5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (11 Apr - Results & Review)

Cody Rhodes goes "spinner"; Rey Fenix shines again; Randy Orton gets a new WrestleMania 41 foe.

Randy Orton Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

Solo Sikoa looks likely to be WWE's replacement for Kevin Owens vs. Randy Orton at WrestleMania 41. That won't satisfy everyone out there, but it's a decent sub. Those yearning to see SmackDown GM Nick Aldis trade his sharp suits for ring gear shouldn't fret though - creative slyly suggested that they'll come back to Aldis vs. Orton at some point in the future. This story ain't over, people, and neither is KO vs. Randy.

A fair chunk of time on this week's show was devoted to a Gauntlet bout with Women's Tag-Team Title ramifications. The winners would challenge Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez on the main card at 'Mania. There was an 'Up' and a 'Down' in the same match, but the highs were great. There's less positivity on the male tag-team front.

Triple H might've let his troops down there, but there's still time yet to put things right.

Rey Fenix showed more of what he's capable of in yet another dazzling exhibition, Drew McIntyre and Damian Priest continued working hard to make something of their upcoming 'Sin City Street Fight', and poster boy Cody Rhodes was put right up against it by the fact John Cena chose not to include Seattle on his retirement tour. Also, where's The Rock?!

Somewhat remarkably, both Charlotte Flair and Tiffany Stratton made up for their messy verbal exchange last week by keeping things simple after a celebration of everything right with NXT. Wade Barrett even stuck his nose in to add a splash of realism to the story. A splash of realism WWE chiefs would've wanted this time!

Here's all the good and bad from the penultimate SmackDown before WrestleMania.


Downs...

4. Cody Tries His Best, But…

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

…segments without John Cena are a tough one so close to ‘Mania.

Cody was in a hard spot here, because he had to carry the entire segment himself without bouncing off anybody. In fairness, he acknowledged that, and put the heat on John for choosing not to make Seattle part of his retirement tour. Then, Rhodes showed off belts held by guys like Bruno Sammartino, The Undertaker, Eddie Guerrero and Cena himself (complete with a little "spinner" action).

Sadly, this wasn't the most must-see promo ever, and it could’ve actually been a complete waste of time had Rhodes not brought up the "spinner" title and Cena’s legacy. Yes, JC is set to be on SmackDown next week, but that couldn't stop this week's show from feeling a little overlooked by the creative team. Seattle's masses had to be feeling that too, because they certainly didn't pay for a Cody TED Talk about old title belts.

The Rock never really being brought up by either side is certainly a choice considering his involvement in Cena's heel turn too. Elimination Chamber went off the air in Toronto with everyone looking forward to a blistering final sprint towards 'Mania. Rock's new 'Corporation' with John Cena and possibly others sounded wonderful, but things haven't really panned out like that.

So, plaudits to Cody for doing the best he could with weak material, but that material was so thin it was practically see through. In the end, his speech boiled down to a pop for Guerrero's name and an excuse to spin one of Cena's old props.


3. The Gauntlet’s Rough Spots

Lyra Valkyria Bayley Michin B-FAB
WWE.com

WWE handed the Gauntlet bout to establish new contenders for the Women's Tag-Team Titles a huge chunk of time on this week's show. Fair play, because it was refreshing to see acts like Maxxine Dupri and the 'Secret Her-vice' duo of Alba Fyre and Piper Niven get plenty of in-ring minutes and a little spotlight. There were some rough moments that threatened to chip away at the match though.

For starters, the Pure Fusion Collective feels totally rudderless without Sonya Deville, and it's not like they were smashing it as a trio before she was released by WWE. Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark have zero heat, so their portion of the match opposite Bayley and Lyra Valkyria played before some rather embarrassing silence. The same was true for spots involving Michin and B-FAB, and then Kayden Carter and Katana Chance.

The finish to the match was great, but it took a while to get there and the lulls were pretty painful. Here's the deal: Fans aren’t interested in some of these teams because they’ve been given no reason to be. That's something Triple H should be spotting and actively working to address. Whilst it's fair to say that not everyone can be pushed at the same time, they should be hearing something/anything from fans when they make their way to the ring.

Lyra and Bayley did everything they could think of to work through the strain, but they weren't met halfway by some of these teams. Worryingly, unlike the winners, a few of them are full-time duos and should really be further down the line than they are.


2. This Isn’t Working

Chelsea Green Zelina Vega
WWE.com

Man, you've to feel kinda feel sorry for Chelsea Green, because it’s like WWE has gone out of its way to make her Women’s United States Title reign difficult. Michin wasn’t a good first challenger, especially considering Chelsea beat her to win the gold at Saturday Night's Main Event, and now Zelina Vega is a chore too. Worse, Green looks set to miss out on WrestleMania 41 despite being one of the blue brand's most entertaining midcard acts.

Look, WWE can't fit everyone on the weekender (they're trying, right enough!), but Chelsea can't be chuffed to look over and see Women's Intercontinental Champ and Raw counterpart Valkyria plucked out of singles and placed into a tag just so she's featured. Now, Green moves on to a nothing six-woman tag on next week's so-called "WrestleMania SmackDown" alongside her buddies Piper and Alba.

They'll work vs. Vega, Katana Chance and Kayden Carter. Cool, but it's hard to see why Vega benefits from beating Green via countout here. She's hardly coming across as a strong challenger worthy of going after the belt. Sure, everyone gets the story they’re trying to tell with Green needing her ‘Secret Her-vice’ to fight her battles, but...boo to wishy washy booking.

This was definitely that.

The Women's US Title has quickly become an afterthought when it should be presented as something worth caring about. Hunter has a champion who gets a reaction from fans, has personality and works as comedic heel foil, but he's content to flush that down the drain in favour of short-term rivalries that achieve nothing.

Someone stage a creative intervention. Quick.


1. Months Of Tag Build For This?!

Byron Saxton Motor City Machine Guns
WWE.com

Well, this is a body blow.

It's worth pointing out that WWE could book a screwy finish between The Street Profits and the Motor City Machine Guns on next week's episode and thus lead into a multi-team affair at 'Mania. Sure, they could, but it's up in the air as things stand. Right now, all we know is that Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley will challenge Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins on "WrestleMania SmackDown".

How about all those other squads who have been vying for the belts? DIY are moaning about conspiracies, Pretty Deadly are laughing at them, Los Garza are busy with Rey Fenix and Andrade, and the new combo of Carmelo Hayes and The Miz are yukking it up in backstage skits. Erm...what happened here, and how did the writers go from a can't miss sleeper hit to everyone potentially skipping the biggest show(s) of the entire year?

It'd be crap if The Profits, MCMG, Pretty Deadly, Los Garza and even 'Melo Don't Miz' had to sit on the sidelines and watch 'Mania happen without them. The entire tag-team scene has been red hot on SmackDown for months, but all of that TV time will be wasted if they're not involved in Las Vegas.

Hopes are dimming on a rumoured ladder match between all of those tandems. Hell, stick it on the card and have The Hardys come out again as a last-minute surprise like they did back in 2017 at WrestleMania 33. That's better than the thought of these teams missing out on a pay day.

They'd be one of the few multi-man matches on 'Mania that actually makes sense.


Ups...

5. NXT Showcase Then A Bit Of Flair

Tiffany Stratton Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Hey, look at this - an 'Up' for the Charlotte Flair vs. Tiffany Stratton feud after they were rightly torched for going off-script to little success on the 4 April SmackDown. Admittedly, that did get everybody talking, and WWE chose to turn it into a bit of storytelling by having Joe Tessitore say that Charlotte had been sent home and Tiffany was facing disciplinary actions.

Later, Stratton matched up against NXT's Roxanne Perez in a fun little match. It shouldn’t be lost on anybody that Tiffany vs. Roxanne was a showcase for two developmental success stories. In context of WWE's tale, that’d infuriate an elitist like Flair, who attacked Tiffany post-bell. To push the idea that this was also going against the grain, Wade stepped in at the broadcast position and said he was trying to help Charlotte so she didn’t get fired.

This skit was a vast improvement over some of the talking that has come before, and it harked back to a memorable brawl from the 14 March episode of SmackDown. Charlotte and Tiffany are at their best as a pairing when the back and forth verbals are minimal and they're strictly physical.

Being honest, WWE might’ve learned to keep this feud off the mic. Hopefully.

Charlotte getting jealous that two emerging stars from the Performance Center tore it up in-ring is believable, and there was some decent fire between Flair and Stratton physically. It's too late to outright save the rivalry, but this merits an 'Up' for slick presentation and 'cause there was no chat about Ludwig Kaiser sliding into anyone's DMs.


4. The Gauntlet’s Finish

Lyra Valkyria Bayley Liv Morgan Raquel Rodriguez
WWE.com

Here's the upside to the aforementioned Gauntlet.

Bayley and Lyra Valkyria went coast to coast in the match. They'd started as opponents on the 7 April episode of Raw, but are now number one contenders for the Women's Tag-Team Titles. In a cool show of cohesive storytelling, WWE didn't force these ladies to be all high fives and smiles. No, they started off with little chemistry yet managed to build some the longer they had to struggle and fight to survive. That works.

The entire match peaked with a sweet surprise one count off Bayley’s elbow on Piper Niven. Honestly, Niven and Alba Fyre showed enough here that they deserve a deep run in this division after ‘Mania. Lyra and Bayley challenging Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez is absolutely fine, but man, the closing match in this Gauntlet was excellently done and 'Secret Her-vice' take a lot of credit for that.

They're such a solid team, which will come as no shocker to anyone who happened to follow their work on the independent scene. Piper and Alba (as Viper and Kay Lee Ray respectively) had some brutal bouts as rivals in groups like ICW in Scotland, and they've been real-life friends for well over a decade. It'd be nice to see them get their flowers, and the same goes for their leader Chelsea Green.

Everybody knows that the Women’s Tag-Team Titles are never the most important, but this is a decent little short-term story involving Bayley, Lyra, Liv and Raquel that could spin Morgan into challenging for the Women's Intercontinental Title.


3. Street Fight Is The Way To Our Hearts

Damian Priest Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

There’s no point in beating around the bush: Drew McIntyre vs. Damian Priest has some backstory due to what happened at last year's WrestleMania 40, but it’s only really happening at 41 because WWE had nothing else for these guys. Even so, they’ve been working hard to make the feud click, and violence is the way to go.

Priest and McIntyre have used car windshields (real glass!) and a string of other bruising bumps to try get fans on board with their beef rekindling just in time for 'Mania. This week, it was Drew's turn to ambush Damian and then cut a promo adding some more context to the rivalry.

Later, once Priest had returned/hammered a few security guards, McIntyre hit a DDT on the steel steps that looked utterly fab. This was a mini preview of what's to come in the pair's ‘Sin City Street Fight’ in Vegas, which should be some scrap. You just know both dudes will lay it in and try to score some brownie points for themselves coming out of the weekend.

Going the 'Street Fight' route is definitely preferable to just putting them in a regular match. That wouldn't have made much sense when they've been attacking one another with weapons or backstage every other week.

Drew smashing into Priest with the corner of the steel steps looked brutal too. Damian surely protected his eyes and nose, but it looked for all the world like the jagged edge of those steps had bashed him right in the face. Anyone who enjoyed their match in Scotland on Clash At The Castle 2024 last summer is in for a treat come Vegas.


2. Rey Fenix Shines Again

Rey Fenix Berto
WWE.com

Berto proved to be the perfect opponent for Fenix.

Nathan Frazer did a neat job on last week’s show during Rey’s debut, and this was more of the same. This writer really hopes Los Garza get their reward for hard work soon, because they’re great any time they’re in the ring. This is maybe the best Humberto Carrillo has looked as a singles act since his earliest days on Raw back in late-2019.

Both he and Angel probably need a wee bit more character/personality, but that can be worked on if WWE gives them the chance to work on it. Something is simmering away between those guys and both Santos Escobar and Andrade, at least. The only worry is that only Santos is really a decent promo, so they might need to rely on in-ring work to get fans interested.

OK, enough of that sidebar. Back to Rey Fenix. He's coming across as a star, which is all anybody can ask from his first batch of matches in WWE. Is anyone else getting Rey Mysterio in 2002 vibes? If so, then that's a major compliment. Fenix perhaps had it tougher than his brother Penta (who came into the company first), but he's really making the most of his in-ring minutes.

Some of his main moves, including that kick after running on the top rope and his Mexican Muscle Buster finish, look spectacular. It's still early days, but Fenix is shaping up nicely as somebody who could (in theory) be a fine challenger for Jacob Fatu. Assuming, of course, that the ex-New Bloodline brute wins the United States Title.


1. Setting The Table For Nick Aldis?

Randy Orton Nick Aldis
WWE.com

Clearly, it doesn’t look like Nick Aldis will be hauling off the suit and dusting off some NWA Title-winning trunks at WrestleMania 41, but there was enough to his opening segment with Randy Orton to tease people. Aldis did well to catch himself any time he nearly turned back into an active wrestler, but Orton mentioning Mickie James could come back around eventually and be a catalyst for the feud.

Fans in Seattle popped for the idea of Randy vs. Nick, which is certainly a good sign for Aldis. Triple H will be paying attention to that; it's obvious there's interest in seeing Aldis work a few matches. He's been in WWE for a while now, and it'll likely surprise some casual company fans just how accomplished he is between the ropes.

Friday's main event tag pitting Randy and LA Knight vs. Solo Sikoa and Tama Tonga was a sprint. One can’t argue with WWE putting Solo in as a contingency plan for Orton, but there’s more interest in what’s brewing with Aldis. However, again, creative didn't have a lot of time to come up with something new for Randy following announcements that Kevin Owens will be out for anywhere between 6-12 months with a nasty neck injury.

Dunno, something about the way Orton name-dropped Mickie and Nick almost throwing hands because of it suggests that there's more to this story. WWE maybe decided to test the waters on SmackDown and ask the question: 'Is there interest in Randy vs. Aldis?'.

They got their answer. Yes, yes there is.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From Rhea Ripley On Stephanie McMahon's WWE Show and 10 Superstars Who Could Debut (Or Return) On WWE Raw After WrestleMania 41!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.