4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 39 Night 2 (Review)

Linear, logical storytelling gets derailed, IC title match rules, EST delivers again.

WWE

WWE headed into WrestleMania 39 Night 2 with a huge leg up after an immensely successful first night. All they had to do was deliver some really good action from its talented wrestlers, stick the landing and this would go down as an all-time great Mania.

And then they got to the main event and self-immolated.

We should be talking about the flawless Intercontinental Championship triple threat, or Bianca Belair’s streak of WrestleMania triumphs, or Edge and Finn Balor delivering inside Hell in a Cell… but the narrative all focuses on the main event, where Roman Reigns inexplicably beat Cody Rhodes after the same, tired interference we’ve seen time and time again.

This isn’t just air coming out of a balloon. It also might not be the Hindenburg crashing (let’s not get too melodramatic here), but this was a colossal failure that will leave a bad taste in millions of fans’ mouths for some time. It would be Steve Austin losing at WrestleMania 14, or Daniel Bryan losing the opening match at Mania 30.

Sure, from a technical standpoint, Mania 39 delivered great action once again and overall was a rousing success. But the last thing fans saw is what is going to stick with them for a while, making this a huge miss of an event.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

5. That’s It For Lashley?

Bobby Lashley Andre The Giant WWE
WWE.com

It’s not Bobby Lashley’s fault that his planned match against Bray Wyatt fell apart because Bray wasn’t able to compete.

Winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal on SmackDown was decent compensation, though nowhere near as good as a Mania bout. But when word got around that the Andre trophy was being brought to SoFi Stadium, you got the feeling we were going to be treated to something with the All Mighty. After all, WWE isn’t shy about doing impromptu matches (as we’d see later), so surely they’d do something for Lashley, even if it was a 30-second squash of Elias.

But no, all we got was Lashley carrying the trophy out onto the stage and waving to the fans for a minute before heading to the back. He went from a match with one of the more celebrated re-signings in recent WWE history to a cameo.

But Snoop Dogg won a match.


4. A Messy And Uninspired Showcase

Ronda rousey Shotzi
WWE.com

After Saturday night’s men’s four-way tag team showcase match, it felt like we were going to get more of the same with the women on Sunday.

Instead, the match was a disjointed and sometimes sloppy mess. Even a spotfest of a match has a flow to it, and this one felt all over the place, with eventual winners Ronda Rousey & Shayna Baszler disappearing moments into the match and not resurfacing until the finish. It made for a confusing and disjointed match that never really clicked with fans.

It wasn’t a bad match, but it certainly wasn’t on the level of the other showcase, and it was the worst announced match on the card Sunday night. So for that alone, it’s getting a “down” here.


3. Shane’s Back… And Gone

Shane McMahon
WWE

When WWE really tries to put on a good, engaging sports entertainment program, they often succeed. But when their failed soap opera writers try to do comedy or straight entertainment, that’s when things can go off the rails horribly.

Witness Miz and Snoop Dogg announcing the totally real attendance for Sunday’s event. Miz – who was totally fine with Snoop during the intro – suddenly had a bone to pick with the Doggfather about putting him in a match with Pat McAfee Saturday night. (Miz, a two-time WWE Champion, was upset about wrestling an announcer and podcaster.)

Snoop got back in Miz’s face and introduced another surprise opponent: Shane McMahon. Dear God no. And then seconds into the “match,” Shane blew out his knee on a leapfrog and things died. That’s when Snoop got back in the ring and laid Miz out and dropped a People’s Elbow, pinning a two-time world champion off two punches and a crappy elbow from a 51-year-old rapper.

There’s stretching things for entertainment’s sake, and then there’s just utter crap that has no place on TV… and this was clearly the latter.


2. Cody Can’t Finish The Story

Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE

So after a year-long quest to finish his father’s dream of winning the WWE Championship, a quest that involved a gruesome injury and intensive rehab, winning the Royal Rumble and cutting spellbinding promos… Cody Rhodes became just the latest interchangeable part in Roman Reigns’ formulaic, never-ending title run.

Rhodes banked everything on this return to WWE, and he’d been booked exceptionally well, especially after returning at the Rumble. His promo work made you believe in him, and after Roman had managed to sneak out of Montreal with his title intact, it seemed like the pieces had all fallen into place.

And then Rhodes’ story fell apart.

The shenanigans at the end are the same, tired routine we’ve seen countless times, dating back to the ThunderDome era: ref bump, Bloodline interference, Roman triumphs again.

But the difference here was that WWE was poised to create a John Cena-level superhero in Cody. Having him “finish the story” would have set him up to replace the part-time champ and put WWE on his shoulders 365 days a year. It could have elevated both him and the company.

Now, Cody is just a guy, another victim. Even if he were to walk out on Raw Monday night and challenge Reigns and beat him in 30 seconds, the magic is gone. The moment has passed. WWE pissed it all away.


1. Blowing All Your Goodwill In 3 Minutes

Cody Rhodes is sad
WWE

For the past two months, WWE did something it has struggled to do for years: They successfully told a difficult story and steered crowd reactions exactly how they wanted them to go.

WWE deserved a ton of credit for deftly navigating the competing storylines between Sami Zayn and Cody Rhodes vying for Roman Reigns’ titles ever since the Royal Rumble, weaving the two together rather than keeping them miles apart. Somehow, they lured even the most cynical fans into feeling something for the product again and believing that things were different this time.

Then they went and pulled the same sh*t Roman finish again, spectacularly botching the easiest main event finish there’s been since Hogan/Andre at WM 3 or Austin/Michaels and Mania 14. They took what was on pace to be possibly the best WrestleMania ever and deflated a large segment of the fanbase in mere moments.

WWE managed to torch the goodwill that they’d built up during the past couple months in those closing moments. Lapsed fans and those who were hanging on due to the strength of the Bloodline story were invigorated by Sami Zayn & Kevin Owens’ win Saturday, but it’s likely that many will turn their backs after this ordeal.

AEW fans who followed Cody over just saw that WWE is exactly who they thought they were. Triple H said afterward that Raw is just the next chapter in the story, but we’d bet that a lot of fans don’t pick the book back up.

Mind-blowingly stupid booking.


Ups…

4. Exactly What Was Expected

Omos Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

No one was expecting a five-star technical classic between Brock Lesnar and Omos. The match clearly was going to be a super-heavyweight slugfest with big men throwing bombs.

And that’s exactly what we got Sunday night at WrestleMania 39. Brock tried for a double-leg at the bell, but Omos tossed him aside like a sack of trash. From there, Omos dominated with slams, kidney shots and bearhugs, targeting Lesnar’s back and trying to wear him down.

But Brock quickly turned the corner after a missed blind charge, unleashing Suplex City on Omos with three German suplexes. He then countered a tree slam with an F-5 for the quick win.

While this seemingly was over before it got started, it more importantly didn’t overstay its welcome. They got in, delivered what was promised, popped the crowd big, and got out.


3. Confining The Silly Drama

Finn Balor Edge
WWE.com

After the video package and theatrical entrances, it’s understandable if you were worried that Edge and Finn Balor’s Hell in a Cell match would be an over-the-top dramatic affair that would take itself too seriously.

Edge and Balor spent the lead-up to their Mania match talking about demons and devils, which left you thinking they were going to go crazy with imagery or props. But once the bell rang, the only thing that was out of the ordinary was the presence of a lot of red and purple weapons.

Demon Balor wrestled like pain didn’t affect him, while Edge kept doing callbacks to his offense from much earlier in his career to get an advantage. The pacing was really well done with this match, as the tension felt very real without dragging (aside from the medical visit after Finn got busted open). Finn’s dive off the cell (from a platform obviously there specifically for that spot) through a table was an obvious high point, but there were several really nice moments without it feeling cheesy or gratuitous.

The violence between the two built as they used more plunder to beat on each other, finally culminating with Edge delivering a conchairto to end their feud. Really solid match in a series of them this weekend.


2. Bianca Belair, MVP-EST

Asuka Bianca Belair
WWE.com

At what point should we start including Bianca Belair in the conversation about best big-match performers in WWE history? The Raw Women’s Champion almost always delivers when the lights are brightest, and Sunday at WrestleMania 39 was no different.

The build to Belair’s title defense against Asuka was lacking – to say the least – but even the most cynical fans knew that this match very easily could rule on the night. The match started with Bianca trying to put Asuka away quickly, but the Empress of Tomorrow just as quickly countered and tied her up in various submission holds to force the champ to rethink her strategy.

This gave way to a battle where Belair’s strength and overall athleticism were contrasted with Asuka’s submission game and strikes. But then Asuka got too cute in going for the mist, which Bianca ducked. Asuka managed to lock in an armbar, but Belair’s power game won out and she hit the KOD for the win.

Wonderful match, once against proving that Belair will rise to the occasion every time and produce special moments on the biggest stages. WWE would be wise to figure this out and save her more for those occasions rather than trotting her out on Raw for a six-minute DQ finish.


1. Intercontinental War

Gunther Sheamus
WWE.com

A Scot, an Irishman and an Austrian walk into a bar… and 20 minutes later, the bar is leveled to the ground.

Drew McIntyre, Sheamus and Gunther absolutely demolished each other in Sunday’s triple threat for the Ring General’s Intercontinental Championship. If you thought Gunther/Sheamus at Clash at the Castle was the hardest-hitting WWE match you’ve seen in years, this one probably easily replaced it. All three men chopped each other until their chests looked like hamburger. The stiff shots never stopped, as they rarely went for a hold.

Sheamus looked to be closing in on his first IC title after an avalanche White Noise and a Celtic Cross on Gunther, but McIntyre saved. Drew looked to win off a Claymore, Sheamus off a Brogue, and Gunter off a powerbomb, but the fight continued as each man kicked out of the bombs they threw at each other. In the end, it was Gunter powerbombing Sheamus onto Drew and then delivering one more powerbomb on McIntyre to retain his title.

Just an absolutely fantastic war that had people simultaneously cringing and cheering for joy. Tremendous stuff.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.