5 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE Raw (Jan 16 - Review)
At least Cody Rhodes is on his way back, because this was painful.
Woof.
Seriously, what else can you sawyabout Monday Night Raw at this point? We’ve given it a wide berth for a while now, said that you can’t make wholesale changes to undo years of bad booking, but it’s clear now that the systemic issues that have plagued Raw for the better part of a decade are… well, systemic.
It doesn’t seem to matter who is in charge of creative, we’ll still get impromptu matches booked, distraction finishes, hapless and hopeless babyfaces, horribly scripted promos, tired match formulas, and less-than-enthusiastic fans.
All of this makes for a product that once again is feeling stale. It’s pretty clear that the excitement that came from Vince McMahon’s forced retirement, Triple H’s ascendance and all the rehires and debuts that came with it has long since faded.
Bianca Belair getting distracted by Uncle Howdy? Pathetic. Elias being too stupid to realize MVP is talking about one of his clients winning the Royal Rumble? Ridiculous. Bayley and Becky Lynch sputtering through a dismal promo? Painful.
But it’s not all bad. Cody Rhodes’ return has been perfectly scripted. The six-man elimination match main event to crown a United States Championship #1 contender was good fun to close the show. And the Judgment Day continues to make the most of their opportunities.
Overall though, ugggh.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
7. Who Is Supposed To Qualify For Rumble?
This is a perpetual problem during Royal Rumble season, but can anyone shed light on this? Why do some wrestlers simply declare for the Rumble, while others have to qualify?
Cody Rhodes is in the Rumble despite not wrestling in more than six months. Omos was entered because his manager MVP negotiated it. Akira Tozawa, however, asked to be in the Rumble, and he was stuck in a match with Bronson Reed – which he lost. Others will undoubtedly just declare for the Rumble, and still more will just show up in the match the night of the event. (There’s a chance Tozawa will end up in it as filler anyway.)
What are the criteria here? Is it wins/losses? Or just Adam Pearce’s whims? Yes, we know this isn’t a “real sport,” but if it’s supposed to be the emulation of a sport, then it should try to adhere to basic rules and principles. Having two systems of getting into a major match like the Royal Rumble is pretty shoddy.
6. Same Ol’ Hurt Business
During the past couple of weeks, it looked like WWE could be re-forming one of its pandemic-era stables, the Hurt Business. For whatever reason, that group is still looked upon by many fans favorably despite a very checkered history.
Monday, we got to see that checkered history on display before the stable could even have its reunion.
Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin teamed for the second time in as many weeks, this time against the Street Profits. The duo had a nice, competitive little match, but then MVP came out to observe. He would horribly mistime a spot where he was supposed to pull Cedric out of the way from Angelo Dawkins’ spinning splash, but everyone would proceed like nothing would happen.
Alexander hit a jumping knee on Dawkins and went for the pin, only for the hometown hero to reverse the pin, sending Cedric & Shelton to defeat and left them whining at MVP for interfering in their match.
Yep, same ol’ Hurt Business. Everyone not named Bobby Lashley underperforms in the ring and complains about it.
5. Elias The Buffoon
If you knew that MVP was talking about Omos when he referenced the “2023 Royal Rumble winner” while talking to Elias, congratulations! You’re smarter than the average WWE babyface.
MVP ran into Elias outside Adam Pearce’s office and a confrontation ensued, with Porter threatening to have the next Rumble winner take on Elias. Like an idiot, the troubadour assumed he was talking about himself, laughed and called it a tune-up match.
Fast-forward to an hour later and Elias was stuck with a hang-dog look on his face when Omos came out for the match, knowing he assumed wrongly and was about to get his a** handed to him.
To his credit, Elias had a spirited little match (showing more babyface fire than Ali was allowed to), but the fact that he wasn’t smarter than a fifth-grader here just made this intolerable.
4. Belair Falls Victim To… Uncle Howdy
We’ve reached the point where the Bray Wyatt Universe has invaded the Raw Women’s Championship title picture, and it ain’t pretty.
Bianca Belair returned after taking a week off due to Alexa Bliss’ attack after their title match, and she wasted little time in calling out Bliss. Before the promo battle could heat up, Bianca threw down the challenge for Royal Rumble and Alexa accepted, which quickly segued to a brawl in the crowd.
It was there that things went off the rails. Just as Belair was about to hit a KOD onto a couple of chairs, she froze as she caught a glimpse of Uncle Howdy standing in a corridor under the stands, backlit with smoke pouring out of the aisle. That allowed Bliss to wriggle free and DDT the champ on the floor.
And just like that, your Raw Women’s Champion has now been thwarted by a chuckling, masked goof. And her title is caught up in the Wyattverse. Wonderful.
3. WWE’s Version Of Babyface Sympathy
It’s a common refrain/criticism: WWE doesn’t know how to book babyfaces, especially sympathetic underdogs.
Take Mustafa Ali for example. Here’s a guy who is perfectly suited for that role and is more than talented enough to be your undersized, never-say-die face whose fight is twice is big as he is. And the announcers make sure to tell us that numerous times during his matches, including Monday’s bout against Solo Sikoa.
But what plays out in the ring is anything but. Monday’s opening match saw Solo dominate the entire contest, making it just an extended squash with Ali desperately trying to get sympathy out of the fans. His lone hope spot came via a Kevin Owens distraction – yep, a babyface needed a distraction to mount any semblance of a comeback – but it was snuffed out after about 10 seconds.
It's hard to ask fans to rally behind Ali when you not only know he’s going to lose, but he’s going to just be beaten down the entire match, land one offensive move, and then get squashed.
Konosuke Takeshita loses most of his high-profile matches in AEW, and yet fans are hanging on every moment of his matches. Why? Not because he’s better than Ali (Mustafa is tremendous), but he battles and competes and makes you believe he can win. Ali is booked to bump like a jobber, get his hope spot, lose, and then be grateful to get TV time.
2. Dying A Slow, Painful Death
It’s hard to watch two wrestlers who are great at their craft just sent out there with abysmal material that they have to slog through.
But that’s what we had to suffer through with Becky Lynch and Bayley on Raw, as they delivered a god-awful promo segment. Becky sucking up to the fans was fine, but it all felt pretty forced. Then she called out Bayley, who came out and declared that her name was not “Karen,” triggering a weird bit with Bayley naming everyone at ringside and a discussion about whether the Role Model knew what the term “Karen” meant.
The meat of the segment wasn’t any better though. Apparently, Bayley is still resentful that Becks and the other Horsewomen were called up to the main roster in 2015 and left her behind, taking her spot on Raw and at WrestleMania (nevermind that Bayley herself is a multi-time world champion and competed at Mania several times).
Lynch’s rundown of how she changed the game despite originally being called up as “just another warm body” was great as usual, but that’s because that’s her real story. Bayley doing her high-pitch heel laugh, however, just killed it.
Sorry to fans of both women (this writer is one of them), but this was horrible. The steel cage match next week has the potential to be great, but the road to get there has been bumpy as hell.
1. Another Dead Crowd
WWE is going to have to reckon with a problem at some point that is going to be really difficult to fix: While they are filling arenas, the fans are not very vocal at all. In fact, they are eerily silent for large portions of WWE programming.
This week’s Raw was yet another example of the sounds of silence or underwhelming reactions. Mia Yim and Iyo Sky’s match played out to something barely bordering on polite murmurs. Mustafa Ali and Solo Sikoa – the opening match of the show – was way quieter than it should have been. Bianca Belair got some cheers, but she barely got an audible “EST” chant.
We’re way past the point of giving a pass and suggesting it might be how the crowd is miked. Fans are paying money to come to a WWE event and sit on their hands at points where you’d expect them to be invested or at least reacting to what they’re witnessing. Go to any sporting event and listen to the crowd when there’s action. They’re up and cheering, booing, or at least chattering.
Sure, the fans came to life for the main event, but where were the other 2.5 hours? It just drags everything down tremendously and makes you question what you’re watching.
Ups…
5. Alphas Give Judgment Day A Run
Elias might have thought he was going to have a tune-up match Monday night, but it was the Judgment Day that had a bit of a warmup match for next week when they tangled with Alpha Academy ahead of their tag title bout at Raw 30.
Chad Gable did a masterful job of being just smarmy enough as a heel but still entertaining as he outfoxed Dominik Mysterio and tried to best Damian Priest. But it was Otis who stole the show in the fans’ eyes, with the crowd actually chanting for him, and he obliged with some big man offense and a Caterpillar.
The closing moments were white-hot, with Priest hitting Otis with an avalanche South of Heaven, Gable nailing a Chaos Theory German suplex on Priest and then Chad cinching an anklelock on Dom until the rest of Judgment Day could save him. Once again, it was a nearly out-of-it Mysterio picking up the pin after a Priest South of Heaven.
All told, this was just good fun with solid action and a nice in-ring story with Dominik continuing to benefit from his stablemates’ work.
4. Cody’s Road To The Rumble
Monday’s Cody Rhodes video didn’t beat around the bush: The American Nightmare is Royal Rumble-bound.
The third instalment traced his post-surgery journey, getting back into shape, rehabbing his repaired pectoral, and finally announcing that it’s not a question of “if,” but “when”… and the when is Royal Rumble.
That was the simplest and most direct route, and it worked perfectly. We didn’t need some convoluted wink-and-a-nod video to hint at his return. We all know he’s coming back, so you might as well build anticipation instead of trying to surprise fans.
Great job all around.
3. Bronson Gets A Nice Showcase
If Bronson Reed succeeds on the main roster, it will be in spite of how he debuted.
But aside from his inauspicious bow alongside the Miz, Reed has at least gotten some decent character beats: We learned he’s a mercenary for hire, and a promo video showing his NXT matches painted the picture of an agile big man.
That helped when he came out to face Akira Tozawa. Reed steamrolled the Stamina Monster, using some typical big-man offense, but he also had some impressive little bits, including catching a cannonball off the apron and turning it into a buckle bomb into the barricade. He followed that up with a diving shoulder off the apron and then a diving splash off the top rope for the win.
It wasn’t an eye-popping turn for Bronson, but the crowd “ooohed” and “aaahhhed” at the right moments, so it seemingly worked just fine.
2. Judgment Day Steps To The Bloodline
Who would have thought that the Judgment Day would be the group that would hold the most dominant force in WWE at bay on Raw Monday night?
The Bloodline was out crowing about their success (as usual) when the purple-and-black-clad foursome interrupted. Rhea Ripley told them that the only thing they need to acknowledge is that the Judgment Day runs Raw, with Finn Balor noting that after winning the tag team gauntlet match last week, they were coming for the Raw Tag Team Championship next week.
It got interesting when Damian Priest wondered why during all their attacks on Raw, the Bloodline has never stepped to them. Dominik Mysterio (whose new “ex-con” gimmick is a fantastic wrinkle) said he smelled fear on the Usos, told them they would have lasted one night in his prison with the convicts he was locked up with, and then turned his attention to Solo Sikoa.
Have no fear though, because Rhea stepped up to Solo, who backed down a bit before Dom jumped him, triggering a brawl. Even though it was two heel stables doing battle, this was good fun.
1. All-Out Crazy Main Event
Hats off to everyone in the six-man elimination match for a United States Championship shot next week. Finn Balor, Bobby Lashley, Seth Rollins, Dolph Ziggler, Miz and even Baron Corbin worked an action-packed, entertaining main event.
It’s impossible to get into the specifics of the match, but it’s worth noting that nearly everyone got moments to shine, with Ziggler in particular looking like a beast right up until Rollins eliminated him with a Pedigree. Seth played the opportunist, sneaking into the ring and hitting knockout blows when no one expected them. He eliminated Miz via stomp while Miz was trapped in a reversed Figure Four. He booted Balor with a stomp right while Finn was getting up from nailing a Coup de Grace.
The closing minutes saw Bobby Lashley take over with his power, spearing Corbin and then Rollins out of the match to earn a title match next week against Austin Theory. It was fun mayhem, which at least ended this show on a positive note.