5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (May 15)

Money In The Bank or 'Meat In The Briefcase'?

Daniel Bryan Renee Young
WWE.com

What do double caterpillars, passionate promos and WrestleMania 36 rematches nobody wanted have in common? The answer? They were all part of this week's SmackDown, one that didn't exactly scream out of the starting blocks or front load the show so that anyone flipping channels might get hooked.

Nope - this was functional WWE fare. Sports entertainment 101, if you like.

That's not necessarily a major complaint. The company are clearly struggling to maintain their own interest in these empty arena shows now that the 'Mania buzz is gone, and it must be a weekly ball ache to try and make episodes must-see television when things are so up in the air in the real world. For what it's worth, SmackDown is doing alright. Some weeks are excellent and logical, and others...not so much.

The latest edition was blatantly filler, but WWE did manage to sneak two worthwhile promos and some solid character work into the booking. The bad news is that they're trying that 'Wild Card' sh*t from last year again (God only knows for how long).

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from Friday...


Downs...

4. Everyone Is Shocked (Again)

Dana Brooke
WWE.com

Everyone, including Dana Brooke herself, needs to stop looking so damn shocked when she picks up a win on TV. The well-muscled smiler has beaten Naomi twice on SmackDown now, and even got a few spots to shine at MITB, but you'd think was some no-name jobber picking up victories with the way Michael Cole harps on.

This isn't doing Brooke any favours; it's like she's being written to know she's out of her depth and lucky to have a gig on the WWE roster. That's hardly going to feed credibility, especially when it comes across loud and clear that she's just 'happy to be here'. It's about time WWE moved on from this one-dimensional, plucky presentation.

Dana is actually quite handy when she's in there with the right opponent. She's athletic, really wants to succeed and has a great look. None of that matters when Cole and Corey Graves are acting as though the Cincinnati Bengals won the Super Bowl every time she scores a 'W'.


3. A WrestleMania Rematch Nobody Asked For

Elias King Corbin
WWE.com

Who in the name of WrestleMania rematches decided to give Elias and 'King' Corbin 15 minutes and two commercial breaks this week? The boys worked hard, no doubt, but this was just too much time for them, and there seemed to be a few breakdowns in communication throughout their match.

Worse, the wrong man won.

Losing to Elias does nothing for Corbin heading into his match against WWE Champion Drew McIntyre on Monday's Raw. On that note, winning via small package does next-to-nowt for Eli either - he got a lucky win over someone who put him on the shelf and has tormented him for months. A lucky win.

That doesn't cut it, and it doesn't make Elias look like a vindicated babyface. He's blatant fodder for AJ Styles when he of many 'Taker flashbacks beats Shinsuke Nakamura next week. This wasn't good despite the graft from both guys.


2. “Brand-To-Brand Invitational”

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Oh, oh no. They're doing it again.

Last year's 'Wild Card Rule' was an abomination of logical storytelling. Firstly, WWE changed the rules to suit themselves on a weekly basis. Second, nobody actually cared enough about the brand jumps to make them worthwhile. Those problems haven't been remedied with this newly-acclaimed 'Brand-To-Brand Invitational'.

Graves said that Charlotte Flair, the NXT Women's Champ, was coming to SmackDown thanks to Raw. It's messy, and it's a total rehash of something that didn't work the first time. Cole also chipped in to give WWE enough rope with which to hang themselves; he revealed that select wrestlers will be able to appear on rival shows "four times a year".

Everyone and their granny knows WWE won't stick to that. Plus, it doesn't make much sense that FOX would willingly use up one of those "four" performances by booking Charlotte to talk rather than wrestle (how could they know Bayley and Sasha Banks would interrupt?).


1. Bray Wyatt?

Otis Braun Strowman Mandy Rose
WWE.com

At Money In The Bank, Braun Strowman picked up a strong win over Bray Wyatt that sets the scene for the 'Fiend' to pop out and have a rematch at Backlash. That's really the only direction WWE can go with Braun unless they have another opponent in mind for him and want to put Wyatt on ice.

That doesn't seem likely, so it's weird that he wasn't on SmackDown at all.

There was zero follow-up from Strowman's win at MITB. Instead, he appeared in a house show-esque tag-team match with Otis against The Miz and John Morrison. WWE declined to have Bray show up afterwards to sow seeds for another crack at the Universal Title - he didn't even show up on 'Firefly Fun House'.

No, Wyatt doesn't need to work every week, but he's in the top feud on the brand right now. Surely that'd mean he has to maintain some sort of presence on SmackDown and weave the next chapter in his feud with Braun? Apparently not.


Ups...

5. More Doubts For Sasha Banks

Charlotte Flair Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Sasha Banks is knocking it out of the park with her facial expressions at the moment.

This week, the slow burn towards her eventual turn on Bayley continued. Charlotte Flair, who was seemingly only invited to the show so she could talk about her own star power, served up some truth and told her old rival that she shouldn't be content in Bayley's shadow. The penny is slowly dropping with Sasha.

Being honest, Bayley vs. Banks is all the SmackDown women's division has in its locker right now. There's literally nobody else who could be a credible challenger for the belt (WWE has burned through Lacey Evans, Naomi and Tamina in recent times). If nothing else, this made steps towards the biggest feud this title has.

If handled correctly, Bayley vs. Sasha will be a marquee offering at SummerSlam, and one WWE can be proud of. Both will be motivated to make their feud the best it can be after years of stuttering, on/off 'frenemies' bullsh*t too. Bring it on, ladies.


4. Otis On Miz TV

Otis The Miz
WWE.com

It's one of this promotion's go-to plot devices, and it usually sucks hard, but the old 'let's make fun of someone's baby photos' trick actually worked here. Everyone played their roles really well. The Miz was an insufferable git, John Morrison piped up with jokey one-liners and Otis came across as quirky and fun.

He might want to be careful he doesn't veer too much into Big E territory with those hip gyrations and crotch thrusts however.

As stock as this undoubtedly was, it somehow worked. Otis is likeable enough that he can offset the comedic jibes at his looks and weight, and it's believable that rich jocks like Miz and Morrison would rip on him for the obvious. Overall, this was a nice piece of work that did at least provide build for the main event tag.

WWE can't keep Tucker out of the frame forever though. He's gonna' have to return at some point and either turn on Otis or back him up as a well-meaning brother who's just happy to see him succeed.


3. Next Week’s Show

Charlotte Flair Bayley
WWE

It feels kinda' weird to use an 'Up' on next week's SmackDown, admittedly.

That card is stacked though. WWE has lined up a 'Champion vs. Champion' match between Charlotte Flair and Bayley (which should be fun and will again further Sasha Banks' inevitable turn) and a mixed tag pitting Otis and Mandy Rose against Dolph Ziggler and Sonya Deville.

Then, there will be another two matches in the Intercontinental Title Tournament - Jeff Hardy will work Sheamus and AJ Styles collides with Shinsuke Nakamura. If one looks at that lineup without prejudice over how WWE might book it, then it's pretty damn strong. There's some serious star power on tap come Friday.

Fingers crossed the writers don't make a balls-up of things. Sasha needs to accidentally cost Bayley again, Jeff Hardy needs to advance and AJ must progress past Nakamura. In the mixed tag, Sonya has to keep making Mandy's life a misery too.


2. Daniel Bryan’s Physical Dissection

Daniel Bryan Drew Gulak
WWE.com

Weirdly, Daniel Bryan vs. Drew Gulak wasn't a patch on their stunning match at Elimination Chamber despite being roughly the same length and following the same technical format. That doesn't mean it was bad, but it wasn't quite as blistering.

The psychology was typically robust, in fairness.

Bryan spent 99% of the match constantly working over Gulak's leg and preparing for the finish. Come crunch time, he locked in a leg submission to win cleanly. It wasn't flashy as much as it was solid as hell, and yet there's just something about this pairing that looks, moves and gels so well together.

Daniel's post-match promo was another credit to the segment. He put over his passion for wrestling, as always, and made sure to put across how much the Intercontinental Title means to the locker room. There was even a handshake between friends to keep the peace.


1. Sonya Deville’s Promo

Sonya Deville Dolph Ziggler
WWE

Sonya Deville is oozing the same kind of edge Becky Lynch did when she first morphed into 'The Man'. That is not said lightly; Deville is just killing it right now, and she's proving that confidence is a powerful tool for anyone looking to come across as a serious threat and big star.

She's coming into her own after years of mediocrity.

This week, Dolph Ziggler said exactly nothing. He let Sonya take the floor and lay out her crazed plans to wreck Mandy Rose's life. This was the best promo WWE has run all week, and it's yet another example of how bullet point direction make things seem way more natural than word-for-word scripting ever could.

If Deville can continue cutting promos like this, and mix in some intense matches, then she can use Mandy as a springboard to the top of the division. She's 10x the heel Bayley is at the minute whether WWE like that fact or not. It might only be a matter of time before she's queen of the women's pile herself.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 18 CRAZIEST Moments From WWE Money In The Bank 2020 and Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1+2 Remaster: 10 Things You Need To Know!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.