2 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Apr 3)

Sh*tty circumstances shouldn't mean lazy booking...

WrestleMania 36 kicks off tonight.

No, really. You just wouldn't know that if you watched this week's episode of SmackDown. On Friday, WWE lined up a 'main event' confrontation between John Cena and Bray Wyatt, furthered the Intercontinental Title picture, injected much-needed life into one long-running angle and more.

For every positive there was, the company bungled by serving up two sins. The entire Universal Title scene was crapped on from an almost dizzying height, another throwback showed up what this year's 'Mania will be like, one woman has re-emerged (out of nothingness) to become an unwanted "dominant force" and WWE's writers are still feigning ignorance over several things going on.

This is the weirdest WrestleMania ever, and it hasn't even aired yet. All that good work SmackDown's team has been doing since the turn of the year has been totally ruined since the promotion went behind closed doors. The lack of butts in seats is hardly their fault, obviously, but sh*tty, unimaginative booking and the decision to knowingly dismiss an entire month's worth of storyline build is.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from 'Mania 36's go home show...


Downs...

6. Continued Pretence

The Miz John Morrison
WWE.com

As The Miz and John Morrison stood tall atop ladders on the stage, this writer couldn't help but remember reading that Miz wasn't involved in those WrestleMania 36 tapings last week. His continued inclusion in the booking might've been forgiveable last Friday. but it wasn't here.

Why couldn't WWE just announce a change? People would've accepted it.

Instead, the writers continued pretending that the announced Triple Threat Ladder bout is on those 'Mania cards that'll air over the weekend. There wasn't even a hint dropped that things might be different, or some last-minute injury tease to help explain Miz's absence on the night.

This weekly pretence is torturous for those who know the card format at 'Mania, and it's insulting to those fans who do stay up-to-date with all the cut and thrust from the daily news cycle. Miz's 'Mania sabbatical should've been implied at least.


5. WrestleMania XXIV's Revealing Throwback

Ric Flair Shawn Michaels Wrestlemania 24
WWE.com

It does feel odd to whinge about awesome wrestling throwbacks, and yet here goes.

The WrestleMania XXIV corker between Shawn Michaels and Ric Flair remains one of the most emotional matches in WWE history. It was the end of Flair's in-ring career with the company, and Shawn's, "I'm sorry. I love you" remorse before Superkicking the lifeblood from Ric's run lives long in the memory.

There's just one fatal flaw in WWE's plan here: 'Mania 36 won't be anything like this. There won't be any fans, and there's unlikely to be a match as organically emotional as Flair vs. HBK. Revisiting a classic from 2008 exposed this year's (unavoidable) shortcomings - that's been the case with many of the throwbacks, but this somehow felt worse.

It hit home when watching that WrestleMania 36 will be sullied by a lack of atmosphere and stadium surroundings. WWE are clearly struggling to fill programming as is, but they shouldn't make fans yearn for a different event.


4. Tamina Smash!

Tamina Bayley
WWE.com

When was the last time Tamina was relevant? Her tag-team run with Nia Jax in 2019, perhaps? Or, how about before that when she was backing up Lana? It's certainly not any time recently, and that's why it sucks that WWE are suddenly painting her as SmackDown's "dominant force".

Everyone knows she's making up the numbers at 'Mania.

Tamina has come out of nowhere to become the focal point of this Women's Title Fatal-5-Way, and not in a cool Randy Orton-esque way either. One of the major issues plaguing WWE booking is that they draft wrestlers back in from the cold without warning and hastily try to thaw them out with a red hot sprint towards pay-per-view.

It hasn't worked for Tamina. She, much like Naomi and Lacey Evans, will play second (or third and fourth) fiddle to Bayley and Sasha Banks. That's the real feud fans are interested in seeing.


3. Contradictory Cena

John Cena
WWE.com

This wouldn't have been bad had Cena not made fun of the way Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' looks and proudly exclaimed that he "wasn't afraid" of the masked nightmare. That one statement set WWE up for yet more failure on an episode rife with it.

If JC wasn't scared of Bray's gimmick, then why did he look so creeped out as SmackDown went off the air?

On one hand, it's interesting that it was Wyatt sans mask that spooked Cena. On the other, this just didn't make much sense. Cena went from supercharged bad ass veteran to scolded schoolboy who didn't know where to look in a few short minutes. He needed to be one or the other, not both.

Contradictions rarely work in pro wrestling, at least not for strong babyfaces. If Cena wanted to play the brave big boy, then he had to do so for the entire segment. Shifting from powerful to panicky when Bray didn't even do anything was rather lame.


2. The Lack Of Momentum

John Cena
WWE.com

There was nothing on this week's SmackDown to suggest that the biggest show(s) of the calendar year will happen this weekend. At times, it was like WWE were sleepwalking through things into a 'B' level pay-per-view, not WrestleMania, and that's pretty worrying.

As aforementioned, the circumstances are obviously sh*tty, but WWE must do more. Way more. SmackDown isn't even doing as good a job as Raw with the gritty, realistic promos. Recent weeks have become completely skippable, and that can't be pleasing execs at FOX who shelled out a ton of money.

They, and the fans, need WWE to pull it together.

Yes, it's going down in an empty training facility and excitement is harder to come by than normal, but this is still 'Mania. That brand is one of WWE's finest, and it comes armed with a sense of importance that should (in theory) be hard to screw up.

The lack of momentum is vexing.


1. Sheer. F*cking. Laziness

Braun Strowman Goldberg WrestleMania
WWE

It doesn't help when the creative team are channeling WCW in 2000.

Michael Cole announced that Braun Strowman was replacing Roman Reigns against Goldberg like he was telling the world he planned to cut his toenails after the show. The sheer lack of oomph in his delivery told the full story; WWE couldn't even be bothered to concoct some sort of explanation for Reigns' removal.

It's happening, so deal with it. That's how the reveal came across, and it sucked hard. Whether some fans already thought Goldberg vs. Roman was inessential or not, it was 10x the attraction Bill vs. Braun is. That doesn't have any heat whatsoever, and it'll do more damage to Strowman's aura if Goldberg mows through him at 'Mania.

That's the most likely outcome, because it wouldn't make sense to take the title from Bill - he and Reigns can still wrestle later in the year when things calm down, and it's not like Braun would be an excellent Universal Champ at this stage in his comedy-laced babyface career.


Ups...

2. The Chemistry Between Bryan & Nakamura

Daniel Bryan Shinsuke Nakamura Cesaro
WWE.com

SmackDown did feature some solid wrestling despite all the storyline fumbles.

Most notably, Daniel Bryan and Shinsuke Nakamura put on a decent exhibition of things to come if Dan becomes Intercontinental Champion. It didn't go too long, but that's fine for TV and they can always have a more protracted pay-per-view match if needs must later on. For what it was, this was good sh*t.

Maybe a Bryan clean win would've been preferable to the disqualification finish? That's, admittedly, a bit of nitpicking though. After Cesaro's interference, the heels kicked the living eco-friendliness out of Daniel and left he and partner Drew Gulak laying. Anyone who knows WWE's booking style should rejoice after seeing that.

The babyface struggle here dropped heavy hints that they'll rally at WrestleMania and Bryan will seize the IC belt from Sami Zayn. That's a good thing, and it means D-Bry is one step closer to reclaiming the glory he fancied back in 2015.

Follow-up matches against Shin and Cesaro sound delicious too.


1. Sonya's Deceit

Sonya Deville Mandy Rose Otis
WWE.com

Forget previous whines about unrealistic dialogue and the fact nobody in WWE seems to talk to one another between broadcasts, because this was the storyline development yours truly was waiting for. With one mighty bound, the writers successfully managed to create friction and motor things along.

Sonya Deville is a deceitful, nasty bitch who deliberately sabotaged her pal Mandy's date with Otis. The reasons will come out later (there's a decent chance this could be the lesbian angle Sonya has been talking to the press about in interviews for the past year or so), and there might be some Otis and Rose tenderness coming.

Bring it on.

Involving the 'glitch guy' was clever too. This hacker character, whomever it is, should be smarter than everyone else around him/her, and they should definitely be poking their nose into things that fans might not see on camera to reveal the truth.

What other takeaways did you have from this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 6 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE's Road To WrestleMania 36 and 10 Things You Didn't Know About Beyond The Mat!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.