4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (13 June - Results & Review)

SmackDown loads up on star power and WWE suffers Fatal-4-Way burnout.

John Cena R-Truth Ron Killings
WWE.com

Bug-eyed and lawless Ron Killings is working a treat for WWE. The company might still be referring to him as R-Truth on commentary, on match graphics etc, but there's an edge to the sudden comeback king that must be prolonged. Fingers crossed Triple H has the sense to make next week's bout with John Cena more competitive than their match at Saturday Night's Main Event was last month.

Cena was the undoubted MVP of this week's show. 'Big Match John' became 'Big Promo John' by delivering not one but two standout speeches that sold him as a champion pinned down by multiple challengers who are hungry to shut his mouth. That includes Cody Rhodes, Randy Orton (again), LA Knight and CM Punk.

SmackDown went Fatal-4-Way crazy as first round matches in both the King and Queen Of The Ring tournaments took centre stage before the Night Of Champions PLE. That dominated 90% of the in-ring time on Friday, but there was some serious over-saturation with the match type by the end of the night. You'd have to really like the formulaic nature of these things to enjoy absolutely everything across every single one of them, but at least the finishes were mostly creative and fed into ongoing storylines elsewhere.

Unfortunately, key characters like The Wyatt Sicks, Jacob Fatu and Naomi all suffered from spotty writing that didn't do any of them any favours. It's cool if creative want to spin things out (they've got a lot of TV time to fill), but some of the booking felt counterproductive or lacklustre.

Here's all the good and bad from SmackDown.


Downs...

5. Wasn’t Digging This Wyatts Win

The Wyatt Sicks Motor City Machine Guns
WWE.com

First, the negatives from Friday night.

Wyatt Sicks members Dexter Lumis and Joe Gacy beat the Motor City Machine Guns in a frankly bang average tag scrap. The story being told for Uncle Howdy’s gang doesn’t make much sense either. So, they think there was a lack of respect and brotherhood in the SmackDown tag division before, and now they’re combatting that by kicking the crap out of everyone? That’s messy. Even despicable heels can’t talk about togetherness whilst causing division. Where's the logic?!

Maybe that’s deliberate to show how out there The Wyatts are and this fan just isn't getting it, but having them job out everyone who’s been competitive in the division en route to The Street Profits could be risky. Something just didn’t click for this guy when watching the show. Perhaps others feel different and explain what's going right over yours truly's head!

Lumis seemed to forget the finish too, which didn’t help. There's a chance they were going for the idea that Howdy calls plays mid-match and changed things on the fly, but it didn't work. On camera, it merely looked like Dex went for a pinfall when he wasn't supposed to before landing a top rope leg drop.

There's nothing altogether threatening about The Wyatt Sicks when the lights come on and they're working regular matches like this one. They lose a lot of menace in a hurry, put it that way. Cue more monotonous wins over DIY and Fraxiom before they tangle with Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins, possibly at Night Of Champions or on the next SNME.


4. Not Really Explosive Follow Up

Jacob Fatu
WWE.com

Presumably, the storyboard for Jacob Fatu's duelling promo with Solo Sikia was scribbled on a napkin in catering once writers realised they'd accidentally left it off the pre-production scripts. That's the only explanation fitting for why this was so lifeless and outright failed to follow up on Fatu turning away from Sikoa's leadership at Money In The Bank.

Jacob prevented Solo from winning the ladder match and became his own man at MITB. Here, Fatu was cutting a promo about all of that when Sikoa interrupted on the big screen to say he wants to hear Jacob say, “I love you, Solo” next week. Sure, it's easy to get what WWE were going for here, but it was tepid follow up to Fatu becoming a concrete babyface. There's a reason why the live crowd were so quiet after Sikoa’s speech, then Jacob left to silence.

Honestly? Too low key for somebody this explosive. There’s also no real aura to Solo and JC Mateo now Fatu is out of the group, so it’s hard to take Sikoa’s threats seriously. He was flitting in and out of comedy spots at MITB, and now here he is making ominous threats like a Mafia kingpin who's ready to put his bloodline down for good.

It does look likely that Hikuleo will replace Jacob by Solo's side, but reports flooded in that he debuted on the Main Event taping before SmackDown went live. That's hardly the most high profile way to introduce him. Christ knows how WWE managed to fumble all of this so badly on Friday. Were the writing team drunk?

Fatu deserved better.


3. Naomi Should Be The Big Threat, Not Nia!

Naomi Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

So, mind you, did Naomi.

Nia Jax ambushed Tiffany Stratton when Naomi left the ring following a verbal spat between old rivals. Then, Jax hit an Annihilator on the champ, and Naomi wanted to come in and cash in her MITB briefcase. Nia warned her off and told her to stay away, and even said: “She’s mine”. No. No, no, no, no, no!

Does anybody want to see Nia remain in the title picture considering Naomi is the hotter heel right now? Or, at least, she should be presented as such. That certainly wasn’t the case here. If anything, Naomi came across as less than to Jax, which isn’t great so soon after hauling down the case and practically guaranteeing a title reign last weekend.

How WWE managed to make Nia more of a threat than MITB-holding Naomi the week after that win is anyone’s guess. They must've been on autopilot for this story the same way they were for Fatu and Solo on the same episode. Nia going after Tiffany is old hat. Please move on, WWE writers! You have the power to do just that, so make it happen.

Honestly, Stratton still struggles to convince as a likeable babyface on the mic too. She's full of catchphrases and soundbites, and always seems to sound like she's been rehearsing even the most basic of lines all day. There's no fluidity to her promos, and they rarely feel like real conversations. That's something she'll need to work on if she wants to last as a babyface. In truth, she's a more natural heel all day long despite the cheers.


2. 2nd Women’s 4-Way Is A Struggle

Alexa Bliss Charlotte Flair Candice LeRae Alba Fyre
WWE.com

Charlotte Flair vs. Alba Fyre vs. Candice LeRae vs. Alexa Bliss was arguably the weakest Fatal-4-Way in the King or Queen Of The Ring tournaments thus far. Fans clearly weren’t into the rinse and repeat double beatdown heat stuff from Fyre and LeRae, because it was the same thing they’d watched Nia Jax and Piper Niven do earlier in the night.

For the record, this was supposed to be Chelsea Green's match, but she said she had travel issues and wanted to postpone. GM Nick Aldis was having none of that, so he forced Alba in as a last-minute sub. That's fine, and it's hardly like Chelsea missed anything special by skipping this week's show. Her rebuild post-Women's United States Title reign continues.

Personally, this writer likes the story beat of Flair being on a downward trend too, ‘cause it’s something different for her career. The finish was well executed (Flair had Fyre in a submission whilst Bliss pinned Candice), but the match passed everyone by for the most part. Suppose that’s what happens when you’re booking so many 4-Ways in a short, concentrated period of TV, especially when we just had a multi-wrestler focused PLE like Money In The Bank as well.

WWE could use a strict diet of straight up singles matches and tags for a while. There have been far too many multi-wrestler bouts over the past month or so on TV. Overall, this one suffered because it had nothing new to say. Of course, it wasn't alone in that respect - some of the company's biggest stars struggled too...


1. One Fatal-4-Way Too Many

Cody Rhodes Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Man, everybody was experiencing major Fatal-4-Way burnout by the time the main event came along. There was nothing especially wrong with Cody Rhodes vs. Andrade vs. Damian Priest vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, but the match type just had nothing left to say come headliner time. The opening half was a case of four guys going through the motions (although the first minute or so was admittedly blistering) in between ad breaks.

Cody was an obvious winner, and both Andrade and Shin are WWE bridesmaids. It was a total given that Rhodes was going to win considering Priest had set out intentions for the United States Title on TV beforehand and Cody was the one in John Cena’s face earlier that same night. WWE will get back to WrestleMania 41's Cena vs. Rhodes at SummerSlam and everyone knows it.

Unless...Trips fancies a curveball. Hmm, nah, it looks like Cena vs. Cody II is on the lineup in MetLife Stadium.

SmackDown's main event was a middle of the road match that skews towards ‘Down’ territory for coming at the end of a 4-Way glut. It's gonna be intriguing to see how WWE plays things with Priest and Jacob Fatu, who are both popular babyfaces, but they'll need to get something moving before Damian stagnates.

Rhodes was doing a little bit of treading water himself before getting the win for his team at Money In The Bank. Now, by virtue of this win, he rockets into the semi finals of KOTR and is a firm favourite to emerge as the tournament victor. He and his fans will forget this match in a hurry.


Ups...

4. First Women’s Fatal-4-Way Proves A Fun Watch

Nia Jax Michin Piper Niven
WWE.com

Being honest, the double team heat stuff with Nia Jax and Piper Niven slowed things to a crawl, but there was enough going on generally to keep things interesting in the first women's Fatal-4-Way. Jade Cargill was the right choice as winner, and the spot with her being thrown over the announce desk then landing on Wade Barrett worked well.

Special mention goes to Barrett for selling that, then making sure to put over that Jade had a more painful landing than him. His sudden shift from selling himself to talking about her made things even more impressive when Cargill collected herself and sprinted back into the ring for the finish. She really does come across as a star in the making no matter what she's doing, so the second half of her 2025 could be worth keeping an eye on.

No, this isn't a match that’ll live long in the memory or win any year end awards, but it deserves an ‘Up’ for Jade’s power performance throughout and the finish. Credit to Niven for posting well and taking Jaded like a champ. She, like Alba Fyre, knows that her role in the women's division these days is to take a kicking and keep coming back for more, and she wears it well; hopefully that gets rewarded with a Women's Tag-Team Title tilt someday.

The first female 4-Way was way better than the second one. So, if you're only going to watch one of them, make it Jax vs. Piper vs. Michin vs. Cargill. They had the benefit of going on earlier than Flair, Bliss, Fyre and LeRae, and that helped.


3. One Hell Of An RKO Finish

Randy Orton Tongue Out
WWE.com

Bronson Reed and Bron Breakker attacked LA Knight to cost him the first Fatal-4-Way. When a grinning Carmelo Hayes went to take advantage with a splash from the top rope, Randy Orton caught him in mid-air with a meaty RKO that looked picture perfect. Capitalising, the veteran then pinned Knight himself to advance to the semi finals of KOTR.

That was a superb finish, one that looked flashy and put across how opportunistic everybody would have to be in these opening round matches. It makes sense that Reed and Breakker showed up if LA is feuding with Seth Rollins going forwards too. That's a killer spot for Knight to be in over the summer months whilst Seth ponders cashing in Money In The Bank.

SmackDown's 4-Way had a clever ending following a so-so opening three quarters of the match. Those commercial breaks were abundant though, weren’t they?! Each one disrupted the flow on TV, but the bout surely had a different pace for those inside the arena live. Guys like Orton and Knight are smart enough to fill downtime during commercials, put it that way.

Orton vs. Sami Zayn in the first semi final will be a great watch, and that's up next before Night Of Champions.

This conclusion gives Knight something to moan about on the mic when going after Seth's goons, and it fit Randy's savvy veteran style nicely. Now, if only WWE could do something more important with Hayes and Aleister Black. They were just making up numbers here more than anything else.

2. That Hot Opening Segment

John Cena Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Initially, it looked like this opening segment would simply be John Cena yakking on about CM Punk without meaningful interruption, but it was more than that. Way more. WWE expertly sold the importance of winning King Of The Ring to Cody Rhodes, Randy Orton and LA Knight, then had R-Truth/Ron Killings ambush Cena from behind once he tried to leave.

The upshot of all this is that John is a marked man due to his behaviour, refusal to go out on a happy high with fans, and the title he holds. Everybody’s coming for him, and the pressure is increasing as time ticks down on his career. Best of all, it's his bloody fault! A lot of the aggro could've been avoided had Cena not sided with The Rock back at Elimination Chamber in March.

Revolving door segments can be a tough sell because they’re so formulaic and played out, but this was a prime example of one done well. Really well. It set the energy levels for the show, which is precisely what you want something like this to do, and there was a lot of star power inside that ring at the same time. That fact wasn't lost on Lexington either.

Tense moments between combos like Cena and Cody, Orton and Rhodes, and LA Knight with everyone added to the story of 'Cena vs. The World'. At the same time, everyone else has their own ambitions. If WWE wanted to put that across and make KOTR seem important all at once, then they positively nailed it in one solitary segment.

Great job.

1. Another Winner For Cena (With Bonus CM Punk)

John Cena R-Truth Ron Killings
WWE.com

Kentucky surely thought Cena was done for the night once Truth ambushed him in the aisle and Nick Aldis set up a match between the pair for next week's show. Not quite. John approached Jimmy Uso behind the scenes, then told 'Big Jim' to tell his pal that he'd be calling him out to the ring soon. The Lexington masses lost their minds once Cena emerged for a second round live in living colour.

Ironically, it was Living Colour that interrupted him. 'Cult Of Personality' blared over the PA as CM Punk showed up to get in John's face instead. This wasn't exactly Punk's most cutting promo despite Joe Tessitore calling it a classic, but there's an undeniable magic in the air whenever Punk and Cena go nose to nose; they could be discussing how to make the perfect cup of tea and make it pulsating to watch.

That was true on Monday's Raw, and it was true on SmackDown.

There was room for one more Ron run-in too. R-Truth hit Cena from behind then locked him in an STF. When leaving, John limped away selling his leg like a total pro. Here's hoping that injured wheel plays a part in the match these dudes will be having next week. It'd be ideal if it came up at NOC when Cena is against Punk too. Why not?

Again, there was nothing groundbreaking in Punk's promo, but the intensity was there and fans ate it up. Remember that point about Cena making himself a marked man to rival Steve Austin at the 1998 Royal Rumble? Yeah, that sense heightened during his second appearance of the night.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling content, check out 15 WWE Gimmick Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired and 15 Times WWE Stars Made Cameos BEFORE They Were Famous!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.