4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (20 Sept - Results & Review)

Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns came face to face in a unique way on WWE SmackDown.

Cody Rhodes Kevin Owens
WWE.com

It was always going to be hard for WWE to top last week's blistering season premiere.

Triple H weaved in steel cage matches, a popular Roman Reigns return, Randy Orton helping out Kevin Owens and a brilliant in-ring sign off for Andrade vs. Carmelo Hayes. Or, so people thought! 'The Game' liked that midcard feud so much he decided to come right back to it on Friday night's show. That was just one of several bum notes.

There's still a lot to like with the blue brand overall though. Don't let the number of 'Downs' fool you - SmackDown is still heading in the right direction, and major players like Reigns, Rhodes, KO and LA Knight are why. There's something interesting happening over in the women's division too. There's a tasty slice of friction between babyface buddies, for example.

It'd be a lie to suggest this episode matched last week's, but the broadest story beats helped keep heads above water. Going the cinematic route with unlikely tag-team partners worked a treat, and so did ending the night without Owens getting to vent his frustrations about it.

Here's all the good and bad.


Downs...

5. Didn’t We Just Wrap This Up?

Andrade Carmelo Hayes
WWE

This is rather sudden.

The plus side to WWE booking Andrade vs. Carmelo Hayes in yet another match is that everyone knows they'll produce another scorcher next week. The downside? Their banging 'Best Of 5' series is already rendered fairly pointless - it looks like we'll be getting a triple threat with these two and LA Knight at Bad Blood.

So, what was the point in booking that competitive series?! Sure, it got 'El Idolo' a United States Title shot on this week's TV, but now he just waltzes into another one because he and Hayes can't see eye to eye? That doesn't make much sense, and neither does Melo being back in the title conversation after losing.

It's a dangerous game to present a 'Best Of 5' as meaningful then trample all over it the very next week. Yes, WWE's product moves quickly, but some things need room to breathe. Trips ignored that here, presumably because he wants. more of Andrade vs. Hayes ASAP.


4. Wasn’t Feeling That Main Event

Kevin Owens Tama Tonga Stunner
WWE.com

The retooled Bloodline unit has been involved in some fun, house show style mains over the piece, but this one vs. Kevin Owens and The Street Profits was a miss. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins replacing DIY was fine, albeit unnecessary, but something was a little off from the start. It didn't really feel like this bout achieved anything.

Answers on a postcard.

The disqualification ending with Tonga Loa sending KO into the ring steps came out looking flat as well. Maybe it's for the best that The Profits didn't stare at the lights, and there's certainly no need to beat Owens right now, but the finish still felt a tad cheap somehow. Again, something was just...missing.

Of course, the six man was little more than a vehicle for creative to get to the parting shot they wanted with a fired up Cody Rhodes. Fair play, although that doesn't excuse how 'been there done that' the headliner came out. There are only so many of these matches fans can see before they start getting old.


3. Erm…Randy Orton?

Randy Orton
WWE.com

Also, where in the name of draping DDTs was Randy Orton?

He returned last week to help Owens take out Austin Theory and Grayson Waller, but 'The Viper' was conspicuous by his absence on Friday night. WWE barely even mentioned him (if they did at all), and that's a head scratcher. Surely Randy would've been on hand to help his good friend out from now on, no?

It'd be great to see some movement on R-KO as a full-time duo rather than the bitty on/off union they are. There's a longer term story to tell here involving Cody and Orton's Legacy history with him; that might be why the writers are taking their time, but there was nothing stopping them from turning the six man into an eight man by cramming in Randy and Solo Sikoa.

In fact, that would've made way more sense rather than Orton suddenly vanishing into thin air again. The reigning tag champs on SmackDown, Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa, don't have anything going on heading into Bad Blood either. Surely developing something with R-KO there would've made sense.


2. Giovanni Vinci Looks Daft Again

Giovanni Vinci Shocked
WWE.com

Honestly, this fan has zero clue what Triple H is playing at with Giovanni Vinci. He debuted after a few hype vignettes and lost to Apollo Crews in seconds a while back. Here, Vinci slipped on the proverbial banana peel once more. This was his second loss to Crews, and no-one is quite sure what the plan is supposed to be with him.

This is all very latter-day Vince McMahon.

Apollo was meant to be building a babyface tag-team with Baron Corbin, and yet here he is stuffed awkwardly into a 'B' story vs. Giovanni. It's a puzzling way to reintroduce Vinci and try to repackage him as a singles star away from Imperium. Let's be honest here: This will not work. Gio already feels dead in the water on SmackDown.

The losing streak trope has been an overused WWE go to when heels need humbled. That's one thing. This isn't that! Vinci hasn't even kicked off his singles career on Fridays and he's already looking like a total chump who couldn't win even if they brought back Gillberg.


1. SmackDown Loses Some Momentum

Kevin Owens Tama Tonga Loa Bloodline
WWE.com

Last week's season premiere was front-loaded and dressed to impress, but this week's show was a step back despite some of the better moments. The whole evening just didn't feel as grand or vibrant. Perhaps that was inevitable, and it's true not every show throughout the year can be world class. Still, WWE should be bending over backwards to make a good impression on USA.

Too much was tepid and filler this week.

The show chugged more than any two-hour window should. Being honest, that's not criticism one could sling at Hunter's product too often. Even his three-hour Raws zip along nicely without degenerating into a humdrum slog like the flagship did for too long pre-Vince disappearance.

SmackDown kinda did get too start/stop. Even The Bloodline's involvement meandered, and they've been one of the most dangerously exciting aspects of programming for a while now. Here's hoping this is just a minor blip and things will pick up again soon.


Ups...

4. The Double Pin Finish

Nia Jax Bayley Naomi
WWE.com

Right, that's enough moping around like Raven on an episode of WCW Nitro in 1998.

The heavily-promoted tag bout pitting Bayley and Naomi vs. Nia Jax and Tiffany Stratton was one of the best things this week's SmackDown had going for it. WWE laid the stakes on thick by alleging that either babyface would be gone from blue brand action "permanently" should they lose. The woman who pinned Jax or Stratton would bag a title shot too.

Naturally, creative went with the path of least resistance and bought themselves some time by having Bayley and Naomi sink in a double pin on Jax. Now, both have a valid claim to getting that title crack at Bad Blood. Does anyone else smell a three way incoming? If not, then there's tension to work with between pals.

Turning Naomi heel and having her appear desperate at this stage in her career wouldn't be the worst idea in the world. All round, WWE did a neat job with keeping the story rolling through to the coming PLE. Tiff's Money In The Bank cash-in still lingers in the background too.


3. A PLE Quality Opener

Andrade LA Knight
WWE.com

Nothing was going to touch obvious match of the night LA Knight vs. Andrade. Together, both guys worked a high-quality United States Title battle that wouldn't have looked out of place on PLE. It was another reminder of what Knight is capable of as champion, and why it was the right move to have him supplant Logan Paul.

One of the best things about Knight is that he doesn't swallow challengers whole. In fact, he gives them a lot, and that'll come in handy if and when WWE fancies using his star power to build some fresh names who'll carry the brand for years (*cough* Carmelo Hayes *cough*). LA is real giving as a champ, put it that way.

Andrade brought it, but keeping the belt exactly where it is makes sense. You'd do well to see a better match than this on wrestling telly across the week. That's high praise, especially when standards are high and it's the norm to see crackers on Raw, NXT and Dynamite.

Top work.


2. KO Never Gets To Vent

Cody Rhodes Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens never actually got to properly respond to the cinematic sequence that saw Cody Rhodes embrace the idea of going after The Bloodline 2.0 with...The Bloodline 1.0's old boss, Roman Reigns. Rhodes agreed to trust Roman as an ally in the short-term, which could've had KO pulling his hair out.

SmackDown's closing sprint saw Kev tease bashing Cody with a steel chair again. He put the weapon down, then the pair shared a frostier-than-usual hug instead. You've got to love the slow burn vibes of this Owens turn - he's a real and conflicted human being, and that elevates Kevin's character above many others on the roster.

It also makes him ideal for situations/stories like this.

This week's show went off the air with Michael Cole questioning whether or not Owens would approve of Cody trusting Reigns. Probably not, but keeping that on tap for coming weeks is smart. Now, KO's frustration gets to simmer, then boil over when the time is right.


1. Cody & Roman’s Cinematic Showdown

Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes Georgia
WWE.com

So, about that "cinematic sequence".

WWE plumped for something a little different than a standard in-ring confrontation between Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns. The old rivals met at Georgia Tech's stadium to thrash out their differences. Roman explained that he's lost "everything" because of Cody and Solo Sikoa, then Rhodes wanted assurances that he can rely on Reigns come Bad Blood.

It was a fantastically tense and fun back and forth. The setting was unique but had personal meaning to both men, and their exchange left a rematch for the WWE Title open-ended too. Coming away from the skit, most fans would agree that Rhodes is putting himself in the firing line by trusting someone who's responsible for The Bloodline in the first place.

That'll play into what KO thinks about the suspect deal. He's been the most consistent towards Roman and his family since it started, after all. Bonus points go to WWE for trying out something fresh rather than having Rhodes and Reigns meet in-arena like they've done a million times before.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 Next Big Things In Wrestling That Totally Flopped and 10 DUMB WWE Booking Decisions (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.