5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (November 22 - Results & Review)

A very nice, very evil show books the World's End main event and the Continental Classic kicks off.

Danhausen AEW
AEW

AEW has gone a bit mad.

Or to be a bit more realistic about it in 2023, AEW has gone a bit mad again.

The Continental Classic Tournament was immediately and effectively established as All Elite Wrestling's take on the treasured NJPW G1 Climax, promoted as it was by Tony Khan and a specifically a returning Bryan Danielson as the "best wrestling tournament ever". So far so good, and if the full field of 16 had been made available longer than 12 hours before the tournament kicked off, the build could have matched the bluster.

Alas, it wasn't. It took until a "selection special" on the day of the November 22nd Dynamite to flesh out the (admittedly awesome) lineups, and even though a 'no interference' rule had potential, Eddie Kingston's cluttered Full Gear promo about feeding his ROH and NJPW Strong belts into a Continental Championship to make a modern wrestling triple crown title for the winner confused things further.

All of this while Khan finds himself in a multitude of creative cul-de-sacs before settling down to try and figure out arithmetic even genius-era Gedo had to spend weeks and months poring over. If he pulls it off, it'll be one of his biggest achievements to date. If he doesn't, it'll be another perception nightmare he really doesn't need. Time for everybody to put their money where their effing mouths are and see which way the pendulum of public opinion swings.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs…

5. Jay White Vs Rush

Jay White Rush
AEW

Jay White and Rush had a perfectly acceptable wrestling match and if there's a better advert for how perfectly acceptable wrestling has not and will not ever be the lone answer to a creatively barren company's problems, your writer is yet to see it.

The LFI are ostensibly babyfaces now, but Rush and White felt like they were working an all-heel match without the competitive chicanery. White nailing a low blow at the first and only opportunity in a contest that robbed the pair of their respective entourages was a nice reminder that 'Switchblade' excels as a tournament villain, but a quarter of an hour of move exchanges didn't exactly generate the energy that allow you to feel earnestly angry at his misdeeds. If anything, it's the sort of thing Rush would have done given the chance, so more fool the recently-returned star for blowing the opportunity.

This wasn't a bad booking for the Continental Classic, but it was one of three of matches on this show that most definitely should have been mid-tournament encounters rather than cold openers.


4. Christian Cage Rechristens Nick Wayne & Luchasaurus

Adam Copeland
AEW

One of the difficulties in viewing and reviewing wrestling through any kind of critical lens is when you're faced with having to analyse the story happening in front of you as well as the one you believe it is attempting to tell going forward.

In the case of the Adam Copeland/Christian Cage situation, there have now been a few cases of the angle not really living up to the expectations. Copeland initially promised not to fight his longstanding best mate then went back on it and swore vengeance after a fortnight. His inability to get what he wanted at Full Gear extended to him taking out the newly-renamed (and downtrodden ex-dinosaur) Killswitch and The Prodigy Nick Wayne here, but he waited a long time to save Shanna Wayne (music cue included), and the violence he subjected her son to in the aftermath may well lead her into the arms of his enemy.

This was quite bad, but the outcome might not be. Like Copeland's run in AEW in general thus far, the jury's still out.


3. Ruby Soho Vs Anna Jay Vs Skye Blue

Ruby Soho Cool Hand Ang
AEW

A noble failure this, not least because the booking of Skye Blue picking up the victory feels like an attempt to move her away from the corruption-verse and find somewhere else to make good on her obvious and clear progression this year. Unfortunately there was more here to dislike than enjoy.

Heatless but not the most heatless of the night despite the doomed spot, where the match really fell away wasn't due to what took place bell-to-bell but the romance angle attached to it between Ruby Soho and Cool Hand Ang.

Auto-pilot booking rather than stopping to ask why results in outcomes and characters less over than they should be. Blue got the win, but it was opportunistic and all the focus was on heels bollocking one another after the fact.

The story isn't a bad one! But why exactly are the lovers so star-crossed? Anna Jay wanted Ang's focus to be on her, but what exactly do Daddy Magic and Saraya have against their friends coming together? The detail wasn't explored, but the fake-feeling splitting up of the pair mirrored Matt Menard's inexplicable hatred of Daniel Garcia's dancing. These are people performing enforced actions like wrestling robots, not doing what their characters might actually do.


2. A Dead Crowd In Chicago

Toni Storm
AEW

It’s lazy punditry to aim fire on crowds when they respond to a wrestling show with collected indifference or vocalised protest via the “what” chants (more on that later) or other various hijacks.

Audiences pay to attend and reserve the right to react however they wish as long as they’re not harming others around them. The wrestlers and bookers are The Show, and are there to dictate the emotional responses if they’re effective in their roles. Too many people creating The Show haven’t been strong enough in their positions for much of this year, and the outcome was Wednesday’s sterile scene.

Chicago will always be one of AEW’s bases, but there were more lively events in Jacksonville in the summer of 2020 than this one. A lower number until a late walk-up should be an alarm bell, and flat disinterest to huge portions of the show shouldn’t be written off as just a still night in ‘The Windy City’.


1. Tournament Tone Setting

Jay White Rush
AEW

AEW could and should be held to the promise Bryan Danielson made about the quality of the Continental Classic, but even with patience extended to the hyperbole, the tournament ultimately got what the slapdash launch of it deserved.

A cold crowd for all the matches made potentially intriguing combinations feel instantly stale, but fans were given less than 7 hours to get hyped due to when the announcements of the leagues were made. Decent wrestling alone can stabilise a product (and AEW needs that), but it cannot wholly reheat and revitalise it. A sense of anticipation was badly lacking, and the company didn’t quite nail the match choices in order to manufacture one.

In 2023, WWE comparisons have constantly been made to illustrate an unfavourable change in direction for the show, but a series of solid-to-good matches runs the product closer to a Raw or SmackDown than any skit or comedy character. And on those shows, the personas have usually had substantially more television time to set their agenda and the audiences right now are way more invested that Wednesday’s Chicagoans.

Not a bad start. But a long way from a best-of-all-time one. And the closest it got was…


Ups…

5. Jon Moxley Vs Mark Briscoe

Jon Moxley
AEW

The Froggy Bow is fast becoming the best near fall in wrestling, or at very least Mark Briscoe's version of the Sami Zayn Blue Thunder Bomb. The possibilities that open up to every wrestling fan during the referee's slapping of the mat twice are dreamlike. This won't last forever, but Briscoe's enduring appeal and fantastic babyface fire-ups will carry it for the duration of the tournament regardless of how he fares.

And what about how he fares, exactly? Should he have seen this one through? He'll be a good hard luck loser and round robin tournaments require them, but at what point will withering fan patience be pushed instead of a man people are desperate to see succeed.

Elsewhere, this was an "impossible-to-be-bad" but "is-this-really-good?" Jon Moxley versus Mark Briscoe match, but a lamentation on the very existence of the Blackpool Combat Club can be saved for another day as long as Mox encounters some sort of peril or strife during the tournament.


4. Toni Storm Makes Up For Lost Time

Toni Storm
AEW

It was impossible to ignore the "what" chants that threatened to drown out Toni Storm's awards-style acceptance speech, and most reactions are as much a part of the macro issues at play in AEW rather than the micro problems with specific characters.

All that said - and that might be too much to keep this an "Up" much longer - the choice of segment was a novel idea, and the gags were sublime. Producers trying to play her off brought the best out in her incredulity, the thanking of long-deceased WB founder Jack Warner was the sort of cute gag this gimmick needs a little more of in place of mispronouncing words, and Skye Blue's interruption (and victory in the three-way that followed) felt pointed based on the multiple interactions they've had in 2023.

Storm's persona is one that risks jumping the shark once a week, but her continued commitment to the bit ensures at least one conversation about women's wrestling within the company can take place without being infuriatingly dispassionate.


3. Danhausen Elevateshausen Badhausen Materialhausen

Danhausen AEW
AEW

Orange Cassidy, Hook & Katsoyuri Shibata Vs Jake Hager & 2.0 was, as a graphic, yet another reminder of what All Elite Wrestling was at its hottest, rather than a summoning of the actual feeling.

Weird and wonderful combinations featuring wrestlers that simply would have never come together in the pre-2019 world were a crucial part of the company's early growth, but four years later they are the best reflection of a bloated roster full of characters that don't really have many reasons to really fight. And when the reason for this match was revealed, it was, appropriately, very nice.

Chicago was briefly brought to life by the return of Danhausen, presented as it was as a thanksgiving surprise from Orange Cassidy. He temporarily made Jake Hager's purple hat patter fun again, and Hook and Shibata disposed of the clown heels in the exact way they deserved. This sort of stuff used to land more on the blood-and-thunder Dynamites of old, but the company shouldn't be discouraged from keeping a bit of lightweight entertainment around while they figure out how to get the stuff that really matters back on track.


2. The Table Is Set For World's End

Samoa Joe Adam Cole MJF
AEW

The ever-divisive MJF/Adam Cole/ancillary characters saga continued on last night's show, but the formal announcement of Samoa Joe as the Champion's World's End Challenger felt like the beginning of the end of 'The Salt Of The Earth's title reign even if he doesn't lose in December.

Joe at long last getting his second shot reflects another wall closing in, and with Wardlow battering AR Fox (or anybody else in his path), Roderick Strong and Cole's relationship formally collapsing and The Devil chuckling his way through the whole sorry scene, time at the top appears limited for MJF.

And all of that assumes that he beats Joe on December 30. Their first match drew a big crowd and viewing audience when it main evented Grand Slam in the summer, and arguably has higher stakes now as a more unpredictable offering second time around. And there are questions still being asked even as this big one was answered too - why has Cole gone to bat for Joe as both partner and challenger over and over again? And why now has he finally severed ties with Roddy Strong? And who, for Satan's sake who - it's Jack Perry, right? - is The Devil?


1. Swerve Strickland Vs Jay Lethal

Swerve Strickland Jay Lethal
AEW

...wasn't particularly engaging as a match, but the ban on outside interference ripped away the opportunity for this to be the traditional Planet Jarrett fare, and Swerve Strickland didn't have to briefly get foiled by the fantastic circus before putting his opponent away.

Like every tournament match on the show, it wasn't really suitable for raising the curtain on the inaugural event. It would have been helped exponentially by being the third or fourth match for both men - the proverbial six-pointer ahead of more gripping closing fixtures - but to the winner went the spoils, and Swerve needs all of them right now.

Strickland and Hangman Page probably should have taken this episode off to sell the damage done at Full Gear, but the former at least got the opportunity to continue the hot streak he's on by racking up the first three points of the first ever Continental Classic and beat a man known as much for his mental acumen as his wrestling skill.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.