2 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania SmackDown (April 1)

WrestleMania 38's "go home" stinks; WWE crack controversial jokes; Vince McMahon appears.

Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

The booking for Drew McIntyre's WrestleMania match vs. Happy Corbin has been a worse joke than anything Madcap Moss could come up with. This week, somehow, things got a little bit bleaker - WWE played a game of chance by throwing controversy at the wall in hopes that it might ignite the feud.

It didn't.

Lateness has been a theme for 'Mania 38 overall. Too many of the matches across both cards don't feel worthy of a stage this big, and McIntyre vs. Corbin is one of them. That's not a dig at the performers themselves, because they're trying their best and could still surprise come bell time, but...yeah, Drew deserves better than this.

SmackDown's final stop before Dallas outright failed to hype the weekend ahead. That's unacceptable, because this should've been a preview of chaos to come at AT&T Stadium. Instead, WWE put on a stinker of a two-hour broadcast that bizarrely shone the spotlight on workers who won't even be at WrestleMania.

They phoned it in, basically, and that's just not good enough at this time of year. Apologies in advance for all the negativity, but this wasn't great.


Downs...

6. Another Slap In The Face

Finn Balor Madcap Moss
WWE.com

Finn Bálor must be wondering by now why WWE even bothered to make him United States Champion. Right, here's the deal: Bálor winning that Andre The Giant Memorial trophy wouldn't have been huge news, but it would've been something - a bone tossed by the writers to a hungry dog.

Instead of looking strong though, Finn lost twice in the same episode. He was the last man eliminated by Madcap Moss in the Battle Royal, and then Bálor took the pin from Austin Theory in a hastily-arranged six-man tag later on. He's going exactly nowhere as US Champ, and that stings.

Why do the company book secondary champions this way?

Finn isn't even in the running for a slot on WrestleMania's Kickoff portions either. The Irishman's current role on WWE telly is to hold a belt nobody cares about (including creative) and make others look good. It's rotten, and it needs to change.


5. Time To Ditch The Tribute?

Madcap Moss Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal 2022
WWE.com

Michael Cole claimed that the Andre Memorial is a career-making moment for the man who wins it, which is just laughable. WWE demoted the Giant's tribute from 'Mania main card to Kickoff show and now to regular TV, but they want to pretend that it's still a launching pad for aspiring midcarders?

Come on now.

It's time to give this Battle Royal a rest. Nothing against Madcap Moss, but the winners are getting lower in stature by the year too - Moss' win will be largely forgotten about by the time SmackDown airs next week. Or, maybe it'll take two weeks. It won't be long, put it that way.

Individual mileage will vary with these brawls too. The old saying is that 'if you've seen one Battle Royal then you've seen them all', and it's difficult to argue against that point. WWE view such matches as a means to be lazy; just stick 15-20 wrestlers in the ring and let them kick/punch for 10-15 minutes.

The 2022 version was a rinse-and-repeat example of why this must be shelved next year.


4. A Senseless Tag Match

Sasha Banks Naomi
WWE.com

WWE pulled the nose up on the Women's Tag Title situation by slotting in a fine fatal-four-way last week. It wasn't perfect, and the old 'reigning champ gets pinned' trope popped up again, but everyone involved put on an energetic display that sucked fans in.

Now for the bad news.

Naomi and Sasha Banks just toppled the current champions Queen Zelina and Carmella in a straight up two-on-two match. Why is this a minor disaster? Well, credibility matters, and now the titleholders have none heading into WrestleMania. If anything, they're only keeping the belts warm.

In retrospect, the past few weeks would've been an ideal chance for WWE to present Zelina/'Mella as partners who might not see eye-to-eye but remain the best duo in the division. It's also sucky that Vega is the one eating pins all the time.


3. “Bitch!”

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

No, no, no, no, no. NO!

WWE's women shouldn't have to resort to busting out the 'B' word when they want to be taken seriously. This, unfortunately, has the opposite effect. Whereas Ronda Rousey's sparring promo was short and to the point, Charlotte Flair's was standard Diva-esque bullsh*t.

She didn't need to call Rousey a "bitch", but she did anyway. That word can work if used sparingly, but it's nonchalantly scripted for women when a pay-per-view bout is right around the corner. Could pro wrestling come up with something else as a replacement, please?

Flair's speech didn't do much to get one excited for the actual match either. Her feud with Rousey has been all over the bloody place; one week, they're working physical spots that reek of intensity. The next, they're trading insults like teenage brats.


2. Too Little, Too Late

Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Some folks out there will take Happy Corbin's joke about Drew McIntyre's deceased mother as another sports entertainment rise designed to get fans on the babyface's side. Others, meanwhile, will detest it and view it as a last-ditch attempt to make this interminable feud mean something before WrestleMania.

This writer is in the latter camp.

Regardless of your personal opinions about using real-life death to inject emotion, one thing is true: WWE waited far too long to try and plonk some actual heat into this rivalry. It was all stolen swords and 'Drew vs. The World' stuff until Corbin and Madcap Moss brought up life-altering family tragedy.

McIntyre's intensity at the end of SmackDown was admirable, but it again illustrated why WWE's writers should be doing more with him. Being brutally honest, the fact they had to go to such extreme lengths in the first place proves that the feud hasn't been clicking.


1. Humdrum “Go Home”

WWE WrestleMania SmackDown 2022
WWE.com

Not. Nearly. Enough.

Those three words could sum up WWE's "WrestleMania SmackDown" experience. The final stop before the biggest weekend of 2022 was video package city, and almost everything came across as filler or totally unimportant to the back-to-back cards that are about to happen in Dallas.

Neither Brock Lesnar nor Roman Reigns were in the house to add a final bit of sizzle to their "Winner Takes All" main event come Sunday, and there was no last-minute brawl between Charlotte Flair and Ronda Rousey. Nah, a hype vid and Flair calling Ronda a "bitch" should do it, eh? That'll get folks excited.

Or not.

WWE must be questioned for giving so much time to workers who aren't even on the 'Mania lineup as well. The Andre Memorial ate up far too much time, and some spotlight for Ricochet was a sh*tty olive branch for leaving him off the pay-per-view.


Ups...

2. Teacher’s Pet

Pat McAfee Austin Theory Vince McMahon
WWE

Credit where credit is due. Everyone involved in this 'Pat McAfee thinks Austin Theory is a little teacher's pet and a coward' storyline is smashing it; McAfee looks passionate, brave and explosive, Theory is coming across as someone who believes he's destined for the top because he's making key connections and Vince?

Well, Vince is Vince.

McMahon showed face on this week's SmackDown (first time in a while on the blue show for ol' Vinnie) to lecture Pat about leaving his position behind the broadcast booth. Behind him, Theory smirked like the head boy in class as his chief rival took a verbal pasting from the headmaster.

WWE's camera crew made sure to keep everyone in shot so you'd see the full range of emotions. Vince was furious, McAfee knew he couldn't push it and Austin was all, 'na-nana-na-naaaaa'. This is the best way this story could've played, to be frank.


1. Top Talent + Time = Results

Ricochet Humberto Angel Los Lotharios
WWE.com

Ricochet dropping to two quick fire losses sucked last week. It didn't make sense, and made the Intercontinental Champion look like a total afterthought. Cheerfully, Rico makes up for WWE's shoddy booking with sheer talent, and he was fired up to show his worth on Friday night.

Together, he, Humberto and Angel produced a fun little Triple Threat bout that achieved several goals. Firstly, it was a successful title defence for Ricochet (which is never a given). Second, WWE teased that Los Lotharios might split up, then kept them together in the end. Thank f*ck for that, 'cause the tag scene badly needs them.

Perhaps the biggest takeaway from all of this is that the IC belt didn't look horrible. That's a relief, especially when recent storytelling has been so wonky. WWE's writers need to learn that great workers will produce results if they're handed time and given some backing.

Is it ideal that a tag-team beat Rico in two matches last week? No. Is it the perfect outcome that he returned the favour to go 50/50 here? Nah. Is it nice to see the IC Title in a featured spot on TV? Absolutely.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 7 Ups & 8 Downs From WWE's Road To WrestleMania 38 and WWE WrestleMania 38: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.