5 Ups And 1 Down From Last Night's WWE Talking Smack (Jan 24)

A guy from Atlanta, a girl from the old days & a dad with an iPhone. 

Mickie James Talking Smack
WWE

Back again to digest the last fallout from Smackdown Live before the Royal Rumble, Renee Young and Shane McMahon picked up the pieces from another week with a major title match, huge shots fired across the bow over the WWE Title, and even more controversies in the expanding Women's division.

With Raw Rumble Match competitors dominating conversation in the final lead up to San Antonio, it was the opportunity for the Smackdown roster to steal some headlines before the Road to Wrestlemania begins in ernest this Sunday.

Ahead of one of the most exciting shows WWE will present all year, here's a look at the Ups and Downs from this week's edition of Talking Smack.

6. Down - Shane And AJ?

Shane McMahon AJ Styles Talking Smack
WWE

Layered within his blistering final address on John Cena (more on that later), the continued resentment from WWE Champion AJ Styles towards the Smackdown Live authority figures was more pronounced this week as he sat alongside co-host and show commissioner Shane McMahon.

From the moment Styles greeted the 'Boy Wonder' with a limp and dismissive handshake, it was apparent that the show's authorities were as much the subject of his vitriol as the leader of the Cenation.

Twice bickering during the intended placidities of a go-home interview with the WWE Champion, Shane bit back at accusations of bias on the brand, and as Styles stormed off the set to bring the show to a close, Renee posited that the pressure of this Sunday's blockbuster AND the possibility of the McMahon-booked Elimination Chamber may be resting too heavily on his shoulders.

Shane largely played down any significant problems in the same way he has during similar in-ring petulance, but the seeds finally appeared sown for an AJ Styles vs Shane McMahon Wrestlemania match.

Though all plans can always change, Styles' task of carrying an increasingly-less-able 'Shane-O-Mac' on 'the show of shows' doesn't feel like it fits WWE's narrative of Wrestlemania being that great stage you spend every year working towards.


5. Up - Brand Bickering

raw smackdown live
WWE.com

If Shane is for keeps on Talking Smack (as Renee implied but McMahon denied), a mantle he's comfortably picked up from Daniel Bryan is the constant degradation of Monday Night Raw in the name of the Brand Extension.

But much like Bryan, there seems a tiny air of legitimacy in the cadence of Shane's delivery, which suits the worked shoot nature of Talking Smack and supports the internal competition WWE tries to perpetuate with the split brands.

This week, Shane took aim at Raw's impossibly big closing segment which saw monolithic megastars The Undertaker, Brock Lesnar and Bill Goldberg face off.

Without demeaning the talents, McMahon cooly inferred to Renee that 'I don't watch Raw. I'll check WWE.com for the news, but that's it', when pressed for his thoughts.

Furthermore, when asked how the huge pre-Rumble events on the Red Brand had gone down in McMahon family conversation, Shane again closed the borders in defence of Smackdown Live, simply replying how he 'didn't talk to Stephanie' outside of occasional texts.

And as when Bryan makes similar digs, a small moment within the body of show such as this can actually lay groundwork for much bigger things if and when WWE choose to revisit Red vs Blue.


4. Up - Remember The Rumble

Royal Rumble
WWE.com

By virtue of it's cute placement on the weekly schedule, Talking Smack is the true last go-home show for Sunday Pay-Per-Views, and with the Royal Rumble encompassing both brands, Renee and Shane took their responsibility to promote the show without compromising the integrity of the talk show format or the Brand Extension.

With every guest on the show having a key role at the Alamodome, the interviews salvaged a slightly embarrassing opening monologue from Shane McMahon, where he rattled off the Raw megastars (included the burgled Undertaker) and was left with the Wyatt Family and a mumble when considering any possible Smackdown winners.

Whilst the Rumble does indeed have a stacked field, it rather awkwardly highlighted how that field has been given lock-stock to the 'A Show'.

Despite this, each time a Rumble match graphic appeared, both presenters were keen to highlight the positives (great line-up) and hide the negatives (that the Smackdown Live guys are the also-rans).

Of course what can't be discussed by either brand is the element of surprise. Could a Samoa Joe or Kurt Angle or be the out-there candidate to scoop the lot? And if they do, there's always a chance Smackdown could draft the winner to add 'Royal Rumble winner' to their trophy cabinet.


3. Up - Mojo Rising

Mojo Rawley Talking Smack
WWE

Though not as strong as the breakout character reinvention two weeks ago, Mojo Rawley had another polished week on Talking Smack to follow up the successful Smackdown Live Battle Royal victory that earned him a spot in the Royal Rumble match.

He spoke candidly of what a dream it was for him to even enter the thirty-man war, let alone possibly win it and head to Wrestlemania.

The tweak to Mojo's personality has been such a welcome change to the obnoxious 'Hype' gimmick he's peddled for several years, and his revelation that his Father had taken a screenshot of Rawley's victory celebration with the 'Royal Rumble ' graphic was a touching and relatable moment to add depth to his own Rumble tale on Sunday.

Of course, it's virtually impossible that Mojo will actually win, but as with Baron Corbin, it's vitally important that outsiders are given the ammunition to seem believable winners in order to protect the sanctity of the Royal Rumble, and Talking Smack has done a commendable job of fleshing out motivation for most of its chasing pack.


2. Up - A Guy From Atlanta

AJ Styles Talking Smack
WWE

AJ Styles may lose the WWE Title to John Cena at Sunday's Royal Rumble, so if this was his swansong as leader of the Blue Brand, it was an incredible way to go out.

Arriving infuriated, AJ had the climax of his Smackdown Live back-and-forth with Cena swirling around his head, and ripped into the Number One Contender in response to 'Big Match John's confident prediction of victory.

Styles accused him of 'acting', suggesting that he was masking an inferiority complex against an opponent who had beaten him twice last year, and angrily shutting down Cena's dismissal of AJ's work on the Independent scene by insisting that 'The Face that Runs The Place' couldn't have made it out there.

He then let loose on the 'insulting' treatment he suffered on The Today Show, where hosts plugging the Rumble with special guest Cena referred to his opponent as 'the guy from Atlanta', which AJ rightly pointed out was both incorrect and hugely disrespectful.

Concluding his rant with a shot at his perceived internal mistreatment ('There I was on the poster right next to Rich Swann!'), it was a near-perfect sales pitch for Sunday and beyond that underscored exactly why he's the best all-rounder in the world today.


1. Up - (Too Much) Talkin' Bout A Revolution

Mickie James Talking Smack
WWE

After her surprising comeback on last week's Smackdown Live, Mickie James was a vital guest for Talking Smack to help flesh out a significant return and the high stakes heel turn that came alongside it.

Reviewing her beatdowns of Becky Lynch with Renee and Shane, Mickie had no sympathy for her opponent, and actually suggested the 'Irish Lass Kicker' was emblematic of a huge issue she had with the 'Women's Revolution' that has permeated WWE over the last couple of years.

Abandoning the pleasantries in discussing her return, James considered the movement triggered by the modern crop of females to be completely disrespectful, suggesting that changes really took place through people like her long before women were even given a chance.

She spoke about taking it extremely personally when her own WWE accomplishments were greatly diminished, calling it 'disgusting' that the political and professional battles her era of females had to fight.

It was an impassioned debunking of the company's current pious attitute towards Women's wrestling, and proffered the possibility of Mickie as a fascinating heel in a radical new landscape she refuses to glorify.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.