5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dark (Feb 4)

A successful mixed tag experiment, The Nightmare Collective split, and more.

AEW Dark banner
AEW

AEW Dark is back, baby.

Well, it's as "back" as Dark can be. This wasn't a perfect pro-wrestling show, but it was an enjoyable one and while not without flaws, it can only be seen as a step forward from recent examples. Props to the promotion for endeavouring to make this thing worth watching again and for bringing the runtime back to its old standard (the upload came in at 1:19 - more than double last week's).

Much of Dark was marketed around AEW's first mixed-gender tag match, with Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford teaming to face Riho and Kenny Omega. It was always going to be interesting to see how this would go down. AEW had previously distanced themselves from intergender wrestling, but a mixed tag featuring an established heel act and two of the most explosive and decorated wrestlers in the company could work, provided the quality levels were there. Spoiler alert: they were.

Elsewhere, Jungle Boy and Marko Stunt of the Jurassic Express faced Sonny Kiss and Brandon Cutler, Hikaru Shida wrestled The Nightmare Collective's Mel, Best Friends met Shawn Spears and the debuting Colin Delaney, and there was a major split in one of AEW's most maligned stables.

Let's get stuck in...


Downs...

4. The Fan Cam

Look at the above gif. That's how Kenny Omega and Riho vs. Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford was shot.

The explanation is pretty simple: AEW probably didn't expect to air this match and likely made the decision to throw it onto Dark at the last minute, so they didn't record it like the Jericho Cruise's other content. They rolled with what is essentially fan cam footage without commentary.

Speaking subjectively as someone who consumes as many tiny independent shows as he does big, bombastic, mainstream events, this wasn't a problem for your writer. For others, though, it may be. Some viewers are going to see this rough and ready footage and think it makes AEW look small-time or rinky-dink. Objectively speaking, it probably does when viewed in a bubble - hence why it's a Down.

That's the Ups and Downs in a nutshell. The format is both objective and subjective, veering closer to the former on most occasions.


3. Uh, Tully...

Tully Blanchard
AEW

Tully Blanchard cut a quick promo prior to Shawn Spears' match with the Best Friends, stating that he was still on a quest to find his charge a perfect tag team partner. He'd been searching, pouring over resumes, consuming footage, and working hard to find the right guy for his man, leading him to Colin Delaney.

Yup, that Colin Delaney.

This doesn't make a whole lot of sense in kayfabe. In the shared mainstream wrestling universe, Delaney is a jobber. He's an enhancement guy, yet Blanchard, whose supposed to be a managerial mastermind, built him up as Spears' elusive perfect partner. That's weird.

Colin did a good job on the show and it was nice to see AEW throwing him a bone, but this was kayfabe chaos.


2. Brandi's Therapy

Brandi Rhodes therapy
AEW

If you follow AEW or Brandi Rhodes on social media, you may have caught the recent vignettes in which the Chief Brand Officer is attending a therapy session. If not, AEW aired one on last night's Dark and... yeahhh, this wasn't good.

Brandi, in full Nightmare Collective garb, said that something still didn't feel right. She still needed help. Screenshots of Twitter criticism flashed on the screen as Rhodes stressed that it doesn't get to her, then there was talk of clenching fists, releasing tension, visualising hurt, all while the therapist morphed in and out of Nightmare-style attire, convincing Brandi that there's nothing wrong with her.

This all led to Rhodes walking out, leaving a little blue monkey (!) behind and while well-produced, this was exactly the kind of hokey nonsense we were told wouldn't feature on AEW programming. The Nightmare Collective evolving is good; they need to find more convincing ways to do it though.


1. Shida Vs. Mel Gets Ugly

Mel Hikaru Shida
AEW

Poor Hikaru Shida. She tried really, really hard to get something watchable out of Mel on last night's Dark, but couldn't make it work. You can't make a glass of delicious fruit juice from a pile of mouldy, withering lemons and apples, and Shida, for all her strengths, is no miracle worker.

Shida vs. Mel wasn't good. At all. Mel is tall and works a traditional hossy style, but she's too slow and plodding to be convincing. This isn't by design, either. Traditional wrestling monsters should work a slower style than their smaller counterparts, but it didn't feel like a stylistic choice in this case. With this as evidence, Mel is just greener than Grinch poop.

That the match was full of Dr. Luther/Awesome Kong nonsense didn't help either. Overbooked, devoid of fluidity, and cumbersome, it was a bad, hard-to-watch mess, though at least the right person won. Shida took the victory with her running knee.


Ups...

5. Jurassic Express Roll Through Kiss & Cutler

Jungle Boy Luchasaurus
AEW

As a solid, functional, dual-purpose opener with plenty of fun action, it's hard to see Brandon Cutler and Sonny Kiss vs. Jurassic Express as anything other than a success.

Jungle Boy and Marko Stunt's victory gives them a nice lick of momentum. In defeat, the ongoing Dark Order/Cutler storyline is advanced. Evil Uno and Grayson have been pursuing him for a while and actually defeated the same duo on last week's Dark, meaning Sonny could feasibly become a target himself. It's not the biggest, most important, or most impactful story in the company, but they're telling it in a way that makes sense.

Stunt was as over as he usually is here and made his opponents look like hosses, despite Cutler's own lean frame. He ended up scoring the fall on Brandon following a double-team rolling Cutter with Jungle Boy, who had a solid, crowd-popping bout himself. A nice, record-padding triumph for Luchasaurus' baby boys.


4. Keep Searching, Shawn...

Colin Delaney
AEW

Shawn Spears' search for his perfect tag team partner continues. Colin Delaney, predictably, wasn't the guy, taking the fall in a good match against the Best Friends of Chuck Taylor and Trent, having eaten the Strong Zero and the pinfall with Spears and Tully Blanchard walked out on the bout. Poor bastard.

This was the most notable development coming out of the clash, though the action definitely delivered. The wrestlers looked like they were having fun. At one point, Spears audibly complained about being teabagged by Trent. Delaney worked hard, clearly relishing this AEW opportunity, and Shawn's struggle to marshall him through the bout was a hoot. They cut the Best Friends' hug spot off and Delaney went for one of his own, only for Spears to get himself the hell out of the ring, hugging Tully on the outside instead. Later, Orange Cassidy did Orange Cassidy things.

Worked at a house show clip it may have been, but there was little to complain about here. These bouts are more about entertainment than workrate and to that end, it delivered. Another W for Best Friends' record, too.


3. Nightmare Over?

Awesome Kong
AEW

A fracture emerged in The Nightmare Collective as Dr. Luther and Mel beat Awesome Kong down after the Hikaru Shida match, leaving the TNA legend's future hanging in the balance.

AEW has put it over as a "serious injury" that Kong may never recover from on social media. Said injuries are almost certainly kayfabe, but it looks like the promotion is writing her out for a while - and she's probably out of the Collective as well. That's a good thing. Kong may not be the performer she used to be and hasn't looked great in recent outings, but she's still a convincing mauler with plenty of name value and her involvement in AEW's worst stable was hindering her.

Kong chastised Mel for losing, so Mel bludgeoned her as Luther held the monster back. Kong was lobbed through the barricades and onto the steps, then guillotine leg-dropped while still on the steel. It was a convincing enough beatdown.

The Nightmare Collective just hasn't taken in AEW. This angle shows that the promotion has at least acknowledged this, so it'll be interesting to see how they follow-up.


2. A Successful Experiment

Riho Kenny Omega
AEW

Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford vs. Kenny Omega and Riho was a successful experiment for AEW, with the mixed tag format something that could potentially serve them well going forward.

Through their Mixed Match Challenge, WWE proved that pseudo intergender wrestling can work at this level, though their guidelines were a little different. In WWE, the men wrestle the men and the women wrestle the women. AEW's version is pure intergender, with Omega working Ford early on before Sabian starting throwing Riho around to big heel heat from the audience, and this continued throughout.

Intergender is a controversial, divisive niche that Impact is attempting to tap into with Tessa Blanchard as World Champion. Aspects of it are never going to be believable, but neither is an Irish Whip. Try doing one of those in real combat and see what happens. Here, AEW at least played to the size and strength discrepancies by having the women wrestle slippery and evasive, and look: the match got over. It was over as hell, in fact, and that alone will likely spur AEW to do more.

This brand of wrestling doesn't need to become A Thing in AEW in the same way it has for Impact. Still, what's the harm in throwing a few matches like this on Dark from time to time?


1. The Mixed Tag Match Itself

We've already spoken about Ford/Sabian vs. Riho/Omega as a concept; now let's talk about the match itself.

This thing was very, very good. It was comfortably the highest-calibre match Dark has hosted in weeks and an absolute riot of a crowd-popper rife with fun spots, good character work, and heat. Sabian and Ford were more over than they've ever been in AEW as they worked Riho over. The AEW Women's Champion sold well for them to boot, leading to the big, explosive Kenny Omega hot tag that everyone knew was coming, but delivered regardless.

'Superbad' was particularly effective here, constantly talking sh*t to both Kenny and the crowd as he controlled Riho. Matches like this, where he's paired with the likes of Omega, will help him take off after recent middling performances.

Kenny and Riho's established chemistry saw them ride to victory. With Ford taken out via Snapdragon, 'The Best Bout Machine' unleashed a cloudburst of signature offense on her partner, pinning Sabian with his instakill - the One-Winged Angel.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.