4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (13 Dec - Results & Review)

A so-so SmackDown puts last minute garnish on WWE Saturday Night's Main Event.

Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Back to back Saturday Night's Main Event specials, the still to be thrashed out "Transfer Window" and a Netflix debut will keep WWE busy until a February Royal Rumble kicks off WrestleMania 41 hype properly. That could mean you'll see more weekly TV shows like this one throughout the rest of December and the entire month of January, especially on the blue side.

Raw's imminent debut on Netflix means big things will be popping on Mondays. Fridays? Yeah, Fridays are anyone's guess at this point. This wasn't the sweetest serving of SmackDown action Triple H has treated his audience to, put it that way. It wasn't bad by any means, but two relatively tame tournament matches, an unnecessary DQ result and an even less essential squash definitely knackered proceedings.

On the plus side, Kevin Owens and Cody Rhodes. They continued warring over broken friendships, Randy Orton injuries and the WWE Title heading into this weekend's Saturday Night's Main Event. It says everything about the strength of this storyline that KO vs. Rhodes could've worked out well on a major PLE like the Rumble. SNME is next up though, so Trips placed their rematch from Bash In Berlin on that.

There was movement on The Bloodline front too. Roman Reigns fired out a challenge that'll delight execs on certain streaming platforms, and Jimmy Uso stopped by to earn a broken jaw to go with his broken toe. Drew McIntyre made sure of that. Again, there's a bit to sort out when it comes to this transfer business - what are the rules, how many picks does each brand get etc etc?

Here's all the good and bad from Friday night before Saturday Night...featuring LA Knight!


Downs...

4. Pick Your Priorities

Solo Sikoa LA Knight
WWE.com

It's pretty clear that Triple H wanted to protect both Solo Sikoa and LA Knight on this week's episode. Hmm, no. This is a fragile period in Solo's career. His team lost at WarGames, and he's the one WWE should be rebuilding right now. Sikoa has 'Tribal Combat' incoming vs. Roman Reigns on a souped up Netflix debut, after all. Knight could've stared at the lights without fuss here.

Just saying.

'The Game' had to prioritise one man over the other. Michael Cole and Corey Graves acknowledged (ha) that Solo's crew need some juice again coming out of Survivor Series, so a decisive win over a star like LA would’ve gone a long way. Was it really worth sacrificing that just so we get this six-man tag with Andrade and Apollo Crews backing up Knight? That's hardly a top match.

The better play would've been Sikoa beating LA due to distractions from Jacob Fatu and Tama Tonga around ringside, then a gang-style beating from The Bloodline on Knight. That's when Andrade and Crews (who were also ambushed by Sikoa and pals previously) could've raced in to even the odds and lead to the six-man tag later on.

The puzzling "Transfer Window" stuff has some fans wondering who's going to be a focal point on the upper midcard heading through WrestleMania season. If Sikoa vs. Reigns is going to work and lead to the next chapter of Bloodline business, then it's pretty vital that Solo goes into it with some steam behind him.

Sometimes, DQ finishes that protect both wrestlers are fine. This wasn't one of those occasions, sadly.


3. A Michin Mistake?

Michin Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

Everyone deserves the chance to shine when the time is right, but...read the room, please. Friday's first semi final result could be a bit of an own goal from WWE. That sounds brutal, but you've got to call 'em how you see 'em and all that. Fans were chanting for Tiffany Stratton throughout the match with Michin, so any bid to make the latter an underdog babyface worth rooting for fell flat as a pancake.

A pancake, bah gawd.

Stratton also just comes across as a much, much, much bigger star than Mia Yim generally. Honestly, your writer thinks this Women's United States prize is Chelsea Green’s title to take, but it would’ve meant more had she beaten someone like Tiffany in the finals due to backfiring interference from Nia Jax and Candice LeRae, or something like that. It's cool that Hunter wants to circle back to the rivalry between Chelsea and Michin, but it doesn't look like the fanbase is too interested in it as a tournament final. Basically, one can see Green (the heel) getting bigger cheers than Michin at SNME.

They botched the finish a bit here too. Stratton went for her Prettiest Moonsault Ever, but Michin rolled into harm’s way rather than evading and the announcers tried to palm it off as Tiff missing. She definitely didn’t. It looked a little messy and unfortunate considering that flubbed spot let directly into the finish.

Dunno, Michin vs. Green feels less than compared to Stratton vs. Green somehow. Let's see how the final shakes out, but this was a little rough near the end.


2. Another Worryingly Flat Semi Final

Chelsea Green
WWE.com

First off, you'd need a heart of stone not to be delighted for Chelsea Green. However, was anyone else expecting a lot more from this semi final match vs. Bayley than we got? The bout meandered along and was the second semi in a row that fell flat. Fans in Hartford barely reacted to anything until the finish, and they weren't given much of a reason to jump up out of their seats or get excited.

Man, Bayley's 2024 has fizzled out after a ridiculously hot first quarter. She had all the momentum in the world after winning the Royal Rumble, splitting from Damage CTRL then beating IYO SKY to become Women's Champ at WrestleMania 40, but the 'Role Model' hasn't kicked on from there. If anything, she's gone backwards and become one of the blandest babyfaces on the entire roster.

It sucks to see.

Hopefully, Green vs. Michin is a surprise package finale at SNME, because both semis were mediocre at best. Of course, the most important thing is that someone like Chelsea benefits from holding a singles title, but the closing stretch of this tourney hasn't exactly filled anyone with hope that the Women's United States or Women's Intercontinental straps will be must see. Perhaps that's totally unfair - these are early days.

Here's the problem: Green is a great comedy character, but she'll need to work lengthier matches like this one more frequently to thrive as a champion. Say your prayers that Friday was merely an off night for both Chelsea and Bayley. Their match lacked energy.


1. This Ain’t It For Carmelo

Braun Strowman Carmelo Hayes
WWE.com

What in the name of hell are WWE playing at?!

Nick Aldis lined up a mystery opponent for Carmelo Hayes on this week’s SmackDown. That turned out to be new blue brand recruit Braun Strowman, and he made short work of Melo. As usual, most can see what WWE wanted to do here with Braun, but it’s a rough spot for Hayes. They’re giving him nothing to work with, and that's plain sad for someone who was hyped up so much after moving on from NXT.

This was a little too 2019 Vince McMahon. You know the drill: Making potential stars look like chumps then being surprised when they aren’t clicking. Triple H's thinking probably doesn't run that deep, but yeah - this was awful, and especially so because Braun defo doesn’t need squashes at this stage in his career. Pressing the reset button on him in December 2024 is certainly a choice.

Strowman would be better placed as part of a big man/little man tag-team like he was with Ricochet before injuries wrecked that tandem. Surely, if nothing else, WWE can see that Hayes looked like a lowly jobber on Friday night. If they can't and think this is the best road for him, then that's even more worrying.

Braun doesn't need to be a focal point like he was back when winning so-called "Greatest" Royal Rumbles and Universal Titles in 2019 and 2020. He could be useful here or there on Fridays, but it feels senseless to job Carmelo out like he's some extra headed for AEW Rampage's graveyard shift.


Ups...

4. Prefer This To Vacating The Belts

Nick Aldis Bianca Belair Naomi
WWE

This was a much more pleasing Nick Aldis segment.

The SmackDown GM told Bianca Belair that his investigation into who attacked Jade Cargill is still ongoing, but added she’d likely have to relinquish the Women’s Tag-Team Titles due to her partner's injuries. Naturally, that didn't well with Bianca, so Naomi stepped up and said she’d sub in for Jade in the interim. Aldis liked that idea, then said he’d run it by WWE management before getting back to them.

Honestly? This is way better than the titles being vacated. Those Women’s Tag belts need some consistency, and if this angle leads to Naomi turning heel as part of some masterplan then even better. Credit where it's due; Triple H has become really adept at lacing shows with this kind of quick storytelling. Segments that don't take much time to get right to the point but motor things along = one big fat thumbs up.

There's been a lot of chat about Cargill's immediate future in WWE due to those aforementioned injury struggles. It's surely coincidence, but Jade was also talking openly about the gruelling company schedule shortly before being written off TV too. All of this, reality and storyline, can be pulled together under one umbrella for Naomi's villain era.

That's pretty necessary, truth be told. She, like Bayley, has been up and down as a baby lately. Turning to the dark side and showing off a mean streak for the first time in years would be great for Naomi. Bonus points if it's prompted by loyalty to Bayley, who hasn't exactly seen eye to eye with Bianca.

Finally, Naomi showed zero concern for her husband Jimmy taking a kicking from Drew McIntyre whilst on crutches mere minutes before. None at all. That was either a terrible oversight or a subtly genius show of selfishness from someone who's about to do a lot of that.



3. Big Boot For Big Jim!

Drew McIntyre Jimmy Uso Claymore Kick
WWE.com

The returning Jimmy Uso almost bagged himself a 'Down' here for outright saying he's proud of Solo Sikoa. 'Big Jim' said he didn't like his baby brother's behaviour, but he is proud of him. Huh? Erm...Jimmy, you should be anything but proud, because Solo's disrespect towards family traditions is the entire Bloodline vs. Bloodline story. That didn't make a lick of sense.

Uso's promo was fairly standard but well delivered overall. He spoke of getting healthy after suffering a broken toe at WarGames, then rhymed off some goals for 2025. Going after a Royal Rumble win? Yeet. Winning a singles title? Yeet. Maybe becoming WWE Champion someday? Yeet. Yeah, Jimmy borrowed his bro Jey's catchphrase to get the fans onside, but that's alright.

Things were ticking along nicely until Drew McIntyre sprinted in out of nowhere and planted 'Big Jim' with a big boot. One Claymore Kick was all it took to knock Jimmy spark out and force Nick Aldis to get security out there as a laughing Drew was escorted from ringside. This dirtbag side of McIntyre is excellent, and it's awesome WWE decided to keep it going since his sudden comeback.

He's attacking Bloodline members around the clock, and that’s the way it should be after everything he’s been through with the group over the years. The opening segment was a nice way to keep Jimmy in the frame whilst giving Drew another excuse to be vicious. It'll also write Uso off the format sheets for the foreseeable without him having to hobble around on crutches.

It's perhaps a pity Drew didn't elect to kick his leg out of his leg though. Ahem.


2. Tribal Combat Is Coming

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Pre-taped vignette-style promos can be tough sledding. They've worked well for someone like Solo Sikoa whilst finding his feet as a would-be 'Tribal Chief', but they don't always get the job done when wrestlers are looking to announce something huge. Leave it to Roman Reigns then. The 'OTC' delivered an emotive and rousing speech on SmackDown before challenging Solo to 'Tribal Combat' on Raw's Netflix bow in early January.

Before getting to that, Reigns expertly set the table by talking about how Solo stole the ula fala, whereas it was gifted to him by family elders because they figured Roman was the right man to lead everyone. That kinda dances around his tyrannical approach from 2020 onwards, but it is what it is. Reigns calling Sikoa's bluff by pitching a strictly one on one match sounds like good fun, and it feels noble from someone who was previously anything but.

WWE is presenting 'Tribal Combat' as a means to end The Bloodline story. Not a chance that happens. Someone else will debut, or The Rock will get things rolling heading into WrestleMania season. Either works. It's also worth pointing out that Rocky still isn't locked in for 'Mania 41 as things stand. Triple H is keen to come up with a strong contingency plan if 'The Great One' is too busy with his other ventures.

Well played to Roman. Creating energy out of nothing with a dry on-location pre-tape is pretty difficult, but he didn't try to get too shouty or 1980's Ultimate Warrior about it. Instead, Reigns calmly vowed to take back what's rightfully his and shut Solo's mouth in front of a massive Netflix audience.


1. Simple But Effective SNME Garnish

Kevin Owens Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes cut an unusually rattled figure once the penny dropped that Kevin Owens wouldn't come to the ring for an incident-free interview before they collide at Saturday Night's Main Event. Some of his banter with fans came across as a little stilted, but that might've been deliberate. After all, Cody is supposed to be frustrated and thrown off his game by KO's actions. That's the whole point.

Owens laid a trap for the champ by firing zingers from his car. A clever heel like Kev knew Cody wouldn't be able to resist coming backstage to find him, and that's what he was banking on. The pair then worked an intense brawl with the usual pull apart spot, and KO blasted Rhodes with the WWE Title before standing tall. You really can't argue with this sort of stuff.

It was an old school wrestling angle leading into a hot main event showdown for SNME, and it was a vast improvement on last week's in-car bit with Michael Cole. Love to see it. To be fair, the skit would've bagged an 'Up' for Kev's Stardust t-shirt alone. That's top class trolling from one of the best at taking potshots and winding everyone up with minor details. Few pay better attention to that side of the game than KO. Well played, good sir. Or...bad sir. Whatever works.

WWE could've reached Saturday's show without airing this segment, but now Owens has a far more cerebral air to him and Cody is totally bewildered about how to approach things. SmackDown showed KO as someone who has both a physical and mental advantage over Rhodes, which is interesting.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble and WWE Saturday Night's Main Event 2024: 5 Things That NEED To Happen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.