5 Ups And 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE Smackdown

Did Kane really need to lay out The New Day or The Dudley Boyz?

As almost every regular viewer of WWE programming knows, Smackdown is often treated as an afterthought by the creative team. Mental burn out must take effect following each epic 3-hour Monday Night Raw broadcast, so the Thursday night show is routinely left out in the cold. There's no real excuse for that, because Smackdown shouldn't simply feel like a Raw re-tread. All too often, that's exactly what happens. This week was certainly no different, but that's not to say there wasn't a lot to enjoy on the show. WWE's focus is definitely on Raw, although even the WWE Network seems more important to the company than Smackdown. That's abundantly clear, but it's a testament to the talent and skill of the actual workers that the matches are often worthwhile. This was the card of results for this week's episode of WWE Smackdown... Team B.A.D def. Team Bella by submission. Ryback def. Kevin Owens by count out (Owens retains the Intercontinental Title as a result). The Lucha Dragons and Neville def. The Ascension and Stardust by pinfall. The New Day and Seth Rollins def. The Dudley Boyz and 'Demon' Kane by pinfall. There were only 4 matches on this week's edition, down from the 5 of last week. Thankfully, all were enjoyable slices of action. There were some other segments on the show, as this article examines. What were the big plus points from Smackdown, and what were the overwhelming negatives?


Downs...

3. Seth Rollins Is Coming Across As A Cowardly Idiot

It's entirely symptomatic of WWE's current booking strategy that Seth Rollins has flipped between confident double-champion and runaway coward in just over one month. At SummerSlam, Rollins conquered John Cena to become both the WWE World Heavyweight and United States Champion. Fast forward to today, and he's scampering away as much as he can from 'Demon' Kane. Of course, this is the creative team's attempt to make Kane look intimidating and fearsome under his masked guise. However, it also has the knock on effect of making Rollins look like a coward. There's no problem with him occasionally showing fear, but he's confusingly also coming across as a blithering idiot during promos. Smackdown was no different from Raw in that respect. Opening the show with cries against Kane's obvious split personality, Rollins didn't come across as a World Champion. He's already being shunted down the card at Hell In A Cell, due to The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar, so it's critical he looks strong. On Smackdown, he most certainly didn't. By contrast, he looked like a frightened child whenever he appeared on screen.

2. Lack Of 'King' Barrett During 6-Man Tag

This past week on Raw, 'King' Barrett made a surprising return. Laying out both Neville and Stardust, the Englishmen grabbed the mic and said, 'All hail the return of the King'. It was an effective segment, and was just begging for some follow up. If ever people needed another reminder that WWE themselves view Smackdown as second rate, it was when both Neville and Stardust appeared but Barrett didn't. Stardust teamed with The Ascension to face Neville and The Lucha Dragons. The writing staff could easily have booked 'King' Barrett to sit in on commentary, but he was nowhere to be found. It's likely there will be some follow up on the next episode of Raw, but this is what many fans are talking about when discussing why Smackdown has become inessential for a lot of folks. Ok, so it would be foolish to claim Barrett would make a significant change in ratings, but continuity is key. Even something as simple as having him present would have helped further the story of why he attacked both Stardust and Neville. Maybe WWE just want fans to move on from the attack, and have other plans for the 'King'.

1. Kane Destroying Everybody Was Unnecessary

At 'Live From Madison Square Garden', The New Day will defend the WWE Tag-Team Titles against The Dudley Boyz. That particular match is one of the most enticing on the card, but it wasn't treated as such on Smackdown. At the end of the 6-man tag-team main event, 'Demon' Kane laid out pretty much everybody, but Seth Rollins managed to barely escape from his grasp. The New Day are one of the most entertaining acts on WWE television right now, and The Dudley Boyz have just returned to the promotion. It's understandable that the writers would want to book Kane strongly, but there was little need for him to single-handedly wipe everyone out at the end of Smackdown. Admittedly, it perhaps does paint Kane as more of a monster. That said, all concerned were treated like little more than canon fodder. The story was that Kane's frustration grew once he couldn't get to Seth Rollins, therefore he decided to take out his anger on The Dudleyz and The New Day. It would have been better if The New Day had managed to escape, keeping them strong for the title match on the WWE Network.

Ups...

5. The Lucha Dragons Get Showcased

A few months ago, news broke online that Vince McMahon was less-than-convinced by the impact The Lucha Dragons were making. The duo looked set to be recipients of a push, but those plans seemed to be in line for cancellation. Thankfully, they've managed to hit the ball out of the park whenever they've been called upon, such as on this past week's Smackdown. It seems WWE feel Neville and The Lucha Dragons vs. Stardust and The Ascension is a go-to match in order to entertain. They're right, but the bout has happened with alarming regularity over the past while. On a more cheerful note, that means more of Sin Cara and Kalisto. Both have been excellent together, and they really suit the high-flying style of Neville too. The Smackdown match only went for around 7 minutes or so, but it showcased The Lucha Dragons perfectly. It was a cool idea to give Kalisto the pinfall victory over Konnor too. A series of matches between the teams could be on the horizon again, and that's not exactly a bad thing. If The Lucha Dragons are going to be on Smackdown more often, that's one good reason to check out the show.

4. Smart Booking Keeps Ryback Looking Strong

Kevin Owens is one of the most obvious heels on the WWE roster. Far from a criticism, that actually means that the man makes it clear he's not one fans should like. They can admire his work, sure, but he has no redeeming qualities aside from that. This was evidenced on Smackdown, when he intentionally decided to get himself counted out to escape his match against Ryback. This feud over the Intercontinental Title is set to continue, so it would have been foolish for creative to book a solid decision. The match was entertaining enough before the screwy finish, so it's unlikely fans would have left disappointed anyway. Better yet, it actually keeps the feud purring along nicely. It's only a matter of time before Owens is forced to defend the title properly. What's cool about the whole situation is that Owens doesn't come across as cowardly. Instead, he's simply arrogant, and getting under the skin of Ryback any way he can. There's nothing wrong with a match that helps that story progress, whilst also keeping the 'Big Guy' looking strong. An outright loss for either man wouldn't have achieved much.

3. The New Day Continue To Thrive With TV Time

As aforementioned, The New Day are killing it right now. As the reigning WWE Tag-Team Champions, the trio have a natural chemistry that must be the envy of every other act in WWE. It's incredible to think that Xavier Woods, Kofi Kingston and Big E previously had nothing else planned by the WWE writing team before banding together. All are very good talkers. The more TV time they're given, the more The New Day excel. Every aspect of their performance is over with the live crowd, and they come across well to those watching at home. On Smackdown, that continued to be the case. During a backstage segment with Seth Rollins, their positive approach had the WWE Champ putting his head in his hands. The New Day have won over management, that much is for sure. That's precisely why they're being given so much to work with recently, and long may that continue. It seems inevitable that they'll eventually lose the WWE Tag-Team Titles to The Dudley Boyz, but there's a lot left in the tank for the group.

2. Team B.A.D Defeat Team Bella

Sasha Banks, Naomi and Tamina have largely been the ones left out of the mix during the 'female revolution' angle in WWE. Team PCB and Team Bella have been handed the most TV time, but Team B.A.D hasn't really been featured all that often. That's why it was so surprising when they wrestled a competitive match against Team Bella on Smackdown, and actually won. Before the match, the trio assessed the situation, telling everyone not to forget about them. The fact WWE had to book such a promo is worrying, because they should have been involved from the get-go. However, at least steps are being made to make them relevant again. Sasha Banks is far too good an in-ring performer to be sitting on the sidelines while everyone else hogs the glory. Banks made Nikki Bella tap out with the 'Bank Statement' submission hold. This seems to signify that 'The Boss' may be inserted into the ongoing WWE Divas Title scene. Nikki will be due a rematch against Charlotte for the belt, but now Sasha has defeated her she must be in for contention too. The match went almost 10 minutes, started slowly, but really picked up towards the finish.

1. Roman Reigns Hell In A Cell Challenge To Bray Wyatt

Aside from The New Day, is there a better promo man in WWE right now than Bray Wyatt? The character may often deal in hyperbole and melodrama, but Wyatt has a captivating way of delivering his lines. That was the case on Smackdown, when he cut a chilling promo discussing his ongoing feud with Roman Reigns. Bray reasoned that the pair are intrinsically linked. That's a cool idea, that Wyatt is slowly trying to turn Reigns into a monster just like himself. Hopefully, this is something WWE keep pressing, because the angle has potential if handled correctly. On the Thursday night show, Roman had a message of his own to deliver to the 'Eater Of Worlds', and it was a big one. In short, Reigns challenged Bray to a Hell In A Cell Match. It's unclear right now just how many Cell encounters will be booked on the Pay-Per-View. The Undertaker is already set to clash with Brock Lesnar inside the structure, but it appears Wyatt and Reigns will blow off their feud there too. The match will need more build in order to ensure it's fully satisfying, but it's heartening to see WWE are moving Reigns away from the hammy promos he was doing earlier this year. What other positives and negatives did you take from the most recent episode of WWE Smackdown? What do you make of the points raised here? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.