2 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (May 8)

Excited for Money In The Bank yet? SmackDown's writers aren't...

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman
WWE.com

If last week's SmackDown was a well-focused episode that smartly put emphasis on Otis' revenge, Sonya Deville's menace, Daniel Bryan's technical ability and passion, Bray Wyatt's Joker-esque delivery and more, then this week's was a tepid go home episode.

WWE failed to really build much last-minute excitement for this weekend's Money In The Bank.

It's hard to pinpoint exactly why, when the SmackDown writing crew has been so solid lately, they lazily leaned on overused tropes. Yours truly is screaming for WWE to once (just once) look back to how they ran into the last MITB pay-per-view, take a note of how the TV show immediately before it ended and do something a bit different.

As sad as it is to report, there wasn't a lot to like here. Whilst the actual in-ring wrestling itself was typically solid, the character work left a lot to be desired and creative stayed within their comfort zone rather than bursting out and raising many questions heading into Sunday.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from a rather disappointing, stock show that did more harm than good...


Downs...

6. Tamina Beating Bayley

Tamina Bayley
WWE.com

Prediction #1: Bayley will beat Tamina to retain her SmackDown Women's Title this Sunday at MITB, and will probably survive by the skin of her teeth even though she should win decisively.

This is one of the examples referenced in the intro with the words "lazily leaned on overused tropes". Before an upcoming pay-per-view, the challenger grabs a "surprise" win over the champion and theoretically rolls into that show with momentum. The only problem is that WWE use this booking so often it's woefully ineffective.

Such writing instantly telegraphs what will happen on the pay-per-view and totally eradicates any sense of threat the challenger has; that's WWE's fault for conditioning fans so relentlessly for decades. Most watching know the result of certain bouts before they happen, especially if they analyse the build up towards them.

Tamina pinning Bayley on SmackDown means she's heading for a loss this weekend. That's just the way it works (and has always worked) in this company.


5. A Tepid Universal Title Segment

Bray Wyatt Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Last week's 'Story Time' segment played to Bray Wyatt's mirthful strengths as a character. This face-to-face with Braun Strowman, during which both struggled with material that clearly just wants their pay-per-view match to happen already, didn't.

It was as tepid as they come.

Wyatt's reading of 'The Black Sheep' children's book last Friday was entertaining, recapped his history with Braun and perfectly summed up why the pair might be feuding. Last night's skit, however, didn't add much flame to the fire and only succeeded in exposing Strowman's contrived promo style.

This was totally avoidable, and only made Braun seem weak for jawing back and forth with Wyatt when he could've easily smashed him. It's starting to become painfully clear that this Universal Title match badly needs some cinematic help.


4. Jeff Hardy Coming Out On Top

Jeff Hardy Sheamus
WWE.com

So, Sheamus has been boasting for weeks now that he's ready to put the returning Jeff Hardy in his place, cement his status as SmackDown's alpha male and send the high-flying veteran back from whence he came. Didn't really work out that way, did it fella'?

The roles in this one should've been reversed.

In order for Sheamus to resonate control, he needed to kick Hardy's ass all over the Performance Center and give Jeff something to avenge. What is there to avenge now? Hardy has already torn Sheamus down a peg or two by hitting him with a Twist Of Fate and Swanton Bomb. If anyone, it's Sheamus who has the gripe now.

Remember this if WWE try to claim at MITB that the Irishman spoiled Hardy's return. He didn't - he enhanced it by giving Jeff someone to thumb his nose and shout, 'Na na na-na na' at. There was a quite stunning lack of babyface peril in this comeback, one that had already spoken at length about Jeff's fragility.


3. Sonya's Lucky Win

Sonya Deville Mandy Rose
WWE.com

Sonya Deville's match with Mandy Rose had a major upside that'll be discussed shortly, but it also starred quite the negative. WWE let Sonya down badly after all the confidence she's shown during her sterling promos lately. Her win over Mandy came across as a fluke stroke of luck rather than carefully-planned devious brilliance.

Why?!

There's an irritating amount of babyface protection at the wrong times in WWE. Rose wouldn't have lost any face had Deville kicked her butt by cheating to cut off comebacks then flexed her bad-assery by beating her old pal with something she could brag about. A quick roll-up cradle isn't something to boast about.

Lucky wins have no place in this rivalry. Its success relies on Mandy eventually dragging Sonya from pillar-to-post and exacting revenge for all her nasty, manipulative behaviour. It won't succeed if WWE continue booking half-hearted, fortuitous victories.


2. 'King' Corbin's New Lackeys

King Corbin Drew Gulak Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

This isn't an issue that's particularly exclusive to this episode, but it's time for another rant.

Why are Shinsuke Nakamura and Cesaro suddenly so keen to watch 'King' Corbin's back? Where is Sami Zayn? What the f*ck happened to Corbin's previous crew Dolph Ziggler and Robert Roode? None of those questions have been answered by WWE. It's almost like the 'King' has the power to make any heel with nothing to do follow him around.

Honestly, Shin saved Corbin mid-match on SmackDown like the guy had incriminating photos of him or something. Both he and Cesaro, who were previously Zayn's boys and had a reason for aligning with him, are now just sorta' spinning their wheels and pretending that Corbin is the best thing since leather-look jumpsuits and ultra-protective mouth guards.

It's not doing Nakamura or Cesaro any favours. Yes, they're WWE vets who aren't exactly a focal point right now, but painting them as Corbin's version of the Mean Street Posse is infuriating for anyone who cares about either man.


1. Every MITB Go Home Ever

King Corbin MITB
WWE.com

Prediction #2: 'King' Corbin won't win the men's Money In The Bank match.

If the chrome-domed royal had a hope in hell of doing so, then he wouldn't have closed SmackDown by holding the green briefcase. Again, much like with Tamina's win over Bayley that won't bag her pay-per-view success, this is just how WWE does business. Those who look dominant on TV beforehand rarely get supershow moments to be proud of.

The massive problem with this method is that it removes a bit of suspense from the coming match. 'Oh well, we know Corbin isn't winning' will be the universal cry from those tuning into SmackDown's go home serving, and they'd be right. Put it this way: Corbin winning MITB would now be the seismic shock of the weekend.

It cannot be that hard to come up with a fresher way to close MITB's build. Seeing one wrestler pose with the case as the cameras fade is so stock now, and it does nothing to sell the pay-per-view as an important or dramatic one.


Ups...

2. The Intensity Of Former Besties

Sonya Deville Mandy Rose
WWE.com

Finally, you might be thinking, some positives.

It's not Sonya Deville or Mandy Rose's fault that WWE booked their finish the way they did. All both women could do was make the best of things, and they tried by injecting their match with a seriously cool dose of welcome intensity. At times, it seemed as though they genuinely hated one another.

That's promising, especially if the company want to run further grudge matches between the pair. They'd be perfect for some sort of Extreme Rules stipulation bout (locking both in a cage and/or giving them weapons to use makes sense), because they blatantly know that their brawls need to be violent and explosive from the first bell.

Little touches, like Sonya clawing at Mandy's eyelashes and face, drew clearly defined lines between heelish brutality and babyface fire. It's good stuff, and it would've been better without the cop out finish. At least anyone enjoying this feud knows that Deville and Rose are on the right track.


1. That Eight-Man Tag

New Day The Miz John Morrison Forgotten Sons Lucha House Party
WWE.com

Holy balls, what a tag-team match this was.

This is the kind of tag that'd have Dave Meltzer rubbing his thighs if it happened in AEW, so it'll be interesting to see what he thinks of WWE's teams on SmackDown. Everything, from Forgotten Sons' aggro and the way Miz and Morrison seemed impressed by their partners, to New Day's usual antics and Lucha House Party flying around, ruled.

The closing stretch was also incredibly satisfying to watch. There's something about that 'body in, body out' approach to these multi-team tags that just clicks. Seriously, if you're in need of a match that'll restore your faith in WWE's doubles division, then this is the one for you.

It went almost 20 minutes, enhanced every squad's reputation (Forgotten Sons are making the most of their jump from NXT), had a hot finish and should whet the appetite for more in that Fatal-4-Way on Sunday at Money In The Bank.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out WWE Money In The Bank 2020: 10 Things That Must Happen and 10 Things You Didn't Know About WCW's Nitro Grill Restaurant!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.