17 Greatest Roman Reigns WWE PPV Matches

Nine matches rated 4 stars or greater!

Roman Reigns Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Some WWE Superstars break through the glass ceiling guarding the main event tier organically. Others become major players thanks to being gifted a chosen status by the powers that be. Roman Reigns is a special mix of both.

When Batista won the 2014 Royal Rumble, the runner-up for that contest seemed like a welcome alternative to the fans. The 2015 Royal Rumble became a role reversal for Reigns as the crowd resented his hand-picked victory.

Getting Roman to the top might have been a rocky ordeal but he's produced a fantastic body of work along the way. Beginning with his early days in The Shield, he has been a part of some of the best matches of the past few years.

The following 17 matches count down Reigns' greatest Pay-Per-View matches. A whopping 9 of these were rated 4 stars or better by the Wrestling Observer and only one dips below 3 stars. His rise to the top has been very enjoyable to watch.

Overall match quality was considered as well as Roman's individual effort and how his career was impacted by each match.

Many tag-team and multi-man matches are included on this list but neither of Reigns' two Royal Rumble appearances were included. The line had to be drawn somewhere so the Rumbles weren't considered. Several other lesser matches were omitted as well.

Here are Roman's 17 best Pay-Per-View bouts...

17. The Shield vs. CM Punk (TLC 2013)

Cm Punk Roman Reigns Tlc 2013
WWE.com

CM Punk was gearing up for a potential WrestleMania match against COO Triple H. His journey found himself in this unfair 3-on-1 match at TLC.

It should be stated that the match itself was enjoyable enough. Roman Reigns was dominant and only stalled momentum when Punk avoided a charge, causing Roman to send himself crashing over the announce table.

It's hard to understand the logic of having three non-comedy wrestlers lose a handicap match like this and WWE probably regretted the call when Punk unceremoniously exited the company for good about a month later.

This would also be the match that CM Punk referenced during his infamous podcast interview with Colt Cabana where he was instructed to make Roman look strong. That comment would do him no favors, creating a swarm of internet memes to follow.


16. The Shield vs. Bryan/Orton (Payback 2013)

Roman Bryan Payback 2013
WWE.com

In the buildup to this match The Shield would receive their first ever 6-man tag team loss at the hands of Daniel Bryan, Kane, and Randy Orton. Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins would now put their Tag Team Championships on the line against a Kane-less version of that team.

The main story of this match was the dynamic of how Orton and Bryan might coexist. Reigns and Rollins were a very solid tag team during their title run that worked well as a unit and that was highlighted here.

One example of their teamwork was when Orton reached out of the ring towards Rollins but didn't see Roman nearby. He was met square in the jaw by a Superman Punch courtesy of Reigns.

Orton and Bryan's loss was ultimately due to their inability to work together. Orton allowed Bryan to take a Reigns spear as he avoided it. Rollins then Curb Stomped Daniel to set up the winning pin.

This was a fond era of Roman's career as he was regularly placed opposite elite talent such as Bryan and Orton. 


15. WWE WHC Ladder Match (Money In The Bank 2014)

966349

In the middle of 2014, Daniel Bryan had to vacate the WWE World Heavyweight Championship due to injuries shortly after he was finally given a proper title run. It was sad, but the show must go on.

Roman Reigns, John Cena, and 6 others would battle it out in a ladder match to determine who would be the new champ. Online retailer Amazon accidentally leaked an image for the upcoming Summerslam event that had Cena and Lesnar's faces on it so there was little doubt that Cena would walk away the victor.

During the match, there was an impressive segment for Reigns where he went on a series of signature moves to take out all of his opponents, sans Cena. This led to one of the match highlights when he and John had a slow stare-down in the middle of the ring. That was about the only real solid moment for Roman because with 7 other guys there's only so much time to go around for everyone to shine.

The seeds had been planted for a while that Roman was the chosen one to receive a singles push so it was no shocker that he was in this main event title match less than one month after The Shield officially split.


14. The Shield vs. The Rhodes (Battleground 2013)

966212

Roman Reigns is typically booked to be the dynamic, rising star. He gets plenty of opportunities to use his mighty arsenal if power moves, just not on this night.

He and his partner Seth Rollins would defend their Tag Team Championships for the last time at Battleground 2013 when the competed in a losing effort to Cody Rhodes and Goldust.

The Rhodes family were involved in a feud with The Authority at this time that had them often-fired and trying to regain their jobs. Patriarch Dusty would accompany them to the ring to either win the belts or be permanently unemployed by the WWE.

Roman got in very little offense during the match but can at least be complemented on his sufficient defensive role. There was a hot tag to Goldust in the middle of this in which Roman would spend several minutes being the elder Rhodes' punching bag.

Cody would hit the Cross Rhodes on Seth to win he and his brother the Titles. It would be the last time Roman would wear WWE gold to date.


13. The Rhodes vs. The Shield vs. The Usos (Hell In A Cell 2013)

Hell In A Cell 2013 Reigns Shield Goldust Usos
WWE.com

After losing their Tag Team Championships the month prior, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins entered this event with hopes of regaining their gold. This match was slightly better than the previous bout at Battleground, in part due to the addition of the dynamic Usos.

Roman Reigns would stand out more in the match as well. His attitude was more on display as he would taunt the aging Goldust. There was a part in the middle where he could be heard calling Goldust an "old man" over and over.

Goldust played the face in peril well, mostly at the hands of the dominant Reigns. When The Rhodes would finally win after Cody hit the Cross Rhodes on Rollins, the crowd erupting for their victory.

Fast forward to present day and considering the history between current WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins and challenger Roman Reigns, it all lends to a highly compelling backstory.


12. Cena vs. Reigns vs. Kane vs. Orton (Battleground 2014)

Roman Reigns John Cena Battleground
WWE.com

This was the show after Money In The Bank 2014, the event where John Cena would win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship in a ladder match due to the title being recently vacated by Daniel Bryan. The Raw prior to Battleground saw Reigns giving a spear to fellow babyface Cena to illustrate the 'every man for himself' aspect of this match.

Roman would be utilized well in this and the crowd was pretty hot for him. At one point he did his running front drop kick to opponents on the outside edge of the ring successively to all three of his foes, then followed it up by spearing Orton through the timekeeper's barricade. That earned him a "This Is Awesome" chant.

Sadly for Reigns it would not be his night to win. Cena retained after AA-ing Orton onto Kane, then pinning Kane. Everyone knew that Lesnar would be returning the next month to face Cena at Summerslam so the outcome wasn't a big surprise.

The crowd liked the tension between Reigns and Cena and would ultimately help establish him in his early post-Shield run.


11. The Shield vs. The Usos (Money In The Bank 2013)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFwsVXtBQBc

It might be cheating to include a pre-show match from the pre-WWE Network era but this match is too good not to. The Usos defeated 3MB and Tons Of Funk to earn a shot at Reign's and Rollin's Tag Team Championships, which doesn't sound very impressive in hindsight.

Roman Reigns was rightfully positioned as the muscle of this match and he worked his role to perfection. He would clothesline an Uso at one point that would cause his opponent to flip like his head was taken off. Later, he was the strongman base in a bananas corner suplex/powerbomb spot involving all four competitors.

Rollins would use his corner powerbomb move as a setup to a Reigns' spear. Roman would then get the pinfall in front of a loud and appreciative Philly crowd.

Dean Ambrose afterward came out to celebrate the win with his Shield brethren. The group was impressive and Roman was the brute trio.


10. Shield/Real Americans vs. Rhodes/Usos/Mysterio (Survivor Series 2013)

Roman Reigns Survivor Series
WWE.com

This traditional Survivor Series match pitted the team of The Shield and The Real Americans against the Rhodes brothers, The Usos, and Rey Mysterio. It took place on the one year anniversary of The Shield's main roster debut and would mark the first attempt at singling out Roman Reigns for super-stardom.

Although Seth Rollins would last throughout most of the match and score one elimination, Roman Reigns would be the one to overcome the big odds. After those two found themselves on the wrong end of a 5 on 2 situation, Roman would utilize his spear on 4 of his opponents to become the sole survivor of this contest.

The heel Roman then received the praise of the Boston crowd, showing WWE that he had the potential for the eventual run that he would embark on. 


9. The Shield vs. Cena/Ryback/Sheamus (Elimination Chamber 2013)

344190

In only their second actual main roster match, Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, and Dean Ambrose found themselves taking on an all-star team of John Cena, Ryback, and Sheamus. WWE did a solid job in positioning them as the real deal early.

In addition to some significant ring time opposite John Cena during the middle of this match, Reigns would be utilized well at the end. Twice his spear would be used decisively.

The first spear would be against Sheamus on the outside. He was drilled through the security wall next to the timekeeper's area, neutralizing the Celt for the remainder of the match. The second spear was given to Ryback, who was in the process of trying to Shell Shock Seth Rollins. Rollins would fall onto the belly of the speared Big Guy, pinning him for the win.

The Hounds of Justice were given a huge win on this night and Roman was positioned as the strongman of the group. The future looked bright for all of them.


8. The Shield vs. Evolution (Payback 2014)

The Shield Payback
WWE.com

While this is the lesser of the two Shield vs. Evolution bouts, it is still a worthy match that ranks fairly high on Reign's list of best Pay-Per-View matches. The Shield seemed to be in the early stages of a new chapter of the collective's career as they were full-on babyfaces at this point. They could have extended their group run for quite a while but it was not meant to be.

The match was slow to start as all 6 men treated this No-DQ match as a traditional tag team bout for about 10 minutes. Why not go into a full brawl immediately? Weapons would eventually be used as Reigns would have his vest removed to get beaten with Kendo sticks.

All members of The Shield scored a pinfall at the end of this elimination match, the final one going to Roman as he put away Triple H via spear. 

Not only is this match interesting because it would be Batista's last match in WWE (so far) but this is also the last time The Shield would compete as a collective. The next night on Raw was the night that Reigns and Ambrose got betrayed by Seth Rollins. 


7. Reigns vs. Big Show (Extreme Rules 2015)

Wwe Extreme Rules Big Show Roman Reigns Table
WWE.com

Who was excited about this match going into Extreme Rules? Not many people were. It was a very pleasant surprise.

Roman Reigns was temporarily out of the title picture since being screwed by Rollins' Money In The Bank cash-in at WrestleMania. He needed a holdover until being reinserted back into a feud with Seth. Cue the world's largest athlete.

The match was a little slow during the first half. Big Show still found a way to entertain with fun moments of breaking Kendo sticks and removing tables. He's a giant who doesn't need weapons; it was also a good way to spite the crowd.

Reigns really stood out due to some impressive bumps near the end. Most notably was when he was chokeslammed out of the ring through a couple of tables on the floor. It was one of the few truly extreme moments of the show, giving Roman a huge deficit to battle back from.

The spears through the barricade and then the announce table helped give the match a well-paced climax as well.

Unlike previous singles Pay-Per-View matches, this bout felt more like Roman was participating more than simply being led by the more veteran wrestler. His presence was that of an equal to Big Show, making the statement that his main event level is rightfully earned.


6. The Shield vs. Bryan/Ryback/Kane (TLC 2012)

Roman Reigns Kane Spear Tlc 2012
WWE.com

The Shield were booked in their first ever main roster match on Pay-Per-View opposite Daniel Bryan, Kane, and Ryback in a TLC match. Talk about an opportunity.

Roman Reigns and his Shield cohorts would seize the chance they've been given and work together as one of the most cohesive stables WWE has ever seen. They logically would isolate each opponent as the match progressed, taking each star out one-by-one.

The pacing of this match set the bar high for what was to come for the Hounds Of Justice. This match was fast and aggressive. Having an exciting talent like Daniel Bryan to wrestle helped keep the athleticism at a high level as well.

This memorable group is the foundation of Roman's current singles career and it's easy to see how well received they were from the very beginning.


5. The Shield vs. Evolution (Extreme Rules 2014)

Shield Evolution Extreme Rules
WWE.com

The Shield has had several notable wars in their tenure with one their finest being against Evolution. Veterans Randy Orton, Batista, and Triple H briefly reunited in 2014 to face off against the young Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins, and Roman Reigns.

Roman intentionally had a minimal role in this match until the latter stages of it. As the action spilled out into the arena for Seth Rollins to make a memorable dive, Reigns and Batista were realized to be alone in the ring.

A Batista Bomb would need to be battled out of, but Roman would finish off the future summer movie superstar with a Superman Punch and a spear.

This first Pay-Per-View match with Evolution (as well as the second one the following month) proved to be an excellent send off to the soon to be disbanding Shield.


4. Reigns vs. Orton (Summerslam 2014)

Reigns Orton Summerslam
WWE.com

This match came about after Roman Reigns costed Randy Orton an opportunity at the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Orton felt like Reigns had stolen the title opportunity from him. This match would serve as the Roman's first true 1-on-1 Pay-Per-View match.

The pacing of this match was more than superb. Orton would be in control throughout most of the time, creating that good comeback feel for Roman. And that's what it felt like when he landed a second-rope Samoan Drop.

Randy would reverse a spear with a beautiful power slam then later stop a Superman Punch with his RKO. Roman would not be pinned after either move.

Roman would offer a reversal of his own when he was able to leg-sweep Orton mid-punt. This set up a spear and a winning pinfall.

This match was simply amazing. On a weaker card it would have stolen the show. It was a brilliant statement match for Reigns in his push to the main event.

Sadly for him he would soon have to take a few months off after this due to injury, resetting sentiment that Roman still needed way more to earn his push.


3. Wyatt Family vs. The Shield (Elimination Chamber 2014)

Shield Wyatt Family Eliminaton Chamber 2014
WWE.com

Talk about a war. These two three-man teams were as over as ever and competed in a match that was highly anticipated. Just watching the pre-match video is enough to give you chills.

After a lengthy brawl, Bray would take out Ambrose unexplainably and unseen while out in the crowd. Then, Harper and Rowan would destroy Rollins by double chokeslamming him through an announce table. Roman would then be left all alone.

Reigns put on one heck of a rally in those final moments. He powered out of a Sister Abigail by brute strength and emotionally screamed in Bray's face before giving him a Samoan Drop.

Unlike most times that Roman has these kinds of odds stacked against him, he would not prevail. Bray finally connected with his finisher and pinned the big man.

This would be the finest match involving The Shield as a cohesive unit, which says a lot when looking at the plethora of fantastic tag team and six-man matches that they've put on.


2. Reigns vs. Bryan (Fastlane 2015)

Daniel Bryan Roman Reigns Fastlane1
WWE.com

As was expected since almost a year prior, Roman Reigns had won the 2015 Royal Rumble and was on his way to the WrestleMania main event for his shot at Brock Lesnar's WWE World Heavyweight Championship. 

Many fans saw Roman's situation as another attempt by WWE to push a corporately chosen star that had yet to be embraced organically by the audience. Those claims had at least some validity when compared to a guy like Daniel Bryan, who is adored by the fans.

Roman still had all the potential in the world but badly needed an injection of credibility before facing Brock. Bryan was returning from injury and wrestled an aggressive style that could more than prepare Reigns for Lesnar. He would be the test that Roman needed.

The two had a lengthy, physical bout that lived up to the hype. Roman not only beat the former champion but also made history when he kicked out of a pin following Bryan's running knee. No one had ever done that before him.

The match succeeded in quieting many of Reigns' detractors and prepared him for his upcoming match with Lesnar.


1. Lesnar vs. Reigns vs. Rollins (WrestleMania 31)

944752

This was it. The entirety of more than a year's effort to single out Roman Reigns as a WrestleMania main eventer came to a head on this night. He would stand across champion Brock Lesnar and prove a worthy challenger.

The bout was physical as expected during a Lesnar fight. Reigns would survive the onslaught, at times with even a twisted grimace on his face. Around 10 suplexes and four F5's failed to put him away.

Roman would mount a late-match rally and deliver multiple Superman Punches and spears. Momentum was on his side but a former Shield brother inserted himself late into the match to create an unforgettable WrestleMania moment of his own.

The singles match ended as a triple threat due to a Seth Rollins Money In The Bank cash-in. It was shocking to see Rollins become the champ at the expense of Reigns.

Roman might have been the man to take the fall at WrestleMania 31 but he could still walk away without a total loss. He entered the prized main event of the grandest stage of them all under heavy criticism and proved he belonged.

Rollins might have had the moment but Roman wrestled a stellar match before Seth inserted himself into the situation.

This was not only a great match for Roman Reigns, it was also a statement that he'd arrived. This was his greatest Pay-Per-View match.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm a dad who loves professional wrestling. Find me on Twitter @MitchNickelson or email me at leonardbeats@gmail.com.