Nominees: Jon Stewart costs John Cena the WWE United States Championship at SummerSlam. Randy Orton turns on Seth Rollins on Raw. (March 9th) Paige attacks Charlotte and Becky Lynch on Raw. (October 26th) Stardust turns on Goldust on Raw. (February 16th) Damien Mizdow eliminates The Miz from the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 31.
There isn't really a blow away moment for this one, as the Dean Ambrose heel turn on Roman Reigns ended up being postponed. What's left for the nominations is a mishmash of minor turns. The Jon Stewart turn is likely winning the celebrity award, and the Paige turn was something nobody cared about. Likewise, Stardust turning on Goldust, it was ultimately meaningless. Mizdow on Miz was fun, but it was a throw away moment. That leaves the Slammy for Randy Orton turning on Seth Rollins, which at least had main event implications. The crowd was hot for it. Winner: Randy Orton turns on Seth Rollins
