he'll rarely blow you away between the ropes, Sheamus is a solid, dependable big man who was green when he started, but has developed immensely over the years. Now, he's comfortably on or above WWE's modern working standard. The Bar's success has as much to do with his consistency as it does Cesaro's ingenuity, and the 'Celtic Warrior' looked good in the gauntlet's opening stretch, battering Kofi Kingston with his trademark clobbering offence, though he was always going to take the fall.

This came when Kingston countered an attempted Brogue Kick for a two-count. They sprung to their feet, and Sheamus was quickly felled by Trouble In Paradise, having played his loser's role well. Kudos to him for once again showing that he's nothing like the big, lumbering lump some still typecast him as.


7. Let Them Fight

Charlotte Flair Becky Lynch Kevin Owens Show
WWE.com

After last week's spiel on the abundance of long talking segments, yesterday's Kevin Owens Show was conclusive proof that WWE's writers read SmackDown Ups & Downs.

Maybe not, but it was great to see Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair doing something other than speaking at each other, and even better to see Owens actively acknowledge the previous episode's chat-heavy format by telling the duo to get down to business and throw leather.

KO's entertaining introductions brought the WrestleMania opponents down to the ring. He set the scene by speaking about friendships gone awry, recapping recent happenings in the Raw Women's Title storyline, then saying that the duo have talked a lot, but nobody wants to see them do that anymore. Cue: the inevitable pull-apart brawl, with Flair and Lynch scrapping to the floor before security could separate them from each other.

The live crowd adored this angle. It was an effective subversion of both the chat show format and the feud's recent goings-on, and Owens was an effective table-setter too.


6. Defanging The Viper

Randy Orton Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Though Randy Orton's portion of the gauntlet took on a similar layout to Samoa Joe's, it still worked. The vicious, unforgiving heel brutalised Kofi Kingston in what was supposed to be the bout's final fall. Though he found himself sent into the steps early, Randy fought back, picking the would-be WWE Championship challenger to pieces inside the ring and out, coming within an inch of hitting a match-ending RKO as things unfolded.

Kofi countered that death-blow and hit Trouble In Paradise to a thunderous pop. That's when Randy took a powder, rolling out of the ring to avoid the pinfall, before the action went to a commercial. We returned to Orton controlling ahead of late dramatic surge. Kofi kicked out of a countered high cross, survived the draping DDT, then squirmed his way out of the RKO, putting Kingston's shoulders to the mat for the 1-2-3, and what looked to be a cathartic victory.

Vince McMahon's shenanigans followed. The final fall was a great way to set up to everything after, and 'The Viper' was the perfect "Final Boss" character for this position.


5. Daniel Bryan Sets The Scene

Rowan Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

This was a night of great promos, and while Daniel Bryan's pre-gauntlet diatribe wasn't the best (we'll get to that later), it still ruled.

He set the scene for the main event by laying into Kingston. Kofi, he said, didn't deserve the opportunity. The bout was an injustice. Unlike Kingston, Bryan had overcome legitimate odds. Kofi has "never been held down," was "handpicked" by management, and though he fought hard, he ultimately lost.

Repeating last week's words, he called Kingston a "B+ player," which is "okay for you fans, but not good enough" for a guy with WWE Title aspirations. "No matter how much you chant for him, he'll lose again."

Daniel's words were, of course, absolute bullsh*t. That's exactly how things should be. The man is supposed to be the most deluded, over-the-top villain in the company, and he fulfilled that by taking Kingston's situation as its opposite. Given the gauntlet's outcome, he's going to be extra c*nty when addressing the New Day next week...


4. Rowan Bludgeons Kingston

Rowan Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Kofi Kingston vs. Rowan's was great because it was different from everything else in the gauntlet.

Sporting a t-shirt emblazoned by legendary Teutonic thrash metal band Kreator, Rowan proceded to give Kofi a Teutonic thrashing all around the place. The actual "match" lasted just a few minutes. During it, the big man beat the tar out of his wee opponent, softening him up before the bigger names arrived, before getting himself disqualified on the outside.

Rowan wasn't there to win, but to bludgeon, and bludgeon he did.

The assault continued after the bell. Rowan sent Kingston into the post, threw him across the timekeeper's area, then put him onto the announcer table with that claw-handed Chokeslam... thing. It worked. Rowan looked like a monster, Kofi became increasingly sympathetic, and the format helped mask the big fella's singles match deficiencies.


3. Fired Up

The Miz
WWE.com

The night's opening segment belonged to The Miz, who, one week after Shane McMahon had "justified" his Fastlane turn, was full of hellfire. This was his big opportunity to follow-up on his former tag team partner's bullsh*t, and he did so with a fantastic babyface promo.

If we have one complaint, it's that Miz, one of the best heels in the company, didn't spend more time showing remorse for past actions. That's splitting hairs, though. He did cover that ground at the start of his spiel, albeit in shortform. Afterwards, we got tremendous face material from 'The A-Lister,' who once again spoke on his desire to make his father proud, and McMahon being the one to make that happen, before getting to the turn itself.

Miz said that while people warned him about Shane, he didn't want to believe them. Then Fastlane happened. McMahon battered him in front of his dad, and Miz told Shane that he was just as rotten as his own father. He was "born the worst, not the best," and while his family may own the company, they don't own him.

The closing act saw Miz espouse his own work ethic ("hard work beats talent when talent doesn't work hard enough"), putting a neat little bow on a segment that fully cemented Mr. Mizanin as a wrestler the fans can get behind at WrestleMania 35. This programme is working out just fine.


2. Joe Picks The Bones

Kofi Kingston Samoa Joe
WWE.com

The gauntlet's finest pre-Bryan stage saw Samoa Joe stomp down to the ring after Rowan had put an almighty beating on Kofi Kingston. It was a perfect setup. The threat level should escalate in bouts like this, and Joe is a tremendous in-ring stalker. He's the ideal guy to pick the bones of a broken, battered opponent, and he spent much of his time in the ring doing that, forcing Kofi into his most defensive role so far.

Wrestlers like R-Truth and Ricochet gathered backstage to watch Kofi battle 'The Destroyer.' His bumping and selling were both on point as Joe hit a particularly gnarly clothesline early on. We got a grisly slo-mo replay of Kofi's head getting spiked into the mat from a Uranage, after which Kingston's spirited fightbacks continued, though Joe, at times, was presented as an insurmountable foe.

But insurmountable he was not. The United States Champion went for the rarely-seen Muscle Buster, and that proved his downfall. Kofi was able to Sunset Flip his way out of the move and into the pinfall, scoring the unlikeliest of victories to the announcers' shock and the building's delight, advancing to face Randy Orton.

The bully fell, and that's okay. Bullies are supposed to fall in the end.


1. The Obstacle Is The Way

Daniel Bryan Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

We got five minutes of Daniel Bryan vs. Kofi Kingston after Vince McMahon had pulled the screwjob, and that's all we needed.

Kofi was going up against the kayfabe best wrestler in the world after almost an hour of gauntlet action, throughout which he'd been soundly battered by all manner of brutish opponents, despite his victories. The man's body was a wreck. Anything longer than five minutes would've been unrealistic and an insult to our intelligence, so him losing relatively quickly after a few fightbacks was the right move.

The layout was perfect. Bryan and Kofi were both brilliant, and in the end, the screwjob resonated.

Kingston now faces another colossal obstacle if he's to make his way to WrestleMania 35. Such is the way WWE book underdog babyfaces in 2019, but while patterns like this often produce diminishing returns, there's no evidence that Kofi is cooling off yet. On the contrary, it felt like the man was more over than ever during the gauntlet. Let's hope that WWE's follow-up is as effective as Bryan's callous opportunity-squasher was. This storyline is wonderful.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.