15 Superstars With The Most Losses At SummerSlam
Who says wins and losses don't mean anything?!
Next to WrestleMania, WWE SummerSlam is viewed by many as the second biggest show of the wrestling calendar. As such, big matches are put on, and even bigger performances are delivered. Not everybody can come out of SummerSlam as a winner, though.
Looking back through SummerSlam history since the PPV debuted in 1988, now is the perfect time to see who SummerSlam's biggest losers are. Be it in singles or tag team action, whether there's stipulations in place, or even if it's not winning a multi-man match, any-and-all failed attempt at victory has been taken into account for this list in order to find out who has picked up the biggest amount of defeats at the biggest show of the Summer.
A couple of participants on this list are actually in matches at this year's SummerSlam event, and so with this piece being penned before SummerSlam, there could even be some amendments needed when this year's extravaganza comes to a close.
So let's get to it. And be warned, some of the inclusions here may very well surprise you.
15. Bret Hart – 4 Losses
Starting off this list is a man renowned for his excellent SummerSlam matches. That’s not to say he won them all, though.
In fact, one of Bret Hart’s greatest ever matches was a losing effort against Davey Boy Smith in a SummerSlam ’92 Intercontinental Title bout. He’d follow this up with a DQ loss against Jerry Lawler at the next year’s event, in a match where he got DQ’d for refusing to break his patented Sharpshooter.
Bret’s only other 2 SummerSlam losses came as part of the Hart Foundation, with him and Jim Neidhart losing to Demolition in 1988 and The Brain Busters in 1989.
Much like the Hitman, there are a few other superstars with 4 SummerSlam losses under their belts, but they feature higher on this list by virtue of having worse overall records at the WWE’s annual August PPV.
Even with 4 losses to his name, Bret Hart is still the superstar with the most high quality SummerSlam matches on his resume.
14. Shawn Michaels – 4 Losses
955270One of several superstars with 4 losses on his SummerSlam record, the Heartbreak Kid has also got 6 wins and a draw under his belt whenit comes to SummerSlam
Whilst 2 of his defeats came as part of The Rockers in 1989 and 1990, Shawn Michaels would have to wait until 2003 for his next loss. Even then though, that wasn’t an out-and-out loss as he was one of 5 losers in the Triple H-won second ever Elimination Chamber match.
As for Michaels’ last SummerSlam defeat, that loss, of course, was Shawn’s famed oversold defeat to Hulk Hogan, brother.
So when you look at it, despite on the record losing 4 times at SummerSlam, there was only really the singular clean-cut defeat for Shawn, and that was his mockery of a match with The Hulkster. So whatcha gonna do, when the Showstopper oversells on YOU?
13. Kane – 4 Losses
The Big Red Machine has competed in more SummerSlam matches than most superstars in WWE history. Of his 11 matches, 4 of them have ended up in failure for the Devil’s Favourite Demon and 1 was a no contest decision.
Glenn Jacobs' SummerSlam debut came under the Isaac Yankem gimmick and ended in a DQ loss to Bret Hart. After that brief soiree, the Kane moniker was slapped on Jacobs and he’d be rocketed to the main event.
The first SummerSlam loss under the Kane name came as he and X-Pac lost the Tag Team Titles to The Undertaker and Big Show in 1999. Surprisingly, though, his next loss at the biggest event of the Summer wouldn’t come until 2012 against Daniel Bryan. This would be followed up by a defeat to Bray Wyatt the following year.
12. Randy Orton – 4 Losses
In his 10 SummerSlam matches to date, Randy Orton has come up short in 4 of them.
His SummerSlam debut was a loss that came in 2003, where he competed in the Elimination Chamber match which saw him assist Evolution mate Triple H to victory. After a few wins, SummerSlam 2006 saw Orton surprisingly do the J.O.B. to the ageing Hulk Hogan, as The Hulkster played politics to go over the Legend Killer.
To follow up on the Hogan defeat, the Viper would then lose in 2007 as he challenged John Cena for the WWE Championship. After that, his next SummerSlam loss wouldn’t come until last year’s defeat to Roman Reigns.
With Sheamus butting heads with Orton at this year's event, it remains to be seen whether another loss will be attributed to the record of this third generation superstar.
11. CM Punk – 4 Losses
756633The Straight-Edge Superstar came out defeated in exactly half of his SummerSlam outings.
With a record of 4 wins and 4 losses, CM Punk is no stranger to leaving the biggest event of the Summer with a loss, the first of which came during a 2007 defeat against ECW Champion John Morrison.
In a bizarre match, Punk and his Straight-Edge Society lost a 3-on-1 match against Big Show in 2010, but even more shocking were the events of SummerSlam 2011.
As WWE Champion CM Punk battled WWE Champion John Cena to determine the Undisputed WWE Champion, Punk won the bout and was set to walk out as ‘the man’. Then came Alberto Del Rio to cash in his Money in the Bank briefcase. Del Rio would get the better of Punk in just 12 seconds.
The Second City Saint’s last SummerSlam match came in 2013 as he lost a fantastic match against Brock Lesnar.
10. Matt Hardy – 4 Losses
Who’d have thought the 1 in V1 would also stand for Matt Hardy’s win count at SummerSlam?
Having only really won just the solitary SummerSlam bout, the Sensei of Mattitude saw defeat in 4 of his bouts at the biggest event of the Summer. Bar a farcical default win against Zach Gowan on a pre-SummerSlam 2003 episode of Sunday Night Heat, Hardy’s only real SummerSlam win came in 2008 when he got a 30 second DQ win against Mark Henry.
SummerSlams 1999 and 2000 were losing tag efforts for the Hardy Boyz, with the 2000 match notable as being the first ever TLC battle. In singles efforts, 2004 saw Matt lose Lita’s hand in marriage to Kane, and then SummerSlam 2005 found Hardy’s match with fierce rival Edge stopped after less than 5 minutes, rendering Hardy the loser due to ref stoppage.
It’s funny how we never got to see the Matt Fact of “Matt really, really sucks at SummerSlam.”
9. Ted DiBiase - 4 Losses
Everybody has a price… well, except when it comes to SummerSlam, apparently.
Despite being able to pay off anyone and their Grandma, the Million Dollar Man’s SummerSlam record actually stands at a solitary victory and 4 defeats. Even then, his only win was a countout success over Jimmy Snuka at SummerSlam 1989.
Still, DiBiase does hold the honour of main eventing the first ever SummerSlam event, teaming with Andre the Giant in defeat against Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage. He’d then go on to lose the Million Dollar Championship to Virgil in 1991.
Further defeats followed as part of Money Inc. against the Legion of Doom in ’92, then a singles loss against Razor Ramon at SummerSlam '93 was DiBiase’s last match in the WWF.
When it came to SummerSlam, the Million Dollar Man struggled to even buy himself a victory.
8. Marty Jannetty – 4 Losses
To a select few of us, Marty Jannetty was always our favourite Rocker. Sadly for Marty, bar brief runs with Intercontinental gold, his singles career amounted to very little. And that’s reflected in his SummerSlam record.
In 4 SummerSlam appearances, Jannetty had the impeccable record of 4 defeats.
3 of Marty’s SummerSlam losses came during tag action, twice as a part of The Rockers and then once as part of the ill-conceived New Rockers. Arguably Marty’s most famous SummerSlam moment, though, was his only singles match.
In that 1993 bout, Jannetty was completely squashed by uber-heel Ludvig Borga.
But fear not Marty, you’ll always be the real talent of The Rockers (at least to some of us).
7. The Undertaker - 5 Losses
Whilst he’ll forever be remembered for his long-running Wrestlemania streak, The Undertaker wasn’t always as successful when it came to SummerSlam.
Despite a hugely impressive 9 victories at the event, the Phenom also has 5 losses (and 1 ‘no contest’) on his record.
After winning his first 4 SummerSlam matches, ‘Taker would then go on to lose the following 3. The first of which was a shocking double-cross as Paul Bearer betrayed Undertaker and sided with Mankind in 1996’s Boiler Room Brawl. After that came another screwed-up finish when special referee Shawn Michaels accidentally nailed the Deadman with a steel chair at the 1997 show, allowing Bret Hart to grab the victory and the WWF Championship. Then came a failed attempt at Steve Austin’s WWF Title in 1998.
More shenanigans occurred in 2004 when Undertaker suffered a DQ defeat to WWE Champion JBL, which was followed at SummerSlam 2005 asRandy Orton got revenge on the Phenom for his WrestleMania defeat earlier in the year.
With Brock Lesnar in his sights, it remains to be seen whether it’ll be ‘Taker’s win or loss record that gets added to come this year’s SummerSlam.
6. Triple H - 5 Losses
781078Whilst Triple H has the second highest amount of wins when it comes to SummerSlam, he also has his fair share of losses.
To go against his 8 victories, The Game also has 5 losses on his record since he made his then-WWF PPV bow at 1995’s SummerSlam. That match would end in a win over Bob Holly, but there were plenty of defeats to come.
A Cage Match loss to Mankind came in 1997, then 1999 saw Foley walk out as the WWF Champion in a match also involving Triple H and Steve Austin. Similarly, 2000 would also see the Cerebral Assassin come up short in a triple threat, this time involving The Rock and Kurt Angle.
2002 would see Triple H lose one of the greatest SummerSlam matches in history as he was defeated by Shawn Michaels in the Heartbreak Kid’s return from retirement. Hunter would then remarkably go undefeated at SummerSlam for a decade until submitting to Brock Lesnar in 2012.
5. Rey Mysterio – 5 Losses
Rey’s SummerSlam career is a chequered one, made up of 4 wins and 5 losses.
Despite only entering in the company in July 2002, Mysterio’s SummerSlam debut that August saw him tap out to Kurt Angle, which was a surprise at the time.
Whilst 2004 saw Mysterio lose in a six-man tag bout against The Dudleyz, 2006 was a losing singles effort against Chavo Guerrero (thanks to a heel turning Vickie Guerrero). It was 2010, though, that was Rey’s biggest SummerSlam defeat, with the high flyer losing a World Heavyweight Championship match to Kane.
In his final SummerSlam appearance, the 2013 event saw Mysterio fail in his attempt to take The Miz’s Intercontinental Championship.
4. Jeff Hardy - 5 Losses
The Charismatic Enigma has a dreadful record when it comes to SummerSlam.
Not only was Hardy’s last ever WWE PPV appearance a losing effort against CM Punk at SummerSlam 2009, he also walked out defeated from all 4 of his other SummerSlam bouts.
In fairness to Jeff, he’s been involved in 3 highly memorable SummerSlam battles, but he’s always come out on the losing side. Those particular 3 matches were the first ever TLC match in 2000, a Hardcore Title Ladder Match again Rob Van Dam in 2001, and then the aforementioned Punk TLC match at the 2009 event.
Less notable were his 2 other losses; a 1999 Tag Team Turmoil Match and then a straight-up singles loss to MVP in 2008.
In fact, the only reason Jeff isn’t at #3 on this list is because 2 of his defeats involved tag team efforts, so he gets a little leeway in comparison to his competition.
3. Booker T - 5 Losses
When it comes to SummerSlam, Booker T is a 5 time, 5 time, 5 time, 5 time, 5 time… loser.
In a clean sweep, Hall of Famer Booker has lost every single SummerSlam match he's ever competed in. For someone so successful, that’s quite the impressive stat.
To Book’s credit, he actually found himself main eventing his very first SummerSlam show in 2001. That would end with him losing his WCW Championship to The Rock, though. By the following year Booker was reduced to the tag ranks, teaming with Goldust in a losing effort against Lance Storm and Christian.
2004 brought defeat against a young upstart named John Cena, then 2006 was a DQ loss against Batista before Booker T wrapped up his SummerSlam career with a 2007 defeat against Triple H.
Now can you dig that, sucka?!
2. Chris Jericho – 6 Losses
Of his 10 SummerSlam appearances, Y2J has come out on the losing side more times than not.
For somebody so decorated, SummerSlam hasn’t been kind to Chris Jericho. His very first appearance at the event saw him lose an excellent 2/3 Falls Match to Chris Benoit in 2000, and that largely set the tone for what was ahead for the Ayatollah of Rock ‘n’ Rollah at the annual August extravaganza.
2002 saw Jericho tap out to Ric Flair, 2003 saw him come up short in the Elimination Chamber (eliminated by Goldberg), 2004 was another losing effort in a triple threat involving Edge and Batista, 2005 was a loss to WWE Champion John Cena, and last year was a defeat against the eerie Bray Wyatt.
At times Jericho has been used as the measuring stick to work with up-and-coming talent to help them get over, and that can clearly be seen with some of his SummerSlam matches. And no, I’m not talking about the Nature Boy.
1. John Cena – 7 Losses
John Cena never loses, right?
The one-time Doctor of Thuganomics has made a career out of being Super Cena, of being the man who simply never loses, of being this generation’s Hulk Hogan, brother. So with that said, it’ll be hugely surprising to many to see that Cena has the most SummerSlam losses of all-time.
After making his SummerSlam debut in 2004, his first couple of appearances saw him knock up a few wins against Booker T and then Chris Jericho. By 2006, Cena would lose against long-time rival Edge before bouncing back with a win over Randy Orton in 2007.
Then came a run of finally losing to Batista, getting bested by Orton, losing to the red-hot CM Punk twice (once in a triple threat with The Big Show), falling victim to the rise of Daniel Bryan, and then getting dismantled by Brock Lesnar. Sandwiched between these defeats was a 2010 win for Team Cena over The Nexus.
For all of those who claim that Cena never jobs, you simply need to look at his horrendous SummerSlam record. “Big Match John”? Maybe, just not when it comes to SummerSlam.