4 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (7 Aug - Results & Review)

Kevin Owens confronts CM Punk; Tatum Paxley debuts; WWE fumbles Chelsea Green.

Randy Orton
WWE.com

WWE loaded SmackDown with a ton of star power, and there was even room for an NXT call up to make a splash on her main roster debut. Tatum Paxley might've just landed in a bloody great spot alongside Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss. Of course, things can go south pretty quickly after coming up from NXT (just ask Jordynne Grace), but at least Tatum's new stablemates guarantee her plenty of TV time.

Elsewhere, Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes vowed to show "the worst" of one another during their rekindled feud. No, they won't be botching RKOs or Cody Cutters. Instead, this is a proper chance for Rhodes (in particular) to show off why he'd be such a fantastic heel. There's a grudge match incoming, and it could be an absolute classic.

In the WWE Title scene, Kevin Owens followed up on his surprise return at SummerSlam by getting right up in the face of reigning champ CM Punk. KO refused to call Punk...Punk. He's plain old Phil to Kev. Later, Sami Zayn did some of his trademark moaning, so it's likely he'll be squeezed into proceedings going forwards. Zayn and Owens meant it when they said "fight forever", huh?

Sadly, creative didn't come through for Chelsea Green. They definitely did at SummerSlam, but then seemed to get cold feet on Friday night. The fact a brand new interim Women's Champion was used as collateral for a Women's United States Title feud is borderline ironic considering it was Chelsea who put that belt on the map.

Here's all the good and bad.


Downs...

4. Tough To Get Into Nakamura’s Words

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE

Let's not play pretend that this is going anywhere meaningful.

Shinsuke Nakamura popped up in his usual pre-tapes to say that he and his partner, whomever that is, will make life hell for The MFTs. Yep, we’re back to calling Tama and Talla Tonga that again even thought it was Solo Sikoa’s faction name. Honestly, it’s hard to care about Shinsuke these days. We’ve seen far too many of these soft resets and ominous warnings from him that lead to pretty much nothing, so…this is the next one, yeah?

That's really all there is to say about it. At this stage in his run, it'd be a minor miracle if WWE bosses paid attention to his new tag-team for longer than a cup of coffee between creative chatter about what Cody Rhodes or Roman Reigns will be doing. There's next to no chance for Nakamura to build any sort of momentum before he fizzles out, vanishes and then shows back up in these pre-tapes to mumble a load of nonsense that's frankly tedious as all hell.

We've been here before. Multiple times. Also, Tama and Talla just got Haku as their new manager but didn't feature on this week's show. They're in a 3-way with The War Raiders and odd couple Damian Priest and R-Truth next week, sure. However, this is why it's borderline impossible for undercard acts to get over - WWE's writers just seem to forget all about building blocks or character development beyond the superficial.

Shin's latest bid for TV time will end the same way of his others over the past 5+ years have.


3. Why Did They Do This Rematch?!

Trick Williams Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Trick Williams tried to avenge his United States Title loss at SummerSlam by taking the belt back from Baron Corbin, but he needs to get the heck away from this rivalry. SmackDown's effort proved to be much the same sort of match we saw on PLE, then Corbin cheated to retain. Yeah, sticking around in this scene isn’t going to help Trick one bit.

Thankfully, at least Lil Yachty wasn’t there. Silver linings, and all that.

If management does want to move Williams up the card, then this won’t do it. Back to back losses to Corbin, whether there were shenanigans or not, won’t work for him. Move Trick on quickly, please. Look, the match was actually solid, but the booking is a problem and truly puzzling. Also, why hasn’t Baron changed that furry US Title? It looks ridiculous when he’s holding it.

It certainly didn't help matters that their finish with the belt shot here also made the referee look totally daft. There was no reason for him to turn his back on the action when he did. This is the sort of thing AEW (rightly) gets heat for from fans, so it's only fair if it's called out on WWE's side as well.

Corbin vs. Carmelo Hayes next week has been made official too. That'll be in Melo's hometown, so there's a chance he leaves with the title and this Baron reign is short lived. Whatever the outcome of that, please just get Trick into some other story on the brand. He's over, but repeat losses like this will suffocate him.


2. Great For Fatal Influence, Disaster For Chelsea!

Chelsea Green Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

The WWE trope of new champions suddenly getting egg on their faces and looking like losers needs to go. This fan really isn't sure what the logic behind pinning Chelsea Green here was. Fatal Influence interrupted Green’s title celebrations, then agreed to a Jacy Jayne title shot vs. Tiffany Stratton next week if Tiffany and Chelsea received a Women’s Tag Title chance here. Everyone said yes, then Green nonsensically took the pin.

Sure, everyone watching the weekly product knows she’s not some dominant alpha female like Rhea Ripley, but come on. You've just made your interim Women’s Champ look like a total afterthought and a loser right off the bat. Chelsea is talented and popular enough to offset this, but the creative is nightmare stuff in terms of choking momentum.

It would’ve made way more sense for Jacy to help Lainey Reid or Fallon Henley pin Stratton before their title bout next week. That way, Green would've been protected somewhat and could've moved on to her next story/feud without having to stare at the lights. No excuses - Chelsea just shouldn’t have been the one beaten in this tag bout. It was so avoidable.

She's a sympathetic underdog and makes that work for her, but it's also important to give people a reason to believe that the tide is turning for the breakout babyface. After this result, there's no reason to invest. Lord only knows how WWE will tackle Ripley's return, assuming Chelsea is even still the interim Women's Champ when that happens.


1. Now Nia Jax Is Next Up?

Irresistible Forces Nia Jax Lash Legend
WWE.com

Good God.

Irresistible Forces duo Nia Jax and Lash Legend attacked Tiffany Stratton and Chelsea Green to add insult to injury, then Nia grabbed the Women’s Title and posed with it. Oh man, is there any excitement for Green vs. Nia, especially after what just happened moments before? Like, at all? This is not the Women's Title program that Triple H seemingly thinks it's going to be.

In fairness, all of this was a last-minute contingency plan due to Rhea’s injury, but WWE are already messing it up. They’ve completely squashed the heartwarming moment Green lived at SummerSlam by having her lose in a nothing tag match for a singles title shot that wasn't even for her belt, and now she's going to have to 'swim upstream' against Jax as Lash prowls ringside.

On paper, that's exactly the kind of impossible odds Chelsea should be going up against, but Nia has been offering nothing for a while now. Her matches have been sinking back into bad territory, and fans are probably sick and tired of seeing her be slotted back into the title picture without warning. At this rate, poor Green is gonna struggle to get onto Saturday Night's Main Event shows never mind anything else.

Chelsea vs. Nia isn't really PLE worthy, let's be real. Surely, if anything, giving Green someone like Jacy Jayne would've made more sense. At least then WWE could build up a fresh star ahead of Rhea's return to action. There's no timeframe for that, but it would've been logical to push Jacy as a proper threat ahead of someone like Jax. Again.


Ups...

4. Decent Main Event Peaks With NXT Call Up

Alexa Bliss Charlotte Flair Tatum Paxley
WWE.com

Charlotte Flair vs. Jade Cargill didn’t show anything to suggest it would’ve worked at SummerSlam (which was the original plan before Rhea’s injury changed everything), but it was a solid TV match and Tatum Paxley’s debut was an unexpected treat. Alexa Bliss came out with her arm in a sling, then the lights went out and Tatum hit a crossbody onto Michin and B-FAB on the outside. That left Flair to beat Jade.

The final stretch of this main event was a cracking watch even if Cargill seemed intent on botching everything before the end, and the debut should represent a fab spot for Paxley on the main roster. Personally, your writer isn't sure we need a 6-woman tag out of this, but we’ll probably get one. Regardless, it’s cool to see Tatum aligned with big stars, at least.

She'd done pretty much all there was to do down in NXT, so moving her up to Raw or SmackDown had been on the cards for a while. If nothing else, it's safe to assume that Paxley won't get lost in the shuffle quickly because of who she's buddying up to. It's hardly like Charlotte is gonna vanish from screens all of a sudden - she's a made woman in WWE circles, and it's difficult to see that changing.

Flair and Cargill probs deserve to have at least one more match to iron out some of the kinks and produce even better. The big story will be Tatum's debut though, not some of those messy Jade botches. Charlotte covered well for those, then celebrated with Alexa and their new recruit.


3. Cody & Randy ‘Bring Their Worst’

Cody Rhodes Randy Orton
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes told Randy Orton he’s “the only legend left in WWE”. Then, he followed up with this gem: “You call yourself the Legend Killer. So my question to you is this: Who kills you?”. Oh yes, Rhodes is at his best when he’s losing it like this and dispenses with the ‘happy to be here’ dignified poster boy kind of presentation. The heelish splashes he showed again here, like he did during the build towards SummerSlam with CM Punk, are very interesting.

Having Orton back also ups the star power on SmackDown significantly, which is another positive. Also, bonus: There was no Pat McAfee. His influence/presence strangled the feud heading into WrestleMania 42 earlier this year. A blow off grudge match between these guys could work well provided it actually results in some major character development for Cody in particular.

It'd be so satisfying to see him finally go full blown heel at the end of it by returning that punt from 'Mania just to be evil, for example. That's merely a fan spitballing some ideas, but it'd fit the tension between both guys nicely if he did something like that. Until then, Rhodes has to keep showing this kind of fire on the microphone rather than smiling and asking fans: "What do you wanna talk about?" like he's contractually obliged to do so (he might well be!).

Seeing "the worst" of Randy and Cody means seeing plenty of violence. Good. WWE could use a few feisty feuds that get full on dastardly rather than the kind of sniping potshots Rhodes and Punk took at one another pre-SummerSlam.


2. The Intense First Chapter They Needed

Kevin Owens CM Punk
WWE.com

CM Punk and Kevin Owens didn’t quite unload everything they have to say during this first face to face promo for their feud, but that’s OK. There’s plenty more to come from both. What we got here was an intense opening chapter, and a little taster of the bitter personal history between them. Then, Nick Aldis and various security/refs made sure it didn’t descend into a brawl.

You know that’s coming at some point, and it’ll be glorious.

Also, Punk told Cody Rhodes to “just say when” on a title rematch, so it looks like there's "unfinished business" between those former friends turned enemies after SummerSlam. That's cool, because Randy Orton's RKO on Cody effectively cost him the chance to become WWE Champion again. Punk didn't see that happen, so he'd be happy to give Cody another crack at it.

In a smart move, KO weaved that into his promo by suggesting that Punk is already looking past him like he's incapable of winning gold. Realistically, that's not what CM is doing, but Punk couldn't resist flashing a smarmy grin at Kev and playing along with the idea that he's arrogant. In turn, he kinda proved Owens point. It all felt realistic and like these were actual human beings talking, warts and all.

Owens is a little nervous after returning, 'cause he wasn't sure he'd be able to. Plus, Punk knows there's a target on his back and presumably can't be bothered with Kevin trying to dig up old beef between them. It's a good story to work with.


1. Sami Zayn Tells KO Straight

Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Backstage, Sami Zayn wanted an apology from Nick Aldis for cramming Gunther and the returning Kevin Owens into his match with Finn Bálor at SummerSlam. Speaking of Finn, where was he? Shouldn't he have been every bit as miffed as Sami? Apparently not. Anyway, Kev showed up, and he had a bit of back and forth bickering with Zayn.

Then, Sami closed by saying KO shouldn’t expect him to give up on what he wants because it’s also what Owens wants. The character work here is believable and just fantastic, but everyone’s used to that from Zayn by now. KO: “Ive been back 6 days. 6 days!”. He said that right before walking off camera once Sami had done the same and left in a huff.

It feels insane to say this, because of course they're going to, but another match between these longtime friends/enemies isn't out of the question. If handled carefully, it could actually be something worth doing at WrestleMania 43 next year. If WWE's writing team can't wait that long, they could always force Aldis to make things right with Sami and book Zayn vs. Owens for the number one contenders spot. Options, options, options.

Both Sami vs. Aldis and KO were teased here, and that's something else worth discussing. Nick stepped up to Gunther at SummerSlam, and he could be coaxed back into the ring for another stab at it if Sami isn't careful. Keep poking the bear, Zayn. Another Nick match on PLE would be great fun.

Really strong segment.

What did you think of this week's episode of WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 12 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: The Fall Of Renegade and 13 New Directions For WWE After SummerSlam 2026!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.