5 Ups & 5 Downs From NXT Vengeance Day 2024
Good title matches, shocking developments keep brisk show on track.
Every so often when watching NXT, it’s worth reminding yourself that, even though it’s sometimes treated as a third brand, it’s technically WWE’s developmental territory, where less experienced wrestlers learn their craft. For example, their North American Champion has just two dozen matches to his resumé.
When watching Vengeance Day Sunday night, that reminder is helpful in tempering criticism of botches and matches that are more recitations and by-the-numbers performances than pseudo-athletic competitions. It doesn’t absolve NXT from putting stuff on its PLE that really had no business being there though.
Vengeance Day survived on the strength of its three title matches, which themselves relied on two big surprises to elevate them. The NXT Women’s Breakout Tournament winner Lola Vice finally executed her contract and went for gold. Meanwhile, the drama surrounding Carmelo Hayes and Trick Williams finally reached a climax and sent fans into a frenzy.
But NXT’s backstage segments were lackluster at best and terrible at worst. Their other matches would have been better served on the Tuesday program than a PLE, and the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic final was a disappointment due to some sloppiness.
The event still was watchable, clocking in well under three hours and not dragging. It just isn’t going to be in the conversation for best WWE PLE of the year, and shouldn’t be for NXT either.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
5. Women Be Catty
There’s nothing wrong with Kiana James and Izzi Dame talking about “future-proofing” the NXT women’s division by targeting women who pose the biggest threat down the line.
But the vignette that aired Sunday night was just bad. Whoever wrote the script should be embarrassed they pitched this for TV. It read like someone asked AI to write a hackneyed, clichéd conversation between two catty women, not a real discussion between two wrestlers about possible enemies. The music that blared over the opening and closing of the video only made it seem more cartoonish.
It’s a shame for Kiana, who seemed to be breaking out a year ago, only to be stuck still doing this businesswoman gimmick unconvincingly. Is anyone watching this segment and buying in?
4. Takin’ It To The Streets
Maybe you need to be fully invested in the story between the Family and OTM to appreciate their six-person tag match Sunday night, but it just felt like something that could have occupied 10-15 minutes on a random Tuesday night, not a PLE.
The match was pretty basic, with a hockey fight thrown in, as they traded moves for a while until OTM got Tony D’Angelo in trouble, hitting a tandem pop-up powerslam. But overall, this match felt like a snoozer for anyone who isn’t a big fan of the Italian stereotype trio. And even then, it was just a match.
But hey, the Family once again established their dominance and showed that they rule the streets, so that’s got to count for something.
3. Forced Line-Reading
The less said about the vignette involving Axiom, Nathan Frazer, Malik Blade, Edris Enofe and Brinley Reece, the better. But that kind of defeats the purpose of a review column.
The segment aired was apparently taped Tuesday, with Blade and Enofe discussing the pros and cons from their loss in the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, which led to Frazer swooping in and being a smarmy goof while Axiom was everyone’s proxy and just groaned. Meanwhile Reece grated on before cartwheeling off. All of this was just to set up a tag match for Tuesday.
While this wasn’t terrible, it’s the kind of unnecessary and fake exposition that WWE and NXT love to throw on TV. Had it aired on Tuesday, most probably wouldn’t have flinched, as this sort of goofy segment is NXT’s bread and butter. But on a PLE? Pass.
2. Just Another Plunder Brawl
Apologies to Dijak and Joe Gacy, but a couple fun spots does not make up for a goofy and mostly dull plunder brawl.
Their no-DQ match involved trash cans, duct tape, chairs, kendo sticks and a nightstick, and if you think you can predict several of the moves, there’s a good chance you’ll get a few right. There were a couple fun moments: Gacy shoving Dijak off the ropes through a table covered in plastic army men was a cute spot, as was Joe duct-taping Dijak’s eyes, which prevented him from covering after hitting Feast Your Eyes.
But overall, this match was 80s movie villain Dijak trying to punish Gacy, who had his usual psychotic grin plastered on his face the entire time. Fans popped for the plunder, and that was about all there was to this.
This was the definition of a skippable bathroom break match. Inoffensive, but not memorable or impactful either.
1. Jitters?
Heading into the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic final, it seemed like Trick Melo Gang and the Wolf Dogs were bound to have a red-hot opener that set the tone for the night.
But for whatever reason, the match was plagued with sloppiness and small mistakes – plus a huge one where Bron Breakker nearly decapitated himself like Nathan Frazer did a while back. Fans were hot for Trick Williams and reacted for everything he did – even if half his moves missed by a country mile. He attempted two neckbreakers and lost his opponent on the way down on both.
There were so many miscues that after Carmelo Hayes slightly slipped on a Lionsault attempt, Wade Barrett wondered aloud if these were regulation ring ropes as a way to try to cover for the sloppiness.
Whether it was jitters, or over-enthusiasm, or just an off-night, this was not the kind of showing you’d want on a PLE for a tournament final.
Ups…
5. Vice Goes The Rollins Route
WWE has employed the Money in the Bank briefcase and NXT Breakout Tournament contract as shortcuts to shock title matches – and title changes – for nearly 20 years. And in those near two decades, only one person had cashed in mid-match to join a title contest already in progress: Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 31.
That is, until Sunday night, when Lola Vice cashed in her Breakout Tournament contract to make the title match between Lyra Valkyria and Roxanne Perez a triple threat. A relative newcomer, Vice has acquitted herself well since coming to NXT proper, and she continued at her first PLE, Vengeance Day.
Lola hung with veterans Perez and Valkyria Sunday night, trading rollups, spin kicks and pin attempts, but unlike Rollins, Vice wasn’t able to get the win.
While it might seem counterproductive to have Vice lose when cashing in, she went into a riskier situation with two opponents (plus a crazed Tatum Paxley) and lost after a good mini-match within the match.
And by robbing Perez of her one-on-one title match, Lola is likely set to face Roxanne soon as the Prodigy will be looking for revenge. So Vice comes out of the PLE with direction rather than just being a loser. All this for someone with fewer than two dozen televised matches under her belt.
4. A Better Effort
Despite the questionable quality in the opening contest, Trick Williams recovered nicely in the main event against Ilja Dragunov.
The two had a surprisingly bloody, hard-hitting NXT Championship match, with both men busted open early on and continuously swinging for the fences. Dragunov must have hit a half-dozen H-Bombs, while Williams wore out his boot kicking the champ repeatedly. There wasn’t anything fancy about this, but it was competent, and fans were way into the match and solidly behind Trick, biting for every near-fall.
The finish, even with a referee bump, was still pretty nicely done. Both men went for home runs, and at the end, they just charged at each other like jousting knights, with Dragunov scoring the knockout blow.
If you’re an NXT coach, you’ve got to be happy with Trick’s performance here and hope to see more like this as he continues to develop.
3. A Tale Of Two Matches
The NXT Women’s Championship match(es) was/were really well done, weaving a serious game of chess between Lyra Valkyria and Roxanne Perez before turning into a pure melee when Lola Vice cashed in her Breakout Tournament contract and joined the fray.
Perez, the former champion who never lost her title, battled Valkyria, trading pinfall attempts and trying to gain an advantage over the other. But just as Roxanne seemed to get an edge, Vice raced out to make the match a triple threat. Pinfalls came much quicker and the action was nonstop until the finish, which saw stalker Tatum Paxley aid her crush, Lyra.
Fans got a little of everything here: a solid back-and-forth classic title match between two outstanding wrestlers, a mid-match cash-in, and a chaotic triple threat that ramped up the excitement in the closing minutes.
For Perez, this was yet another obstacle, another unfair curveball thrown at her. She never lost her title, and now she lost her one-on-one title match without being pinned. And that might be the best part: justification for Roxanne to slide further into darkness. Fans should expect to see her become even edgier in her presentation going forward.
2. Femi Is Inevitable
The success of Sunday’s North American Championship match obvious can be placed mainly at the feet of Dragon Lee, an experienced and electric veteran who makes magic between the ropes on a regular basis.
But holy hell, you have to take your cap off for Oba Femi, whose presence, power and raw talent were on full display at Vengeance Day. Femi tossed Lee around, swatted him off the apron, caught him and carried him like a child with ease, and looked intimidating doing all of it. The guy just has that unteachable characteristic that makes you take notice of him right away.
Dragon was fantastic in this match, playing the undersized challenger perfectly, though his speed, experience and skill evened the playing field – for a bit. He strung together a series of kicks, a tornado DDT and even a running Liger Bomb to put Femi on the ropes, but he was just too much to overcome.
Wade Barrett said it best during the match, noting that we had barely scratched the surface of what Oba Femi can do, and that we have no idea how good he could be.
1. ‘F*** You Melo!’
If you’re going to turn heel, it might as well be in the most convincing and soul-crushing way possible. Otherwise, what’s the point? You get one shot to generate that nuclear heat of turning your back on everything good.
Carmelo Hayes didn’t miss his shot Sunday night, finally paying off a story that dragged on for too long by turning on longtime running buddy Trick Williams, hitting his friend when he was down, just moments after Trick lost an NXT Championship match. Hayes was there in Williams’ corner throughout the match, but at one point he “inadvertently” chop-blocked Trick. But he mainly acted as a cheerleader and played it close to the vest.
Afterward, he turned on Williams, wearing out a steel chair on his injured knee and leaving him in a heap in the ring, walking out to a chorus of boos and angry chants from a very pissed-off audience. Melo shot back to the fans, “You made me like this!”
Hayes will likely explain himself on NXT on Tuesday (and hopefully won’t say, “I don’t owe you an explanation”) and will probably be revealed as the guy who attacked Trick all those months ago. If played right, Hayes could be a nuclear heel to give Williams an even bigger rub at Stand and Deliver.