3 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Rampage: Slam Dunk (Feb 17)
Keith Lee returns with a new look; AEW becomes the NBA; Jade Cargill needs something fresh.
Hey, did you know there's some basketball on this weekend?
Cross-promotions are clearly nothing new in the world of professional wrestling, but subtlety and this biz rarely go hand-in-hand when they should. Why run some simple ads for the NBA during those relentless pic-in-pic ad breaks when you could literally have wrestlers play ball mid-match, eh? AEW's decision to do that badly hampered this week's Rampage.
This should've been an overwhelmingly-positive broadcast for All Elite. Kenny Omega and The Bucks were in the house to work some six-man action, two young lions were squaring off elsewhere, and they were even about to blow off the fun mini-feud between Dustin Rhodes and Swerve Strickland by turning attentions to a major return instead.
Sadly, things didn't exactly go as planned. Only one of that hot trio of matches had any real merit, and Tony Khan couldn't resist plugging any remaining time with yet another TBS Title scrap that happened with zero build up.
There were positives, but this was not the "Slam Dunk" AEW wanted it to be. Here's all the good and bad from it!
Downs...
5. This Was Just Irritating
Yes, AEW has to hype upcoming events, but pick your spots to do it! There was no need for Excalibur to run through the cards for next week's Dynamite, Rampage and some of the Revolution pay-per-view during the closing stretch of Friday's main event. That was an insult to Dustin Rhodes and Swerve Strickland.
Pick. Your. Spots.
Excalibur's breathless deluge of match graphic hype was especially irritating because it happened just as Swerve was hitting a move to Rhodes on the ring apron. That was a big moment in the match, because it cut the icon's comeback off, but nobody else could get a word in to sell it.
Can you imagine the feedback if Michael Cole ignored a main event's final moments to talk about midcard battles on Raw? People would be angry, and rightly so. This writer isn't saying WWE has never done that, but AEW deserves the same criticism when they do.
Fair's fair.
4. Starting To Become A Real Struggle
There were numerous problems with this segment.
Firstly, the Ricky Starks vs. Daniel Garcia match was a slight disappointment. Dunno, man, maybe it was unrealistic but...it seemed everybody in attendance was expecting a bit more from these guys. The extended ad break certainly didn't help it from a TV perspective; that killed their momentum.
Second, the ongoing Action Andretti vs. Sammy Guevara subplot isn't that interesting and is only diluting Starks' own push. Thirdly, Ricky has already beaten Chris Jericho, and AEW has done a rather poor job of explaining why this feud is still going on, or why it's such a big deal if he beats the legend again.
That win came in early-January, but JAS started f*cking with Ricky again afterwards. So? Why does he care about wrestling Jericho one-on-one a second time? Just fight back outside the confines of a standard wrasslin' match, Starks. Surely that'd make sense.
3. “Serious” Title Match
Fun is fun, but there was a real disconnect between JR hyping up the Trios Title match as serious and the way it started. That basketball tip off was silly, obviously, and it seems no-one backstage thought it wise to brief the announcers on it. As a result, they all looked even sillier for preambling as though this would be a super-serious affair.
It wasn't.
AR Fox and Top Flight also came out looking like morons by repeatedly falling for basketball tricks from The Elite. The worst example of this came when Fox followed some passes like a dog watching a ball, then tried to catch it and got hit. Wasn't he watching the opening spot with Dante Martin?!
Chris Jericho summed it up with one line: "I love how this match is all about the basketball". Yep, and that was the biggest problem with it. Such hijinks have their place, but only when they're minimal and don't outright ruin a match.
2. HOB = The Elite's Next Sacrificial Lambs
You might be surprised to see this hit the 'Downs'.
House Of Black had something going on with Eddie Kingston and Ortiz recently, but it seems AEW has dropped that story. It wasn't really given any proper closure, and now Malakai Black's crew has set its sights on The Elite and their World Trios Tag-Team Titles. Cool?
Decisions like this make All Elite's product feel so erratic at the minute. Also, HOB challenging Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks was already teased on Wednesday's episode of Dynamite, so it wasn't the shock it was presented as on Rampage.
The Elite threesome appears content to completely devour every set of opponents they work with right now. There's nothing in this HOB challenge to suggest they won't do the same to Malakai, Brody King and Buddy Matthews soon, and that'll leave Black's gang rudderless.
1. 53-0, And Yet…
...Jade Cargill's TBS Title run is on life support in terms of overall fan interest.
So, she's beaten another sudden challenger who did nothing to earn a title shot in the first place. Wow. Come on, Tony Khan - give people a reason to care about the clearly-charismatic Jade, and move her career along before it hits the skids for good. These endless squashes don't cut it.
53 straight wins is an impressive number, but analysing the range of opponents (and the quality of matches she's been having) don't do much for Cargill's aura as an unstoppable force. Her character is sucking wind when it shouldn't be, and there's only one man to blame for that: TK.
Some context as to why Leila Grey is the only remaining member of 'The Baddies' would also be welcome, 'cause that hasn't been touched on at all. Right now, she's a poor woman's version of Rebel to Britt Baker and Jamie Hayter, and that won't change until there's some actual character development here.
Ups...
3. This Was Good
Too many simmering AEW champions and feuds are currently framed by unwanted silliness (The Elite and their endless string on Trios conquests) or a lack of logic (Ricky Starks still chasing Chris Jericho when he's already won). So, it was lovely to see something stripped-down and serious take centre stage on Rampage.
Wheeler Yuta crashing Orange Cassidy's sit-down with Mark Henry, then challenging for the champ's All-Atlantic Title, was strong sh*t. There was a nice intensity to both men, and there's some backstory there due to their prior onscreen friendship that All Elite can tap into.
Orange has been a standout performer for this company lately, and now he has another no-doubt-cracking match to look forward to. Bring it. Yuta vs. Cassidy, if it's handed enough time on Wednesday's edition of Dynamite, could steal the entire show.
Fingers crossed on that, but this was a good start.
2. Top Pacing/Storytelling
Speaking of top mini-feuds; it's Dustin Rhodes vs. Swerve Strickland.
They've been a highlight on AEW programming lately, and it was sweet to see them handed the main event slot on this week's Rampage. Swerve dominated much of the match. He even made Dustin bleed during an extended heel heat section that really clicked.
Then, the old-stager used fan support to launch a popular comeback before Parker Boudreaux saved his Mogul Affiliates leader by pulling Dustin out and breaking up his pin attempt. That forced a disqualification finish, which isn't all too common in All Elite circles.
Your writer really enjoyed this match, especially because both Rhodes and Strickland refused to rush through anything. The bout had top pacing, and it didn't try to do too much. Some other workers backstage should pay attention to Dustin's selling and Swerve's facials here.
This headliner told a story.
1. Keith Lee’s Comeback
It's a neat banner moment for Rampage as a show to host Keith Lee's crowd-pleasing return. That's the sort of thing Tony Khan would typically keep back for Dynamite, but it made sense here given Swerve and Boudreaux's attempt to use the same cinder block trick that injured 'Keef' on Dustin Rhodes.
That was too much for the 'Limitless' returnee.
Lee sported a fresh look (embrace that grey, big man), and had enough menacing facial expressions of his own to sell hatred for Mogul Affiliates and their leader Swerve. Keith is out for revenge on Strickland for putting him on the injured list, and he'll probably net a singles bout vs. his old tag partner come Revolution.
Rampage could use a few more major story beats like this one throughout 2023. They're a real boost to the show's format, and should hopefully sell more fans on tuning into AEW's B-show. That should be Khan's long-term plan for Friday nights.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out WWE Elimination Chamber 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True and WWE 2K23: 21 Wrestlers Making Their Series Debut!